$US vs. $CDN rates at ATMs

In past trips I have always received the official exchange rate - currently, 0.77 when I get $CDN from a U.S. debit card at ATMs.

However this trip at a CIBC Atm I only got a 0.82 rate (real rate has been 0.77xxxx for about two weeks with very little change.

Tonight I went to an RBC ATM and got the correct rate of 0.77! Odd!
 
In past trips I have always received the official exchange rate - currently, 0.77 when I get $CDN from a U.S. debit card at ATMs.

However this trip at a CIBC Atm I only got a 0.82 rate (real rate has been 0.77xxxx for about two weeks with very little change.

Tonight I went to an RBC ATM and got the correct rate of 0.77! Odd!
A bank trying to take as much as it can for as little expense as possible? Never heard of such a thing!

Your experience is a good argument for dealing with humans you can argue with at least, or void the transaction and go somewhere else. Besides, humans can process the loose change part of such a transaction, and you might pick up some 'unearned' cents by rounding to the nearest nickel.
 
Still make exchanges at Casinos as ATMs don't give rates as good as in the past.
 
Your experience is a good argument for dealing with humans

Except for night owl, Dave usually replenishes cash like at 2- 3 AM! The was even a Timmy's that was supposed to be open 24 hours but was closed one night at 3 AM yet open another night about the same time. I normally don't get to bed till 4-5AM and get up about noon. To avoid being wakened by cleaning ladies put a sign out do not disturb till get up and never been a problem.
 
With FX transactions on credit cards, Canadian banks normally charge 2% more than the bid-ask spread on the spot currency. My bank has just upped the charge to 3% more than the spread. These are very lousy rates compared to converting cash at a reputable currency dealer.

IF you are comfortable carrying money, CASH is king !
 
With FX transactions on credit cards, Canadian banks normally charge 2% more than the bid-ask spread on the spot currency. My bank has just upped the charge to 3% more than the spread. These are very lousy rates compared to converting cash at a reputable currency dealer.

IF you are comfortable carrying money, CASH is king !

the other important thing is when you use cash (or a USD denominated credit card) you can buy the exchange at a favourable time and lock in your rate - with a CAD credit card you are at the mercy of the prevailing market rate when posted to your statement (at a gang rape rate)
 
Now back in Phoenix been looking at conversion on credit card charges and they are within a few dollars of the fairly steady current 0.77 rate. I get cash from my debit card and the ATM fee is refunded automatically (I use a smaller bank you never heard of). But the exchange rate as mentioned was marked up at CBIC atm and not at Scocia Bank (used twice and was at 0.77 rate). So even though I used the same Phoenix bank debit card for cash, the local bank that owned the ATM must have been doing the write up as you suggest.

Not sure what an honest currency exchange dealer is the rates at the airport are very marked up, so I have always gotten $CDN via ATM debit card and on previous trips were all at the real exchange rate.
 
Currency folks are pirates at Pearson lol...once asked how much CAD for 100 USD at one of the exchanges and was told 88 CAD....back then the exchange rate was 1 CAD = .80 USD...thus my 100 USD should have been 125 CAD straight up..of course you don't get interbank bank rate ...but should have got at least 120 CAD...apparently they were going to put on a transaction fee. Maybe they got confused and thought 100 canadian would get me 88 USD...still a shitty rate if real rate is .80). If driving through I find those kiosks on border pretty good...they add a penny or two...thus at 77 cents per US dollar (thus 129CAD for 100 USD) , you might get 79 cents. (126CAD for 100 USD). Used to get good credit card rates but now they tack on a service charge for overseas...
 
Now back in Phoenix been looking at conversion on credit card charges and they are within a few dollars of the fairly steady current 0.77 rate. I get cash from my debit card and the ATM fee is refunded automatically (I use a smaller bank you never heard of). But the exchange rate as mentioned was marked up at CBIC atm and not at Scocia Bank (used twice and was at 0.77 rate). So even though I used the same Phoenix bank debit card for cash, the local bank that owned the ATM must have been doing the write up as you suggest.

