Use clean renewable power on the grid

Moraff said:
So, if I understand what I've read correctly, the green power is coming from already established hydro-plants for the most part right? Why would I want to sign up then? They're already supplying it to the grid at the price I'm currently paying aren't they?

That seems to be the implication, that they used to be used for powering Brascan plants, and now they are hooked up to the grid. So it is not clear how how you signing up for the clean power service actually results in any more clean power. If they took the money and built windmills, that would be different.
 
C Dick said:
So it is not clear how how you signing up for the clean power service actually results in any more clean power. If they took the money and built windmills, that would be different.

From the first post in this thread
Questor said:
Bullfrog has just commissioned 2 new wind generators on Manitoulin Island in order to meet increased demand. The wind generators are being built by a leading Canadian owner and builder of renewable energy generation projects. This new development is the second to come on line in the past year to meet the needs of Bullfrog customers.
It seems pretty clear to me. If new customers sign on for 3 Megawatts of power, Bullfrog isn't going to go to Brascan and ask them to close a mill so that they can take over their power plant. They are going to commission additional wind generators to meet the new demand. The choice seems straight forward to me. Stick with what you have and support conventional electrical power generation that comes from sources that are affecting our environment in a negative way. Or sign on with Bullfrog and support green alternatives. Why is that so complicated? I can understand that some people are on very tight budgets and may choose to stay with a cheaper power source. And some people just like to resist the idea of green power because it is too progressive for them. Or they are threatened by the thought of new ideas that may require society to change its ways. On the other hand, others who read about Bullfrog may not be aware that there is an alternative, and might like the idea. I'm just trying to spread the word. If you don't want to sign on, so be it. But don't throw out silly arguments trying to discredit the idea.
 
Well, I was looking for a better understanding, not trying to discredit the idea per se. I saw the initial post about them building a couple new generators, but also got the impression that most of their power comes from existing hydro facilities.

Wind generators aren't necessarily that green a solution if you include visual pollution in your list of pollutions. And just because you have a need for 3 MW more power doesn't mean that one new 3 MW wind generator will solve your problem. You also need a source of 3MW of power that doesn't rely on the wind blowing to generate it.

Wind farms aren't very nice to birds either.
 
Terbevore said:
Green electricity is yet another feel-good smokescreen created by the political elites to divert attention away from the real issue of imminent shortages. If we here in Ontario wish to continue to enjoy a high standard of living in the future, we should start now to build more nuculear generating capacity before the brown-outs start and the air conditioning goes off.


Right on! Plus, if we are really afraid of CO2, we should give nuclear stations to China. (China is currently adding, every WEEK, new CO2-emitting coal stations equivalent to Canada's total output per YEAR.)
 
Questor said:
...It seems pretty clear to me. If new customers sign on for 3 Megawatts of power, Bullfrog isn't going to go to Brascan and ask them to close a mill so that they can take over their power plant. They are going to commission additional wind generators to meet the new demand....

This is going a long way back in my memory, so I don't know if this is still true. It goes something like this:

There's a complicated system for water rights in the Great Lakes based on who was on the river first and how much water they use. You basically have a share to the amount of water and you can't affect anybody else's share:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riparian_water_rights

The Brascan plants don't run full out 24 hrs a day because they don't have rights to enough water to do so. It's possible to purchase water rights from other owners or share the profit from the use of that water (based on the contract Bullfrog has with Brascan).

A good example of this is the Niagara River System and the International Control Dam (Chippawa-Grass Island Pool) http://www.ijc.org/conseil_board/niagara/en/niagara_mandate_mandat.htm
http://www.nfpl.library.on.ca/nfplindex/show.asp?id=92386&b=1
http://www.opg.com/power/hydro/niagara_plant_group/intl_control_dam.asp

Essentially, there are multiple generating stations at Niagara Falls:
http://www.nfpl.library.on.ca/nfplindex/specials/power/upper.html
http://www.nfpl.library.on.ca/nfplindex/specials/power/lower.html

Quite a few of these stations are no longer in use, however the water rights are still in effect and the owner of those rights can sell them to the other stations that are still running.

An older station (less efficient) can sell their water rights to a more modern station (more efficient) and the Control Dam is adjusted to push the water to the right place. The more efficient station can make a greater profit than the older station which then sits idle.

