War with Iran

Saudi Arabia fought the Houthis for years, the Lebanese government has repeatedly sought to curb Hezbollah's independent military power, and Yemen's internationally recognized government is also fighting the Houthis.
You didn't answer my question. I will repeat it for you. Why should the west get involved?

Let Saudi fight the Houthis. Let Lebanon fight Hezbollah. What business is it of ours?
 
You didn't answer my question. I will repeat it for you. Why should the west get involved?

Let Saudi fight the Houthis. Let Lebanon fight Hezbollah. What business is it of ours?


Trump Drops 20% Shakedown. TACO (put in your day of the week)


Trump drops plan to charge fees in Hormuz, seeks Gulf investment deals instead
Jon Gambrell
Dubai, united arab emirates
The Associated Press
Published 5 hours agoUpdated 19 seconds ago
Open this photo in gallery:

People walk past a billboard showing the late Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei in Islamic Revolution Square in Tehran, July 5.Vahid Salemi/The Associated Press


1x
U.S. President Donald Trump on Tuesday announced a reversal of plans to charge a 20-per-cent toll on cargo going through the Strait of Hormuz, saying that Middle Eastern countries will instead make investment and trade deals with the U.S.
“Based on highly productive conversations with Middle East leadership, I have decided to replace the 20-per-cent United States Reimbursement Fee with Trade and Investment Deals that the various Gulf States will be making into the United States,” Trump said on social media.
The president said the investments “will be MASSIVE,” though it’s unclear if these would be new commitments relative to what Trump announced after a visit last year to the Middle East.
The U.S. had launched strikes earlier in the day, and Iran retaliated by attacking American allies in the region.
The latest exchange of fire leaves in tatters an interim deal meant to pause the fighting, reopen a waterway that is key to world energy supplies and give negotiators time to hammer out a permanent end to the war. Instead, fighting has once again engulfed the region, threatened the global economy and brought warnings to commercial airlines. Unless a diplomatic solution is found quickly, it could intensify into all-out war.
The focus of the conflict now is the strait, through which a fifth of all traded crude oil and natural gas passed in peacetime. Iran effectively shut the passage during the war by attacking and threatening ships – a tactic that proved its greatest strategic advantage. It sent the price of oil, fertilizer and other goods soaring at a time when world leaders were already struggling to address rising costs.
The interim deal was supposed to reopen the waterway, but Iran has attacked ships moving through the strait on a route overseen by the U.S. military that is outside Tehran’s control.
The U.S. has now threatened to reopen the strait by force – but experts say that will require a much bigger armada if not tens of thousands of American ground troops. It’s possible Trump will back down, as he has previously.


2:04


Reuters
Attacks resume across the Mideast
The U.S. military’s Central Command said it struck several areas in Iran, targeting “coastal defence systems, missile and drone sites and maritime capabilities.” Iran acknowledged the strikes but provided no immediate casualty or damage assessments.
“These strikes will continue imposing a heavy cost on Iranian forces and degrade their ability to attack innocent civilians and commercial shipping in the Strait of Hormuz,” the U.S. military said.


Iran responded with attacks targeting Bahrain, Jordan and three tankers that travelled through the strait. Kuwait’s military said it was responding to an aerial attack without providing further details.
Two of the ships were associated with the United Arab Emirates and were set ablaze for a time. The Emirati Defence Ministry said the attack on the tankers Mombasa and Al Bahiyah killed one mariner and wounded eight others. The Emirates threatened to retaliate.
Dutch shipping firm Stolt Tankers said that one of its ships came under attack. The attack on the Stolt Magnesium off Oman sparked a fire in the engine room, but the company said all the mariners were safe.

