LancsLad said:Agreed... I am a supporter of the Fraser Institute ( no surprise there) and their publications have highlighted the travesty that is the Professional Indian that leads the high life syphoning off the guilt money.
james t kirk said:No different than Israel.
hyperbole said:Can we cool it with the "Injun" slurs? These people are human beings. Tragically misguided human beings but human beings all the same.
hyperbole
james t kirk said:With regard to the issue of the land in Caledonia, my sympathies lay with the Indians. They obviously feel very strongly about this and they have mobilized en masse to stop a development of some idiotic subdivision because they know (and they are right) that if those houses are built, they can kiss that land goodbye forever. If they didn't feel strongly about it, they could have never massed the kind of force that they have.
A very simple settlement in my eyes would be for the gov't to buy the land in question from the developer and give it to the indians.
Yeah yeah yeah, I can hear you all now saying that you can't give into terrorists, but the fact of the matter is that the Indians are simply not going to back down. So lets do right by them at a very small cost.
In fact, in 1812, the British gov't promised the Indians that if they fought with Britain in that war against the Americans that Britain would give the Indians a large area of land to live in as their own country. (It was supposed to be Michigan in fact.)
KWI said:So I guess all the others slurs are okay as well. N*****, W**, CH***, should I go on? It is a slur and you just don't care because you are looking at the $$ and it pisses you off. Why not just admit that? Much better then making a lame excuse of how it is not a racial slur when we all know it is.
KWI
james t kirk said:Having read all the posts here, I feel I must disagree with the tone of most of them.
The indians have historically come up with the short end of the stick. They were here first and the Europeans basically came here and took over the place. Rightly or wrongly, this is a fact of history. The indians were not in a position to oppose it with any kind of success, they weren't set up for it, nor advanced enough.
With regard to the issue of the land in Caledonia, my sympathies lay with the Indians. They obviously feel very strongly about this and they have mobilized en masse to stop a development of some idiotic subdivision because they know (and they are right) that if those houses are built, they can kiss that land goodbye forever. If they didn't feel strongly about it, they could have never massed the kind of force that they have.
They (the Indians and the gov't) have been talking forever and nothing has been settled; meanwhile, the developer's shovels are working away.
A very simple settlement in my eyes would be for the gov't to buy the land in question from the developer and give it to the indians.
Yeah yeah yeah, I can hear you all now saying that you can't give into terrorists, but the fact of the matter is that the Indians are simply not going to back down. So lets do right by them at a very small cost.
And by the way, I resent them being labelled as terrorists. That's a crock of shit, or maybe the word doesn't apply. If it weren't for the indians fighting with the British in 1812, we'd all be speaking American right now. And that's a fact.
In fact, in 1812, the British gov't promised the Indians that if they fought with Britain in that war against the Americans that Britain would give the Indians a large area of land to live in as their own country. (It was supposed to be Michigan in fact.)
Well, that never happened, the British broke their word on that one and other treaties too (see Sitting Bull).
So, if it takes buying a postage stamp sized parcel of land friom some developer and giving it to the Indians, so beit.
xdog said:it would take to learn american. lol. As far as I know, the British never broke any treaty with Sitting Bull. I believe SB dealt with the Americans.
I think that the natives have to decide, once and for all, if they want to be part of Canada or to be a sovereign nation. If they want to be part of Canada, they have to follow Canadian law. If they want to form their own country, let's give them the reserves and start-up money and let them be on their way.
Would I be allowed to go to court and state that some piece of land belonged to me because my great grandfather received it from someone? The first question that the judge would ask for is a copy of the contract. I would be SOL.
Like some previous posters have stated, we are all immigrants here. The natives emigrated from Asia a couple of thousand years ago. Let's not kid ourselves. The earlier natives fought amongst themselves for land and resources. Ask the Hurons how they were treated by the Iroquois.
It's easy to say"Give them the land and the problem will be solved" If it was so simple, why haven't anyone posting here offered to give up their land or money. It's ok for the gov't to do it because who sees that money anyway.
LancsLad said:...They are breaking the law plain and simple and should be dealt with quickly and with sufficient force that they will not be foolish enough to try and fight back.