It's actually much more complicated than this because all the stations on the Great Lakes interact. For example, extra water put into Lake Huron by a Brascan plant can then be re-used later by one of the Beck plants.

Also, on the topic of wind mills. The ratio of unit rating to capacity is about 25%. If a wind farm is rated at 100MW, then it is considered the same as a 25MW hydro unit. In other words, to displace 100MW of coal power requires 400MW of wind power. If a customer contracts with Bullfrog for 3MW-hrs, then they need to build 12 MW-hrs of wind power to support that
 
Questor said:
I'm just trying to spread the word. If you don't want to sign on, so be it. But don't throw out silly arguments trying to discredit the idea.

And what is it that qualifies you to hold such a pompous attitude? The feeling of superiority that comes from thinking you are buying green power? Nobody was making arguments, some of us wanted to understand how the green power really works, because it is topical. If you have accepted it blindly and can not answer the questions, that is fine, say so.

Buying green power is like giving to charity, a lot of people might consider it the right thing to do, but be concerned that they were not achieving the goals they thought they were, because someone was scamming and taking advantage of people that wanted to do the right thing. Green power is ripe for scams, because you spend your money, and get nothing tangible. So you have to have confidence in the providers, that they really are doing the right thing. No doubt there are or will be green power scams, and when they are exposed, it will be the excuse that lots of people use for not buying it. So it is important for everyone who supports green power to be informed and do their homework, not just accept it on faith.

The Brascan hydro thing seems like something that could be a good idea, where the incremental power comes from wind farms, so you really are getting what you paid for. Or, it could be a shell game that does not really make anything greener. If anyone has real information about how it works, I and others would like to hear it. But scolding people for not accepting what they are told without question contributes nothing. Do you think that people who do not care about green power would be taking the time to ask these questions?
 
l69norm said:
This is going a long way back in my memory, so I don't know if this is still true. It goes something like this:

There's a complicated system for water rights in the Great Lakes based on who was on the river first and how much water they use.
<snipped for brevity>
It's actually much more complicated than this because all the stations on the Great Lakes interact. For example, extra water put into Lake Huron by a Brascan plant can then be re-used later by one of the Beck plants.

Wow, definately a complicated subject, thanks for taking the time to dig all that out.

l69norm said:
Also, on the topic of wind mills. The ratio of unit rating to capacity is about 25%. If a wind farm is rated at 100MW, then it is considered the same as a 25MW hydro unit. In other words, to displace 100MW of coal power requires 400MW of wind power. If a customer contracts with Bullfrog for 3MW-hrs, then they need to build 12 MW-hrs of wind power to support that

Okay that makes pretty good sense.

So what happens when Bullfrog's generating capacity isn't sufficient to supply Bullfrog's clients energy demands (it's a calm day for example)? Do they rebate their customers on the difference since they're now using non-green electricity instead of the green power they paid for?
 
C Dick said:
And what is it that qualifies you to hold such a pompous attitude? The feeling of superiority that comes from thinking you are buying green power? Nobody was making arguments, some of us wanted to understand how the green power really works, because it is topical. If you have accepted it blindly and can not answer the questions, that is fine, say so.

Buying green power is like giving to charity, a lot of people might consider it the right thing to do, but be concerned that they were not achieving the goals they thought they were, because someone was scamming and taking advantage of people that wanted to do the right thing. Green power is ripe for scams, because you spend your money, and get nothing tangible. So you have to have confidence in the providers, that they really are doing the right thing. No doubt there are or will be green power scams, and when they are exposed, it will be the excuse that lots of people use for not buying it. So it is important for everyone who supports green power to be informed and do their homework, not just accept it on faith.

The Brascan hydro thing seems like something that could be a good idea, where the incremental power comes from wind farms, so you really are getting what you paid for. Or, it could be a shell game that does not really make anything greener. If anyone has real information about how it works, I and others would like to hear it. But scolding people for not accepting what they are told without question contributes nothing. Do you think that people who do not care about green power would be taking the time to ask these questions?
C Dick, I don't understand why you interpret my attitude as pompous or, if I am reading your response correctly, why you have taken such offence to my comments. I was not scolding you for not accepting without question what I was saying. I thought, and still think, that your statement "If they took the money and built windmills, that would be different," was clearly answered in my original post. That is why I reposted the information. If I misinterpreted your questions as insincere where they were not, you do have my apologies. And I am sincere in that. I do not accept anything green without question and would not expect you or anyone else to do so.

