War with Iran

I don't see a meaningful distinction especially in the case of AIPAC.
Politicians know exactly what happens if they step out of line.
They toe the line because the political consequences are obvious. That's being owned.

What policy shifts? Name them.
What I saw was Biden insisting Israel hadn't crossed his "red line" while continuing U.S. support.
I saw officials talking about asking Israel to be "more careful" or "putting an arm around a friend" (Buttigieg) while civilians in Gaza were being murdered in a genocide.
So what exactly changed? I don't recall any fundamental shift in U.S. foreign policy toward Israel.
If anything, this war with Iran in service of Israel is an example that directly disproves your claim.

Question, Shaquille.
Is the war going on now exactly the same as it would have unfolded with Biden in charge?
If so, why did Netanyahu express a clear preference for Trump?
 
  • Like
Reactions: squeezer
Ryan's kind of got it backward there, though.
They were taking the money and voted against it anyway.
Now the money is being withdrawn.
If anything, that's an argument politicians aren't "owned" by lobbyists in the most simplistic description of the term.
No, he’s got it right. Vote the wrong way and lose your money. It happened. They might hang on to their seats. It’s a lesson to those still receiving genocide funds. Fortunately, reporters like Ryan exposed the lobby and its sycophants in Congress - voting according to AIPAC to receive AIPAC genocide funding is often becoming re-election suicide. This kind of reporting changed the landscape. These politicians don’t want to sacrifice themselves for POS Nation and it‘s foreign agent - AIPAC.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
I agree that lobbying has far too much influence in U.S. politics, whether it's AIPAC, the NRA, Big Pharma, Big Tech, or the fossil fuel industry. That's a broader problem with the American political system.
Do you understand the difference between a domestic and foreign lobby? Under FARA, Foreign lobbies are not allowed to donate to US political campaigns.

AIPAC is not registered under FARA. The Kennedys tried, and well ...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Question, Shaquille.
Is the war going on now exactly the same as it would have unfolded with Biden in charge?
If so, why did Netanyahu express a clear preference for Trump?

Oh god, you're still trying to blame the voters for Harris losing the election over AIPAC and support of the genocide.
Why aren't you blaming Israel for screwing over america?
They put trump in office and they drove him to war in Iran and they are driving the destruction of america.

trump targeted desalination plants.
Israel relies on one for most of their water.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
Do you understand the difference between a domestic and foreign lobby? Under FARA, Foreign lobbies are not allowed to donate to US political campaigns.

AIPAC is not registered under FARA. The Kennedys tried, and well ...

Tucker has been posting that he thinks Israel killed JFK.
Marge is now a giant 'antisemite'.
Even Alex Jones is attacking zionists.
Charlie Kirk went anti Israel before he was assassinated though Netanyahu posted 3 videos denying he killed him.

MAGA conspiracy theory has flipped on Israel.
 
Nah, it shows they were owned and knew that voting against AIPAC orders meant losing AIPAC funding.
The only difference now is that popular vote is worth more than AIPAC advertising and direct cash.

So they weren't owned, since they made their own choice despite receiving the money.
They can make choices and be influenced and there are elements more than money and donations that determine a politician's vote.
 
So they weren't owned, since they made their own choice despite receiving the money.
They can make choices and be influenced and there are elements more than money and donations that determine a politician's vote.

So now you are arguing you can never 'own' a politician because they could always just do what they want.
That's a very naive argument coming from you, val.
Do you think anyone's going to buy it?

The interesting part of this debate is that you've mostly moved on from whining about why Harris lost to now defending AIPAC.
You must understand how threatened Israel now are with AIPAC becoming as toxic as I warned you would happen, with you know, genocide.
 
Do you understand the difference between a domestic and foreign lobby? Under FARA, Foreign lobbies are not allowed to donate to US political campaigns.

AIPAC is not registered under FARA. The Kennedys tried, and well ...


You're mixing up a few different things in my humble opinion.

