War with Iran

I don't share that viewpoint. Obama's agreement (JCPOA) had sunset clauses that came upon us this decade. It pushed out the timeline, but it still allowed Iran to work towards nuclear weapons. It's with good reason the JCPOA is described as kicking the can down the road.



No, but Trump did what many of us long expected to be necessary in the Iran situation. I can't emphasize this enough, but people were here discussing the problems with the JCPOA long before Trump. The JCPOA didn't resolve anything. It merely postponed things.



Beyond your rant above, my point is the media is hostile to Trump. I don't care why, how or whether its understandable. The point stands. Rationalizing this media hostility as justified, obscures the need for the public to get information. Having said that, one should always look out for bias from any media source.



We have to see what the a settlement would look like. A nominal toll could be a face-saving mechanism for Iran. We also have to consider how other Persian Gulf nations will circumvent the Strait. Even without a toll, we would expect this effort to accelerate. Furthermore, Iran's ability to export aggression and threaten the region has been greatly reduced over the last two years. I'm not sure why this isn't acknowledged by you and others.

Squeeze seems to realize he doesn't want to roll around on TERB with our supporters of the radical Islamicists. I'm not sure you have found a way to distance yourself. For some reason, you seem to want to accept and find ways to support the pro-Iran arguments.



This seems like you are carefully tip-toeing around actually taking a realistic position.
We would all like to see a world without nukes. For that matter, I would also like to see an end to all wars.
As far as comparisons to North Korea, the Iranians make Kim Jong Un look like a model citizen on the world stage.
I really don't want to go down this path where people try to make the argument that the Iranian nation is defensive in nature.
Regardless of explanations and pretext, Iranian aggression has been directed at the U.S. off and on for several decades.

Trump may have done something. But what was necessary ain't it. Iran is now unsanctioned on oil, got to give Israel a bunch of head shots, weakened the Americans in the eyes of the world, changed(with Ukraine) how warfare happens, is also giving it to Saudi Arabia, and has, remarkably, actually rehabilitated some of their international reputation.

China is now a more key player in the region. Several US allies are even further distant. And the whole Gulf States becoming the new modern economic hub for the rich is literally blown up.

What I don't think you have fully comprehended is there is a click ticking. Every day oil is offline means 10 to recover back to normal. This isn't me, this is oil experts saying these things. And the clock isn't on Iran. It's on the USA.

Thats why Iran is winning.
 
Perhaps you should watch the Rogan-Trump long-form interview or at least watch a summary clip.
He did fine. Great would be a stretch, but he did sit and talk for three hours.

The fact that Kamala's team wanted to limit the time, have her handlers in the room and do in interview at a site of her choosing says everything.

Can't go that long without another bottle of California red being opened......
 
So tell us how Trump has put the Iranians in their place, Earp?
This is what I said "Furthermore, Iran's ability to export aggression and threaten the region has been greatly reduced over the last two years. I'm not sure why this isn't acknowledged by you and others."

What would you have done with Iran?
We have the Iran should be allowed to have nuclear weapons (and ballistic missiles) crowd.
We have the Iran nuke deniers. (According to them, Iran wasn't close to having a bomb regardless of UN weapons experts pronouncements.)

People aren't offering reasonable alternatives because most of the Western media is not discussing them. Everything is a prosecution of Trump rather than a policy discussion.
 
Trump may have done something. But what was necessary ain't it. Iran is now unsanctioned on oil, got to give Israel a bunch of head shots, weakened the Americans in the eyes of the world, changed(with Ukraine) how warfare happens, is also giving it to Saudi Arabia, and has, remarkably, actually rehabilitated some of their international reputation.

China is now a more key player in the region. Several US allies are even further distant. And the whole Gulf States becoming the new modern economic hub for the rich is literally blown up.

What I don't think you have fully comprehended is there is a click ticking. Every day oil is offline means 10 to recover back to normal. This isn't me, this is oil experts saying these things. And the clock isn't on Iran. It's on the USA.

