We deserve better...

elmo

Registered User
Oct 23, 2002
4,719
5
0
here and there
There have been a few threads recently where posters have, despite their political stripe, agreed on the fact that we as taxpayers deserve better representation and performance from our elected officials.

This thread is not about your political stripe so please try to keep that out of it. It's about our system and the sad lack of leadership in the municipal, provincial and federal levels of government, the fact that many of the issues we currently face are a result of historic blunders by politicians of all parties and the fact that there are no clear leaders going forward.

The questions: what can be done about it? How do we get better?
 
"We" get the politicians we deserve.

The fact is, most people are disconnected from politics and government - they would rather sit back, watch the train wreck happening and then complain after-the-fact. Then the media (complicit in this as well) move on to the next story and the public's interest wanes. All of which is exactly what politicians want.

Public participation isn't that hard; most people are just too stupid and/or lazy to take part.
 
In one nutshell: Do everything possible to eliminate political parties from the picture. If we can't do that, then we need to do everything possible to make parties seriously responsible to the democratic system, ahead of their fund-raisers. Anything that makes parties less the tool of their insiders and more of an avenue for citizens and politicians to communicate would be an improvement. But the best would be actual dialogues between government member and citizens without the artificial and distorting mechanisms of party getting in the way.

When Parliament looks more like a debating society and less like the highschool cheerleading contest it is now, we'll be on the way.
 
"We" get the politicians we deserve.

The fact is, most people are disconnected from politics and government - they would rather sit back, watch the train wreck happening and then complain after-the-fact. Then the media (complicit in this as well) move on to the next story and the public's interest wanes. All of which is exactly what politicians want.

Public participation isn't that hard; most people are just too stupid and/or lazy to take part.

In one nutshell: Do everything possible to eliminate political parties from the picture. If we can't do that, then we need to do everything possible to make parties seriously responsible to the democratic system, ahead of their fund-raisers. Anything that makes parties less the tool of their insiders and more of an avenue for citizens and politicians to communicate would be an improvement. But the best would be actual dialogues between government member and citizens without the artificial and distorting mechanisms of party getting in the way.

When Parliament looks more like a debating society and less like the highschool cheerleading contest it is now, we'll be on the way.

Hear hear!

(Especially that part about making politicians responsible for their actions!)
 
I guess what I'm asking is how do we get the political parties to put better candidates in front of us? I agree we get what we deserve when we vote but when the pickings are slim our odds on getting good representation are bad from the outset.
 
I guess what I'm asking is how do we get the political parties to put better candidates in front of us? I agree we get what we deserve when we vote but when the pickings are slim our odds on getting good representation are bad from the outset.

Again, public participation... Stop sitting back and waiting.
 
Lack of quality candidates IMO is a big part of the problem. It seems that some of the people entering politics would never make it in the business world. The people that have the leadership, communication and decision making skills needed for politics don't run for office; they build their own business or stick with the corporate world.

One of things that needs to be in place in Canada is recall voting. If a politician does something dumb, we should have the power to fire them just like the corporate world.
 
I guess what I'm asking is how do we get the political parties to put better candidates in front of us? I agree we get what we deserve when we vote but when the pickings are slim our odds on getting good representation are bad from the outset.
I still think we have to begin by losing the assumption that political parties are necessary or do anything useful for us citizens.

If we don't think the party candidates are any good, nominate and vote for an independent. Every single City Councillor and the Mayor is an independent, and most of the time municipal government functions as well, if not better than either provincial or federal. Parties are useful for a PM or Premier, because the keep her or him in power; they're useful climbing structures for pols who want power. They offer us voters only choices that are far too simple for our own good, and deliver us like windfalls to the party hacks who wrote the promises they'll never deliver. Nothing else.

Refuse to play their party-game, vote for the best person, get them to run if they aren't, and insist all those you talk with get past party labels and deal with facts and issues.
 
I still think we have to begin by losing the assumption that political parties are necessary or do anything useful for us citizens.

