War with Iran


Ok, we now have one accusation of groping as sexual assault.
That's it?

No rape, just groping a prisoner.
Like cops do with every criminal to check for weapons.

Is that all you've got?
And for the record, she should take those charges to court, like all charges of war crimes, occupation, genocide and apartheid.

Is it as bad as the treatment that the Israeli group, B'tselem detailed?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
Yes he is a liar, and a devious one. A guy that literally said with a straight face that Israel did "most" of the killing on October 7th, not Hamas.

After that, there isn't much to debate: you're dealing with a psychopathic Jew hater.

View attachment 629328

The Hannibal Directive is Israeli policy, kill everyone so that Hamas can't take hostages.
Its idiotic to deny that didn't mean they killed their own people.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
You seem more interested in arguing with the version of me you've invented than with what I've actually written.

I've explicitly said Israel has gone too far and that I oppose war crimes regardless of who commits them. The fact that I also hold Hamas responsible for initiating this war doesn't magically become an endorsement of every action Israel has taken.

Your entire argument boils down to: "Unless you agree with every one of my conclusions, you support genocide." That's not debate; it's me trying to have a conversation with a delusional person.

You can disagree with my views all you like, but repeatedly claiming I support genocide because I refuse to adopt your framing doesn't make it true. It just makes the accusation lose credibility but then again, denying the heinous war crimes HAMAS committed on OCT. 7th has completely blown your credibility.

I can definitely argue that you are promoting genocide by your refusal to back ICJ charges against Israeli leaders and your continual justification of the genocide through blaming the victims of the genocide and occupation.

It should be easy for someone to say they back international law, human rights and the idea of equality.
Following through with that should mean backing human rights reports, ICC, ICJ and UN findings and applying them to both sides.

On these threads you have not once been outraged by any Israeli acts and the most angered you get are by arguments that Hamas didn't rape and torture people the way that Israelis constantly do.

We still don't know the full fatalities, since Israel kills all journalists and blocks international aid and human rights workers.
Its quite likely that these numbers are correct, that Israel has killed 380,000 children.
You will read that and still blame Hamas.

 
First, have a read of this article:


Then have a peek here


This one too!!!



Given the opportunity, Hamas demonstrated on October 7 that it was willing to deliberately target and kill Israeli civilians, including children. That doesn't excuse the deaths of Palestinian children caused during Israel's military campaign, nor does it diminish their suffering. Civilian deaths on either side are tragic and deserve acknowledgment.

My point is simply that this conflict is not morally one-sided. Hamas has committed atrocities against civilians, and Israel's military actions have resulted in devastating civilian casualties. Both sides have blood on their hands, even if people disagree about the legal characterization of those actions.




If you are quoting Amnesty, why do you not back their findings on the Israeli genocide, apartheid and occupation?
 
Given the opportunity, Hamas demonstrated on October 7 that it was willing to deliberately target and kill Israeli civilians.....
Nobody is debating or justifying Hamas’ crimes on October 7. But so what if Hamas killed civilians? How does that justify Israeli genocide?
Whenever this is raised, you equivocate. The correct response is to condemn Israel.
Israel’s actions haven’t merely resulted in civilian deaths. Israel has deliberately KILLED civilians and demonstrated intent to do so.
Hamas committed an act of terrorism. These are different crimes, with different levels of moral culpability.
Israel is far more morally and legally culpable than Hamas.
That’s just a fact, not an opinion.
 
Nobody is debating or justifying Hamas’ crimes on October 7. But so what if Hamas killed civilians? How does that justify Israeli genocide?
Whenever this is raised, you equivocate. The correct response is to condemn Israel.
Israel’s actions haven’t merely resulted in civilian deaths. Israel has deliberately KILLED civilians and demonstrated intent to do so.
Hamas committed an act of terrorism. These are different crimes, with different levels of moral culpability.
Israel is far more morally and legally culpable than Hamas.
That’s just a fact, not an opinion.

Agreed, the correct moral and legal approach is to demand both sides be investigated and charged as warranted.
End the funding of genocide, end the occupation, give Palestinians full human rights and/or their country back.

The problem is that Israel supporters and zionists, like squeezer, do actually know that one day of war crimes by Hamas is nowhere near as evil as 3 years of genocide as part of 78 years of occupation and colonization.