I agree with your analogy to charity and one's concern that money donated is in fact doing what it is supposed to do. Among green energy companies, I am not aware of any scams out there, although of energy companies that are less than green, Enron comes to mind. If you have any information about green energy scams, I'd be interested in seeing it.

169norm has offered some additional information about water rights and the ratio of unit rating to capacity that I was not aware of. I do not have all the information about Bullfrog's energy sources. I saw on the web page that 80% comes from certified low impact hydro while 20% comes from wind power. I haven't done in depth research about Brookfield Power (formerly Brascan), although the criteria for EcoLogo certification seems legit. What I know is that I like wind power, even if it kills birds and looks ugly to some people, and that Bullfrog is promoting that kind of power, as opposed to the burning of fossil fuels. If you or anyone else has any information about Bullfrog being a scam, I'd be really interested in learning of it.

I hope you and others check out Bullfrog Power and seriously consider it.
 
Moraff said:
Wow, definately a complicated subject, thanks for taking the time to dig all that out.



Okay that makes pretty good sense.

So what happens when Bullfrog's generating capacity isn't sufficient to supply Bullfrog's clients energy demands (it's a calm day for example)? Do they rebate their customers on the difference since they're now using non-green electricity instead of the green power they paid for?
Very good question. Does anyone here have the answer?
 
Questor said:
If I misinterpreted your questions as insincere where they were not, you do have my apologies.

Thank you. I apologize if I overreacted. My questions are sincere, I am interested in clean power, I was not trying to be a smartass. I know of no green power scams either, but human nature being what it is, I assume that it is only a matter of time. The notion that 80% of their power is from hydro just struck me as being too good to be true.

I like wind power also, I have driven through the wind farm by Shelbourne a few times and it is pretty impressive. But I don't think it can ever be a large scale solution, because when the wind is not blowing all across Ontario, you still need power, and at this point it is pretty inefficient to store electricity, you would have to pump water back over a dam or something.

I looked at making my own power at home, but it is nowhere near feasible. A decent home system, consisting of solar panels, windmill, controllers and batteries was $100,000, just for the materials, not including design or installation. And it would produce about one eighth of the amount of power that I use. So I conclude that the technolgy is not ready for that yet, perhaps something like Bullfrog is a reasonable alternative until I can do it on my own.
 
Questor said:
...Among green energy companies, I am not aware of any scams out there, although of energy companies that are less than green, Enron comes to mind. If you have any information about green energy scams, I'd be interested in seeing it...

Bullfrog has big contracts with Walmart, Royal Bank and Ivanhoe Cambridge (13 shopping malls: Burlington Mall, Dixie Mall, Oakville Place, etc)

It is kinda of a scam in that you already paid to build 4 of these hydro plants (488MW capacity) as part of Ontario Hydro and continue to pay for the cost of those 4 plants as part of the "Debt Retirement Charge".
http://www.energyprobe.org/energyprobe/index.cfm?DSP=content&ContentID=6144

Brascan/Brookfield purchased the plants because they were/are big supporters of the provincial Conservative Party whom were in power at the time of the sale. OPG (who is rate capped) sold these plants to Brascan who then sold/sells the power back to the grid at the premium rate (not rate capped). The value of the sale went into OPG's general revenue, not towards the debt.

One could argue that the price of electricity should be higher to promote conservation, however the extra cost is profiting a few rather than going to pay down the debt.
 
Moraff said:
...So what happens when Bullfrog's generating capacity isn't sufficient to supply Bullfrog's clients energy demands (it's a calm day for example)? ...

Bullfrog has to either hedge the difference with another supplier like OPG ( by contracting for extra capacity from another hydro plant like Beck) at a higher rate or Bullfrog purchases power on the open spot market (price set every 5 min)

Also, it not just a matter of plant generator capacity. The transmission lines must also be in place to deliver the power to the consumers. There are many places in Ontario that do not have enough transmission line capacity. This is partially because Ontario Hydro/ Hydro One stopped building new lines and cut back on maintaining old ones in preparation for privatization (i.e. maximize revenue, minimize costs to get the best sale price). This is why the wind mills are popping up in southern Ontario.