Thats why Iran is winning.
Wow!
You got all that from five weeks of conflict.

There is a whole lot that is playing out. I don't even think we will know the outcomes in a year. Perhaps in three to five years we can look at the region and the aftermath of the conflict to assess the outcome.

Remember when some of us were saying "reading is not knowing". I will be honest. I don't know entirely what is happening in the Mideast. Nor do I know what will happen there. I have read and watched a lot of opinions from media commentators in Washington, New York and London. I don't even pay attention to tertiary YouTubers and Twitterati.

Same question for you as Mandy.
What would you have done with Iran?
We have the Iran should be allowed to have nuclear weapons (and ballistic missiles) crowd.
We have the Iran nuke deniers. (According to them, Iran wasn't close to having a bomb regardless of UN weapons experts pronouncements.)
 
Last edited:
This is what I said "Furthermore, Iran's ability to export aggression and threaten the region has been greatly reduced over the last two years. I'm not sure why this isn't acknowledged by you and others."

What would you have done with Iran?
We have the Iran should be allowed to have nuclear weapons (and ballistic missiles) crowd.
We have the Iran nuke deniers. (According to them, Iran wasn't close to having a bomb regardless of UN weapons experts pronouncements.)

People aren't offering reasonable alternatives because most of the Western media is not discussing them. Everything is a prosecution of Trump rather than a policy discussion.
Trump essentially attacked Iran with no plan re how to proceed with the war and backed down like a wanker as soon as Iran hung tough.

This is the biggest, saddest TACO of them all. Don't try and sell it as some kind of a "win"!
 
Perhaps you should watch the Rogan-Trump long-form interview or at least watch a summary clip.
He did fine. Great would be a stretch, but he did sit and talk for three hours.

The fact that Kamala's team wanted to limit the time, have her handlers in the room and do in interview at a site of her choosing says everything.
My favourite memory of trump's campaign is when the senile, bizarre old man jigged around for several minutes to Macho Man and then stared into space, having forgotten what he was supposed to do next.

They must have really cranked up the old fucker's adderall for that Rogan interview. You're getting as bad as Richie.
 
There is a whole lot that is playing out.
Yeah, am sure Trump is playing 5D chess lmfao.
What would you have done with Iran?
Engaged in diplomacy with Iran like Obama did.
They promised to handle over all enriched Uranium, never develop nukes, and were in compliance with the JCPOA per IAEA before Trump tore it up.
They have proven they are trustworthy negotiators, which is more than can be said for the US and Israel.
 
My favourite memory of trump's campaign is when the senile, bizarre old man jigged around for several minutes to Macho Man and then stared into space, having forgotten what he was supposed to do next.

They must have really cranked up the old fucker's adderall for that Rogan interview. You're getting as bad as Richie.
I've always agreed Trump's too old to be President.
In fact, I think I have said I wouldn't be upset the least if he was pushed out by way of the 25th amendment.

Do you have a record here saying the same of Biden?
 
Trump essentially attacked Iran with no plan re how to proceed with the war and backed down like a wanker as soon as Iran hung tough.

This is the biggest, saddest TACO of them all. Don't try and sell it as some kind of a "win"!
You didn't answer the straightforward question.

What would you have done with Iran?
We have the Iran should be allowed to have nuclear weapons (and ballistic missiles) crowd.
We have the Iran nuke deniers. (According to them, Iran wasn't close to having a bomb regardless of UN weapons experts pronouncements.)
 
I've always agreed Trump's too old to be President.
In fact, I think I have said I wouldn't be upset the least if he was pushed out by way of the 25th amendment.

Do you have a record here saying the same of Biden?
IICR, I do, after his disastrous presidential debate.
 
