War with Iran

Israel continues to bomb Lebanon, so Iran closed the strait. Israel bad!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Americans were not interested in another Bush-Clinton election.

Both Jeb and Hillary both went down to defeat. In democratic politics, the mood of the nation plays an important role.

I would say the nation as a whole. Trump won the primary on anti war, anti generic. Won the election on the same. Biden won on return to normalcy, but he killed things for obvious reasons. Obama won on the same.

The nation is imo getting closer to another FDR.
 
My opinion is the anti-Trump world is eagerly defining victory as an end to the Iranian regime. They can point to Trump's own words. These words were imprudent in a 24/7 media environment which is quite frankly hostile to the President.

That definition of victory simply ignores the new, unambiguous U.S. foreign policy that Iran cannot be allowed to have nuclear weapons. The U.S. policy is no longer Iran will be allowed to inch towards accumulating enough enriched uranium.

As a historical reference when Bush the Elder drove the Iraqis out of Kuwait but suspended the conflict, was this in some form an Iraqi victory? Of course not, the Iraqi military was severely weakened and never a threat to the region. Trump's rhetoric aside, whatever we say is the outcome of the conflict today will be revised by future events over the next several years. Social media makes everyone with a keyboard and internet access an expert in real-time.

As far as Iran wreaking havoc in the Strait of Hormuz, you can see from the Millennium Challenge this has been contemplated for a long time. The question is do you allow Iran to proceed with its nuclear program because of their shoreline along the Strait. The second question what would stop a nuclear Iran from taking complete control of the Strait of Hormuz. I don't think this is a novel perspective by any means.

I believe you have stated your view that Iran should be allowed to possess nuclear weapons. That's fine, but nuclear weapons is really what the conflict is about and we are discussing U.S. objectives.

Trump, maybe rashly, stupidly or ignorantly, never really put out what his terms for success were. He made a big deal out of regime change, which frankly, has not happened. And, the reality here is that from what we can see, Trump is working towards a deal that Obama hammered out in 2015, but worse. So, the question here is, what did Trump accomplish? By tearing up the Iran deal back in 2017, he basically created the path to this conflict. Does he deserve a pat on the head for that??? And, calling the media hostile to Trump is idiotic. He's hostile to the media, says things that sane leader would say, and then righties get their panties in a bunch when they call him out on it. You can't have it both ways. Trump is reckless and ruinous. He got the US into this mess without a defined goal and no exit strategy. He already declared victory...And regardless of how bad the deal he signs might be, he'll still call it a victory.

I know you aren't usually a Trump fart-catcher. But, can you honestly say that Iran isn't winning this? I mean, they aren't changing their goals, have absorbed all sorts of damage, but are still capable of fucking up the entire energy industry around the world with a few well placed missiles. They've sent oil prices through the roof, and we haven't even reached the point where Europe or Asia is running out of oil (though we are very close). We'll see how this unfolds, but I do not believe anything Trump says.

If the Millennium Challenge was incorporated into this plan....then how was the Strait closed? Regardless of the nuclear threat (or lack of one), the deal Trump is pursuing could see a toll on the Strait, something that had never existed before.

Now, I do not think Iran should have nuclear weapons. I'm pretty sure I said that those weapons should be destroyed for all parties...But, let's look at the fact that the only country to use them in war has been the US. What I did say was that I highly doubt Iran would nuke Israel like many people seem to believe. That makes absolutely no sense. Now, I know some people think that Iran is not led by rational people, but they certainly are. I mean, they have done some shitty things over the past 47 years, but never really stepped over the line to total war (keep in mind Iraq attacked them). I also think Iran sees how the world treats North Korea, and wants Israel and the US from bombing them every five years or so....
 
Not sure I agree with that. They claimed they got regime change in Venezuela, but the same party is in power. Sure, they seem to be cooperating with the US right now, but how long will that last? Does Trump want to actually invade the country??? I'd say it might be more of a tie.
Kind of a continuation of my recent post on Iran, you can't always define victory in terms of regime change. Frankly, that seems to be a residual concept from World War 2 that even Trump dwells on too much.

