USSC rules against Gitmo detainee policy (for 3rd time)

slowpoke

New member
Oct 22, 2004
2,899
0
0
Toronto
http://www.cbc.ca/world/story/2008/06/12/uscourt-gitmo.html

U.S. court deals Guantanamo detainee policy major legal blow
Detainees have 'habeas corpus' rights, judges say
Last Updated: Thursday, June 12, 2008

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled Thursday that foreign suspects held at the high security military jail at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, have rights under the American constitution to challenge their detention in U.S. civilian courts.

The Supreme Court handed the administration of U.S. President George W. Bush its third major legal setback since 2004 over its treatment of prisoners who are being held indefinitely and without charges at the U.S. naval base in Cuba.

The vote was 5-4, with the court's liberal justices in the majority. Conservative judges, led by Chief Justice John Roberts, wrote dissenting opinions warning of the effect of the ruling at a time of "war with radical Islamists."

Justice Anthony Kennedy, writing for the majority, said, "The laws and constitution are designed to survive, and remain in force, in extraordinary times."

It was not immediately clear whether this ruling, unlike the first two, would lead to prompt hearings for the detainees, some of whom have been held for more than six years. Roughly 270 men remain at the prison, classified as enemy combatants and held without charge on what U.S. government officials say is suspicion of terror-related crimes or links to al-Qaeda and the Taliban.

Canadian Omar Khadr, the only remaining detainee from a Western country, is charged with providing material support to terrorism and related crimes in the death of a U.S. medic in Afghanistan in 2001.

It's not clear how many Guantanamo inmates have been formally charged with crimes, but the U.S. has said it intends to put about 80 detainees on trial and release the rest, once countries can be found to take them.

Enemy combatant process legally flawed: court
The Bush administration opened the detention facility at Guantanamo Bay shortly after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks to hold some of the hundreds of people detained by the U.S. military and intelligence agencies had detained during the invasion of Afghanistan later that year.

The Guantanamo prison has been harshly criticized in the United States and abroad for the detentions themselves and the aggressive interrogations that were conducted there.

Thursday's Supreme Court decision said not only do the detainees have rights under the U.S. constitution, but also the system the administration has put in place to classify them as enemy combatants and review those decisions is inadequate.

The administration had argued at first that the detainees have no rights. But it also contended that the classification and review process was a sufficient substitute for the civilian court hearings that the detainees seek.

The highest U.S. court has twice struck down central contentions by the Bush administration about the need for restrictions on legal rights for detainees at Guantanamo Bay.

In 2006, the court found the Guantanamo military tribunal process unconstitutional, but the U.S. government re-established it by pushing a law through Congress that set up the current trials process.

Two years earlier, the Supreme Court gave Guantanamo detainees the right to use U.S. courts to fight their continuing detention.
 
DonQuixote said:
Each argument the administration presented was rejected.

This decision will throw the entire process dealing with
the detainees into doubt.

It is a landmark decision and will be discussed for some
time to come.

The Writ of Habeas Corpus has been preserved.
As if the process hadn't been in doubt since it began. Until the detainees are either freed or charged under established statutes in properly constituted open court, I'd say habeas corpus may have been preserved but has not yet been applied. When it has, we can start believing in the US as a democracy again.
 
This "feel good" discision by the Court's liberal wing and swing Justice may very well come back to bite the Court, it ignores the president of Johnson v. Eisentrager 339 US 763

I must agree with Justice Scalia’s dissent in which he wrote: “Today, for the first time in our Nation’s history, the Court confers a constitutional right to habeas corpus on alien enemies detained abroad by our military forces in the course of an ongoing war. . .the writ of habeas corpus does not, and never has, run in favor of aliens abroad. . .the Court’s intervention in this military matter is entirely ultra vires.

This issue is larger than the issue of Guantanamo Bay, and this is a very unfortunate precedent for the U.S. Supreme Court to have set.

http://www.scotusblog.com/wp/wp-cont...06/06-1195.pdf
 
Aardvark154, lest you confuse people who might think you're referring to President Johnson v. Eisentrager, you might correct the spelling to 'precedent'

Habeas corpus dates back to medieval times, if it is a right, then it's unworthy of a nation that claims to follow the rule of law to try to restrict it to its own citizens and its own territories. Among them is the military base at Gitmo, which the Cubans would love the US to treat as a forein territory and return to them. Scalia and his ilk imagine laws so slippery the US can have the territory without it being US territory. Why not have everybody's 'trial' there?

If the US had chosen to honour its Geneva Convention obligations and treated the detainees as POWs there would be less objection. Likewise it might have referred them to the International Criminal Court. By choosing instead to write bad law to serve its current purposes, irrespective of all past principles of American justice, the Bush Gang has brought shame on their country. Fortunately, America's own laws and constitutional principles keep tripping them up, and their days are numbered.

For a Justice of the America's highest court to say that its power to adjudicate US laws does not extend military matters, or indeed any matter of American law is tantamount to saying there is no rule of law in America. Just legislate officers of Homeland Security as 'military' and scrutiny of their actions would also be ultra vires. Scalia's either overcome by partisanship or senile. And his days too are numbered.