The shortage of transmission capacity has lead to something called a transmission rights auction where the right to use the powerline capacity is sold to the highest bidder. There are people who buy these rights and speculate on reselling those rights at a great profit on the peak days. Again, you already paid for those lines as part of Ontario Hydro. You pay for the maintenance as part of the "Transmission Charges" and pay for the construction cost as part of the "Debt Retirement Charge".

While it's not the same as what Enron was doing in the deregulated California electricity market, this all adds up as a higher end price for the consumer.
 
l69norm said:
It is kinda of a scam in that you already paid to build 4 of these hydro plants (488MW capacity) as part of Ontario Hydro and continue to pay for the cost of those 4 plants as part of the "Debt Retirement Charge".
http://www.energyprobe.org/energyprobe/index.cfm?DSP=content&ContentID=6144

Brascan/Brookfield purchased the plants because they were/are big supporters of the provincial Conservative Party whom were in power at the time of the sale. OPG (who is rate capped) sold these plants to Brascan who then sold/sells the power back to the grid at the premium rate (not rate capped). The value of the sale went into OPG's general revenue, not towards the debt.
Thanks for bringing your expertise to this discussion. It sounds like you have done some reading on the issue. However, if I am understanding what you are saying correctly, this is not a green energy scam. This is a public utility privatization scam. It is happening not because Bullfrog is generating green power, but rather because Ontario Hydro was privatized. At least that is the way I understand it.
 
C Dick said:
Thank you. I apologize if I overreacted. My questions are sincere, I am interested in clean power, I was not trying to be a smartass. I know of no green power scams either, but human nature being what it is, I assume that it is only a matter of time. The notion that 80% of their power is from hydro just struck me as being too good to be true.

I like wind power also, I have driven through the wind farm by Shelbourne a few times and it is pretty impressive. But I don't think it can ever be a large scale solution, because when the wind is not blowing all across Ontario, you still need power, and at this point it is pretty inefficient to store electricity, you would have to pump water back over a dam or something.

I looked at making my own power at home, but it is nowhere near feasible. A decent home system, consisting of solar panels, windmill, controllers and batteries was $100,000, just for the materials, not including design or installation. And it would produce about one eighth of the amount of power that I use. So I conclude that the technolgy is not ready for that yet, perhaps something like Bullfrog is a reasonable alternative until I can do it on my own.
Yikes, sounds like you are using a lot of juice. There are neighbourhood groups in Toronto that are organizing bulk purchases for solar photovoltaic cells and solar hot water heaters. The hot water heaters can be installed for between $4000 and $7000 and have a payback period of 5-7 years (for the uninitiated, I mean you can save enough on your electricity bill to pay for the system in 5-7 years). Photovoltaic cells can be installed for about $12,000 for a basic 1 kw system or $18,000 for a 2 kw system, with an expected payback of 15-20 years. But if you are talking about installing a wind generator, it sounds like you are on a farm or at least out in the country somewhere. And at the prices you just quoted, I'm guessing that you are doing more than running a household. Am I right about that? For info about solar bulk purchases, check out www.ourpower.ca
 
Questor said:
Yikes, sounds like you are using a lot of juice. There are neighbourhood groups in Toronto that are organizing bulk purchases for solar photovoltaic cells and solar hot water heaters. The hot water heaters can be installed for between $4000 and $7000 and have a payback period of 5-7 years (for the uninitiated, I mean you can save enough on your electricity bill to pay for the system in 5-7 years). Photovoltaic cells can be installed for about $12,000 for a basic 1 kw system or $18,000 for a 2 kw system, with an expected payback of 15-20 years. But if you are talking about installing a wind generator, it sounds like you are on a farm or at least out in the country somewhere. And at the prices you just quoted, I'm guessing that you are doing more than running a household. Am I right about that? For info about solar bulk purchases, check out www.ourpower.ca

No, just a household. But with a big house, electric heat, hot tub, nobody in the family has ever turned off a light but me, etc. Yes, I have the room for a windmill. The reason it is so expensive is that it is the cost to go off the grid, not just to be a net zero user of Hydro. If you are aiming for net zero power, you can just get a big windmill and generate it into the grid (Hydro must buy the power you make, though they hate it), then draw it out when you need it. The meter runs forward sometimes and backwards others, but the net is zero.