If we don't think the party candidates are any good, nominate and vote for an independent. Every single City Councillor and the Mayor is an independent, and most of the time municipal government functions as well, if not better than either provincial or federal. Parties are useful for a PM or Premier, because the keep her or him in power; they're useful climbing structures for pols who want power. They offer us voters only choices that are far too simple for our own good, and deliver us like windfalls to the party hacks who wrote the promises they'll never deliver. Nothing else.

Refuse to play their party-game, vote for the best person, get them to run if they aren't, and insist all those you talk with get past party labels and deal with facts and issues.

Interesting in theory, how would we candidates to talk past party labels and deal with facts from a practical perspective?
 
Lack of quality candidates IMO is a big part of the problem. It seems that some of the people entering politics would never make it in the business world. The people that have the leadership, communication and decision making skills needed for politics don't run for office; they build their own business or stick with the corporate world.

One of things that needs to be in place in Canada is recall voting. If a politician does something dumb, we should have the power to fire them just like the corporate world.
We might disagree about who has what abilities, but it is certainly true that many choose between politics and business (leaving aside other possible choices of arts, agriculture, religion education, the law medicine or the trades) as if they were exclusive, when we'd likely all benefit from experienced people from one field, taking their expertise an knowledge to the other—and back—more often.

I'm not so much in favour of recall; pols need the confidence and security to push through hard and not always popular measures. I am against people making a career of political office-hopping never doing any really significant good, just never fucking up either. And then there's the Putin model. Like recall and term-limits—another remedy often proposed—I think the regular elections are the best place to deal with such things, rather than arbitrary laws and rules. Again, if we had less important party attachments, some of these hackeries would wither, to the extent they do not, some versions of recall, term limits and such might help. But let's beware simple solutions.
 
I still think we have to begin by losing the assumption that political parties are necessary or do anything useful for us citizens.

If we don't think the party candidates are any good, nominate and vote for an independent. Every single City Councillor and the Mayor is an independent, and most of the time municipal government functions as well, if not better than either provincial or federal. Parties are useful for a PM or Premier, because the keep her or him in power; they're useful climbing structures for pols who want power. They offer us voters only choices that are far too simple for our own good, and deliver us like windfalls to the party hacks who wrote the promises they'll never deliver. Nothing else.

Refuse to play their party-game, vote for the best person, get them to run if they aren't, and insist all those you talk with get past party labels and deal with facts and issues.

An independent would not be able to get anything done in the current party system. It is true that councillors and the mayor are supposed to be independents, but it seems that the current administration punishes people for actually making independent decisions.
 
An independent would not be able to get anything done in the current party system. It is true that councillors and the mayor are supposed to be independents, but it seems that the current administration punishes people for actually making independent decisions.

I'm sure that's true of most administrations, let's keep on topic.
 
In one nutshell: Do everything possible to eliminate political parties from the picture. If we can't do that, then we need to do everything possible to make parties seriously responsible to the democratic system, ahead of their fund-raisers. Anything that makes parties less the tool of their insiders and more of an avenue for citizens and politicians to communicate would be an improvement. But the best would be actual dialogues between government member and citizens without the artificial and distorting mechanisms of party getting in the way.

When Parliament looks more like a debating society and less like the highschool cheerleading contest it is now, we'll be on the way.

This is exactly how it should be no political sides just the right decision on a issue. Plus if they as elected officials screw up they are gone and their pay ends, no lavish contracts.
 
I'm sure that's true of most administrations, let's keep on topic.
I think that is on topic. The Ford-Ainslie brouhaha is an example of punishing independent thinking outside of parties. The last session of Parliament had several of punishing within a party, and the unending string of personal attack ads speaks to how some view any dissent and the lengths they'll go to smear and disable it.

