We Must Be Doing something Right!

blackrock13

Banned
Jun 6, 2009
40,049
1
0
According to the Economists, from 2011 study, 3 of the top 5 best cities to live in, out of 140, are in Canada. Vancouver, Toronto, and Calgary top the list. The top US city is 29th(?), Pittsburgh.

The Canadian model must not be that bad.
 
The biggest factors, Heath care, Education, Crime rate. Most the actual cities have little control over.
 
Pittsburgh as the Top US City... that's a joke.
(with apologies to Stealers fans.... I was rooting for you)

OTB
 
The biggest factors, Heath care, Education, Crime rate. Most the actual cities have little control over.

I would also add Transportation...Cities control/develop transportation models and manage the police (hence crime, such as occured in New York when they focussed on it).

Education and health care are a Canadian/provincial benefit, so deos help each of these Canadian cities be higher on the list (just as it would stop some US cities rising to the top).

I often see Australian cities right up there and having spent time in both Canada and Australia they are very similar...is there a link to the list?
 
My thoughts as well, but hey ............

What would be your choice?

Oh I don't know, New York, San Francisco, Chicago all leap to mind... unless you're going for boring, then Pittsburg, Cleveland, Omaha.....

OTB
 
oh i don't know, new york, san francisco, chicago all leap to mind... unless you're going for boring, then pittsburg, cleveland, omaha.....

otb

lmao!!

According to the report;

Pittsburgh was the top U.S. city with 29th place — just ahead of Honolulu — while Los Angeles moved up three places to 44th and New York held onto the 56th spot.
 
I guess it depends on how you measure things.
The recent Demographia study, an annual effort to rate the affordability of housing markets in global metropolitan areas, saw Vancouver emerge as the least affordable housing market in Canada. Toronto was listed as seriously unaffordable. A quick glance at p. 8 and 15 of the report gives you those stats.
http://www.demographia.com/dhi.pdf

Of course it depends on how you measure things. The Demographia study looked at housing alone, thus the tittle,

"7th Annual Demographia International Housing Affordability Survey:2011", one factor.

The Economist took as many as 30 factors into calculating the list, including a combination of healthcare, culture, environment, education, personal safety, stability, and infrastructure. I'd say it's a more complete study.
 
Imagine where we'd be if you took out the gang related shootings, death, stabbings, swarmings, fire bombings, home invasions, robberies etc out of our major cities.

Well you can't go much higher than 1st.

Notice that the top 10 cities might be described as left leaning government styles and societies, although I'm not too familiar with Vienna.

1. Vancouver, Canada
2. Melbourne, Australia
3. Vienna, Austria
4. Toronto, Canada
5. Calgary, Canada
6. Helsinki, Finland
7. Sydney, Australia
8. Perth, Australia
8. Adelaide, Australia
10. Auckland, New Zealand

Since the realignment of New Zealand to a much stronger user pay system in the late 80's(?), the socialist leaning system might be consider less of a factor, but it is still considered a socialist system like Australia and Canada.
 
I guess it depends on how you measure things.

If it was just crime and tranquil life style, you could end up with Cow Lick PEI rating number one. My problem is that they don't grade in number of dance clubs, strip clubs, MP's, SP's , nude beaches, and inversely - morality squad 'dickiness'. Unless my dick was cutoff, I can't imagine living in an area with no access to pussy.
 
I award Blackrock the lunch-time Stating the Bleeding Obvious award. Of course it is a study of housing affordability, you nitwit, which is how I introduced it.

The point, lost on the Blackrocks of the world busy basking in their serfdom, is that while the cities identified are clearly decent cities, many of them are failing to provide affordable housing. This is an economic and social problem, and it does not go away just because the same city fares well in other measures. It is shallow thinking, to coin a metaphor, to be so blinded by shiny trinkets that you cannot discuss dark underbellies.

Not lost at all and that why I posted what I did.

You were the one who brought up a study looking at one aspect of life in a city, not even knowing whether or not that same aspect was taken into account in the Economists' study. I only listed the 7 factors reported in the news releases, as I've been unable to find a complete list.
 
Pittsburgh as the Top US City... that's a joke.
(with apologies to Stealers fans.... I was rooting for you)

OTB

i was under the impression that pittsburg really cleaned up their act...it is a beautiful city, no?..with those 3 rivers running through it....it must be mighty fine....any of our American members want to chime in?
 
