We All Missed It. part deaux

blackrock13

Banned
Jun 6, 2009
40,049
1
0
I'm posting this here as I think it's important for some of us who don't cross over to the darker side and read the P&IA section of this BB, to remember something that happened not too long ago. It doesn't need discussion here in the lounge as there's plenty of room elsewhere and we wouldn't want two threads on the same subject going a once, heavens.

It amazed me that with all the doom and gloom that gets batted around on this BB, that an anniversary of a a very scary moment in world history, came and went and not a mention, even by our US contributors. I missed it and it's something that surfaces every so often in my mind, briefly.

On Oct 23 1962, we were within 30 ft. and approximately 15 seconds of a nuclear war. If it hadn't been for a clear thinking soviet sub commander, who basically said if I do this, hell will be let loose on this planet and he said 'niet', not this time.

Cool heads prevailed in Moscow and Washington and backed away.

I was reminded of it because I began to watch CNN's Latinos in America.
 
General "Buck" Turgidson said it best.

"I'm not a sentimentalist at all, by nature, but I think I know what's in every heart in this room. I think we ought to all just bow our heads and give a short prayer of thanks for our deliverance.

Lord, we have heard the wings of the angel of death fluttering over our heads from the valley of fear. You have seen fit to deliver us from the forces of evil..."

jwm
 
There were several close calls during the cold war. Some were by shear stupidity and some by coincidence. If we knew them all, I'm sure we wouldn't sleep at night.
 
you can either go through life worrying about what might have been, or you can lead your life as if nothing is wrong...your choice.

Better than any man made crisis or close call, we were narrowly missed by a "planet killer" meteorite last year too.....(aka the movie Armageddon).

Our days are numbered, how are YOU going to spend them?
 
you can either go through life worrying about what might have been, or you can lead your life as if nothing is wrong...your choice.

Better than any man made crisis or close call, we were narrowly missed by a "planet killer" meteorite last year too.....(aka the movie Armageddon).

Our days are numbered, how are YOU going to spend them?

What your definition of 'nearly'? I suspect different than mine.

Armageddon was an interesting fun movie but seriously flawed, especially with the solution at the end. The last thing you want to do is destroy the asteroid into smaller bits, as it becomes more deadly, think sub-munitions. if your going to do it, the result would have to be more like teanny tiny little itsy bitsy bits that burn up in the atmosphere as most do today and that would be tough. If the killer 'roid is going to happen bend over and kiss you cheeks goodbye. OR go to sleep and wake up tomorrow.
 
If you want to talk about potential threats, right now we would be under Nazi rule if any one of the following took place.

1) Germany was moving in for the kill on Britain during WW2. Nazi's were systematically taking out the air warning systems and aircraft, estimated within 2 weeks of its collapse. Winston Churchill decided to piss off Hitler by bombing Berlin, of which made him irate. All concentrations were then put to bombing London of which gave time to recover all damaged air defenses and prepare for D-day.

Without the foothold of Britain there would have been no close assembly point to make an effective invasion of Europe.

2) Again Hitler was anxious to take over his nemesis Stalin therefore attacked Poland in preparation for Barbarossa during a simultaneous assult on Britian.

By taking Poland Hitler created a two front war which significantly depleted his attacks. Nobody was strong enough in a one on one against Germany during that time.

3) Hitler screwed up again, anxious to take Moscow he got his armies headed for Stalingrad en-route to Moscow. This turned out to be a stalemate until the supplies ran out.

Hitlers generals all advised him to put a priority on taking the oil fields in southern Russia which would have given them the power to take on all of Russia and hamper the Soviet war machine.

In all three cases were of decisions that were incorrectly made with the passion to conquer by an extreme force. The best part is we live in a free society because of it.
 
If you want to talk about potential threats, right now we would be under Nazi rule if any one of the following took place.

1) Germany was moving in for the kill on Britain during WW2. Nazi's were systematically taking out the air warning systems and aircraft, estimated within 2 weeks of its collapse. Winston Churchill decided to piss off Hitler by bombing Berlin, of which made him irate. All concentrations were then put to bombing London of which gave time to recover all damaged air defenses and prepare for D-day.

Without the foothold of Britain there would have been no close assembly point to make an effective invasion of Europe.

2) Again Hitler was anxious to take over his nemesis Stalin therefore attacked Poland in preparation for Barbarossa during a simultaneous assult on Britian.