 
Nobody is debating or justifying Hamas’ crimes on October 7. But so what if Hamas killed civilians? How does that justify Israeli genocide?
Whenever this is raised, you equivocate. The correct response is to condemn Israel.
Israel’s actions haven’t merely resulted in civilian deaths. Israel has deliberately KILLED civilians and demonstrated intent to do so.
Hamas committed an act of terrorism. These are different crimes, with different levels of moral culpability.
Israel is far more morally and legally culpable than Hamas.
That’s just a fact, not an opinion.


At least, unlike Franky, you acknowledge that Hamas committed serious crimes and carried out an act of terrorism on October 7. That's a good starting point.

So let me ask you a few straightforward questions.

Do you honestly believe that if October 7 had never happened, Israel would have launched the military campaign we've seen in Gaza? If your answer is no, then October 7 wasn't just another event it was the catalyst.

And is it really unreasonable to ask whether Hamas anticipated exactly this kind of response? History shows that armed groups sometimes seek to provoke overwhelming retaliation, knowing the political and diplomatic fallout can work to their advantage. Given Hamas's public statements and tactics over the years, it's a legitimate question whether they expected Israel to respond with massive force and believed the images of destruction would shift international opinion in their favour. Which, for the most part, it has.

None of that excuses Israel if it committed unlawful acts. Israel is responsible for its own decisions, just as Hamas is responsible for launching the attack that, in my opinion, triggered this war. Those aren't mutually exclusive positions.

What I find frustrating is that some people seem willing to analyze every Israeli decision while refusing to ask whether Hamas also had a strategy beyond simply carrying out a terrorist attack. If we're interested in understanding the conflict rather than reinforcing our own narratives, shouldn't we ask questions of all sides?

Goes back to "it takes two to tango"....<-----this one is mostly for Klatty!

ps...I will no longer be answering Klatty/Franky in this thread because it has been derailed once again and off topic.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
At least, unlike Franky, you acknowledge that Hamas committed serious crimes and carried out an act of terrorism on October 7. That's a good starting point.

So let me ask you a few straightforward questions.

Do you honestly believe that if October 7 had never happened, Israel would have launched the military campaign we've seen in Gaza? If your answer is no, then October 7 wasn't just another event it was the catalyst.

And is it really unreasonable to ask whether Hamas anticipated exactly this kind of response? History shows that armed groups sometimes seek to provoke overwhelming retaliation, knowing the political and diplomatic fallout can work to their advantage. Given Hamas's public statements and tactics over the years, it's a legitimate question whether they expected Israel to respond with massive force and believed the images of destruction would shift international opinion in their favour. Which, for the most part, it has.

None of that excuses Israel if it committed unlawful acts. Israel is responsible for its own decisions, just as Hamas is responsible for launching the attack that, in my opinion, triggered this war. Those aren't mutually exclusive positions.

What I find frustrating is that some people seem willing to analyze every Israeli decision while refusing to ask whether Hamas also had a strategy beyond simply carrying out a terrorist attack. If we're interested in understanding the conflict rather than reinforcing our own narratives, shouldn't we ask questions of all sides?

Goes back to "it takes two to tango"....<-----this one is mostly for Klatty!

ps...I will no longer be answering Klatty/Franky in this thread because it has been derailed once again and off topic.

My god, beneath all that insipid equivocation is nothing more than the grubby, low IQ wifebeater defense.
 
At least, unlike Franky, you acknowledge that Hamas committed serious crimes and carried out an act of terrorism on October 7. That's a good starting point.

So let me ask you a few straightforward questions.

Do you honestly believe that if October 7 had never happened, Israel would have launched the military campaign we've seen in Gaza? If your answer is no, then October 7 wasn't just another event it was the catalyst.

And is it really unreasonable to ask whether Hamas anticipated exactly this kind of response? History shows that armed groups sometimes seek to provoke overwhelming retaliation, knowing the political and diplomatic fallout can work to their advantage. Given Hamas's public statements and tactics over the years, it's a legitimate question whether they expected Israel to respond with massive force and believed the images of destruction would shift international opinion in their favour. Which, for the most part, it has.

None of that excuses Israel if it committed unlawful acts. Israel is responsible for its own decisions, just as Hamas is responsible for launching the attack that, in my opinion, triggered this war. Those aren't mutually exclusive positions.

What I find frustrating is that some people seem willing to analyze every Israeli decision while refusing to ask whether Hamas also had a strategy beyond simply carrying out a terrorist attack. If we're interested in understanding the conflict rather than reinforcing our own narratives, shouldn't we ask questions of all sides?

Goes back to "it takes two to tango"....<-----this one is mostly for Klatty!

ps...I will no longer be answering Klatty/Franky in this thread because it has been derailed once again and off topic.

