Want to Revoke a Work Contract

xix

Time Zone Traveller
Jul 27, 2002
6,000
2,673
113
La la land
Here is the situation in short.
Right now I am with ACME investment group. They posses several licenses to manufacture certain items. One of the licenses owners from Europe decided to go alone in Canada. ACME told them to take us along, since they couldn't give us jobs in the other departments.

So our current Manager is given the task to setup the new place. VWXZ agreed with his recommendation to move to another city which is an extra 1/2 hour to an hour drive for some people. VWXZ offered us jobs but the location is only convenient for the Manager not the rest of us. Since he lives near the area and not the rest of us.

Since my contract states "As of Dec 1" I start there, and ACME has us employed until Nov 30th, then we are transfered with our seniority.

We all know the manager is doing this for his own convenience and not the rest of us.

But if I find a new job say ... next week.

Am I committed to VWXZ at all? Although I signed the contract?

Of course I would quit ACME then tell this clown asswhole that I am no longer interested in VWXZ. So I terminated that contract.

The money may be more but only after I complained several times, so he changed the contract 3 times.
Then the location is far.
I feel like I am getting screwed twice and there may be a third time.
And the third is the worst. In the contract he put " can't work for the competition for two years." The clown is hiring from the competition right now. More like he is breaking his won rules. But I think he plans on keeping me/us for a week then letting me/us go just because of that clause.

Afterwards I would send a letter to VWXZ head office explaining my termination with them. In the end I don't think they care but I been told they do because they don't want to loose secrets and what ever.


How much can their lawyers screw me for if I revoke that contract?

What if I go to the competition after he fires me? Can they screw me?
My defense would be you hired the competition.

Anyone in this situation before.
 
Smiley is correct, NO company can limit your ability to earn a living in your chosen field. That clause is in so many employment contracts yet is totally illegal.....
 
The Law Society of Upper Canada has a good web site. I think you should log on and and see if you can line up a one hour date for Saturday night. Go for multiple positions and shots on goal. Work her over real good. Then come back here, tell us how it went, and then ask us again for legal advise on a complex contractual situation. Then in the end, you can compare and decide if you get better sexual service on the legal web site, or better legal service on an escort web site.
 
Non compete clauses are common, legal and enforcable.

On non-compete clauses (Law for Professional Engineers, DL Marston):

"... Such contracts may attempt to restrict the employee after he leaves such employment. The courts will apply principles of reasonableness and public policy to determine the enforceability of non-competition clauses in employment contracts. The courts are reluctant to enforce restrictive covenants that would severely limit the former employee's ability to earn a livelihood; each decision will depend upon the particular circumstances."

Length of non-compete may be assessed as unreasonable.

An employee starting/buying a business similar to one he recently left (common law presumes non-compete, in this case agreement in restraint of trade, is against public policy, and therefore void).


From your tortuous description maybe wrongful hiring may be more applicable?
 
tboy said:
Smiley is correct, NO company can limit your ability to earn a living in your chosen field. That clause is in so many employment contracts yet is totally illegal.....

Yes and No.

A company can't limit your ability to work in a chosen field but it CAN have you sign a contract that limits your ability to work for their competition. Remember, you're agreeing to sign the contract and work for the company. If you can't tolerate the conditions, then don't sign the contract.

A legal contract can't tell a doctor they can't practice, but it can tell an engineer that he can't work for a rival competitor for a limited time period. Six months is normal. A year is borderline and beyond that is likely excessive. But it all depends on the profession.

And then there's the whole issue of confidentiality. If you share information or trade secrets with your new company that you learned or developed in your old job, you're opening yourself up to being sued big time.
 
The original post is a rambling mess that complicates the issue unnecessarily. The bottom line is that the op's employment and work location are being transferred to a new employer. Unless the contract states that the op's work location will be X (which I can pretty much guarantee it doesn't), then he's tough out of luck. All the shit about the boss wanting to work closer to home is irrelevant (and sour grapes).

If the op doesn't want to move, then he can provide notice (usually 2 weeks but it depends on how long he's been with the company) and find himself a new job. If he were to quit tomorrow, technically the company could sue him if his sudden quitting caused them financial harm. But from the sounds of the job, that's not an issue. But let's say he had a client who subsequently ended their relationship with the company solely b/c the op suddenly quit on them. Then the employer could potentially sue him for damages. But as I said, it doesn't sound like this is that significant of employment.

It didn't sound like there was any breach of contract or constructive dismissal going on. It sounded like the op's contract was renegotiated several times and the op continued to work throughout so this isn't a case of the employer unilaterally changing the working conditions. If it had, the op should have quit immediately and sued for constructive dismissal. The fact that he kept working and even renegotiated (and I'm assuming signed) new contracts means he doesn't have a leg to stand on.

