War with Iran

I don't think you're giving this enough thought.


Do you really think Trump gave this much thought, or was it more that Netanyahu was guided by the war hawks, people like Graham, on how to manipulate Trump into giving the order to strike?

It’s been reported that Trump was warned against attacking Iran, yet he went ahead because he “felt it in his bones.” He often disregards the expertise around him, dismisses science, and relies heavily on intuition. In my view, this reliance on gut instinct is what has brought us to this dangerous point.

I also believe that Israel likely would not have taken such action independently. It seems the decision was heavily influenced by external pressures and the unique dynamics of Trump’s decision-making style.




Yes, the ambition was as Butler1000 said, is to destroy the middle east so Israel can enjoy regional hegemony.

I don't believe they want to destroy the Middle East. Only the countries that they perceive as their enemies and that is Lebanon (Hezbollah) and Iran. Especially Iran who has been funding militias to cause trouble for Israel.
 
Only the countries that they perceive as their enemies....
They perceive the entirety of the middle eastern Muslim Arab nations as enemies, as most of them do not recognize Israel as a state.
So I totally believe that their goal is to destabilize and make all of these countries failed states in one way or another.
But they cannot do that without the US, and hence their control over the US via AIPAC and other lobby groups.
 
Oh I see. The mullahs and jihadis are the victims. Their religion is a religion of peace.
The west and Israel, they deserve it. They are evil. Except of course you and self-righteous suicidal radical lefties, who are probably hoping that the jihadis will spare them.

Iran didn't start the war, trump did.
Iran was in negotiations and agreed to strict terms and then trump attacked the next day.

I think americans are the ones that want and need a regime change now.

 
  • Like
Reactions: crocket
  • Haha
Reactions: SaulGoodman777
They perceive the entirety of the middle eastern Muslim Arab nations as enemies, as most of them do not recognize Israel as a state.
So I totally believe that their goal is to destabilize and make all of these countries failed states in one way or another.
But they cannot do that without the US, and hence their control over the US via AIPAC and other lobby groups.

AI Netanyahu is a bit like trump these days, no filter and totally ok with saying the really evil stuff out loud.

'we are the attacking side'

so much for anyone ever saying Israelis are peaceful.

 
In this case the US constitution. Remember Bush went to Congress and got permission for Afghanistan and Iraq. It's about getting the consent of the reps of the people, making sure one man does not have the power to unilaterally declare war.

It's also needed to fund the war, as Congress approves all spending..
I see. I am def not an expert on the US constitution but my understanding that the this is still an ongoing debate - it’s not black and white, and there is some nuance. I would defer it to the US court to conclude.
 
Standard military doctrine is attackers have a 3-1 ratio advantage of personnel, and if it is mountainous, 9-1. Iran is mountainous.
Technology can reduce that, as per Gulf war with less advanced opponent arnies..
There are around a million military members (soldiers, reservist etc) in Iran plus heaps of irregulars.

Hopefully the US troop movements a negotiating thing. But I fear dick waving is clouding judgments.
 
Bin Laden was a good guy at one time. He was working for the US, via the CIA.
Saddam Hussain was a good guy at one time. USA gave him chemical weapons to fight Iran. Iran did not use chemical weapons.
USA got rid of the Syrian leader Assad, and replaced him with a isis leader, a former head chopper.

Do you see how the USA is causing the problem?
The US may have caused problems sure. But that doesn’t matter right now, because the war has started already. It is happening. Therefore, they better achieve a desired outcome from it.
 
I see. I am def not an expert on the US constitution but my understanding that the this is still an ongoing debate - it’s not black and white, and there is some nuance. I would defer it to the US court to conclude.

Essentially the power was conceded by Congress by just ignoring what he does as President. It's been doing this for awhile because they don't want to vote on it. Then they have to take responsibility.

It's cut and dried. They just have to assert it.
 
Essentially the power was conceded by Congress by just ignoring what he does as President. It's been doing this for awhile because they don't want to vote on it. Then they have to take responsibility.

It's cut and dried. They just have to assert it.
I heard that argument but again there are other opinions and it is nuanced, not a straight cut. See e.g. this https://constitutioncenter.org/blog...te-take-on-a-new-context-in-the-iran-conflict
Again, I am not an expert in the US laws, and you might well be right. But, the jury is still out on this so I will wait until their court decides it was illegal, before calling it so.
 
Oh I see. They are not that bad then?
And the west should have waited until they have a nuclear bomb and long range ballistic rockets. Right. Makes sense.

trump was the one that tore up the JCPOA that guaranteed they weren't building the bomb.

40% of the world's helium is offline, MRI's and AI will suffer.
Aluminum, fertilizer, LNG....

 
AI Netanyahu is a bit like trump these days, no filter and totally ok with saying the really evil stuff out loud.

'we are the attacking side'

so much for anyone ever saying Israelis are peaceful.

That is all they know.
Air strikes, death and destruction.
They think it is going to bring them security.
But all they get are more missiles, rockets, terror attacks and global hate.
They are the architects of their own decline.