C'mon squeezer, Hamas did commit war crimes on Oct 7 and should be investigated and charged for them. But not rape and torture, according to the real reports.
Was it terrorism? Hamas' goal was to capture prisoners to use in exchange for some of the 10,000 Palestinian hostages held by Israel. That's a war crime but its not terrorism. Did they intentionally target civilians, possibly, just as Israel has admitted they targeted civilians on Oct 7 with the Hannibal Doctrine. Same crime, if you want to call it terrorism call it terrorism by both sides. The law and legal terms should not be based on race.

In 2022 settlers stormed the Al Aqsa and Hamas responded.
That is exactly what happened before Oct 7, settlers stormed the Al Aqsa and Hamas responded.
Only in 2023 guards were sent home and Hamas got over the prison walls.


None of that excuses Israel if it committed unlawful acts.

You mean like illegally occupying Palestine and Gaza, multiple attacks on Gaza and a 20 year long blockade?
Even before Oct 7?

The problem with this line of debate is that you will not admit Israel has done anything unlawful.

 
Do you honestly believe that if October 7 had never happened, Israel would have launched the military campaign we've seen in Gaza?
Yes, we would have. On another day, using another pretext, as it's been for the last 80 years.
The difference is it would have been slower and more deliberate instead of psychotic and indiscriminate as we see now.
Israel's crimes in Gaza didn't start on October 7, 2023.
They've been ongoing for 80 years.
....October 7 wasn't just another event it was the catalyst.
Agreed. October 7, acted as a catalyst to hastening the already ongoing ethnic cleansing and genocide of Gaza.
And is it really unreasonable to ask whether Hamas anticipated exactly this kind of response?
Yes, it is not just unreasonable but downright criminal to commit genocide.
What I find frustrating is that some people seem willing to analyze every Israeli decision while refusing to ask whether Hamas also had a strategy beyond simply carrying out a terrorist attack. If we're interested in understanding the conflict rather than reinforcing our own narratives, shouldn't we ask questions of all sides?
Hamas definitely had an agenda and a strategy.
Which is why I asked a very pointed question after calling Hamas' actions war crimes and terrorism. Which is:
Regardless of Hamas' crimes, do you condemn the Israeli genocide? In other orders, is genocide EVER an acceptable response, regardless of the provocation?
PS: As far as Hamas' strategy goes, whether it was intended or unintended, one has to admit it opened the world's eyes to Israel's true nature.
It certainly did mine as I had no idea what Israel was upto all these decades.
 
At least, unlike Franky, you acknowledge that Hamas committed serious crimes and carried out an act of terrorism on October 7. That's a good starting point.

So let me ask you a few straightforward questions.

Do you honestly believe that if October 7 had never happened, Israel would have launched the military campaign we've seen in Gaza? If your answer is no, then October 7 wasn't just another event it was the catalyst.

And is it really unreasonable to ask whether Hamas anticipated exactly this kind of response? History shows that armed groups sometimes seek to provoke overwhelming retaliation, knowing the political and diplomatic fallout can work to their advantage. Given Hamas's public statements and tactics over the years, it's a legitimate question whether they expected Israel to respond with massive force and believed the images of destruction would shift international opinion in their favour. Which, for the most part, it has.
Bingo!!

Hamas 100% controls Gaza society and it publicly tortures and kills any Gazan who inconveniences it. Hamas is like a pyramid scheme - except participation is mandatory for Gazans. The whole purpose is to suck in foreign aid and to redistribute that foreign aid to the top echelon Hamassholes. The top elite Hamas guys who live in Qatar lick the bowl most fruitfully. Then there is a descending hierarchy of gobblers and bowl-lickers in Gaza itself.

To get a job as a doctor, lawyer, teacher or aid worker in Gaza, you have to be a Hamas loyalist. All "journalists" are simultaneously Hamas commanders. There is no deviation. Participation is mandatory if you want a job other than a labourer. Any turncoats are hunted down and tortured to death in the subterranean death cellars.

The jihad against Israel gives the corrupt, repressive violent Hamasshole regime surface credibility and purpose. And it keeps the foreign aid flowing, so the corrupt motherfuckers in Qatar can grift millions more each month.

7 Oct was perceived as a "win-win" by the Hamassholes. If they provoked a military invasion by the IDF, they could crank up international public sympathy from the Franks and Klatties. If Israel hesitated to invade Gaza, that in itself would be a win, as Hamas could then escalate to even bigger rape-torture-murder parties.

What Hamas didn't bargain on was a full-on invasion that widely trashed Gaza itself. But Hamas will now exploit the widespread destruction to prompt even more humanitarian aid, so the leeches in Qatar can get even more obscenely rich.

