War with Iran

That's never really been a secret. Pro-Israel lobbying groups have long been among the most influential lobbying organizations in Washington, just as other industries and interest groups spend heavily to influence U.S. policy.

The key point, though, is that lobbying isn't the same as control. At the end of the day, elected officials still decide whether to go along with those positions or not. Sometimes they do, sometimes they don't.

Pretending Israel single-handedly dictates every U.S. foreign policy decision is a bit out there.

AIPAC was paying about 90% of the congress and house, they had handlers for politicians.
Great scam, pay off politicians, get them to send money to Israel, use that money to pay AIPAC and politicians and get more money.

 
I don't believe those two things are the same.

A lobby can have enormous influence without politicians being completely "owned." If they were truly owned, there would never be disagreements or policy shifts, yet we've seen plenty of examples where U.S. administrations have clashed with Israeli governments over settlements, arms sales, peace negotiations, and other issues. Perhaps not so much with Trumpshart at the helm.

I do agree that the amount of money and lobbying in U.S. politics is unhealthy. That's a systemic problem that goes well beyond AIPAC. Corporate interests, unions, industry groups, and other advocacy organizations all compete to influence policy.

Where we differ is that I still think elected officials ultimately bear responsibility for the choices they make. If they cave to political pressure, that's still their decision. In my opinion, blaming a lobby for everything lets the politicians who actually cast the votes off the hook too easily.

No, we haven't seen that in america. Up until this year no politician could afford to say they don't back Israel or funding for Israel.
Now we are seeing blowback, finally, but before then just check out how demonized the squad was or check how many politicians were primaried by AIPAC money, like Massey.

 
I don't believe those two things are the same.

A lobby can have enormous influence without politicians being completely "owned." If they were truly owned, there would never be disagreements or policy shifts, yet we've seen plenty of examples where U.S. administrations have clashed with Israeli governments over settlements, arms sales, peace negotiations, and other issues. Perhaps not so much with Trumpshart at the helm.

I do agree that the amount of money and lobbying in U.S. politics is unhealthy. That's a systemic problem that goes well beyond AIPAC. Corporate interests, unions, industry groups, and other advocacy organizations all compete to influence policy.

Where we differ is that I still think elected officials ultimately bear responsibility for the choices they make. If they cave to political pressure, that's still their decision. In my opinion, blaming a lobby for everything lets the politicians who actually cast the votes off the hook too easily.

That’s it. More puerile equivocation.
 
I don't believe those two things are the same.
A lobby can have enormous influence without politicians being completely "owned."
I don't see a meaningful distinction especially in the case of AIPAC.
Politicians know exactly what happens if they step out of line.
They toe the line because the political consequences are obvious. That's being owned.
If they were truly owned, there would never be disagreements or policy shifts, yet we've seen plenty of examples where U.S. administrations have clashed with Israeli governments over settlements, arms sales, peace negotiations, and other issues.
What policy shifts? Name them.
What I saw was Biden insisting Israel hadn't crossed his "red line" while continuing U.S. support.
I saw officials talking about asking Israel to be "more careful" or "putting an arm around a friend" (Buttigieg) while civilians in Gaza were being murdered in a genocide.
So what exactly changed? I don't recall any fundamental shift in U.S. foreign policy toward Israel.
If anything, this war with Iran in service of Israel is an example that directly disproves your claim.
 
I just can't see this administration accepting that outcome, even if it ultimately meant putting boots on the ground. Politically, it would look like a complete defeat.

Accepting what outcome?
Iran having any control over the strait?
If so, you've just agreed with Butler that increasing the military effort to the point of putting boots on the ground is the alternative to that.

If Iran ended up with effective control over the Strait after all of this, the Democrats would have an obvious line of attack: "The Strait was open before you started this war. What exactly did you accomplish?"

This is a major reason the US doesn't back out of military action, even when it is the right thing.
Remember how much everyone attacked Biden for the Afghanistan withdrawal?

That's a difficult question for any administration to answer. From a political standpoint, it would hang around their necks for years.

Yes, but that is the argument for perpetual military action. "The USA can never be seen to lose."

Whether that's the right strategic decision is a separate debate. I'm just saying I don't think this administration believes it can afford that outcome politically.

So your argument is that the USA will at least stay in active military conflict with Iran throughout the rest of Trump's reign, then?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
I agree that lobbying has far too much influence in U.S. politics, whether it's AIPAC, the NRA, Big Pharma, Big Tech, or the fossil fuel industry. That's a broader problem with the American political system.

Where I disagree is the idea that politicians are simply "owned." Lobbying can influence policy, but it doesn't eliminate the fact that elected officials still make the final decisions and are accountable for them.