There are several geopolitical objectives that can or already have been achieved:

- Venezuela's economy improves and the exodus is stemmed.
- Chinese influence is hindered.
- Cuba is no longer supported by Venezuela.
 
I would say the nation as a whole. Trump won the primary on anti war, anti generic. Won the election on the same. Biden won on return to normalcy, but he killed things for obvious reasons.

That damn Rogan killed things. ;)
 
Essentially Russia and China?
China would be shooting himself in the foot and Russia is irrelevant due to the low trade volume and pre-existing sanctions.

It's going to shake shit up for sure.

Top that off, I thought I read here that Israel attacked China somewhere, can't be bothered to search for it.
 
From The New York Times today:

Trump Finds His Offramp With Iran. But the Causes of War Remain Unresolved.
President Trump’s short-term intimidation may have worked, but the fundamental divides with Iran are as sharp as they were in February.

By David E. Sanger
David E. Sanger has covered five American presidents in more than four decades at The Times. He has written extensively for the past 20 years on successive efforts to negotiate with Iran, sabotage its nuclear program and impose sanctions to contain its actions.
Published April 7, 2026Updated April 8, 2026, 11:13 a.m. ET

At 8:06 a.m. on Tuesday, President Trump delivered an apocalyptic threat to Iran, declaring that unless his demand to open the Strait of Hormuz was fulfilled by nightfall, “a whole civilization will die tonight, never to be brought back again.”

Ten hours and 26 minutes later, at 6:32 p.m. Eastern time, he lifted the threat, for now. He said an intervention by the Pakistani government had led to a two-week cease-fire in a war that has wracked the world economy and showed off American technological dominance and unexpected Iranian resilience.

Mr. Trump’s tactic of escalating his rhetoric to astronomical levels certainly helped him find an offramp he had been seeking for weeks. That success alone may fuel his belief that the tactics he learned in the New York real estate world — ignore old conventions, make maximalist demands — work in geopolitics as well.

Without question, it was a down-to-the-wire tactical victory, one that should, at least temporarily, get oil, fertilizer and helium flowing again through the Strait of Hormuz, and calm markets that feared a global energy shock would lead to a global recession.

But it resolved none of the fundamental issues that led to the war.

It leaves a theocratic government, backed by the vicious Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, in charge of a cowed population that has been pummeled by missiles and bombs, and finds itself still under the thumb of a familiar regime, even if under new management. It leaves Iran’s nuclear stockpile in place, including the 970 pounds of near-bomb-grade material that was, in theory, the casus belli of this war.

It left Gulf allies reeling, with the discovery that the glass skyscrapers of Dubai and the desalination plants that make wealthy enclaves in Kuwait livable can be taken out by Iranian missiles and drones. Gas prices have soared, and are about to test Mr. Trump’s promise that they will fall again to old levels as soon as the fighting stops.

And it has left Mr. Trump’s political base fractured, with onetime supporters now accusing the president and his loyalists, starting with Vice President JD Vance, of violating their promise not to get America tied up in unwinnable wars in the Middle East.

It all happened at a moment when Iran has demonstrated that it can absorb 13,000 targeted strikes and still conduct an impressive asymmetric war, choking off oil supplies and sending its cyber army to attack American infrastructure.

Now Mr. Trump faces the challenge not only of reaching a more permanent settlement but proving to the United States and the world that this conflict was worth fighting in the first place. And to do so, he will have to demonstrate that he has removed Iran’s death-grip on the 21-mile channel that makes up the strait, and its chances of ever building a nuclear weapon.

On that point there was an ominous-sounding element buried in the Iranian description of the deal. Shipping would proceed, the Iranian foreign minister, Abbas Araghchi, wrote, but under the control of “Iran’s Armed Forces,” who would determine who passes, and when.
“Iran remains in the control of the Strait, which was not the case before the war,” said Richard Fontaine, the chief executive of the Center for a New American Security, a Washington think tank. “I find it hard to believe that the United States and the world could accept a situation in which Iran remains in control of a key energy checkpoint indefinitely. That would be a materially worse outcome than existed before the war.”

So might a final agreement. Four weeks ago Mr. Trump was demanding Iran’s “unconditional surrender,” saying he would determine when the country had been completely defeated. On Tuesday evening his tone was different. He agreed to base the next two weeks of talks on a 10-point plan Iran submitted to the Pakistanis. Mr. Trump called it “a workable basis on which to negotiate.”

“Have you looked at Iran’s plan?” asked Mr. Fontaine. “It reads like a Tehran wish list from before the war, calling for a global recognition of Iran’s right to enrich uranium, the removal of all American forces from the region and a lifting of economic sanctions. And it calls for the payment of reparations to Iran for damage caused in the war.”

Of course, that is just the starting point for the negotiation. But the gap between the Iranian view of a final peace agreement and the American view is so wide that imagining a settlement in two years, much less two weeks, requires some diplomatic jujitsu. It took two-and-a-half years for the Obama administration to negotiate the 2015 nuclear accord, which Mr. Trump dispensed with in 2018, and that was in peacetime. This negotiation will be held under the sword of a possible resumption of hostilities.

Presidents have been negotiating with Iran, sanctioning Iran and sabotaging Iran for 20 years. Now Mr. Trump faces the challenge of showing that warring with Iran achieves better results. It will not be easy.

If he fails to get the 970 pounds of 60-percent enriched uranium out of the country, along with far larger quantities of lower-enriched nuclear fuel, he will have accomplished less in the billion-dollar-a-day war than Mr. Obama accomplished 11 years ago. In that agreement, Iran shipped 97 percent of its nuclear stockpile out of the country.

If he fails to win agreement that Iran will limit the size of its battered arsenal of missiles, or the distance they can travel, he will have fallen short on one of his top objectives.

And if his talks with a government led by the new Supreme Leader, Mojtaba Khamenei, who is believed to be recovering from injuries in the bombing that killed his father, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, end up cementing the new government’s authority, he risks selling out the Iranian people.

It was only a little more than five weeks ago that Mr. Trump was urging the Iranian people to rise up and overthrow their government. Now he is doing business with that government. On Tuesday he repeated his claim that the new Supreme Leader is part of a generation of “different, smarter, and less radicalized” leaders. American intelligence agencies have their doubts.

“Maybe this will work out,” said Mr. Fontaine, a former aide to the late Senator John McCain. “But there is a chance that this ends with the U.S. and the world in a worse situation than when it started.”

Farnaz Fassihi and Anton Troianovski contributed reporting.
David E. Sanger covers the Trump administration and a range of national security issues. He has been a Times journalist for more than four decades and has written four books on foreign policy and national security challenges.
 
I thought about your focus on gas prices contributing to a midterm loss for Republicans. Which is a totally fair assessment.

Gavin will do fine in the Democratic primaries because there is a progressive core that will make him formidable.
I just wonder how he distracts the national public from California's chronically high gas prices.
For reference, I currently pay far less for gas than my friends in California were paying last year.

PS- I don't think Kamala was hurt by this because she wasn't a two-term Governor of California. She didn't win in 2024 anyway.


Kamala Harris, in my view, faced unique challenges that went beyond policy. As a Black woman, she did not receive the same level of unified support that Barack Obama once did, even among key Democratic constituencies like Black voters, particularly Black men and men in general.

At the same time, the economic environment worked against her. While macroeconomic indicators under Joe Biden showed strength, many Americans experienced rising costs in everyday life, especially groceries and housing. That disconnect between “strong economy on paper” and “expensive reality at home” created an opening for the bumbling clown.

Donald MushroomdickTrump capitalized on that perception. He framed his pre-COVID presidency as a period of relative affordability and stability, promising to lower costs and avoid new wars. That message resonated with key groups, including younger men, Latino voters, and a notable share of Black men, helping him rebuild a broader coalition. They were ticked, fooled by a conman.

As for California having higher gas prices than other states is real, but blaming this solely on Newsom is an oversimplification that ignores how the system actually works.

It will be up to Gavin to explain this and use this as his off-ramp. Place the blame squarely on Trump!




BELOW IS FROM AI...

"California requires a special cleaner-burning fuel blend that most other states don’t use. That’s not accidental—it’s a policy choice to reduce pollution and improve public health in a state that historically struggled with severe smog. Cleaner air comes with higher production costs, and that shows up at the pump.

California has higher gas taxes, but those aren’t arbitrary. They fund infrastructure, road maintenance, and long-term climate and transportation projects. Other states often keep gas cheaper by underfunding those same areas or pushing the costs elsewhere.

The state has limited refining capacity and geographic isolation from the rest of the U.S. fuel supply. When a refinery goes down, prices spike because California can’t easily import the exact fuel blend it requires. That’s a structural issue that predates Newsom.

California is intentionally transitioning away from fossil fuels. That creates a situation where oil companies are less willing to invest in expanding refining capacity, which can tighten supply and raise prices in the short term.

And finally, there’s a credible debate about oil company pricing behavior in California, with evidence suggesting higher profit margins compared to other states. That’s not something a governor directly controls, but it absolutely affects what consumers pay."



Gas is more expensive in California. But that’s largely the result of policy trade-offs: cleaner air, better infrastructure funding, and a faster transition to clean energy. You can disagree with those priorities, but it’s not accurate to frame it as simple mismanagement by Newsom. However, I am aware the Republicans will use it against him in an election.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
Kamala Harris, in my view, faced unique challenges that went beyond policy. As a Black woman, she did not receive the same level of unified support that Barack Obama once did, even among key Democratic constituencies like Black voters, particularly Black men and men in general.

At the same time, the economic environment worked against her. While macroeconomic indicators under Joe Biden showed strength, many Americans experienced rising costs in everyday life, especially groceries and housing. That disconnect between “strong economy on paper” and “expensive reality at home” created an opening for the bumbling clown.

Donald MushroomdickTrump capitalized on that perception. He framed his pre-COVID presidency as a period of relative affordability and stability, promising to lower costs and avoid new wars. That message resonated with key groups, including younger men, Latino voters, and a notable share of Black men, helping him rebuild a broader coalition. They were ticked, fooled by a conman.

As for California having higher gas prices than other states is real, but blaming this solely on Newsom is an oversimplification that ignores how the system actually works.

It will be up to Gavin to explain this and use this as his off-ramp. Place the blame squarely on Trump!




BELOW IS FROM AI...

"California requires a special cleaner-burning fuel blend that most other states don’t use. That’s not accidental—it’s a policy choice to reduce pollution and improve public health in a state that historically struggled with severe smog. Cleaner air comes with higher production costs, and that shows up at the pump.

California has higher gas taxes, but those aren’t arbitrary. They fund infrastructure, road maintenance, and long-term climate and transportation projects. Other states often keep gas cheaper by underfunding those same areas or pushing the costs elsewhere.

The state has limited refining capacity and geographic isolation from the rest of the U.S. fuel supply. When a refinery goes down, prices spike because California can’t easily import the exact fuel blend it requires. That’s a structural issue that predates Newsom.

California is intentionally transitioning away from fossil fuels. That creates a situation where oil companies are less willing to invest in expanding refining capacity, which can tighten supply and raise prices in the short term.

And finally, there’s a credible debate about oil company pricing behavior in California, with evidence suggesting higher profit margins compared to other states. That’s not something a governor directly controls, but it absolutely affects what consumers pay."



Gas is more expensive in California. But that’s largely the result of policy trade-offs: cleaner air, better infrastructure funding, and a faster transition to clean energy. You can disagree with those priorities, but it’s not accurate to frame it as simple mismanagement by Newsom. However, I am aware the Republicans will use it against him in an election.
You can tout Kamala the Presidential candidate if you need to satisfy some personal need.
The proof of her viability will be if she can gain traction in 2028.

As far as all of your explanations for California gas prices, Newsom will take some heat and have to explain it to the American public.
My opinion is that he will have trouble selling that to them.
Of course, taxes go to fund infrastructure and other things.
Everything you said is true, but you don't mention Calfornia has some of the highest taxes in the Union beyond gas taxes.
Faster transition to clean energy sounds good, but it also doesn't sell to the American public.

My point is I think the Democrats would be better served nominating a candidate who comes from a more moderate state.