A more complete listing of the factors (note the hi-light in Cat 5);

Category 1: Stability (weight: 25% of total)

Indicator Source
Prevalence of petty crime EIU rating
Prevalence of violent crime EIU rating
Threat of terror EIU rating
Threat of military conflict EIU rating
Threat of civil unrest/conflict EIU rating

Category 2: Healthcare (weight: 20% of total)

Indicator Source
Availability of private healthcare EIU rating
Quality of private healthcare EIU rating
Availability of public healthcare EIU rating
Quality of public healthcare EIU rating
Availability of over-the-counter drugs EIU rating
General healthcare indicators Adapted from World Bank

Category 3: Culture & Environment (weight: 25% of total)

Indicator Source
Humidity/temperature rating Adapted from average weather conditions
Discomfort of climate to travellers EIU rating
Level of corruption Adapted from Transparency International
Social or religious restrictions EIU rating
Level of censorship EIU rating
Sporting availability EIU field rating of 3 sport indicators
Cultural availability EIU field rating of 4 cultural indicators
Food and drink EIU field rating of 4 cultural indicators
Consumer goods and services EIU rating of product availability

Category 4: Education (weight: 10% of total)

Indicator Source
Availability of private education EIU rating
Quality of private education EIU rating
Public education indicators Adapted from World Bank

Category 5: Infrastructure (weight: 20% of total)

Indicator Source
Quality of road network EIU rating
Quality of public transport EIU rating
Quality of international links EIU rating
Availability of good quality housing EIU rating
Quality of energy provision EIU rating
Quality of water provision EIU rating
Quality of telecommunications EIU rating

More on methodology, http://www.eiu.com/site_info.asp?info_name=The_Global_Liveability_Report_Methodology&page=noads
 
I'm trusting, Blackrock, that you are reasonable enough to put more weight on the study I cited than the EIU study, when it comes to affordable housing. One line saying good quality housing, wherein the methodology section just says they used in house reps making judgments plus some field correspondents, hardly outweighs an entire study devoted to housing affordability, which outlines an actual methodology. This is not a point about the entire EIU study, just about the fact that a more methodologically transparent study of one of the indices (housing affordability) suggests there is a problem going unadressed in cities that otherwise fare well in cross-city livability measures.

I also think JustSex's humorous response makes the same point I did earlier. It depends upon how you measure things!

You're commenting on apples and oranges. Of course the EIU study won't go into the depth of the DEMO study, that wasn't its purpose, but you seemed to be trying to downplay the EUI report by saying it didn't take in affordable/quality housing as a factor. Apparently it did.

In the spirit of TERB, they also didn't take inn the quality of pooning in the various cities so it missed an important fact in judging the quality of life. in some eyes that might make it a flawed study. Geeeesh! We also don't get a view of JustSex's poon-centric life style.
 
Of course it depends on how you measure things. The Demographia study looked at housing alone, thus the tittle,

"7th Annual Demographia International Housing Affordability Survey:2011", one factor.

The Economist took as many as 30 factors into calculating the list, including a combination of healthcare, culture, environment, education, personal safety, stability, and infrastructure. I'd say it's a more complete study.
But the Demographia numbers might be read as proof of The Economist's ranking, with prices rising due to demand from those wanting to live in such fine places.
 
Nope, not saying that. I'm saying just what I said above. Do you wish to refute the Demographia studies' findings? If not, then you have to temper the praise of the EUI study by noting that while it might indicate livable as opposed to avoidable cities, unaffordable housing might be an issue in it's own right. Two studies, measuring different things. If I am to move cities I would take account of the EUI study. But if I wanted to wonder about the fate of the middle and working classes of many nations, I would take into account the Demographia study. Multi-tasking, grasshopper, multi-tasking.

We're guys, I think, it can't be done, but that's another thread.
 
But the Demographia numbers might be read as proof of The Economist's ranking, with prices rising due to demand from those wanting to live in such fine places.

Somebody gets it. There are parts of some of my favorite cities that can't be had by those who are well heeled; gentrification. The EIU report does touch on that, but only as part of the larger picture.

There are grand cities that have affordable housing in spades, but I wouldn't allow my pets in them.
 
Not to mention somewhat legalized prostitution, at a reasonable price!

The one thing perhaps missing from the list is economy: Pittsburgh does not sound like a great place to be looking for a job. I think if you gave greater weight to economic factors New York would rise up higher in the list.
 
i was under the impression that pittsburg really cleaned up their act...it is a beautiful city, no?..with those 3 rivers running through it....it must be mighty fine....any of our American members want to chime in?

Since the steel industry left it is much cleaner.... it's just a little boring at night.... Nice place to live, don't get me wrong, but nicest city in the US - not even in the top 10.

OTB