Iran’s paramilitary Revolutionary Guard said the Mombasa and Al Bahiyah “ignored repeated warnings.” Iran has targeted ships that use a route through the strait that passes near Oman outside of its territorial waters.
Hours after the U.S. said it ended its campaign of strikes, the Iranian city of Bushehr on the Persian Gulf was hit in at least four locations, the state-run IRNA news agency reported. It again raised the possibility that Gulf Arab states were attacking Iran in retaliation.
Bahrain, home to the U.S. Navy’s 5th Fleet, sounded its missile alert sirens three times early Tuesday. Jordan’s military said it intercepted four missiles from Iran. Jordan hosts U.S. forces and has come under attack by Tehran in recent days.
The European Union Aviation Safety Agency warned airlines against operating in the airspace of Bahrain, Kuwait, Qatar and the United Arab Emirates, as well as over the Gulf of Oman.
It said in a bulletin that “unpredictable military developments, combined with the possible use of missiles, drones, combat aircraft and air-defence systems, create a high risk to civil flights.”
Open this photo in gallery:

Vessels at the Strait of Hormuz, as seen from Musandam, Oman, Monday.Stringer/Reuters
Interim deal is in peril
Exchanges of fire in recent days had already cast doubt on the interim peace deal – now almost halfway through the 60-day period in which negotiators were supposed to agree to a final accord, which also was meant to address Iran’s disputed nuclear program and other issues.
But Trump’s vow to impose a blockade further imperils it. Washington lifted a blockade it imposed in mid-April as part of the deal. The U.S. military said it will resume it at midnight Wednesday in Dubai.
“We are reinstating the THE IRANIAN BLOCKADE,” Trump said on social media Monday. He had also said the U.S. would charge fees on other ships equal to 20% of the value of their cargo to help cover “any and all costs necessary to do the job of providing safety and security.”
That would have been a change to longstanding U.S. policy and a departure from recent U.S. promises that the strait would remain open to all without tolls – recently offered by U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio on a trip to the region.
Under the interim deal, Iran agreed that passage through the strait would remain free of charge for 60 days – but the agreement left open what would happen after. Iran asserts it has the right to manage traffic through the strait and potentially charge fees. The U.S. has disputed that.
Any attempt by the U.S. or Iran to charge fees would violate global norms on freedom of navigation and raise tensions, likely causing further economic disruption far beyond the region.
The price of Brent crude oil, the international standard, rose to a one-month high of over US$87 in trading Tuesday, still well below the nearly US$120 reached at the height of the war but threatening to raise costs everywhere.

This photograph taken from the southern Lebanese city of Nabatieh shows smoke as it rises from the site of an Israeli-controlled explosion in the village of Kfar Tibnit, with the Beaufort citadel seen in the distance, on Monday.ABBAS FAKIH/AFP/Getty Images
Mediators working to prevent a return to full-scale war
Regional mediators are still trying to get the United States and Iran back to the negotiating table, according to two regional officials.
The officials, speaking on condition of anonymity to discuss the delicate diplomatic process, said Pakistan-led mediation was working around the clock to reactivate the ceasefire.
Meanwhile, Lebanese and Israeli delegations were expected to meet in Rome on Tuesday to continue U.S.-mediated negotiations. Shortly after the U.S. and Israel launched the war on Feb. 28, the Lebanese militant group Hezbollah joined the conflict in support of its ally, Iran, and began attacking Israel. Israel responded with a ground invasion of Lebanon.
Last month, Lebanon and Israel announced a “framework agreement” outlining the withdrawal of Israeli forces from southern Lebanon in exchange for the disarmament of Hezbollah. Implementation has stalled.
Before the fighting around the strait intensified, Israel’s war against Hezbollah in Lebanon repeatedly threatened to derail the interim deal. A truce now exists in Lebanon, but it remains unclear whether it will hold if the U.S. and Iran return to full-scale war.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Is trump just now asking for direct payments to him, instead of the tariff he had no hope of implementing?

HNMxE0YXAAAJk3G
 
You didn't answer my question. I will repeat it for you. Why should the west get involved?

Let Saudi fight the Houthis. Let Lebanon fight Hezbollah. What business is it of ours?


