Upgrade to Wireless Network - Competition for Rogers

cali

Member
Jan 16, 2004
106
0
16
http://www.financialpost.com/story.html?id=755887

BCE and Telus in 3G network pact
David George-Cosh, Financial Post
Published: Friday, August 29, 2008


BCE Inc. and Telus Corp. are set to announce an upgrade to a next-generation wireless network next week that will allow the companies to provide the same popular mobile devices, such as the iPhone 3G, that industry leader Rogers Communications Inc. offers, sources have told the Financial Post.

Multiple sources in the telecom industry said Bell Canada and Telus are expected to share the costs of upgrading from their current code division multiple access (CDMA) networks to the globally adopted high speed packet access (HSPA) network. It is estimated to cost the two companies as much as $1-billion and take about one year to install.

The announcement will put pressure on Rogers and not just because its two entrenched competitors will be able to offer a similar high-speed network. As well, new wireless companies may now choose to negotiate with Bell or Telus for roaming agreements, giving the two incumbent telcos a revenue boost.

The new network will allow the companies to support such popular mobile devices as Apple Inc.'s iPhone 3G and Research In Motion Ltd.'s BlackBerry Bold, which are already offered by Rogers but so far unavailable to Bell and Telus customers due to incompatible networks.

Nokia Siemens Networks, one of the largest telecommunication-equipment makers in the world, is said to be the vendor that will provide Bell Canada and Telus with the HSPA network upgrade.

Sources said Bell and Telus won't offer so-called "2G" GSM devices to avoid their customers paying roaming charges that would eventually go to Rogers, the only wireless provider in Canada with a GSM network.

Genuity Capital Markets equity analyst Dvai Ghose said avoiding a GSM network build-out will help the companies save capital expenditure costs while being able to tap into the "plethora" of new HSPA devices that will become available to cellphone users in the next year.

"It may not be an immediate reason to do it for the cost savings, but there's a more immediate reason to do it for the iconic devices," Mr. Ghose said.

Representatives from Bell Canada and Telus declined to comment on the possibility of a unified network upgrade.

The timing of the network announcement may be no accident.

This Wednesday will be the due date that wireless companies will have to pay Industry Canada following the conclusion of the federal government's spectrum auction this past July.

After more than one month of bidding by 15 companies, several new potential cellphone companies emerged such as Quebecor Inc., Shaw Communications Inc., Data & Audio-Visual Enterprises (DAVE) Wireless Inc. and Globalive Communications Corp. which appears positioned to become Canada's next national wireless carrier.

According to Industry Canada, to encourage competition in the $14-billion industry any new entrant will be allowed to roam on an incumbent operator's network while building out its own infrastructure for five years.

Although the new entrants have not released details of their cellphone businesses, analysts say DAVE Wireless and Globalive have stated their wish to pursue a low-cost voice-centric model to appeal to the roughly one-third of Canadians who do not have cellphones.

"If you want to want any of the new entrants roaming revenue, you pretty much have to be on HSPA," Mr. Ghose said. "This is important in the near to medium term [for Bell and Telus] to offset the loss of market share they will have."

However, telecom consultant Iain Grant of the Seaboard Group disagreed. He said that wireless companies focussing on voice packages, not data, will not necessarily need an HSPA network to roam on.
 
I'm confused by what this means for regular phones. It's not "GSM" but lets you use a GSM phone that supports 3g?
I have a 3g phone and would dump rogers in a heartbeat if I could switch back to telus (I don't give a shit about data BTW)..
Any insight?
 
It means...

Tangwhich said:
I'm confused by what this means for regular phones. It's not "GSM" but lets you use a GSM phone that supports 3g?
I have a 3g phone and would dump rogers in a heartbeat if I could switch back to telus (I don't give a shit about data BTW)..
Any insight?


...if you have a 3G phone (UMTS) it will work on the networks Bell and TELUS are building...(BTW...they are awhile away)...but if you have a "regular" Rogers phone it will not...and a "regular" Rogers phone will be +95% of the phones out there.

There is a VERY good chance your phone is not 3G, save for if it is an 3G iPhone or a Blackberry Bold. Do you know for certain it is?