Give all your money, Frank-Ibn-Futah!!! Hamas needs more bullets, so it can shoot down Palestinian gays in the streets of Gaza City and then gang-rape their Arab sisters until they die from vaginal tearing!
 
Bingo!!

Hamas 100% controls Gaza society and it publicly tortures and kills any Gazan who inconveniences it. Hamas is like a pyramid scheme - except participation is mandatory for Gazans. The whole purpose is to suck in foreign aid and to redistribute that foreign aid to the top echelon Hamassholes. The guys who live in Qatar lick the bowl most fruitfully. Then there is a descending hierarchy of gobblers and bowl-lickers in Gaza itself.

To get a job as a doctor, lawyer, teacher or aid worker in Gaza, you have to be a Hamas loyalist. All "journalists" are simultaneously Hamas commanders. There is no deviation. Participation is mandatory if you want a job other than a labourer. Any turncoats are hunted down and tortured to death in the subterranean death cellars.

The jihad against Israel gives the corrupt, repressive violent Hamasshole regime surface credibility and purpose. And it keeps the foreign aid flowing, so the corrupt motherfuckers in Qatar can grift millions more each month.

7 Oct was perceived as a "win-win" by the Hamassholes. If they provoked a military invasion by the IDF, they could crank up international public sympathy from the Franks and Klatties. If Israel hesitated to invade Gaza, that in itself would be a win, as Hamas could then escalate to even bigger rape-torture-murder parties.

What Hamas didn't bargain on was a full-on invasion that widely trashed Gaza itself. But Hamas will now exploit the widespread destruction to prompt even more humanitarian aid, so the leeches in Qatar can get even more obscenely rich.

Give all your money, Frank-Ibn-Futah!!! Hamas needs more bullets, so it can shoot down Palestinian gays in the streets of Gaza City and then gang-rape their Arab sisters until they die from vaginal tearing!

Now that’s a whopper. I can’t believe you Zio’s think you can reset the narrative back to the old scripts. All you do is look pathetic and poorly educated trotting out the wifebeater defence. You lose people every time you post these tone deaf screeds.
 
Last edited:
Bingo!!

Hamas 100% controls Gaza society and it publicly tortures and kills any Gazan who inconveniences it. Hamas is like a pyramid scheme - except participation is mandatory for Gazans. The whole purpose is to suck in foreign aid and to redistribute that foreign aid to the top echelon Hamassholes. The top elite Hamas guys who live in Qatar lick the bowl most fruitfully. Then there is a descending hierarchy of gobblers and bowl-lickers in Gaza itself.

To get a job as a doctor, lawyer, teacher or aid worker in Gaza, you have to be a Hamas loyalist. All "journalists" are simultaneously Hamas commanders. There is no deviation. Participation is mandatory if you want a job other than a labourer. Any turncoats are hunted down and tortured to death in the subterranean death cellars.

The jihad against Israel gives the corrupt, repressive violent Hamasshole regime surface credibility and purpose. And it keeps the foreign aid flowing, so the corrupt motherfuckers in Qatar can grift millions more each month.

7 Oct was perceived as a "win-win" by the Hamassholes. If they provoked a military invasion by the IDF, they could crank up international public sympathy from the Franks and Klatties. If Israel hesitated to invade Gaza, that in itself would be a win, as Hamas could then escalate to even bigger rape-torture-murder parties.

What Hamas didn't bargain on was a full-on invasion that widely trashed Gaza itself. But Hamas will now exploit the widespread destruction to prompt even more humanitarian aid, so the leeches in Qatar can get even more obscenely rich.

Give all your money, Frank-Ibn-Futah!!! Hamas needs more bullets, so it can shoot down Palestinian gays in the streets of Gaza City and then gang-rape their Arab sisters until they die from vaginal tearing!

What a pathetic and hateful old man you've become.

People all over the world just want Israel to stop killing people and taking their land.
Instead we've got racists like you just sounding more and more vile.


 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Now that’s a whopper. I can’t believe you Zio’s think you can reset the narrative back to the old scripts.
It is the neo-con script.
They give you one reason first, fail to convince people and then flip to "But he is a bad guy!".
Examples:
Iraq: Started with WMDs, and when none were found, flipped to "Saddam is a bad guy"
Iran: Started with nukes as being the reason for war, and ended with "But the Iranian regime is brutal!"
Same with Hamas. Now they have flipped to how Hamas is bad, as if that explains away genocide. lmfao.