But I was looking at going off the grid, which means that you never draw power from Hydro, so you have to be able to always make it, or have enough stored. That is why you need solar, and windmill, and a lot of batteries, and fancy controllers and software, so that even when it is still and dark, you always have enough stored. Realistically if I wanted to go off the grid I would first scale back my consumption dramatically, with more insulation, better applicances, laptop computers instead of desktop, more family discipline, etc. Then I might have a shot at it. But the technology is advancing so quickly, and the pricing coming down, that for now I am focusing on energy efficiency, I will not put in a full system for at least a few years.
 
Wow! Sounds like a big project that will keep you busy for awhile. Off the grid would be amazing for you, but net zero would be great too. Good luck with it. The whole province needs to get serious about conservation before it will ever come close to meeting future needs with green(er) power.
 
Questor said:
Wow! Sounds like a big project that will keep you busy for awhile. Off the grid would be amazing for you, but net zero would be great too. Good luck with it. The whole province needs to get serious about conservation before it will ever come close to meeting future needs with green(er) power.

I don't like the idea of conservation so much. I like efficiency, better lightbulbs and things like that, but to me, lowering your standard of living to save power is not what humanity should be aiming for. Some of the hard-core guys I read about in the home power magazines are nuts, they have a 9 inch TV, the keep their 500 square foot house at 15 degrees in winter, they have tiny fridge, etc, just to save power.

My solution would be to build a giant nuclear plant, using the most up-to-date technology, far up North. Big enough to supply all of North America's power, without undue conservation.
 
Questor said:
... It is happening not because Bullfrog is generating green power, but rather because Ontario Hydro was privatized..

Yes, you are correct. Bullfrog is not at fault here and the power is actually "green". Brascan/ Brookfield maybe a little less so. What happens when you have a dry summer and more water rights than there is water?

http://www.energyprobe.org/energyprobe/index.cfm?DSP=content&ContentID=6144
In doing just that, Great Lakes Power (Brascan) drained the upper Mississagi watershed - to the point that it virtually emptied a cottager's recreational haven and forced tourist lodges and outfitters to temporarily close.

"It was not a pretty sight," says Mike Brown, the Liberal MPP for Algoma-Manitoulin. "There were beaches where water used to be, and fish trapped in small pools. Rocky Island Lake turned into a desert. Cottagers on Tunnel Lake went to bed and woke up the next morning to see their boats beached, sometimes hundreds of feet from shore​

Great Lakes Power operations manager Andy McPhee said the hydro plants abided by all legal requirements, and provided much-needed power to the Ontario grid​

Hydro based power is a lot more complicated than just running water through a dam (and I'm no expert in this either. Just about the same as you guys)
 
C Dick said:
No, just a household. But with a big house, electric heat, hot tub, nobody in the family has ever turned off a light but me, etc. Yes, I have the room for a windmill. The reason it is so expensive is that it is the cost to go off the grid, not just to be a net zero user of Hydro. If you are aiming for net zero power, you can just get a big windmill and generate it into the grid (Hydro must buy the power you make, though they hate it), then draw it out when you need it. The meter runs forward sometimes and backwards others, but the net is zero.

But I was looking at going off the grid, which means that you never draw power from Hydro, so you have to be able to always make it, or have enough stored. That is why you need solar, and windmill, and a lot of batteries, and fancy controllers and software, so that even when it is still and dark, you always have enough stored. Realistically if I wanted to go off the grid I would first scale back my consumption dramatically, with more insulation, better applicances, laptop computers instead of desktop, more family discipline, etc. Then I might have a shot at it. But the technology is advancing so quickly, and the pricing coming down, that for now I am focusing on energy efficiency, I will not put in a full system for at least a few years.

As far as energy storage is concerned, Hydrogenics to the rescue! The wind turbine at the EX runs, or has run, an electrolyser that produces and stores hydrogen. Vehicles and other energy consuming devices would use that hydrogen as required. This is but one way that energy can be stored. There are a few other ways out there to store the energy until when it is needed.

shakenbake

http://www.hydrogenics.com/power/powermedia.asp

and

http://www.hydrogenvillage.ca/Projects.htm
 
My guess would be that a system for my house that converted hydrogen to and from electricity would be expensive. Making hydrogen from electricity is cheap, but you would need a compressor to pressurize it, tanks to store it, and a fuel cell to burn it. Sounds like $100K+.