War with Iran

God I hope you're wrong. So sick of this.

Iran is not going to agree to complete capitulation. And that is all Israel will agree to. The USA can't look weak .

So enjoy the break. Once they change the tires on the planes and reload it starts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: crocket

Define it and we can discuss. To answer another of your responses, I'm for the 1967 borders, as the real mess, IMO, has happened since then. I want the Palis to have a legit state with legit bordered land. Those would be my compromises - no napkin maps either. We draw it, and it sticks. Get the UN to monitor the new border for a decade to ensure neither side blows it.

I'm reasonable Footer, it's others that are not.
 
Bullshit, Netanyahu ordered the IDF to kill Israeli Jews in order that Hamas couldn't take them prisoner.
Hamas' goal was to take prisoners to exchange for some of the 10,000 Palestinians Israel holds as prisoners.

Total lies. Hannibal Directive does not apply to civilians, that's a fact. You're just an illiterate Arab spewing nonsense as usual.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: SaulGoodman777
If it's Resolution 242? Yes. I'm against the occupation of the West Bank or Gaza in any capacity.

Resolution 242 did not demand the return of all territories, it only said "the territories" meaning up for negotiation. This is why the Israeli's fought hard to keep the word "all" out of the wording. Also, occupation of West Bank is legitimized by Oslo II
 
Last edited:
Resolution 242 did not demand the return of all territories, it only said "the territories" meaning up for negotiation. This is why the Israeli's fought hard to keep the word "all" out of the wording. Also, occupation of West Bank is legitimized by Oslo II

That's open to interpretation - I'm in the anti-occupation camp on the 1967 version of the West Bank, East Jerusalem, Golan and Gaza. I believe there is enough land for everyone. We just need courageous adults in the room on both sides willing to truly end 8 decades of this shit.
 
Define it and we can discuss. To answer another of your responses, I'm for the 1967 borders, as the real mess, IMO, has happened since then. I want the Palis to have a legit state with legit bordered land. Those would be my compromises - no napkin maps either. We draw it, and it sticks. Get the UN to monitor the new border for a decade to ensure neither side blows it.

I'm reasonable Footer, it's others that are not.

According to your terms, only the 1948 borders are legit.
Now you want to keep illegally occupied land in Palestine?
I suppose you think the same for Syria and Lebanon as well.

That's not reasonable.
 
That's open to interpretation - I'm in the anti-occupation camp on the 1967 version of the West Bank, East Jerusalem, Golan and Gaza. I believe there is enough land for everyone. We just need courageous adults in the room on both sides willing to truly end 8 decades of this shit.

I think its too late and it should be the one state solution with votes for everyone under Israeli rule.
Including all Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza.

fair?
 
I think its too late and it should be the one state solution with votes for everyone under Israeli rule.
Including all Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza.

fair?

The level of hate and distrust each side has for each other? Gotta be two states IMO. I'd take Barak's offer, draw real borders as above, and place UN peacekeepers at every sensitive border location to keep both fragile states moving forward.
 
That's open to interpretation - I'm in the anti-occupation camp on the 1967 version of the West Bank, East Jerusalem, Golan and Gaza. I believe there is enough land for everyone. We just need courageous adults in the room on both sides willing to truly end 8 decades of this shit.

Well the PLO accepted Israeli occupation of West Bank because they can't defend it from Hamas. Also, with Resolution 242 it required negotiation which the Arabs rejected with the Khartoum Three No's and by declaring war again in 1973.

The reason there isn't peace is because the Arabs don't have desire for it. They reject peace deals with unrealistic demands, and Hamas doesn't even have any interest in a peace deal.
 
According to your terms, only the 1948 borders are legit.
Now you want to keep illegally occupied land in Palestine?
I suppose you think the same for Syria and Lebanon as well.

That's not reasonable.

I'm just being realistic - Israel was invaded a few times and there has to be accountability for that as well. The 'illegal' occupation is, IMO, 1967-onwards.

I'm in favour of the Golan and South Lebanon being populated by UN forces again to enforce a true peace until it sticks - trust doesn't exist at this time. No Israelis to be in either area.

That's my deal. The Palis will NEVER get a better one.
 
I think its too late and it should be the one state solution with votes for everyone under Israeli rule.
Including all Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza.

fair?
Fair is not what Zionists want. They’ve been doing everything to avoid fair for 80 plus years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Historically a new nation and new regime was very rarely created by its
founders through land purchase and resolutions decreed by some coalition
of nations outside the region where the land was grabbed. Neither
chairman Mao and Chiang Kai-Sek had to pay landlords in mainland
China and Taiwan to found PRC or ROC; nor did they have to seek
UN authorization to become leaders of the countries they ruled. And
as far as I know territories within boundaries defined by nations in
the North America and South America were not purchased from
natives. By comparison to most of the sovereign states created in
history the state of Israel is bogus.
 
The level of hate and distrust each side has for each other? Gotta be two states IMO. I'd take Barak's offer, draw real borders as above, and place UN peacekeepers at every sensitive border location to keep both fragile states moving forward.

Ok, back to 1948 borders with restitution.
Add to that restitution for 2.5 years of genocide in Gaza and rebuilding everything there.
Then add in health care for the 2 million people who have survived the genocide.
 
I'm just being realistic - Israel was invaded a few times and there has to be accountability for that as well. The 'illegal' occupation is, IMO, 1967-onwards.

I'm in favour of the Golan and South Lebanon being populated by UN forces again to enforce a true peace until it sticks - trust doesn't exist at this time. No Israelis to be in either area.

That's my deal. The Palis will NEVER get a better one.

Palestine.

Its Palestine that was invaded in 1948 and has been invaded and occupied since.
Israel are the perps, Palestine are the victims.

You have to start from there.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: richaceg
I'm in favour of the Golan and South Lebanon being populated by UN forces again to enforce a true peace until it sticks - trust doesn't exist at this time. No Israelis to be in either area.

I'm in favour of Israelis getting the fuck out of Lebanon and paying restitution to rebuild everything there as well.
Hezbollah can stay, they are the only people that kept Israel from taking more of Lebanon.

UN forces should move to Israel to protect Palestinians from genocidal zionists.
 
Well the PLO accepted Israeli occupation of West Bank because they can't defend it from Hamas. Also, with Resolution 242 it required negotiation which the Arabs rejected with the Khartoum Three No's and by declaring war again in 1973.

The reason there isn't peace is because the Arabs don't have desire for it. They reject peace deals with unrealistic demands, and Hamas doesn't even have any interest in a peace deal.
Brainwashed from birth. Just Ziodrivel
 
  • Haha
Reactions: richaceg
Ok, back to 1948 borders with restitution.
Add to that restitution for 2.5 years of genocide in Gaza and rebuilding everything there.
Then add in health care for the 2 million people who have survived the genocide.

Then what you want is something resembling the Treaty of Versailles - how well did that one work out? Sorry to break it to you, but your side will have to compromise too. That's the only way anything positive gets accomplished there in either of our lifetimes. I'm willing to cede all land won/occupied in the 1967 War and kick every settler out of the West Bank immediately. That's my compromise.
 
  • Like
Reactions: richaceg