Copied and pasted from Esquire magazine:

Contrary to What Pete Hegseth Says, This Two-Week Ceasefire with Iran Isn’t a “Historic and Overwhelming Victory”
And it’s definitely not the “ninth war” that President Art O’Deal has “stopped.”
By Charles P. PiercePublished: Apr 08, 2026 2:11 PM EDT

The late Senator Wayne Morse of Oregon often is credited with devising the formula for ending U.S. involvement in Southeast Asia: that we should declare victory and get out. There’s no credible evidence that Morse actually wrote or said any such thing. But it certainly is an apt summation of Morse’s brave opposition to that bloody fiasco. And now, what with a two-week ceasefire in which fire has not ceased, it maintains a certain salience. From Reuters:
The United States and Iran agreed to a two-week ceasefire brokered by Pakistan, suspending a six-week-old war that has killed thousands, spread across the Middle East and caused unprecedented disruption to the world’s energy supplies.
There was relief on many of the region’s streets and in world financial markets after President Donald Trump announced the agreement late on Tuesday, two hours before a deadline he had set ‌for Iran to open the blockaded Strait of Hormuz or face the destruction of its “whole civilisation.”
Though the United States and Iran both declared victory, their main disputes remained unresolved, each sticking to competing demands for a potential peace deal that could shape the Middle East for generations. A senior Iranian official involved in the discussions told Reuters Tehran could open the Strait of Hormuz on Thursday or Friday ahead of planned peace talks in Pakistan, if a framework for the ceasefire is agreed.
The administration’s reaction to this is as predictable as a kickback. This will become the “ninth war” that President Art O’Deal has “stopped.” Iran walks away with more than it had in the previous agreement it struck with the Obama administration. Israel is still firing missiles into Iran, to say nothing of laying waste to half of Lebanon. Iran maintains control of the Strait of Hormuz. Indeed, the deal turns the strait into an Iranian tollbooth. I think we’re lucky that Iran doesn’t now own half of Montana. On the other hand, Pete Hegseth thinks the whole thing is/was a masterstroke:
This morning, a big day for world peace. Iran wants it to happen. They’ve had enough. Operation Epic Fury was a historic and overwhelming victory on the battlefield. A capital V.
And JD Vance, fresh off canoodling with Viktor Orbán and still cosplaying Urban II in Budapest, emphasized that the U.S. is not kidding around this time. No sir. Not us. Uh-uhhh. From (forgive me) Fox News:
“This is why I say this is a fragile truce,” Vance said. “You have people who clearly want to come to the negotiating table and work with us to find a good deal, and then you have people who are lying about even the fragile truce that we’ve already struck. ... If the Iranians are willing in good faith to work with us, I think we can make an agreement. If they’re going to lie, if they’re going to cheat, if they’re going to try to prevent even the fragile truce that we’ve set up from taking place, that they’re not going to be happy.”
According to the ten-point Iranian plan that (apparently) is going to be the basis for whatever negotiations take place, Iran and Oman will be allowed to assess a $2 million fee per ship using Hormuz. Why the hell would Iran cheat on a guaranteed windfall like that one? For the moment, however, Armageddon is called on account of Stupid.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
You didn't answer the straightforward question.

What would you have done with Iran?
We have the Iran should be allowed to have nuclear weapons (and ballistic missiles) crowd.
We have the Iran nuke deniers. (According to them, Iran wasn't close to having a bomb regardless of UN weapons experts pronouncements.)
No, I don't think they should have the bomb and I think the Islamic state should be overthrown. But Trump's not the man to achieve either of those goals.
 
  • Like
Reactions: xmontrealer
IICR, I do, after his disastrous presidential debate.

Wasn't that too late for Democrats?

Did you call for Biden to step down?
That was always a strange admission for many.
Biden's not fit to run, but his cadre should help keep him in office.
 
Wasn't that too late for Democrats?

Did you call for Biden to step down?
That was always a strange admission for many.
Biden's not fit to run, but his cadre should help keep him in office.
Earp, is this a thread about Biden? Or about the War in Iran?
 
  • Like
Reactions: crocket