Now if the op's employer came to him on Monday and told him that he'd be working for a different company next week, that's a different story. First off, the op would have to agree to that (in writing) with a new contract. If the op didn't agree, then the current employer would be forced to lay him off and the op would be entitled to notice (or pay-in-lieu of notice) and possibly severance pay (but severance only applies if the employer has 50+ employees and a payroll of, IIRC, $2.5 million dollars or more). The amount of notice and/or severance depends on a number of factors, such as how long the op has worked for the employer, what his prospects for future employment are, the general economic conditions in the area, etc. But if the op agreed to the transfer then he's shit out of luck.

Shit happens. If you're not happy at your job and you don't have the leverage to get changes made to your benefit, then move along.

p.s., the "defense" that they can't prevent you from working for the competition when they're hiring the competition isn't a defense at all. It's quite possible that the people they are hiring didn't agree to the same restrictions on employment that you did.

Remember, YOU signed the contract and YOU implicitly agreed to its terms by continuing to work for the company. If you didn't like the terms, you shouldn't have signed the contract.

Seek out an employment lawyer before you do something stupid and get yourself into serious trouble.
 
Keebler Elf said:
....And then there's the whole issue of confidentiality. If you share information or trade secrets with your new company that you learned or developed in your old job, you're opening yourself up to being sued big time.

I thought that was the key issue in any "can't work for the competition clause". You can actually work for the competition, but you can't use give any confidential information from your old employer that would put him at a disadvantage with your new employer. It's quite common in some specialized high-tech industries to see the same person work for various competitors.

Consider the case of José Ignacio López de Arriortúa. He was in charge of global purchasing for GM and had access to confidential details of all GM supplier contracts worldwide. He left GM for the same position in VW.
http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpa...25751C1A960958260&sec=&spon=&pagewanted=print
 
I don't think so. I believe it's reasonable to restrict employment with competition for brief periods of time. It can't be unreasonable and it can't be for a huge area but I know I've read legal cases involving restrictive terms of employment that were upheld in court (at least in principle; the area/duration may have been found unreasonable but the idea was not).
 
Keebler Elf said:
I don't think so. I believe it's reasonable to restrict employment with competition for brief periods of time. It can't be unreasonable and it can't be for a huge area but I know I've read legal cases involving restrictive terms of employment that were upheld in court (at least in principle; the area/duration may have been found unreasonable but the idea was not).

http://labourlawblog.typepad.com/managementupdates/2007/03/index.html

Latest Word on Enforceability of Post Employment Restrictions

It is becoming increasingly difficult, though not impossible, for employers to enforce post-employment restrictions on competition and, so it seems, solicitation. Courts have, of late, taken a rather dim view of these types of restrictions.

The most recent discussion in this province comes from my former partner, now Mr. Justice Frank Newbould of the Ontario Court of Justice in Trapeze Software Inc. v. Bryans.

This was a motion by Trapeze Software Inc. to enjoin certain former employees by way of interlocutory injunctions from being employed by a competitor of Trapeze named Transched Systems Limited for a period of one year from the time when each of the defendants left the employment of Trapeze. Trapeze sought to enforce non-competition agreements signed by the defendants with Trapeze which provided that they would not be involved with a competitor of Trapeze for twelve months after they left the employment of Trapeze. Trapeze also asked for interlocutory injunctions (i) to enforce a non-solicitation clause under which each of the defendants agreed not to contact or solicit any Trapeze clients within twelve months of their leaving their employment with Trapeze and (ii) to enjoin the misuse or disclosure of confidential information of Trapeze which each of the defendants acquired in the course of their employment with Trapeze.

Justice Newbould summarized the law in the area thus:

* The general rule in most common law jurisdictions is that non-competition clauses in employment contracts are void.
* However, for a restraint on trade to be valid it must be reasonable in the interests of the contracting parties and also reasonable in the public interest.
* There are competing interests at play here. While there is an important public interest in discouraging restraints on trade, and maintaining free and open competition unencumbered by the fetters of restrictive covenants there is also a need to enforce contracts, freely entered into, “by knowledgeable persons of equal bargaining power.”
* The notion of “reasonableness” strikes an appropriate balance between these interests.
* Restrictive covenants must be reasonable in the following respects (a) whether the employer has a proprietary interested entitled to protection (b) whether the temporal or spatial features of the clause are too broad (c) whether the covenant is unenforceable as being against competition generally, and not limited to proscribing solicitation of clients of the former employee.