First, if you're Canadian, you don't get a vote in what foreign policy the United States chooses to pursue any more than Americans get a vote in Canada's.

Second, Canada isn't fighting alongside Israel in the Middle East. If your argument is that the West should stay out of it, then Canada already largely is. The real debate is about U.S. foreign policy, and that's a decision for Americans and their elected government, not the Canadian government.
 
Nope, not even close.

The Hormuz straight was open and free before trump acted on Netanyahu's order to attack Iran.
It was open with a small tariff before trump attacked again.

Both times the closing is the result of the trump and Israel war on Iran that you continue to defend.
The problem is not the resistance to the attacks by Israel and america, the problem is the attacks on Iran, Lebanon, Syria and Yemen.

I don't disagree that U.S. military action against Iran has caused the shutdown of the Strait.

Where I disagree is your characterization of Lebanon, Syria, and Yemen. Their instability didn't begin because of Israel. Lebanon has struggled with Hezbollah's independent military power and political divisions for decades. Syria's devastation is primarily the result of its civil war, which began in 2011 and involved the Assad regime, numerous rebel groups, ISIS, foreign powers, and Iranian- and Russian-backed forces. Yemen's conflict also began as a civil war, with the Houthis fighting the internationally recognized government before Israel became directly involved.

Read a history book; it will help.
 
The real debate is about U.S. foreign policy, and that's a decision for Americans and their elected government
Indeed, and that debate is finally happening. About fucking time.
 
Indeed, and that debate is finally happening. About fucking time.

Never know what's going to happen in 2028 once Trump is gone and buried. I suspect the US will always be in Israel's corner, but to what extent will be up for grabs.
 
Never know what's going to happen in 2028 once Trump is gone and buried. I suspect the US will always be in Israel's corner, but to what extent will be up for grabs.
I love how your feet are firmly planted in the air.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Iran is definitely a problem for the Middle East.


A sailor was killed and eight others were wounded when two Emirati oil tankers were struck by Iranian cruise missiles in the Strait of Hormuz, the UAE said on Tuesday

Take your pick.

Forever war in the Strait
Near Genocide of Iran
Walk away and Iran, along with Gulf States control the Strait

Those are your options.
 
I don't disagree that U.S. military action against Iran has caused the shutdown of the Strait.

Where I disagree is your characterization of Lebanon, Syria, and Yemen. Their instability didn't begin because of Israel. Lebanon has struggled with Hezbollah's independent military power and political divisions for decades. Syria's devastation is primarily the result of its civil war, which began in 2011 and involved the Assad regime, numerous rebel groups, ISIS, foreign powers, and Iranian- and Russian-backed forces. Yemen's conflict also began as a civil war, with the Houthis fighting the internationally recognized government before Israel became directly involved.

Read a history book; it will help.

Again, you need to read a few history books.
There would be no Hezbollah if Israel didn't invade and occupy Lebanon in the 1980's. Israeli actions created Hezbollah.
Israel was still occupying parts of Lebanon even before the genocide and war on Iran, that is again, Israeli created strife.

Yemen was fighting the Saudis, that war was long and bad. It had ended before the Iran war, Israel brought them back into war.

Syria was a civilian revolt that became international groups vying for land. Now its lead by Al Qaeda who are tied to Israel and trump. And still Israel is building settlements in Syria.

If you invade and occupy other people's land than you are the aggressor, not the victim.
Israel is occupying Palestine, Syrian and Lebanese land.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
Never know what's going to happen in 2028 once Trump is gone and buried. I suspect the US will always be in Israel's corner, but to what extent will be up for grabs.

AIPAC and the genocide have made Israel toxic in america.
The GOP and dems are still lead by politicians who are bought with american money that comes back from AIPAC.

But the people hate Israel.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
Even if they attack a NATO member?


Bibi hasn't said he wants to attack Turkey. He's publicly opposed the U.S. selling advanced weapons like the F-35 to Turkey, but that's a very different claim from advocating military action against a NATO member. Those are two separate issues.