War with Iran

Some sp's are wacko right wingers, though most lean left and are interesting. Ever tried talking politics with Penelope of hush/sfto/secrets or wherever she is now? She's a wacko. I don't talk politics unless there is a clue that it won't be like talking to larue.

The Jewish community in town is split about 50/50 zionists and moral Jews. Your community sounds like it tends towards right wing weirdos, mine definitely skews left and I only know about 3 or 4 who still defend Israel. And they are feeling it. I expect you only have a couple of Jewish friends and they are either extreme right wingers or they don't talk politics to you ever. Like I won't talk politics with Penelope.

You're way off. The majority of my circle of friends and family are centre left. Work colleagues are 50/50 left and right, but the majority, even if they are Conservatives, are anti-Trump. I do agree the majority of sexworkers are left with the odd whacko MAGA. I actually have many Jewish friends and the majority side with Israel but are not a fan of Bibi. I also have quite a few Arab friends, and as to be expected, many are anti-Israel.




Israel has wiped Palestine off the maps and continues genocide in Palestine and Lebanon.
And you still argue they are the victims.

Your victim card is officially retracted.

You're the one who admitted you feel Israel should not exist.
 
Luckily for Israel, most Western countries and it would seem quite a few Gulf States do not agree with you and would probably prefer the Iran regime completely gutted and changed.

Most of the world says otherwise.
Israel should get the fark out of Palestine or give all Palestinians, including those in Gaza, full rights and the vote.
 
Luckily for Israel, most Western countries and it would seem quite a few Gulf States do not agree with you and would probably prefer the Iran regime completely gutted and changed.
Not true.
Yes, most Western nations are targets of Israeli lobbying and propaganda.
However, most residents of Western nations, are now seeing through this and even have politicians now calling for defunding Israel. You are going to see this get worse for Israel.
Most Gulf do not even formally recognize Israel as a state. Only UAE and Bahrain do.
Their opposition to Iran is purely regional rivalry and possibly religious sectarianism.
Their hatred of Israel however is far deeper and ideological.
Were they not so dependent on the west for money, they would readily stand opposed to Israel.
 
Luckily for Israel, most Western countries and it would seem quite a few Gulf States do not agree with you and would probably prefer the Iran regime completely gutted and changed.
I have no problem with Israel existing as is. An apartheid ethnostate. Thats their business. But they have to pay for it themselves.

The west did not give apartheid South Africa billions every year in free aid and weapons. Same with North Korea, a communist state.

I'm sure Saudi Arabia gets billions from the west every year for their oil. Thats trade, not aid. I have no problem with Israel buying all the weapons they want.

The truth is that the Zionists couldn't pull off half the shit they do (genocide in Gaza, war with all their neighbors) without US backing. They're like a spoilt brat that found daddy's gun.
 
Not true.
Yes, most Western nations are targets of Israeli lobbying and propaganda.
However, most residents of Western nations, are now seeing through this and even have politicians now calling for defunding Israel. You are going to see this get worse for Israel.
Most Gulf do not even formally recognize Israel as a state. Only UAE and Bahrain do.
Their opposition to Iran is purely regional rivalry and possibly religious sectarianism.
Their hatred of Israel however is far deeper and ideological.
Were they not so dependent on the west for money, they would readily stand opposed to Israel.

Bernie has a theory on why trump likes the gulf countries.
Israel has none of this, just dirt on trump.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal
Saudi Amarco Refinery that handles about 400,000 barrels a day is on fire due to Houthi attacks. That effectively takes it offline.
 
Not true.
Yes, most Western nations are targets of Israeli lobbying and propaganda.
However, most residents of Western nations, are now seeing through this and even have politicians now calling for defunding Israel. You are going to see this get worse for Israel.
Most Gulf do not even formally recognize Israel as a state. Only UAE and Bahrain do.
Their opposition to Iran is purely regional rivalry and possibly religious sectarianism.
Their hatred of Israel however is far deeper and ideological.
Were they not so dependent on the west for money, they would readily stand opposed to Israel.

That's a pretty selective reading of the situation.

Public opinion and government policy are not the same thing. It's true that criticism of Israel has increased in many Western countries since the Gaza war, and some politicians have called for sanctions or reducing military support. But the governments of the U.S., Germany, the U.K., France, Canada and most other Western states continue to recognize Israel, maintain diplomatic relations, and generally view Iran as a major regional security threat.

As for the Gulf states, it's also inaccurate to say their opposition to Iran is "purely" a regional rivalry. Iran has been accused of supporting armed groups and carrying out or backing attacks against Gulf states, shipping, and energy infrastructure for decades. Their security concerns about Iran are based on more than ideology.

And while only the UAE and Bahrain established relations through the Abraham Accords, Egypt and Jordan have had peace treaties with Israel for decades, and several Gulf states have maintained varying degrees of quiet security and intelligence cooperation with Israel because of shared concerns about Iran.

You can argue that many people in the Arab world remain strongly opposed to Israel; this is true. But it's incorrect to suggest Gulf governments would automatically side with Iran if not for Western support. Their own national security interests have often put them at odds with Tehran, regardless of Israel.
 
