War with Iran

Would Israel have devastated Gaza

Prior to Oct 7
2008 war on Gaza
2014 war on Gaza
2018-2019 Great March of Return
2021 - Gaza massacres

This doesn't even mention the 15 year long blockade which included Israel 'counting calories' in 2012 and deciding to put Gaza on a 'diet'
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
I never stated the cause and effect in any order, did I?

It's true that Hezbollah emerged after Israel's 1982 invasion of Lebanon, and Hamas grew out of the First Intifada during the Israeli occupation. Those historical events absolutely contributed to their rise.

But that doesn't mean they're simply passive "consequences" with no agency of their own. Both groups have made their own decisions for decades, including carrying out attacks against civilians, taking hostages, launching rockets, and rejecting various peace initiatives at different times.

History explains why groups emerge. It doesn't excuse everything they do afterward. Responsibility doesn't belong to only one side as your team likes to portray.

At least you are finally admitting that the Israeli occupation of Palestine and Lebanon has always been the problem.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
POS Nation terrorists murdering Palestinians with the assistance of soldiers. They behave like animals.
Zionism is a murderous and racist ideology. It must be exposed. It cannot be taught anymore.

 
At least you are finally admitting that the Israeli occupation of Palestine and Lebanon has always been the problem.

Man, you sure love to jump to conclusions and put words in people's mouths, eh???

Franky, would you do a hot Jewish SP? I will have a follow-up question depending on your answer.
 
Man, you sure love to jump to conclusions and put words in people's mouths, eh???

Franky, would you do a hot Jewish SP? I will have a follow-up question depending on your answer.

I have and will again, my issue is with zionists, not Jewish people.
You know that but your form of antisemitism argues that all Jews are genocidal zionists.

Look, you admitted that Hamas and Hezbollah were responses to Israeli aggression.
The next step, which is a tough one, is to admit that Israeli aggression and occupation is the problem.

There are a lot of smart, moral and not racist Jewish people, like Avi Lewis and the Rabbi below. And then there are zionists.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
I have and will again, my issue is with zionists, not Jewish people.
You know that but your form of antisemitism argues that all Jews are genocidal zionists.

If you have, and would again, does that include discussing your views on Israel with the young Jewish woman?

Look, you admitted that Hamas and Hezbollah were responses to Israeli aggression.
The next step, which is a tough one, is to admit that Israeli aggression and occupation is the problem.

If Hamas had never existed, Palestine would likely be in a far better position today. Likewise, Lebanon would almost certainly be better off without Hezbollah. The Lebanese government itself has repeatedly stated that it wants Hezbollah disarmed or dismantled because of the group's influence and the damage it has caused to the country. Remember Franky, facts matter.
 
You've got the cause and effect backwards.
Hamas and Hezbollah didn't create the conflict.
They emerged because of decades of Israeli occupation, military action and the various crimes against humanity committed over the last 80 years.
They're a consequence of Israeli actions, not its cause.
Facts based arguments don't work on people like this, unfortunately. These people truly do believe this all started on October 7th and hasn't been an ongoing thing for the past 80 years
 
If you have, and would again, does that include discussing your views on Israel with the young Jewish woman?

I don't have zionist friends, all my Jewish friends back human rights and are against genocide.
You need to get out more.

If Hamas had never existed, Palestine would likely be in a far better position today. Likewise, Lebanon would almost certainly be better off without Hezbollah. The Lebanese government itself has repeatedly stated that it wants Hezbollah disarmed or dismantled because of the group's influence and the damage it has caused to the country. Remember Franky, facts matter.

Bullshit on both accounts.
Palestine and Lebanon would be far better without Israel and zionism.

Then neither Hamas or Hezbollah would have been needed.

The government?

 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
I don't have zionist friends, all my Jewish friends back human rights and are against genocide.
You need to get out more.

I asked you if you would book a Jewish SP, and you said you have and would. HOW would you know her thoughts on GAZA until you were in the same room? Do you ever stick to the facts or always jump onto different tangents to deflect from the truth?

Bullshit on both accounts.
Palestine and Lebanon would be far better without Israel and zionism.

There we go, you spouted off what the problem is and why Israel views this as an existential threat and must eliminate Hezbollah, HAMAS, the current Iran regime, and all its proxies.

Congratulations, Franky, you have given the reason and a justification for Israel's behaviour.
 
I asked you if you would book a Jewish SP, and you said you have and would. HOW would you know her thoughts on GAZA until you were in the same room? Do you ever stick to the facts or always jump onto different tangents to deflect from the truth?

Some sp's are wacko right wingers, though most lean left and are interesting. Ever tried talking politics with Penelope of hush/sfto/secrets or wherever she is now? She's a wacko. I don't talk politics unless there is a clue that it won't be like talking to larue.

The Jewish community in town is split about 50/50 zionists and moral Jews. Your community sounds like it tends towards right wing weirdos, mine definitely skews left and I only know about 3 or 4 who still defend Israel. And they are feeling it. I expect you only have a couple of Jewish friends and they are either extreme right wingers or they don't talk politics to you ever. Like I won't talk politics with Penelope.



There we go, you spouted off what the problem is and why Israel views this as an existential threat and must eliminate Hezbollah, HAMAS, the current Iran regime, and all its proxies.

Congratulations, Franky, you have given the reason and a justification for Israel's behaviour.

Israel has wiped Palestine off the maps and continues genocide in Palestine and Lebanon.
And you still argue they are the victims.

Your victim card is officially retracted.

HN_3EFkWQAALDVd