They can, but the Red Sea is harder for them to hit the tankers
Yes, it is generally harder for Iran to directly strike oil tankers in the Red Sea than in the Strait of Hormuz. The Strait of Hormuz offers a significant geographic advantage for Iran, with, as noted by shipping broker
SSY Global on Reuters, only two-nautical-mile-wide shipping lanes allowing for rapid, close-range attacks using missiles, drones, and small craft, as described in
this article from The New York Times. In contrast, the Red Sea is a much broader, more exposed maritime area.
Strait of Hormuz (Higher Threat Environment for Tankers):
- Geographic Chokepoint: The strait is narrow, forcing ships close to Iranian territory. This allows for easy deployment of asymmetric threats like swarms of fast-attack boats, drones, and mines, as discussed in this article from The New York Times and on Ynetnews.
- Direct Access: Iran can launch attacks directly from its mainland or nearby islands, notes The Guardian.
- High Insurance Risk: As reported on Winnipeg Free Press and by CNBC on Yahoo, insurance premiums are exceptionally high here, indicating high danger.
Red Sea (Lower Direct Threat from Iran):
- Greater Distance: The Red Sea is significantly further from Iran, reducing its ability to use its own assets for surprise attacks compared to the Persian Gulf.
- Reliance on Proxies: While the Iran-aligned Houthis in Yemen have attacked shipping in the Red Sea, these strikes are less immediate than the direct threats posed by the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) in the Hormuz strait, as discussed on Ynetnews and Yahoo.
- More Space: The wider, more open water allows more room for naval defense and surveillance, notes Foreign Affairs.
While Iran can use proxies in the Red Sea, the logistical challenges and distance make it a less effective venue for shutting down traffic compared to its ability to instantly threaten the narrow lanes of the Strait of Hormuz, says
Chatham House and The New York Times.