Wealth Tax - Consider This

Nothing says you are property more than having a wealth exit tax and taxing income of citizens no matter where they live.

Well I suppose slavery says you are property much more but still, it's pretty shitty.

I find it funny when all these asshats claim the wealthy are "not paying their share" without ever discussing how they came up with what is fair. It's a bullshit term. Fair means more always more. Much like when those on the other end of the Spectrum say taxes are too high when really any non 0 number of taxation will get the same reaction.

What makes it not fair is that if you're rich you can buy influence and have the tax codes changed in your favour, hide income offshore or in other ventures and end up paying a lower overall rate than poor and middle class.
 
  • Like
Reactions: danmand
What makes it not fair is that if you're rich you can buy influence and have the tax codes changed in your favour, hide income offshore or in other ventures and end up paying a lower overall rate than poor and middle class.
Not to mention that capital gains and dividends are taxed less than salary income which is all what the poor have.
 
Not to mention that capital gains and dividends are taxed less than salary income which is all what the poor have.


Nobody stops anyone from investing for capital gains and dividends
if your making a salary and your poor., obtain the skills needed to command a salary which will make you poor no more
 
Last edited:
Nothing says you are property more than having a wealth exit tax and taxing income of citizens no matter where they live.

Well I suppose slavery says you are property much more but still, it's pretty shitty.

I find it funny when all these asshats claim the wealthy are "not paying their share" without ever discussing how they came up with what is fair. It's a bullshit term. Fair means more always more. Much like when those on the other end of the Spectrum say taxes are too high when really any non 0 number of taxation will get the same reaction.

"Their fair share" will always be a moving target
The loonies have an ideology which relieves them of responsible thinking and sound judgement
 
Nobody stops anyone from investing for capital gains and dividends
I've met with Department of Finance officials in Ottawa many times over the years.

1) Capital gains -- the preferential tax rate is to encourage investments in companies that produce goods and services and employs people. There was a time when there was no tax on capital gains.

2) Dividends - It's call "integration". Income earn by the corporation is already taxed when earned, dividends are paid in after-tax income.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnLarue
Nobody stops anyone from investing for capital gains and dividends
if your making a salary and your poor., obtain the skills needed to command a salary which will make you poor no more

Total 'let them eat cake' response.

Yes, the poor could heavily invest all that extra cash you get while living on minimum wage.
 
I have this feeling that the lefties will bring in a tax on the gain (if any) when one sells their principle residence. Time will tell.
 
If the poor got off their asses and made something of themselves they wouldn’t be poor.
There are better ways than a wealth tax to reduce inequality.

The best way, in my opinion is to create a level playing field:

1. Make sure children have good nutrition, health care and education. This of course requires a proper welfare system to assist poor families.

2. Provide free tuition and living expenses for post secondary education for qualified students.

3. Enforce tax laws strictly and fill loopholes to make sure everybody pays their share.

4. Tax salary income lower than investment income.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
So the wealthy would get trickled down on for a change? I could live with that...
 
1. Make sure children have good nutrition, health care and education. This of course requires a proper welfare system to assist poor families.
This sounds very much like Saudi Arabia.

2. Provide free tuition and living expenses for post secondary education for qualified students.
This sounds very much like Saudi Arabia.

3. Enforce tax laws strictly and fill loopholes to make sure everybody pays their share.
There is no personal income tax in Saudi Arabia. This is great!

4. Tax salary income lower than investment income.
There is no income tax on residents of Saudi Arabia. This is great.

Additional comments:
1) Saudi Arabia is a welfare state.
2) Saudi Arabia still has poor people.
 
YOu can do certain things, like eliminate the capital gains exemption on all homes greater then $3m for example (maybe 5M) Capital Gains tax rates only available for 25K/year all the rest taxed at FULL income rates. (unless in RRSP). Or alternatively eliminiate capital gains taxation rates altogether and give people a one time 500K allotment at 25% tax. This will allow the middle class to build wealth faster and fully tax capital gains from the rich. Of course there are no tax polices that can really help the poor as they pay no tax mostly and have no savings. But I would lower the rate for the first tax bracket by 5% and increase the top the appropriate amount to make it neutral. Of course this would all have to be run through modeling to see what the predicted impact on the economy is.
 