The Court went on to consider these factors and, as a general comment, concluded that, in the circumstances, 12 months was reasonable. Where the non-competition clause “fell down” was with respect to the geographic scope which was Canada, the United States and anywhere else in the world where Trapeze marketed its products or services during the period of employment of the defendants.

The clause was “overkill” which, as a general statement, is a good way to look at the law in this area - what is the absolute minimum level of protection that an employer requires to protect some legitimate business interest? If the clause is “overkill” or overreaching, it will not be enforced.

In concluding that the non-solicitation clause also was unenforceable, Justice Newbould relied on the recent Court of Appeal case of IT/NET Inc v. Cameron where the following non-solicitation clause was found to be unenforceable:

4.2 he/she will not attempt to solicit business from any IT/NET clients or prospects without the written consent of IT/NET. The intent of this clause is to reasonably protect the goodwill of IT/NET while at the same time not unduly limiting the ability of the Subcontractor to continue in the practice of his/her profession.

Goudge J.A. for the court sated:

However, clause 4 goes considerably beyond what is needed to protect this proprietary interest. The language of clause 4.2 prevents the contractor from soliciting business from any IT/NET client or prospect, not just from the client where the contractor has been placed. This prohibition applies whether or not the contractor knows that the target of his solicitation is an IT/NET client or prospect or whether he has any prior relationship with that client or prospect due to his work for IT/NET.

Justice Newbould concluded that the clause before him did not contain a geographic scope restriction which was also problematic from an enforceability perspective.

As he said, “as with the non-competition clause, Trapeze has failed to satisfy me that it has a strong prima facie case that the non-solicitation clause as drafted in this case is reasonably required or valid.”

The bottom line: don’t overreach. Courts are examining these clauses very closely, having regard to all of the circumstances, including the nature of the business, and the position that the employee held while employed. The deck seems to be stacked against employers in these cases, though there is some support for the view that there is a “scale” of clauses with confidentiality provisions being at one end and non-competition clauses at the other.
 
Just like to add

The job is not white collar, but just below. Also it is not general labor but up there with Trades ( machinist).

Mind you he made mistakes by copying other people's contract into my contract and making it look like I am with that group. Like I am not salary but hourly paid. He even put I need to give 8 weeks notice if I quit. My job is service or on the shop floor.

This guy is not on the ball and he is getting worse. Read his whole new bible manual and there is mistakes in every page. Not just from typing errors or sentence structure but incoherent links. Mind you the clown has broken half his own rules.

He said he had the lawyer look at it. But personally I don't even think the lawyer opened the envelope or look at it.

Well there is a lesson to learn here:

- when there is a switch in companies move to a different company
- Don't trust or take the manager word for anything
- Let HQ [ the other company or buyer ] know why you are not going with them not your manager
- gather the other company's representatives cards. ( even if you are not qualified )

- Kiss asses will always a get a better deal than you. [ although they DON'T do any work.. which is the case with us ]

- never work for a manager that brings in his own buddies [ sales will drop]
- they talk on the phone about personal stuff and not work

- if manager and other workers are from the same country be weary
- Never stay longer than five years in a company.
- if they hire from the competition and no new clients come in or brought in, from the new employee, he is not there to work, just play.


Oh well time to start looking for a new job, don't care about his idiot clause, let them take me to court.
 
I think he can claim constructive dismissal. He's being transferred to a different company, at a different location, to do a different job. That sounds like a "material change" to me, and I don't think that he has to accept it.

If he shows up to work and starts working he will be deemed to have accepted the new job. If, on the other hand, he refuses to do that he should be able to claim constructive dismissal and receive severence pay.

Moreover, he can take the rewritten contract and tell them to shove it up their ass, if he is not worried about being dismissed, or wants to be dismissed. He can cross out all the things he doesn't like, such as "can't work for the competition", especially if those things weren't in his current contract.

The employer then has the option of accepting the contract as he has rewritten it, or dismissing him with severence.

So he has options here.

On the enforceability of the "can't work" provision: Like many things, it depends. If he has no genuine opportunities to work outside that specific industry, based on his skills, it will not be enforceable. However, if he should able to find equivalent employment in a different industry then it will be enforced. The test will be whether or not it deprives him of a means of making a living. The more educated and informed he is, the more biased the court will be to enforcing it. The less educated and informed he is the more the court will be inclined to give him a break.
 
xix -- have you signed the new contract?

If you haven't signed it, you are entitled to go through it and cross out anything you dislike. Cross out "8 weeks notice" and cross out "can't work for competition" and cross out anything else you think is unfair. Make sure you highlight somehow the sections you have crossed out. Then sign it back to them (if you want to). You could also go even further and write in things you think are missing, making sure to highlight that as well.

A contract is negotiable and that is the standard way of indicating that you do not agree to certain terms. They will then either accept your revisions, or contact you to discuss.
 
A couple of notes on this topic:
-The non-contacting of the current/former company's existing customers is totally reasonable and (as stated enforceable).
- I would challenge the 12 months as being reasonable. In effect they are saying that you have to get a McJob instead of working in your current field.
- The way around this mess is to not advertise where you're going if you leave. It would be very time consuming for a company to try and locate an ex employee (unless of course the industry is extremely small).
- I would also say if challenged, the 12 months rule would indicate that the HRDC rules ought to be changed to reflect these rules if they are going to be enforced. ie: if you cannot work for a competitor, and this is enforced by the "government" then the "government" should support you at your current rate.

This topic is indicative of some things that have always bothered me about the way companies operate. It is only when you leave, they find that you have all this knowledge and value and want to restrict your use of that. I know the argument has come up with me that: we trained you, we gave you all this knowledge, and now you're going to use it elsewhere? My attitude (and I've openly stated this during my exit interview) is: Well, if my knowledge is so valuable, and you spent so much training me, why didn't you treat me better/pay me more etc while I was working here? Why is it so valuable to you now that you don't want me using it to benefit a competitor?
 
Sukdeep said:
I have had friends get severance packages because their employers relocated and they did not want to commute. Is this a courtesy or a statutory requirement? If it is the latter, perhaps XIX should simply ask to cancel the contract and get a severance/termination?

Sukdeep -- it depends on how much of a relocation it is. You are not required to accept a "material change" to your employment. If the move is across the street that is probably not a material change. If the move is across town such that it inconveniences you, it becomes arguable. If the move is far enough that you likely have to move to, that certainly is a material change.

Once you've established a "material change" in the terms of employment the employee does not have to accept the change, and can claim "constructive dismissal", receiving severance as though they had been laid off.
 
Sukdeep, but what if his commute is already 45min, and this is making it a 1:15 commute? What if he has children he has to pick up from daycare, and he will be unable to do that in this new job?

I think it becomes debatable. An extra hour a day that he isn't being paid for could be construed as a material change. Or not. It's not clear cut either way.
 
Right on

fuji said:
Sukdeep, but what if his commute is already 45min, and this is making it a 1:15 commute? What if he has children he has to pick up from daycare, and he will be unable to do that in this new job?

I think it becomes debatable. An extra hour a day that he isn't being paid for could be construed as a material change. Or not. It's not clear cut either way.

This remark is correct for another employee. She is a single mother, it will be an 1:25 commute. Do you think the manager offered a 407 transponder?

We been looking at the whole picture and noticed a lot of discrepancies.
- you will be trained.... DD employee is not and is worried
- new title... EE has no idea how to do that job and needs training
- from Joe to shop manager - current shop Mgr is retiring in a year,,, supposedly his successor will not be the shop mgr. and has been there for 8 years.
- rehired people that were fired before and they said they wouldn't come back.

What happen...

The first two they were promised these thing and it hasn't happen.
The third is funny and sad. Mgr got into a car accident he is not feeling well and will be off work for a month.
The fourth guy came to sign the contract and didn't walk into the other offices to say hi to people he used to know nor shook hands with a few of the females. He is marked as an ass.

Now what is the big deal???
well the kiss ass has already been sent to get some training in new product. HE is the CAD guy for crying out loud and doesn't sell anything and he cries when he has to. Leaves all his work for other to do.
Shop mgr was schedule for a trip to Europe next month, February, May and June. HE retires in August. Trust me he WANTS to retire.


Next time I will do what Fiji suggested and take a severance pay then find another job.

20071022
 
Last edited:
tboy said:
A couple of notes on this topic:
-The non-contacting of the current/former company's existing customers is totally reasonable and (as stated enforceable)...

Ontario courts have all ready ruled that generic clauses are not enforceable. The old employer must prove that the clause is "the absolute minimum level of protection that <the old> employer requires to protect some legitimate business interest. If the clause is “overkill” or overreaching, it will not be enforced."

Keebler Elf said:
..., then the current employer would be forced to lay him off and the op would be entitled to notice (or pay-in-lieu of notice) and possibly severance pay ...

That is what I have seen in this situation. You are given the choice to move to the new company under a certain set of conditions. If you disagree, you may remain at the current company, but you'll be subject to lay off if there isn't enough work for you.