US hypocracy in Haiti

cogterb

New member
Aug 1, 2003
60
0
0
As leaders of the free world the US makes a lot of noise about bringing freedom and democracy to countries such as Iraq.

To get a taste of the hypocrisy of this see the excerpt below which I found by doing a google search using the terms: aristide peoples government.

(When they say freedom thay really mean free markets).

I also included the link.


xxxwww.radioproject.org/archive/1999/9902.html

The three years that followed the 1991 coup in Haiti, led by Generals Raoul Cedreas and Philip Biamby, were brutal. A paramilitary organization known as FRAPH tortured and killed thousand of Aristide supporters and leaders of the Lavalas movement. FRAPH's top commander, Emanuel Constant, was on the CIA payroll. In fact, the establishment of the organization had been aided by the US Defense Intelligence Agency. Allan Nairn is an investigative journalist who has written for the Washington Post, New York Times and The Nation magazine. According to Nairn, who has covered Haitian paramilitary ties to the US, President-in-exile Jean Bertrand Aristide eventually succumbed to US demands for Structural Adjustment Programs prescribed by the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund. These institutions wanted the Haitian government to privatize public sectors of the economy and eliminate import tariffs, a fundamental shift away from Aristide's previous efforts to bring health care and education to the country's poor
 
LATEST UPDATE:

The official news is that Aristide has resigned.

This is not true!

He was interviewed by a US congress member around 9.30 am EST March 1 2004.

In that interview he stated that he wants the world to know that he was removed from his residence against his will by a diplomat and US marines and escorted to a location in Central Africa where he is being guarded by French speaking troops.

If true, that qualifies this as a US backed coup-detat against a democratically elected leader of another country and is therefore illegal.

My news source is WBAI radio. (Democracy Now, The War and Peace Report): website xwww.wbai.org
 
I don't know about Aristede, but from the beginning I found it interesting that when a country being torn apart by imminent violence asks for US assistance they hold back (so did Canada but we consistently play monday morning QB in these situations). apparantly a policy of preemptive war means ONLY preemptive wars.
don't know if the US is wrong for staying out that long or getting in at all or what, just an interesting variation on their policing hte world policy.
 
red said:
the US took months to get a force together before attacking iraq- the first US marines were in haiti in a week? you can call it foot dragging but if they were there an hour after the call from Haiti would you say it was a conspiracy like cogterb

Let's see, the US sent 1,000 troops to Haiti and well over 100,000 troops to Iraq. That timespan sounds about right to me. Plus, the fact that the US wasn't sending heavy armour or logistical support.
 
Goober Mcfly said:
George "Damned if you do, damned if you don't" W. Bush.

George "Dumb if he does, dumb if he doesn't" W. Bush
 
calling Aristide a democrat is absolute nonsense, this guy was freely elected the first time around but a clause in the Haitian constitution forbids a second term, so he has it cancelled out and runs and wins a second term in which alot of international officials observing the election called it fraud, alongside this guy was a former Catholic priest who embraced the idiotic liberation theology nonsense, i am glad to see him go, but the country should not be left to the thugs and murderers.
 
HYPOCRISY is spelled HYPOCRISY not HYPOCRACY

Sorry HYPOCRISY is spelled HYPOCRISY not HYPOCRACY.

Anyhow to get news on this I suggest doing a google search with keywords: aristide kidnapped.
 
It is pretty sad, that in many parts of the world (and that includes the US) most people have lost their trust in the US government. Even if they did something right, they would hardly be trusted.

It is at least partly caused by the US being the only superpower on the planet. Power corrupts, absolute power corrupts absolutely.
 
I wasn't aware of the circumstances around the last election scouser mentioned, which if they are generally accepted (the validity of the result far more then changing the one term max which is fine by me) then I think the US choice of not getting involved in the cout to protect him could be legitimate. it's just questionable from my viewing because of what appears to be an inconsistency in it's policing of the world.

ps questionable means there's question about the subject, not that I'm condemning one side.
 
Hey

gramage said:
... when a country being torn apart by imminent violence asks for US assistance they hold back (so did Canada but we consistently play monday morning QB in these situations). ....

Do what you do best!

OTB
 
scouser1 said:
calling Aristide a democrat is absolute nonsense, this guy was freely elected the first time around but a clause in the Haitian constitution forbids a second term, so he has it cancelled out and runs and wins a second term in which alot of international officials observing the election called it fraud, alongside this guy was a former Catholic priest who embraced the idiotic liberation theology nonsense, i am glad to see him go, but the country should not be left to the thugs and murderers.


Being as it may I still think a policy of covertly organizing/supporting armed insurrection against any elected leader flies in the face of everything the USA CLAIMS it stands for.
 
gramage said:
I don't know about Aristede, but from the beginning I found it interesting that when a country being torn apart by imminent violence asks for US assistance they hold back (so did Canada but we consistently play monday morning QB in these situations). apparantly a policy of preemptive war means ONLY preemptive wars.
don't know if the US is wrong for staying out that long or getting in at all or what, just an interesting variation on their policing hte world policy.
Pre-emptive action requires some sort of perceived threat to us. Haiti really doesn't have any vital resources or any supposed ties to terrorism that affects our interests.
Every nation looks out for its own self-interest. There is very little real charity on the international level...
 
ocean: accept that the instability that will doubtless result from this insurrection makes Haiti an ideal base of operations for terrorists (to land them onto US soil or to launch an assault from there possibly).
I don't believe that the US backed the insurrection, but I think there refusal to protect the existing government and then assisting his exit giving the cout legitimacy as he 'resigned' is a curious choice of action.
 
red said:
And your evidence to back such an allegation would be?


Maybe you missed this...

xxxwww.radioproject.org/archive/1999/9902.html

The three years that followed the 1991 coup in Haiti, led by Generals Raoul Cedreas and Philip Biamby, were brutal. A paramilitary organization known as FRAPH tortured and killed thousand of Aristide supporters and leaders of the Lavalas movement. FRAPH's top commander, Emanuel Constant, was on the CIA payroll. In fact, the establishment of the organization had been aided by the US Defense Intelligence Agency. Allan Nairn is an investigative journalist who has written for the Washington Post, New York Times and The Nation magazine. According to Nairn, who has covered Haitian paramilitary ties to the US, President-in-exile Jean Bertrand Aristide eventually succumbed to US demands for Structural Adjustment Programs prescribed by the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund. These institutions wanted the Haitian government to privatize public sectors of the economy and eliminate import tariffs, a fundamental shift away from Aristide's previous efforts to bring health care and education to the country's poor
 
Maxine Waters is so far to the left that she doesnt even have a right turn signal on her car. Take it with a grain of salt, she has a definite agenda.

Also, if you are criticizing the US (yet again) for taking action beyond its borders, what was your alternative suggestion? Leave Aristide in power to drive the country into further poverty and depression? Or perhaps Canada was about to launch its own pre-emptive strike ..... if the canoes werent in drydock.