There are better ways than a wealth tax to reduce inequality.

There has been wealth inequality throughout mankind's history. It is part of human nature.
Why do you think you can "FIX human nature?
You are already trying to "FIX the climate" ?

Are you sure one physically impossible, absolutely ridiculous plan is not enough and you want to have two?

The best way, in my opinion is to create a level playing field:
Really, you want a flat tax?
Well that is a bit of a surprise coming from you


1. Make sure children have good nutrition, health care and education. This of course requires a proper welfare system to assist poor families.
Or perhaps more poor people gain skills that will enable them to command more compensation and become poor no more?
Help for those that have physical / mental disabilities preventing them from improving their lot in life. Absolutely no problem there
Reallocation of education salary dollars to children's food programs? Sure please try that, but you will have a fight on your hands with the unions

The current health care system in Canada is unsustainable due to medical equipment inflation which traditional runs double the CPI, and a very big expected increase in medical service demand due an aging population
You want more from a system which will not be able to maintain current levels of service.
Naturally details such as these are best ignored in your plan

2. Provide free tuition and living expenses for post secondary education for qualified students.
Or eliminate/ downsize the programs which have limited prospects for commanding the compensation required to support a student loan
Tenue is very expensive to pay for via higher student debt

Trade are going to be in demand
There are far too many sociology majors serving coffee at Starbucks or carrying protest signs

3. Enforce tax laws strictly and fill loopholes to make sure everybody pays their share.
Justin tried more enforcement. As predicted he spent more money on investigations and court costs than the incremental revenue achieved

I know fair share will always be a moving target (upwards) for you.
More than half the income taxes (54%) are paid for by the top 10% , so make sure you understand what you are asking for
A truly fair share would have to address that disproportionate contribution ratio and put a greater burden on the lower 90%.
I sense that is not what you really want

Maybe you could try rebranding the idea to something which is not so misleading as "Fair Share"
The downside for you is that you would not be able to mislead anyone with a rebranding.

4. Tax salary income lower than investment income.
Nope, Can not do that. Dividends have already been taxed once at the corporate level
One of the underlying principles in the tax code is avoiding double dipping on earned income. Only one bite at that apple
The dividend tax Credit minimizes this impact

In addition you would adversely impact savers, particularly retires 15.6% , soon to become closer to 20% or more of the population
They have paid taxes as per the rules all of their lives, you can not retroactively apply punitive taxation on the savings / cash flow of the elderly

That is political suicide
I am assuming your plan still permits free elections ?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: fall
You really have no idea, do you?
My father left home before he turned 18 with a grade 9 education and couldn't speak tete carre, only pea soup. [yeah this was a while ago]
He was literally a hobo sadly without a shotgun for a while. He had to sell a nice jacket he managed to buy to eat. He has relied on Sally Ann.
Managed to better himself in the land of the tete carre even before joining the RCAF. Even taught himself the language. In an era where there was much less supports.
I don't know how he did it, but I know plenty of minimum wage people and dole people and they are usually but not always their own worst enemy. The stories I could tell. But then you can't do much for stupid and unreasonable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnLarue
YOu can do certain things, like eliminate the capital gains exemption on all homes greater then $3m for example (maybe 5M) Capital Gains tax rates only available for 25K/year all the rest taxed at FULL income rates. (unless in RRSP). Or alternatively eliminiate capital gains taxation rates altogether and give people a one time 500K allotment at 25% tax. This will allow the middle class to build wealth faster and fully tax capital gains from the rich. Of course there are no tax polices that can really help the poor as they pay no tax mostly and have no savings. But I would lower the rate for the first tax bracket by 5% and increase the top the appropriate amount to make it neutral. Of course this would all have to be run through modeling to see what the predicted impact on the economy is.

You best not be thinking you are qualified to mess about like that in the tax code

Any party that proposes a capital gains tax on the principal residence of any Canadian Citizen needs to make it part of their election platform
And any party that proposes a capital gains tax on the principal residence and is upfront about it will get destroyed in the election
Middle class home owners / voters can recognized a slimly slippery slope when they see one

Of course the liberals will only promote the bribes of more spending and foolishly trot this abomination out post election