Very difficult IQ problem

I asked because 1 = 1 and 3 = 3.

1 is not 0 and 3 is not 2.25. Ever.

i guess that really depends on what rules you are playing by...what is 1 and what is 3? why cant they equal different things, they are just digits. i can assign whatever values to them that i like, the question wasnt defined.

I'm just pointing out that when you attempt to solve mathematical problems, you must do so using the laws of mathematics. If you don't, your answer is going to be wrong.

the title of the thread was "a very difficult iq problem", not "a very difficult mathematical problem". who ever said i was doing math?

Therefore, the key to this question is less about "knowing math" and more about the test taker being able to problem solve.
Exactly.
 
i guess that really depends on what rules you are playing by...what is 1 and what is 3? why cant they equal different things, they are just digits. i can assign whatever values to them that i like, the question wasnt defined.

I'm sorry but this line of thinking makes no sense.

The number 1 represents the value 1. You can't arbitrarily assign another value to it. Its value is already embedded in it.

If you see a question on a test with the number 1 in it, it is because the person that created the test wanted the value to be 1. If they wanted it to be 0 or 2.25, they would have written that instead of 1 and 3. This is as basic as it gets, I don't know how else to express it.

If numbers can magically change in value, then numbers themselves are meaningless. Hence there is no test that you will ever take where 1 = 0, and 3 = 2.25.

Without using math to solve a math problem, how can you expect to get the correct answer.

the title of the thread was "a very difficult iq problem", not "a very difficult mathematical problem". who ever said i was doing math?

I didn't say it was a "difficult" mathematical problem. I simply said it was a mathematical problem. It is an IQ problem because the difficulty of the problem lies in the ability to solve it rather than being great at math.
 
Last edited:
IQ tests are a guessing game. The idea is to outguess the questioner.

If the question asked for the best fit 2nd-order function with the fewest non-zero coefficients to match the chosen data sample, then the answer would have a single mathematical solution. Only people that took the math courses required to understand the question would be able to find the solution.

Instead, the IQ test poses psychologically weighted pattern puzzles. The better answers are given higher point weights. Thus maximizing one's score on an IQ test involves guessing at which solutions are given the highest point weights. "Intelligent" people improve their IQ scores by taking multiple tests. It is possible to get better at solving the puzzles, guessing which solutions have the highest weights, and to achieve higher IQ scores.

The original IQ test, which wasn't presented here, was complete because it a) contained multiple choice answers and/or b) asked for the simplest solution. He omitted both. Some people rationalized two answers. The original question only has one solution. So his version is not a proper test.
 
sure, you could do that, you could even make 9 x 9 = a puppydog if you really wanted to. but why complicate things and make 3 assumptions like in your example? i just picked the easiest way i knew to get the answer, but adickson came up with an answer that makes only 1 assumption, so i guess he is more right. if i knew more math i would have gone with that answer as well.

Puppydog? I guess using your method, you can assume that.

My point is that your rationale behind your solution is arbitrary and incorrigible. You make more than 2 assumptions actually. For instance, you assume that if 3 is 2.25 and that 9 is NOT 9/3 x 2.25 = 6.75.

Adickson wasn't being arbitrary. He used a consistent formula, where #s represent what they appear to be. He only makes an assumption about the @ operand, which the OP said is a mathematical operation (the OP said it was an arbitrary operand but it isn't arbitrary in that it is consistently applied).
 
i guess that really depends on what rules you are playing by...what is 1 and what is 3? why cant they equal different things, they are just digits. i can assign whatever values to them that i like, the question wasnt defined.



the title of the thread was "a very difficult iq problem", not "a very difficult mathematical problem". who ever said i was doing math?


Exactly.

I think dirtyharry means that you don't have to be a mathematician to solve the problem, but basic algebra seems to be required.
 
If algebra was required, then it would be a math test; anyone of trainable intelligence with algebra knowledge would be able to do it. But it was billed as an IQ test. Testing intelligence is supposed to be knowledge independent. Given adequate presentation of the problem, and use of only known symbols (using '@' to stand for 'some combination of arithmetical operands, consistant in each of the examples, which is the answer to this question' was certainly not a use familiar to me) the only requirement for solving it should be intelligence. A quick mind could solve it by testing guesses, or if it had been multiple-choice as stinky said, by testing the chouces.

As an IQ test the guy who insisted on plodding thru the algebra might well prove to be less intelligent—though perhaps better schooled—that the good guesser.