Not sure what an honest currency exchange dealer is the rates at the airport are very marked up, so I have always gotten $CDN via ATM debit card and on previous trips were all at the real exchange rate.

So the moral of the story is to avoid CIBC ATMs if you can? Of course CIBC appears to have more ATMs in convenient locations than the other banks...
 
I think all the Canadian banks charge in the range of 3 % these days for currency conversion. I've used Scotia, CIBC, and TD and it used to be 2.5, but they all raised it to 3.5 this year. That's compared to the mid-market rate, and not including any transaction fees, and withdrawing at ATMs. I don't know how you could be getting the actual mid-market currency rate from any of them (Canadian banks)...but in the US you might get that with some banks...I don't know.
 
I use the CIBC often - both bank and credit card - for US$ transactions, or conversions of US$ to CDNS, and I'm with Mencken: they seem to add (or subtract) roughly three percent to whatever the official exchange rate is being broadcast at the moment. That's their profit margin, I guess, and I can live with that.

However, they also add $3 to each ATM transaction of a cash withdrawal when I'm in the US, and often the US ATM will add its own $2-$3 fee. The one moral: take out money less often, in larger amounts, or better still, get it from your bank before you go to the other country.

Interestingly, when I wire money from Toronto via Western Union (those yellow Money Mart stores all over Toronto) to someone in the US, I get a slightly better exchange rate than I do at the CIBC! Western Union is a great way to wire a small amount of money across the border. The fees are very low compared to a bank wire transfer, and the person on the other end receives their money in cash almost instantaneously (versus a couple of days with the CIBC). I've done this several times with Western Union, and been astonished with how well it works, and for such low fees. It's really for the little guy, for amounts under $1000US.
 
My credit/debit cards are of course all from U.S. banks but seems the exchange rate is set by the Canada bank that owns the ATM.

I am also charged a typical $3.50 ATM fee but my bank immediately credits it back.

I tried what Einer suggested and ordered $CDN 500 from my bank a few weeks before I left to see how the rate would be and have some $CDN when I landed. However, the exchange rate was terrible.

Einer's Western Union suggestion I just checked on. What if I sent $1000 to myself to be picked up on Canada at a WU office which of course would be in $CDN. I used WU price estimator and if I paid in $US.

If I paid in cash with $US1000 the WU fees (but no clue on what exchange rate would be) the cost would be (all in $US):
Pay credit/debit card $95 transfer in minutes
Bank account $19.99 transfer in 4 business days
Pay in store (cash) $10.00 transfer in minutes.

However, then footnote 2 says:
Western Union also makes money from currency exchange. When choosing a money transmitter, carefully compare both transfer fees and exchange rates. Fees, foreign exchange rates and taxes may vary by brand, channel, and location based on a number of factors. Fees and rates subject to change without notice.

Conclusion at this point is to just find a RBC ATM since at least on this trip that was a no cost way from a debit card of getting the real xe.com exchange rate which was rounded $0.77 and quite stable last few weeks. Now that I got back to Phoenix the rate got slightly better last 0.759 per xe.com

Or, using https://www.finder.com I find four money transfer services that give me .756/1.308 to 1.312 reversed depending on how fast need transfer. Slow is fine since I get flights and hotels more than a month before trip.

Today had a long talk with a older client planning a trip to Toronto to visit his kids. He knows I am a bit of a Toronto travel person. Decades ago lived in Montreal and has dual citizenship. He also gets a Canadian pension and and his wife have four RBC accounts. He only has bank accounts and credit cards with RBC (in $CDN so no currency conversion issue). It is usually expensive to get a cash advance from a credit card vs no cost on a debit card. After my suggestion be called RBC (on Sunday) and was told they could issue a debit card for any account but have to come to an RBC bank to do so, not just send to his Phoenix address.

Also I directed him how to get fare quotes for Air Canada which is the only non-stop now from Phoenix - American dropped a few years ago and Southwest only goes to Buffalo. When SW was much cheaper have gone to Buffalo, enjoyed strip clubs in old days in Niagara, then Hamilton and drove to Toronto. But Air Canada is less expensive now direct to Toronto than Southwest to Buffalo.