AIPAC is an American lobbying organization. It's not registered under FARA because it argues it isn't acting as an agent of a foreign government. Whether people agree with that is a separate debate, but that's the legal distinction.

And no, foreign governments can't directly donate to U.S. campaigns. That doesn't mean Americans who support a particular foreign policy position can't organize, lobby, or donate through U.S.-based political action committees. That's true whether the issue is Israel, Taiwan, Ukraine, Cuba, or anything else.

So if you argue that FARA should apply to AIPAC, that's a policy debate worth having. But acting like this is some settled legal fact isn't accurate. If it were, the courts would have settled it decades ago instead of people still arguing about it today.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: southpaw
AIPAC is an American lobbying organization. It's not registered under FARA because it argues it isn't acting as an agent of a foreign government. Whether people agree with that is a separate debate, but that's the legal distinction.

Do you really believe that?
You really think AIPAC represents american Jews and not the state of Israel?
wow

 
You're moving the goalposts.

Your original claim wasn't that AIPAC is influential. Now it's that U.S. politicians are completely "owned." Those are two different arguments.

There does seem to be fuzziness in the claim.

You may think those measures were weak or insufficient. That's a perfectly valid opinion. But weak action isn't the same thing as no disagreement.

Unless the policy difference results in you getting everything you want it is meaningless.
(At least this is the theory many people seem to operate under.)

And yes, Trumpshart's decision to strike Iran aligns closely with Netanyahu's objectives. I've said that repeatedly. I think Trumpshart was manipulated into a war that serves Bibi's interests. But one president making a decision you disagree with doesn't prove every U.S. administration, Congress, and politician is "owned" by Israel.

If your standard for being "not owned" is "the U.S. must completely abandon Israel whenever Israel wants something," then you've created a definition that can't be disproven.

That's not quite right, it could be disproven if the US did, in fact, do that thing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: squeezer
You're mixing up a few different things in my humble opinion.

AIPAC is an American lobbying organization. It's not registered under FARA because it argues it isn't acting as an agent of a foreign government. Whether people agree with that is a separate debate, but that's the legal distinction.

And no, foreign governments can't directly donate to U.S. campaigns. That doesn't mean Americans who support a particular foreign policy position can't organize, lobby, or donate through U.S.-based political action committees. That's true whether the issue is Israel, Taiwan, Ukraine, Cuba, or anything else.

So if you argue that FARA should apply to AIPAC, that's a policy debate worth having. But acting like this is some settled legal fact isn't accurate. If it were, the courts would have settled it decades ago instead of people still arguing about it today.
That’s funny. You can’t take yes for an answer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
He often seems to view foreign policy less through long-term strategy and more through the lens of personal deals, loyalty, and what benefits him politically or financially.

Not seems.
There is no evidence he views foreign policy as anything else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knuckle Ball
You just saw evidence that if they don't submit, they lose AIPAC support.

Yes.
So therefore not owned.

There are lots of lobbyists for different issues, but none spend as much as AIPAC both directly and in advertising along with media influence.

They are very influential and powerful, no one has argued against that point.

You know how many progressive dems have been primaried by AIPAC candidates over the last 3 years just as you know how big this change marks.

Yes.
Which is proof that you are all overstating the case when you say "owned".
 
I agree. Every politician responds to donors and political pressure to some extent, but I don't think we've ever seen a president who appears as personally driven by money, branding, and transactional relationships as Trumpshart.

That's part of what makes him so unpredictable. He often seems to view foreign policy less through long-term strategy and more through the lens of personal deals, loyalty, and what benefits him politically or financially.

So what personal gain do you think trump was after here?
Did someone tell him he could take all their oil as easily as Venezuela?
Or is there some other reason he decided to go against the advice of almost everyone around him?

What transactional reason was their for starting this war 3 times?
 
You break the rules in war but expect the victims of your attack to still play by the rules?

Yes.
Unless you just think the idea of war crimes is weak woke bullshit and wars are better conducted without any pretense of war crimes.
Which seems to be your position here.