I've got a whole stack of old vinyls, including an old Stones album in blue vinyl (Get yer Yah Yah's out).James_kw said:Theres a Velvet Underground lp on Ebay , http://cgi.ebay.ca/VELVET-UNDERGROU...309QQihZ020QQcategoryZ306QQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem
do you have it? Ill give you A buck for it.....
frankcastle said:In terms of the frequency range that can be captured on vinyl vs CD. Vinyl comes out the winner.
Frank,[LEFT said:frankcastle[/left]]Hey Garrett I can't confirm or deny your claims. All I can say is that a buddy of mine belongs to the audiophile version ofterb andhas studied this extensively. According to him the low and high ends of the spectrum are wider for vinyl vs CD.
Anyways, I think we agree on the main point though which is that a well recorded vinyl album sounds better. Ultimately I think that's the important issue.
Garrett said:This is not true. On technical grounds, CD has some major advantages, frequency range in particular. However, most CDs are now compressed to the max (some interesting articles on this) and we have no dynamic range (once again, an area where CD kills vinyl). As a result, most vinyl actually sounds better as it was simply recorded/mastered better. The primary reason for compression is most people think louder music sounds better (it is not subtle, but it really sucks emotion out of the music).
frankcastle said:Mark you're preaching to the choir..... as mentioned in my original post I did mention the turntable, arm and stylus. For those interested I think Aries and VPI make some killer turntables. Some of those arms look pretty funky I know people who will buy a broken turntable just to swap out the arm to another functional table.
As for tubes vs solid state you are correct.
As for the human ear it goes beyond that. There are frequencies that we can't hear but can feel which gets lost in low quality stereos and sound formats (e.g. mp3s). This too contributes to the genuine feel.
As for volume you are right again. A good system will allow you to hear everything without having to crank the volume.
shakenbake said:Sorry, but the LP has better frequency resopnse. CDs, conventiuonal ones, cut off at 22 kHz. Vinly have been known to contain well above 27 kHz. It is the harmonics that define a violin form a flute, or an English horn. Even at my old age, I can hear the difference when the harmonics are absent on a CD. There is also a granularity effect with the conventional CD that makes the higher frequencies seem a bit raspy. I have compared the same music, on more than one occasion on CD and LP, and the LP sounds more accurate. In addition, the placement of the sound is better IMNSHO on vinyl.
shakenbake said:Sorry, but the LP has better frequency resopnse. CDs, conventiuonal ones, cut off at 22 kHz. ...
l69norm said:but how many people have that kind of gear.
l69norm said:Actually it's somewhere between 4-22KHz.
Stymie said:but how many ppl have that kind of ear/ears