If a president or Congress chooses to support Israel, Ukraine, Taiwan, or anyone else, that's still their decision. I don't think it's helpful to pretend they're just puppets with no agency except perhaps in Trumpsharts' case. Offer him a side deal with $$$$$, and he will bend like a leaf in a hurricane.

Even Trump has offers he likes and offers he doesn't.
In a way, it would be easier if the politicians were just purely venal. You could just offer more money and always win.
 
Meanwhil, in the real world. I look forward to seeing your latest need to equivocate.


Ryan's kind of got it backward there, though.
They were taking the money and voted against it anyway.
Now the money is being withdrawn.
If anything, that's an argument politicians aren't "owned" by lobbyists in the most simplistic description of the term.
 
You are contradicting yourself.
If you agree lobbying has enormous influence in the US, that automatically means politicians are "owned".

But that doesn't make sense.
Influence isn't ownership.
If you take that model, then every politician has multiple owners who don't agree with them.

Sure they have agency. But they wilfully submit to the demands of groups like AIPAC for their own political careers.

But you just saw Klaatu present evidence that they don't always submit.
 
Ryan's kind of got it backward there, though.
They were taking the money and voted against it anyway.
Now the money is being withdrawn.
If anything, that's an argument politicians aren't "owned" by lobbyists in the most simplistic description of the term.

Nah, it shows they were owned and knew that voting against AIPAC orders meant losing AIPAC funding.
The only difference now is that popular vote is worth more than AIPAC advertising and direct cash.
 
Iran's statement is clear.
And note that america has hit desalination plants and nuclear power plants now.

The US is also quite capable of committing war crimes.



"They did war crimes, so we will do war crimes back" isn't good justification.
 
I don't see a meaningful distinction especially in the case of AIPAC.
Politicians know exactly what happens if they step out of line.
They toe the line because the political consequences are obvious. That's being owned.

You're moving the goalposts.

Your original claim wasn't that AIPAC is influential. Now it's that U.S. politicians are completely "owned." Those are two different arguments.


What policy shifts? Name them.
What I saw was Biden insisting Israel hadn't crossed his "red line" while continuing U.S. support.
I saw officials talking about asking Israel to be "more careful" or "putting an arm around a friend" (Buttigieg) while civilians in Gaza were being murdered in a genocide.

As for policy differences, there have absolutely been disagreements between Washington and Israeli governments over the years. The Obama administration publicly opposed settlement expansion and allowed U.N. Security Council Resolution 2334 criticizing settlements to pass by abstaining. Biden repeatedly criticized settlement expansion and sanctioned some extremist Israeli settlers. There have also been disagreements over arms sales, judicial reforms, and ceasefire negotiations. Were those disagreements enough? That's a fair debate. But to claim there were none simply isn't accurate.


So what exactly changed? I don't recall any fundamental shift in U.S. foreign policy toward Israel.
If anything, this war with Iran in service of Israel is an example that directly disproves your claim.

You may think those measures were weak or insufficient. That's a perfectly valid opinion. But weak action isn't the same thing as no disagreement.

And yes, Trumpshart's decision to strike Iran aligns closely with Netanyahu's objectives. I've said that repeatedly. I think Trumpshart was manipulated into a war that serves Bibi's interests. But one president making a decision you disagree with doesn't prove every U.S. administration, Congress, and politician is "owned" by Israel.

If your standard for being "not owned" is "the U.S. must completely abandon Israel whenever Israel wants something," then you've created a definition that can't be disproven.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
Even Trump has offers he likes and offers he doesn't.
In a way, it would be easier if the politicians were just purely venal. You could just offer more money and always win.


I agree. Every politician responds to donors and political pressure to some extent, but I don't think we've ever seen a president who appears as personally driven by money, branding, and transactional relationships as Trumpshart.

That's part of what makes him so unpredictable. He often seems to view foreign policy less through long-term strategy and more through the lens of personal deals, loyalty, and what benefits him politically or financially.
 
  • Like
Reactions: geezerbuter
But that doesn't make sense.
Influence isn't ownership.
If you take that model, then every politician has multiple owners who don't agree with them.



But you just saw Klaatu present evidence that they don't always submit.

You just saw evidence that if they don't submit, they lose AIPAC support.
There are lots of lobbyists for different issues, but none spend as much as AIPAC both directly and in advertising along with media influence.

You know how many progressive dems have been primaried by AIPAC candidates over the last 3 years just as you know how big this change marks.
Just as it seems clear that its upsetting for you.
 
No, we haven't seen that in america. Up until this year no politician could afford to say they don't back Israel or funding for Israel.
Now we are seeing blowback, finally, but before then just check out how demonized the squad was or check how many politicians were primaried by AIPAC money, like Massey.

And that's why none of those people were ever elected or re-elected.