War with Iran

But isn't the U.S. a sovereign country that gets to decide......what its foreign policy will be?
Not if it's politicians are all bought and owned by the Israel lobby which is the case today.
A country that independently decides foreign policy, won't have politicians who display such loyalty, piousness and servility to a foreign power, more than they do to their own nation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
You're presenting a false choice.

No, I don't want Iran controlling the Strait of Hormuz, and no, I don't want a decades-long ground war in Iran either. Those are not the only two possible outcomes.

My position has been pretty consistent. Trumpshart was wrong to drag the U.S. into this war, especially without broad allied support. I also think Iran's regime has spent decades destabilizing the region through its proxies, while BIBI has made decisions that have inflamed the conflict even further.

There are no saints here. But pretending the only options are "Iran controls the Strait" or "permanent ground war" is just another made-up bullshit and nonsense. Reality is usually more complicated than that. I don't want either scenario.

The Hormuz was open until trump and Netanyahu's war, that its closed is a fair price for their illegal war of aggression. A 2% fee for passage was no big deal.

Iran is way less destabilizing than america, who you constantly excuse.
Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria, Yemen, Libya, Iran, Venezuela, Cuba, decades in South America, Vietnam, Korea.....
The list of destabilizations that you accept in comparison to Iran aiding Hezbollah and Hamas is ridiculous.

To argue that Iran was a major threat when they abided by the NPT and hadn't attacked anyone in 200 years is nutso.
Which country is the one with 800 bases around the world?
The one that just raided a country, put its president in jail and is bragging about stealing its oil?
Which country is committing genocide and at war with 5 countries at once?

You present a false equivalency.
 
This is true https://apnews.com/article/iran-str...desalination-25e6d5c8d8a027897b3fb80fad57b7d2, so now let's see what the US does. Trumpshart has been very quiet on the Iranian front all day.

70% of the attacks on Iran came from Kuwait, so Iran hit Kuwait.

You do know that Israel relies on one desalination plant and one nuclear plant, don't you?
Iran has been knocking out defences in Jordan in preparation.



 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
One more thing.

To the Iran supporters: if reports that Iran deliberately targeted civilian electricity and desalination infrastructure are accurate, would you call that a war crime too?

Because if Israel or the U.S. had struck the same type of civilian infrastructure in Iran first, I'm pretty sure this forum would be flooded with posts screaming "WAR CRIME!"

Just wondering if the standard is the same for everyone, or if it depends on who's launching the missiles.

Yes, its a war crime.
But once america and Israel start committing war crimes do you expect their victims to then abide by the rules?

Squeezer, I got a question I don't think you will answer.

Do you agree that targeting civilians and civilian infrastructure for political reasons is 'terrorism'?
 
Last edited:
I honestly don't know, because I wasn't the one who decided to start a war without a clear endgame. If there were a coherent long-term plan, I certainly haven't seen it.

That said, I have a hard time believing the U.S. or its regional partners would accept Iran effectively controlling the Strait of Hormuz and charging tolls or otherwise restricting passage. The Strait is one of the world's most important shipping lanes, and freedom of navigation has long been a core U.S. strategic objective.

But what level of military effort are you willing to expend for that goal?
That was the core of Butler's objection - he thinks its boots on the ground or not possible militarily.
How much military capital are you willing to spend for this goal?

Politically, it would also be very difficult for Trumpshart to accept an outcome that could be portrayed as a major victory for Iran. Whether you call it "losing the war" or not, I don't see him agreeing to a settlement that hands Tehran that kind of leverage.

"I don't want to accept this outcome" is a long-standing reason for people to prolong a war that isn't getting you what you want.
Look how long the US stayed in Afghanistan.
In the end, they left anyway.
Same result, but much more expensive.

So, no, I don't know what the eventual outcome will be. I just don't think the two choices are "Iran controls the Strait" or "a decades-long ground war." There are likely other diplomatic and military outcomes somewhere in between, even if they're hard to predict.

I agree that there is a broad spectrum, but there isn't likely a version where Iran doesn't have some say over the strait or the military expenditure takes an extremely long time.
 
But what level of military effort are you willing to expend for that goal?
That was the core of Butler's objection - he thinks its boots on the ground or not possible militarily.
How much military capital are you willing to spend for this goal?



"I don't want to accept this outcome" is a long-standing reason for people to prolong a war that isn't getting you what you want.
Look how long the US stayed in Afghanistan.
In the end, they left anyway.
Same result, but much more expensive.