By taking Poland Hitler created a two front war which significantly depleted his attacks. Nobody was strong enough in a one on one against Germany during that time.

3) Hitler screwed up again, anxious to take Moscow he got his armies headed for Stalingrad en-route to Moscow. This turned out to be a stalemate until the supplies ran out.

Hitlers generals all advised him to put a priority on taking the oil fields in southern Russia which would have given them the power to take on all of Russia and hamper the Soviet war machine.

In all three cases were of decisions that were incorrectly made with the passion to conquer by an extreme force. The best part is we live in a free society because of it.

1) The Germans had already started bombing London. In fact the bombing of Berlin was a reprisal, and a direct consequence of Herr Goering's bravado (just call him Meyer). You are right, the RAF was on the verge of collapse, but Hitler still needed to cross the channel and with the Royal Navy and shore defenses, it was not a slam dunk. Remember, they had no landing craft, and did not have enough shipping to move the troops required.

2) Hitler attacked Poland in 1939, with the Russians attacking from the East. Poland was conquered and Hitler moved the same divisions to the West to attack France. There were not 2 fronts this early in the war, so the point is moot. If Britain and France had attacked from the West while the bulk of the Wehrmacht was tied up in Poland, the war would have been over with Allied troops in Berlin by the end of October. He had nothing to stop them with on the Western front.

3) Agreed, he could have stretched the war in the East out another 2-3 years if he had done that. It still would not have been enough. The Russians would eventually have defeated them, even on their own (they still had access to the Middle East). You could argue that his 6 week Balkan diversion also left him without enough time to make it to the Urals before winter. Either way, the Russians had more manpower and industrial capacity, and raw materials.
 
1) The Germans had already started bombing London. In fact the bombing of Berlin was a reprisal, and a direct consequence of Herr Goering's bravado (just call him Meyer). You are right, the RAF was on the verge of collapse, but Hitler still needed to cross the channel and with the Royal Navy and shore defenses, it was not a slam dunk. Remember, they had no landing craft, and did not have enough shipping to move the troops required.

2) Hitler attacked Poland in 1939, with the Russians attacking from the East. Poland was conquered and Hitler moved the same divisions to the West to attack France. There were not 2 fronts this early in the war, so the point is moot. If Britain and France had attacked from the West while the bulk of the Wehrmacht was tied up in Poland, the war would have been over with Allied troops in Berlin by the end of October. He had nothing to stop them with on the Western front.

3) Agreed, he could have stretched the war in the East out another 2-3 years if he had done that. It still would not have been enough. The Russians would eventually have defeated them, even on their own (they still had access to the Middle East). You could argue that his 6 week Balkan diversion also left him without enough time to make it to the Urals before winter. Either way, the Russians had more manpower and industrial capacity, and raw materials.

1) Yes there was some bombing of London but the primary goal was to crush the air defenses until the bombings in Berlin.

2) There was no attacks against Germany prior to the Poland invasion. There were treaty's between Germany and all the eastern block countries. Hitler only needed to use minimal coverage on the east protection.

3) Due to the timing Russia wouldn't have been able to stop the onslaught of a fully supplied German army (they were capable of taking 100 miles per day with their mechanized attacks, this is a role model for modern army tactics).
 
1) Yes there was some bombing of London but the primary goal was to crush the air defenses until the bombings in Berlin.

2) There was no attacks against Germany prior to the Poland invasion. There were treaty's between Germany and all the eastern block countries. Hitler only needed to use minimal coverage on the east protection.

3) Due to the timing Russia wouldn't have been able to stop the onslaught of a fully supplied German army (they were capable of taking 100 miles per day with their mechanized attacks, this is a role model for modern army tactics).

1) Agreed. Then Goering pride was severely wounded, as was Hitler's

2) The French and British could have been in Berlin in 2 weeks while the Germans were tied up in Poland. They could not move their units back West fast enough. Would have ended the war the same year it began.

3) The German advance was slowing as their supply lines lengthened, also a fact of quick advances. You need to consolidate periodically, and cannot maintain that level of advance indefinitely. And the issue is as they advanced, their front got longer, opening them up to counter-attack. They could not be strong every where, which was proven when they were cut off at Stalingrad.

Again, Russian industry was producing more planes and more tanks each month, and they had more manpower. Eventually that would have taken it's toll. And they advanced across the "flat". Fighting through the Urals would have been an entirely different story.

I love these mental exercises of what if! Can you tell I've studied history? Thanks for the intelligent debate!
 
1) Agreed. Then Goering pride was severely wounded, as was Hitler's

2) The French and British could have been in Berlin in 2 weeks while the Germans were tied up in Poland. They could not move their units back West fast enough. Would have ended the war the same year it began.

3) The German advance was slowing as their supply lines lengthened, also a fact of quick advances. You need to consolidate periodically, and cannot maintain that level of advance indefinitely. And the issue is as they advanced, their front got longer, opening them up to counter-attack. They could not be strong every where, which was proven when they were cut off at Stalingrad.

Again, Russian industry was producing more planes and more tanks each month, and they had more manpower. Eventually that would have taken it's toll. And they advanced across the "flat". Fighting through the Urals would have been an entirely different story.

I love these mental exercises of what if! Can you tell I've studied history? Thanks for the intelligent debate!

Agree to a point on all above.

I did study WW2 in depth as well from both the Allies and German perspective. I even got to see banned German propaganda films. Very powerfull and mind controlling stuff.

Ok, for Brill Hitler discussion is over.
 
Agree to a point on all above.

I did study WW2 in depth as well from both the Allies and German perspective. I even got to see banned German propaganda films. Very powerfull and mind controlling stuff.

Ok, for Brill Hitler discussion is over.

Me too! I took a course once on propaganda, and obviously Nazi Germany was studied. After all, how many regimes have a "Minister of Propaganda"?
 
Me too! I took a course once on propaganda, and obviously Nazi Germany was studied. After all, how many regimes have a "Minister of Propaganda"?

Never under estimate propaganda, the most powerful thing you can do is to have everyone focused on the same goal, even if it was pretty atrocious.

I was lucky enough to see the German propaganda films because of my History teacher was a comm officer in a tank. When they liberated Berlin they found a bunch of the films and brought back.
 
Never under estimate propaganda, the most powerful thing you can do is to have everyone focused on the same goal, even if it was pretty atrocious.

I was lucky enough to see the German propaganda films because of my History teacher was a comm officer in a tank. When they liberated Berlin they found a bunch of the films and brought back.

wow, talk about a primary source. Was it still in film or had it been trnsfered.

One of the most amazing things I've seen and on two ocassions, was WWII colourd film of the war and also every day life. It really plays with the mind after all the b/w film watched over the years. The Russian and Germns filmed EVERYTHING and the Germans kept meticulous records 'of course'. That was one of their downfalls at the Nuremberg trials. Even the allies had loads of colour film.
 
wow, talk about a primary source. Was it still in film or had it been trnsfered.

One of the most amazing things I've seen and on two ocassions, was WWII colourd film of the war and also every day life. It really plays with the mind after all the b/w film watched over the years. The Russian and Germns filmed EVERYTHING and the Germans kept meticulous records 'of course'. That was one of their downfalls at the Nuremberg trials. Even the allies had loads of colour film.

Most of the footage was pre war heavily documenting the marches and rallies, a little bit on the Hitler youth. The craziest was how it showed how all women were encouraged to have sex with German service men on leave to increase the population of the pure Aryan race. Oh it was b/w I think 8mm. I seen it 20+ years ago, at the time he was retiring so I would assume he has passed by now, but this left a lasting impression on me.
 
Germany should have pulverized Russia next after Poland..... Just obliterated them scorched earth style along with Japan. Secured the oil & resources so that the Americans coudln't starve Japan into attacking them to get into the war...

Regroup, entrench & THEN carpetbomb the fuck out of England while marching oa path to Calais... By the time London & the defenses were smashed they could take the short trip over to turn it into another fortified base...

Smaller sabotage teams could have been sent to smaller targets to soften them up for destruction by air...

The world could have been theirs but they completely fucked it up...
 
if you want to talk about potential threats, right now we would be under nazi rule if any one of the following took place.

1) germany was moving in for the kill on britain during ww2. Nazi's were systematically taking out the air warning systems and aircraft, estimated within 2 weeks of its collapse. Winston churchill decided to piss off hitler by bombing berlin, of which made him irate. All concentrations were then put to bombing london of which gave time to recover all damaged air defenses and prepare for d-day.

+1...