Public opinion and government policy are not the same thing.
Government policy usually follows public opinion in some way, shape or form.
That said, the government policy in the middle east, in a majority of nations is to not recognize Israel.
It's true that criticism of Israel has increased in many Western countries since the Gaza war, and some politicians have called for sanctions or reducing military support. But the governments of the U.S., Germany, the U.K., France, Canada and most other Western states continue to recognize Israel, maintain diplomatic relations, and generally view Iran as a major regional security threat.
The fact that these countries recognize Israel, are subject to influence from Israeli lobby groups and consequently push the false narrative that Iran is a threat, are well known facts that are not in dispute anyway.
Some of these nations also recognize Palestine, fwiw.
As for the Gulf states, it's also inaccurate to say their opposition to Iran is "purely" a regional rivalry. Iran has been accused of supporting armed groups and carrying out or backing attacks against Gulf states, shipping, and energy infrastructure for decades. Their security concerns about Iran are based on more than ideology.
No. This is not true.
Iran has not attacked Gulf states for decades.
They have aimed to attack US bases since the start of THIS war, which is justified since those bases were being used to attack the sovereign territory of Iran.
Their fear of Iran is regional geopolitics and religious sectarianism.
It is pretty much the reason why one of these nations - Iraq, actually invaded Iran back in the 80s.
And while only the UAE and Bahrain established relations through the Abraham Accords, Egypt and Jordan have had peace treaties with Israel for decades, and several Gulf states have maintained varying degrees of quiet security and intelligence cooperation with Israel because of shared concerns about Iran.

You can argue that many people in the Arab world remain strongly opposed to Israel; this is true. But it's incorrect to suggest Gulf governments would automatically side with Iran if not for Western support. Their own national security interests have often put them at odds with Tehran, regardless of Israel.
The primary reasons Egypt, Jordan and a few other states, cooperate behind the scenes, is as I said, due to economic dependence and their need for regional stability.
However their security and regional stability are themselves threatened not by Iran, but by Israeli and American actions in the middle east.
Therefore, they are caught between a rock and a hard place.
They have to side with the nations they actually hate and who actually cause this regional instability, because they are dependent on them for money, weapons and survival.
However, whether it be government, or the citizenry of these nations, they are all primarily opposed to Israel and the US on a deep ideological level. I don't think anyone really doubts that.
This is why they do not formally recognize Israel.
So understand this distinction between what they actually believe and what they are forced to do.
Don't get this twisted that they are somehow ideologically and politically on the same page as the United States and Israel.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
That's a pretty selective reading of the situation.

Public opinion and government policy are not the same thing. It's true that criticism of Israel has increased in many Western countries since the Gaza war, and some politicians have called for sanctions or reducing military support. But the governments of the U.S., Germany, the U.K., France, Canada and most other Western states continue to recognize Israel, maintain diplomatic relations, and generally view Iran as a major regional security threat.

As for the Gulf states, it's also inaccurate to say their opposition to Iran is "purely" a regional rivalry. Iran has been accused of supporting armed groups and carrying out or backing attacks against Gulf states, shipping, and energy infrastructure for decades. Their security concerns about Iran are based on more than ideology.

And while only the UAE and Bahrain established relations through the Abraham Accords, Egypt and Jordan have had peace treaties with Israel for decades, and several Gulf states have maintained varying degrees of quiet security and intelligence cooperation with Israel because of shared concerns about Iran.

You can argue that many people in the Arab world remain strongly opposed to Israel; this is true. But it's incorrect to suggest Gulf governments would automatically side with Iran if not for Western support. Their own national security interests have often put them at odds with Tehran, regardless of Israel.

And that is why the DSA is winning primaries and your boy Newsome likely won't be the nominee
 
That's a pretty selective reading of the situation.

Public opinion and government policy are not the same thing. It's true that criticism of Israel has increased in many Western countries since the Gaza war, and some politicians have called for sanctions or reducing military support. But the governments of the U.S., Germany, the U.K., France, Canada and most other Western states continue to recognize Israel, maintain diplomatic relations, and generally view Iran as a major regional security threat.

As for the Gulf states, it's also inaccurate to say their opposition to Iran is "purely" a regional rivalry. Iran has been accused of supporting armed groups and carrying out or backing attacks against Gulf states, shipping, and energy infrastructure for decades. Their security concerns about Iran are based on more than ideology.

And while only the UAE and Bahrain established relations through the Abraham Accords, Egypt and Jordan have had peace treaties with Israel for decades, and several Gulf states have maintained varying degrees of quiet security and intelligence cooperation with Israel because of shared concerns about Iran.

You can argue that many people in the Arab world remain strongly opposed to Israel; this is true. But it's incorrect to suggest Gulf governments would automatically side with Iran if not for Western support. Their own national security interests have often put them at odds with Tehran, regardless of Israel.

american cash is the only reason gulf countries back them.

If the DSA come to power AIPAC is turfed and Israel loses funding.
Only american money is protecting them now.

Israel can't fight a real army, they can't even take on Hezbollah, Hamas or Yemen.
and now america is admitting they can't beat Iran.