I'd blame the teaching example of party discipline plainly evident in Queens Park and on Parliament Hill, where any dissent, reasonable or not is crushed as quickly and completely as possible for the latest City Hall embarrasment. The logical outcome is always that the Party, and everyone must speak the Leader's mind and only the Leader's. All concept of debate, as an open contest of contending ideas to arrive at a better place together than any single person could have reached alone has been lost. Instead anything but the party-line is viewed as dangerous to the Party/Leader. So Ainslie was attacked for the sin of thinking for himself and voting independently of his leader. In Ottawa it's called Cabinet solidarity, in Toronto's Executive Committee it has no special name, but the punitive consequences clearly go beyond, "you can't be part of our team any more" as the game is being played today.

It's the same either-or deathtrap that the two-party system inevitably produces and no one more loves to follow American models—like the two party deadlock in the process of wrecking US politics for a long time to come—than the average Toronto conservative. "If you aren't with us, you are an enemy to be crushed, for we—us guys in the red/blue/black/brown shirts—must win". Which makes all the rest of us losers.

Before gave in to the metaphors of war and football that Rove and his ilk so love, we used to boast to the Russkies and other oppressed nations that in democracy we all win. Not with parties the way we run them these days we don't. Not even in the bits of politics where we still pretend there are no parties.
 
Another thing we should keep in mind is that there really is no such thing as a truly "independent" candidate. We naturally group ourselves with people that think like us, have similar values, etc. and it takes a many people to get anything done. You can't tackle political issues independently and you need to work with a group. I don't think abolishing parties will have any effect since people will naturally form their own groups. If there is one thing that the Ford brothers need to learn, it's how to work with other people even when they disagree with you. Publicly chastising others (actually lying about them) is not the way to get anything done.
 
A lot of the decisions politicians make have long timelines before the outcomes are determined. These timelines need to be taken into account at the front end , with the longer term impacts at least reasonably considered. Decisions should be attached to the people that actually made them. If say in 2002 a decision was taken by a certain group of politicians and today that decision goes wrong , horribly wrong, or something negligent is proven , then those politicians need to be punished. If its over budget or the penalty clauses kick in, they lose their pension or something-- as an idea. If a business person fucks up, they go down. Same should hold for politicians.

What Im trying to suggest is that there has to be downside to bad decisions other than not being reelected. It pisses me off when these incompetent partisans get a cushy job at an elite law firm or lobbying shop- without consequence of prior action. Right now it seems like its all upside and a lifetime pass to rivers of flowing money once you are connected.
 
A lot of the decisions politicians make have long timelines before the outcomes are determined. These timelines need to be taken into account at the front end , with the longer term impacts at least reasonably considered. Decisions should be attached to the people that actually made them. If say in 2002 a decision was taken by a certain group of politicians and today that decision goes wrong , horribly wrong, or something negligent is proven , then those politicians need to be punished. If its over budget or the penalty clauses kick in, they lose their pension or something-- as an idea. If a business person fucks up, they go down. Same should hold for politicians.

What Im trying to suggest is that there has to be downside to bad decisions other than not being reelected. It pisses me off when these incompetent partisans get a cushy job at an elite law firm or lobbying shop- without consequence of prior action. Right now it seems like its all upside and a lifetime pass to rivers of flowing money once you are connected.

Um. Well that's not really how it works in business. Many a CEO have walked away from a business with a "golden parachute" to make an politico salivate.

But to how to get qualified people. We need to get back to when it was a calling and not a career. When people would go up for the sessions of parliment then home to their businesses. A nation was built on both sides of the border by a lot of part-time politicians. Get rid of pensions for them outright. And term limits.

One one question is do we need to increase representation in a case like this. The argument could go both ways.
 
Good question. Unfortunately, as long as there are; partisan politics, pandering to special interest groups, a lack of interest from genuinely interested people to seek office, and no regard for the taxpayer, we will always have shitty governments at all levels.
 
Well, we're not going to get better. There are many here who hate Rob Ford, and just as many who like him, but his situation will be a lesson for all. A political outsider, someone who made a career in the real world, decided to try to make his world a better place only to be crucified by every insider within the province. At the same time, Olivia Chow, a political lifer who has accomplished absolutely nothing in the real world, is favoured to be Toronto's next mayor. The sheep don't want better, just the right lies from the right insider.