I agree that there is a broad spectrum, but there isn't likely a version where Iran doesn't have some say over the strait or the military expenditure takes an extremely long time.


I just can't see this administration accepting that outcome, even if it ultimately meant putting boots on the ground. Politically, it would look like a complete defeat.

If Iran ended up with effective control over the Strait after all of this, the Democrats would have an obvious line of attack: "The Strait was open before you started this war. What exactly did you accomplish?"

That's a difficult question for any administration to answer. From a political standpoint, it would hang around their necks for years.

Whether that's the right strategic decision is a separate debate. I'm just saying I don't think this administration believes it can afford that outcome politically.
 
Pat Buchanan, 1991.


That's never really been a secret. Pro-Israel lobbying groups have long been among the most influential lobbying organizations in Washington, just as other industries and interest groups spend heavily to influence U.S. policy.

The key point, though, is that lobbying isn't the same as control. At the end of the day, elected officials still decide whether to go along with those positions or not. Sometimes they do, sometimes they don't.

Pretending Israel single-handedly dictates every U.S. foreign policy decision is a bit out there.
 
Not if it's politicians are all bought and owned by the Israel lobby which is the case today.
A country that independently decides foreign policy, won't have politicians who display such loyalty, piousness and servility to a foreign power, more than they do to their own nation.


I agree that lobbying has far too much influence in U.S. politics, whether it's AIPAC, the NRA, Big Pharma, Big Tech, or the fossil fuel industry. That's a broader problem with the American political system.

Where I disagree is the idea that politicians are simply "owned." Lobbying can influence policy, but it doesn't eliminate the fact that elected officials still make the final decisions and are accountable for them.

If a president or Congress chooses to support Israel, Ukraine, Taiwan, or anyone else, that's still their decision. I don't think it's helpful to pretend they're just puppets with no agency except perhaps in Trumpsharts' case. Offer him a side deal with $$$$$, and he will bend like a leaf in a hurricane.
 
I agree that lobbying has far too much influence in U.S. politics, whether it's AIPAC, the NRA, Big Pharma, Big Tech, or the fossil fuel industry. That's a broader problem with the American political system.

Where I disagree is the idea that politicians are simply "owned." Lobbying can influence policy, but it doesn't eliminate the fact that elected officials still make the final decisions and are accountable for them.

If a president or Congress chooses to support Israel, Ukraine, Taiwan, or anyone else, that's still their decision. I don't think it's helpful to pretend they're just puppets with no agency except perhaps in Trumpsharts' case. Offer him a side deal with $$$$$, and he will bend like a leaf in a hurricane.
Meanwhil, in the real world. I look forward to seeing your latest need to equivocate.

 
I agree that lobbying has far too much influence in U.S. politics, whether it's AIPAC...
Where I disagree is the idea that politicians are simply "owned."
You are contradicting yourself.
If you agree lobbying has enormous influence in the US, that automatically means politicians are "owned".
Sure they have agency. But they wilfully submit to the demands of groups like AIPAC for their own political careers.
When you scale that across states, it has the impact of losing sovereignty because now your politicians are all working for a foreign nation, which is exactly the problem in the US today, especially with regards to Israel.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
You are contradicting yourself.
If you agree lobbying has enormous influence in the US, that automatically means politicians are "owned".
Sure they have agency. But they wilfully submit to the demands of groups like AIPAC for their own political careers.
When you scale that across states, it has the impact of losing sovereignty because now your politicians are all working for a foreign nation, which is exactly the problem in the US today, especially with regards to Israel.


I don't believe those two things are the same.

A lobby can have enormous influence without politicians being completely "owned." If they were truly owned, there would never be disagreements or policy shifts, yet we've seen plenty of examples where U.S. administrations have clashed with Israeli governments over settlements, arms sales, peace negotiations, and other issues. Perhaps not so much with Trumpshart at the helm.

I do agree that the amount of money and lobbying in U.S. politics is unhealthy. That's a systemic problem that goes well beyond AIPAC. Corporate interests, unions, industry groups, and other advocacy organizations all compete to influence policy.

Where we differ is that I still think elected officials ultimately bear responsibility for the choices they make. If they cave to political pressure, that's still their decision. In my opinion, blaming a lobby for everything lets the politicians who actually cast the votes off the hook too easily.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar