War with Iran

I can. They are still fighting a 20th century war doctrine. Carriers can no longer be parked at will a few hundred km away. Ballistic missiles and drone swarm are cheap and will eventually get through. And it only takes one good hit.

And the USA military industrial complex is built around that doctrine. They don't have any secret weapons. There is no Hail Mary super weapon. Now its just going to be either leave, or ground war.

Trump is planning the latter.
Hey buddy. Wouldn't the "secret weapons" be secret. Why would you know about them?
 
I can. They are still fighting a 20th century war doctrine. Carriers can no longer be parked at will a few hundred km away. Ballistic missiles and drone swarm are cheap and will eventually get through. And it only takes one good hit.

And the USA military industrial complex is built around that doctrine. They don't have any secret weapons. There is no Hail Mary super weapon. Now its just going to be either leave, or ground war.
How do you know that for sure?
It seems we were unaware that Iran had the long range missiles they used or the level of surveillance and anti aircraft demonstrated.

When the U.S. dropped the bombs on Japan, the program wasn't a secret but the actual final product wasn't known.
The general public was definitely unaware.
It was actually the first test run.


AI Overview

The world did not officially know about United States nuclear capabilities before the bombing of Japan
. The development of the atomic bomb (Manhattan Project) was one of the most tightly guarded secrets of World War II, with only a small number of top U.S., British, and Canadian officials privy to the full scope of the project.
Wikipedia +1
However, the knowledge was not completely hidden from everyone:

  • Soviet Intelligence: The Soviet Union was aware of the U.S. atomic program through espionage, with agents reporting on Manhattan Project progress as early as 1941, well before the project was officially created. Stalin was informed of the project’s progress and believed the U.S. was working on a bomb before Truman officially hinted at it at Potsdam in July 1945.
  • Scientific Speculation: The scientific community globally knew that atomic energy was a possibility after the discovery of fission in 1938-1939. Many physicists knew that atomic bombs were theoretically possible.
  • Suspicious Activity: By 1942-1943, scientists in other nations noted the sudden disappearance of American scientists from academic publication in the field of nuclear reactions, causing them to suspect a major secret war research effort was underway.
  • Germany and Japan: Both Germany and Japan had modest nuclear research programs, but by 1943, they were falling behind and concluded that a functional bomb was likely too costly and technically difficult for the U.S. to produce in time for the war.
  • General Public: The general public did not know that the US had atomic bombs until they were used on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. The Trinity test on July 16, 1945, was reported publicly as an ammunition dump explosion in New Mexico.
    Reddit +6
In summary, while top allied leaders and Soviet intelligence knew or strongly suspected, the general public, and the leadership of Germany and Japan, did not know that the U.S. possessed a functional atomic bomb prior to its use in August 1945.
 
Sometimes the smartest guy in the room has to play dumb to get ahead, you don't put your brain on full display. Same with warfare, just because you're the strongest you don't show your full hand.

As much as Iran may have been underestimated, I'm sure the U.S. have more than meets the eye. People get wrapped up in wishful thinking.

Iran is playing the long game, america and Israel have used up most of their missiles and smart bombs.
Now Iran takes out infrastructure like airports and fuel depots and it becomes that much harder to fly bombers.

 
  • Like
Reactions: crocket
If you don't believe it's only 15, then any number you throw out is just wishful thinking because you cannot verify what data doesn't exist. It's basically believing all tweets that Frankie throws out.

I have no idea how many are dead, I just don't think its believable that its only 15.
But you are certain that only 15 americans have been killed because trump said so.

I completely agree with this because militarily, Iran doesn't stand a chance, but winning the war doesn't depend on winning militarily

You miss the effect of refineries and LNG being hit and didn't notice issues with Russia's biggest refinery or Australia's sole LNG plant.

Iran is sticking to their plan.

 
  • Like
Reactions: crocket
I have no idea how many are dead, I just don't think its believable that its only 15.
But you are certain that only 15 americans have been killed because trump said so.

It is not Trump stating so. Trump doesn't mention the dead at all after the ceremonies. Again, stick to the facts.

You miss the effect of refineries and LNG being hit and didn't notice issues with Russia's biggest refinery or Australia's sole LNG plant.

Iran is sticking to their plan.

The fact that I stated Iran has a chance of strategically winning the war goes over your head, eh? If someone doesn't give your side complete supremacy, you can't take it. AGAIN, stick to the facts instead of pushing only your hopes and dreams as reality.
 
Israel displaces another 1.2 million Palestinians in southern Lebanon. They are now homeless. They blew all the bridges so they can't return. Net result. Another land grab by Israel.


Israel is 7 million Jews and 7 million Palestinians.
But there are another 5 million Palestinians living around Israel.
With Iran, Hezbollah, Yemen, Hamas and the refugees who are rightfully pissed, Israel is playing with fire.

 
  • Like
Reactions: crocket
It is not Trump stating so. Trump doesn't mention the dead at all after the ceremonies. Again, stick to the facts.

Where is that number coming from?
Hegseth?


The fact that I stated Iran has a chance of strategically winning the war goes over your head, eh? If someone doesn't give your side complete supremacy, you can't take it. AGAIN, stick to the facts instead of pushing only your hopes and dreams as reality.

Again, you were talking about Iran winning by outlasting militarily.
That is not their long term goal, that's to take out Israel and bring america's economy to such pain they don't try this again.

Its not about who bombs more.
Try to understand.

 
  • Like
Reactions: crocket
How do you know that for sure?
It seems we were unaware that Iran had the long range missiles they used or the level of surveillance and anti aircraft demonstrated.

When the U.S. dropped the bombs on Japan, the program wasn't a secret but the actual final product wasn't known.
The general public was definitely unaware.
It was actually the first test run.


AI Overview

The world did not officially know about United States nuclear capabilities before the bombing of Japan
. The development of the atomic bomb (Manhattan Project) was one of the most tightly guarded secrets of World War II, with only a small number of top U.S., British, and Canadian officials privy to the full scope of the project.
Wikipedia +1
However, the knowledge was not completely hidden from everyone:

  • Soviet Intelligence: The Soviet Union was aware of the U.S. atomic program through espionage, with agents reporting on Manhattan Project progress as early as 1941, well before the project was officially created. Stalin was informed of the project’s progress and believed the U.S. was working on a bomb before Truman officially hinted at it at Potsdam in July 1945.
  • Scientific Speculation: The scientific community globally knew that atomic energy was a possibility after the discovery of fission in 1938-1939. Many physicists knew that atomic bombs were theoretically possible.
  • Suspicious Activity: By 1942-1943, scientists in other nations noted the sudden disappearance of American scientists from academic publication in the field of nuclear reactions, causing them to suspect a major secret war research effort was underway.
  • Germany and Japan: Both Germany and Japan had modest nuclear research programs, but by 1943, they were falling behind and concluded that a functional bomb was likely too costly and technically difficult for the U.S. to produce in time for the war.
  • General Public: The general public did not know that the US had atomic bombs until they were used on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. The Trinity test on July 16, 1945, was reported publicly as an ammunition dump explosion in New Mexico.
    Reddit +6
In summary, while top allied leaders and Soviet intelligence knew or strongly suspected, the general public, and the leadership of Germany and Japan, did not know that the U.S. possessed a functional atomic bomb prior to its use in August 1945.

They knew. They discounted it as relevant thinking their counter missiles would surfice. And that the airforce would neutralize them fast. They were quite wrong.

So you are admitting then the USA went in fat and lazy. Which they are. My point stands. They did not, DESPITE THE EVIDENCE IN UKRAINE, adjust doctrine. Iran has been supplying Russia. FFS. They had three years of real time watching what war looks like now. As I said and stand by. They are fighting as if its 1985 and Maverick and Goose are on the cockpit.

They went too high tech and expensive. A macro of what Nazi Germany did in Tank warfare. Look it up. The Americans won with small cheap easy to build and repair on site tanks. Except now its fighters vs dtones.
 
They knew. They discounted it as relevant thinking their counter missiles would surfice. And that the airforce would neutralize them fast. They were quite wrong.

So you are admitting then the USA went in fat and lazy. Which they are. My point stands. They did not, DESPITE THE EVIDENCE IN UKRAINE, adjust doctrine. Iran has been supplying Russia. FFS. They had three years of real time watching what war looks like now. As I said and stand by. They are fighting as if its 1985 and Maverick and Goose are on the cockpit.

They went too high tech and expensive. A macro of what Nazi Germany did in Tank warfare. Look it up. The Americans won with small cheap easy to build and repair on site tanks. Except now its fighters vs dtones.
I did?
Maverick and Goose?
Whatever....
 
Ironically as bad as all of battles were, the worst, according to the Marines, were Guadalcanal, New Guinea, and Pelilieu. The Japanese may have lost the war, but they absolutely decimated the USMC.

Funny those costs always seem to be for america.
Like they wouldn't want to admit they killed 3 million people in Vietnam alone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal
I understand.
What are the equivalent territories the U.S,. would have to send troops into to liberate from Iranian occupation before they go after Iran?
Are post war intentions with Iran the same as they were with Japan?

I'm not pretending to know, I don't think anyone else in here knows either.
My only point is that nobody can make a determination as to the full capabilities of the American military
based on far past historical precedent and what we've seen take place in this war to date.
Technology and weaponry have evolved exponentially, the dynamics are completely different.
Based on this, is my position that controversial or offensive?
I hope to hell the U.S. takes an ass kicking but I'm also cautious about any certainty around motives or an understanding
of full strategic capabilities or the absolute truth of where everything stands at this point.
Only thing I can think of right now is night vision goggles. Does anyone know if Iran has them? If not, US has an advantage with night vision.
 
I did?
Maverick and Goose?
Whatever....

I'm going to give you this. The possibility exists the Americans are indicating a ground force to retry to get the Iranians to concentrate forces, whether at Kargh Island to simply ambush bomb them, or to see if they fortify where the Uranium canisters are and get a better read on their location. Both plausible and I acknowledge the strategy behind it.

The issue I see however is what does Iran do. If they feel times up, especially if the Kargh Island infrastructure is destroyed they can, if they have the capability, all out launch on the Gulf oil infrastructure, and the Houthis on the other side.

And the world is fucked. That is always my argument, this isn't about military objectives. It's about protection of the world economy.