Strictly speaking..there is no such thing as a "GSM phone that supports 3g". However, it is true that the migration from GSM to UMTS (the 3G technology of choice here in North America so far) was easier than the CDMA transition, so the first carriers to make the switch (Cingular, T-Mobile, Rogers) were GSM carriers. That said, UMTS is actually WCDMA...so no, your GSM phone will not work.
 
Great news!! We desperately need MORE competition to keep cell phone service fees competitive in Canada.

No wonder that Rogers, who obviously saw this all coming, wants to suck everyone into 3 year contracts! When the new competition hits the market in a year or so, with attractive pricing, everyone signed up with Rogers will be locked in and unable to move!
 
MLAM said:
There is a VERY good chance your phone is not 3G, save for if it is an 3G iPhone or a Blackberry Bold. Do you know for certain it is?

Definitely is.. I have a nokia e90. Apparently has HSPA support too.

Thanks for the clarification.. I left Telus a happy customer and have been longing to rejoin them ever since..
 
3g / Umts....

rubmeister100 said:
I'm a bit slow here...

I understand that the 3G is a separate data channel.

But will Bell and Telus switch over to GSM/Sim Cards for voice or will Apple make a special iPhone with CDMA voice and 3G data radios?


...is a different protocol. Same "channel" (meaning...same frequencies...within the assigned band). 3G accommodates both voice and data....the focus is on data because of the higher speeds, but a 3G phone is still a phone....and phones are used to.....talk to other people with phones.

No, Bell and TELUS will not be "switching over"...they will overlay a UMTS network on top of their existing CDMA networks...perhaps the disconnect is that you thought UMTS (what you and everyone else is calling "3G") was for data only...
 
Last edited:
I'm a little confused too. What is HSPA? Is that an improvement to GSM? Do HSPA phones use a SIMM card?

When Bell and Telus switch to HSPA, what happens to their current CDMA customers?
 
Nothing happens...

Cinema Face said:
I'm a little confused too. What is HSPA? Is that an improvement to GSM? Do HSPA phones use a SIMM card?

When Bell and Telus switch to HSPA, what happens to their current CDMA customers?

...to the current customers. Its an "overlay"...the current network stays in place...just like when Rogers turned their UMTS network up they operated it concurrently with the GSM network.

HSPA / HSPDA is the "data" portion of the UMTS protocol.

Really, none of you folks need to be concerned about any of this...just keep using the phones you have, and when you want to buy a new phone, the (presumably knowledgeable) sales person will tell you about the faster data speeds, etc. You are only confusing yourself about stuff you don't need to know anyway...
 
MLAM said:
Really, none of you folks need to be concerned about any of this...

Personally I do like to know a bit about the technical details.. but bottom line, I can take my 3g phone and switch back to telus when they have the network up.. that's all that really matters!
 
Errr...

Tangwhich said:
Personally I do like to know a bit about the technical details.. but bottom line, I can take my 3g phone and switch back to telus when they have the network up.. that's all that really matters!


...no. Not necessarily.

If you purchased your phone from a carrier, then that carrier is the only network that phone will operate on.

UMTS is NOT GSM....you cannot simply unlock the phone...UMTS is WCDMA...

I actually do not know for certain if you can switch carriers with a UMTS phone...I DO know you cannot (not without a LOT of hassle...far more than with GSM) switch carriers with a CDMA phone...so i would not assume that you can do so with a UMTS phone.

Again...despite the fact that Rogers was the first to go UMTS (for reasons explained earlier) UMTS is NOT GSM...
 
My phone is unlocked.. I purchased it that way as Rogers does not offer it.
It's a while away like you said, so it's possible I'll want a new phone by that time anyway!
 
Which...

Tangwhich said:
My phone is unlocked.. I purchased it that way as Rogers does not offer it.
It's a while away like you said, so it's possible I'll want a new phone by that time anyway!


...means nothing.

"Unlocked" means you can insert any other carriers SIM in it and it will work.

TELUS and Bell have CDMA networks...no SIMs.

Like I said (and will say again) UMTS is NOT GSM.

While it is not a sheer coincidence that Rogers has the first UMTS network in Canada (or that all the existing UMTS networks were built by GSM carriers), for this discuss it might as well be.