Vigilante Justice?

Vigilante justice

  • Should the vigilantes be punished

    Votes: 13 65.0%
  • Should the vigilantes get off with a slap on the wrist

    Votes: 1 5.0%
  • Should the vigilantes be rewarded?

    Votes: 6 30.0%

  • Total voters
    20

Geographic

Member
Jan 21, 2002
392
0
16
Toronto
Check out this story from the smoking gun

http://www.thesmokinggun.com/archive/0818042nroyalton1.html

This poses a question. DId the vigilantes go too far considering the crime or did they give the perpetrator his just desserts?

Should the vigilantes go down for the crime?

Should they get off with a slap on the wrist?

Should the be rewarded?

My opinion is that they should have captured the guy and called the cops. Let the criminal justice system deal with him.
 
If we want to consider ourselves anything approaching a civilized society - there is no place for vigilante justice. (Having said that - try to explain that to the parent of a child who has been molested.)
 
Ditto box hunter....they didn't go far enough, imho....I agree that we are supposed to be civilized but hey, I think all child molesters should be put to death.....

If I was on the jury they'd get off with a reward, not a slap on the wrist.....come on now folks, the girl he was peeping on was FIVE!!!! I bet the next time he thinks about something like this he will remember the beating he took as a result and maybe JUST maybe he won't do it again.

If the cops had caught him he'd probably be back at the window the following night....
 
Whether or not an individual gets the death penalty is a separate but equally contentious issue. Before we get to that point - the accused needs to have the benefit of "his day in court".
 
Not saying what's being assumed didn't happen as the attackers claim, but there's always two sides to every story. From the police report when the officer described the victim to a resident:

"When I gave her the best description of the male she thought maybe it was the ex-brother-in-law of the tenant in # 102".

And that's who they end up arresting. So the ex-brother-in-law went over there just to peep in the little girl's window? Possibly, or maybe he was looking for his ex-sister-in-law?? Or, maybe he wasn't looking in the window at all, and that's the story they came up with? Whatever...it doesn't seem like the punishment fit the crime even if there was one.

zydeco said:
Whether or not an individual gets the death penalty is a separate but equally contentious issue. Before we get to that point - the accused needs to have the benefit of "his day in court".

I agree totally....
 
[ Possibly, or maybe he was looking for his ex-sister-in-law?? Or, maybe he wasn't looking in the window at all, and that's the story they came up with? Whatever...it doesn't seem like the punishment fit the crime even if there was one.


I don't say this often but I think this is a "shoot first ask questions later" situation. I think you lose all rational thought after you see someone looking into your- barely- out- of- toddler-stage child's window.