Unprofessional interviews: how to handl them

stinkynuts

Super
Jan 4, 2005
8,939
3,220
113
I was interviewing for a position as a waiter, when the guy asked me "How old are you?" The other interviewer specifically told me that they were looking for waitresses, and not waiters.

What a waste of my time. But more than that, I feel outraged that they would have the audacity and lack of manners to ask how olld I am, and then discriminate against me because of my sex. I'm sure both are illegal.

This is not the first time I've been in very unprofessional interviews. When I was interviewing for a tutoring position, I was asked if I was married. The same guy told me that he preferred to hire white Canadians.

In both cases I just grinned and beared it, since I needed the job, and didn't want to jeopardize my chances by making a big deal out of it.

Has anyone else had these types of unprofessional interviews? I wonder if I'm alone here. What is the best way to deal with these situations, other than to tell them that what they are asking is illegal, and that I am not required to answer them. I feel very angry and upset over the incident.
 
Age and sex questions are illegal, outright discrimination is also illegal, you seem to have collected all three of the big crash landings.

The best option is to finish the interview and walk out. Then reevaluate wheather you want that particular job.
 
Razon said:
Not legal to do that.. entrapment you have to state your recording, if you were gonna do that as a legal case, you would get your case thrown out and the person would be safe unless he did it again.. If someone did that during one of my interviews, i would end the interview and throw their ass out.
Err, you sure about that, cause last time I checked W5 did secret recordings all the time.

So did CBC 5th Estate
 
I had a similiar situation couple months back when i was looking for PT work at a new club.
First question dude asked me after i handed him my resume is "is that the name you have on your drivers license?" Yes (but i'm thinking WTF has that got to do with anything)
Then he also asked me how old I was.

Then at the end i was asking about pay and how tips work.
"dont know, you can work for a week or 2 and if you dont like it you can quit"
That was just the final straw. Was hired already by that point but after that i was definitely not going work for this guy. I just dislike rude people in general. But this was 1 of those situation where soon as i saw the guy i had a weird feeling about.
 
I once got an interview with the post office because they thought I was a black female...............That made for an interesting 3 minutes. :D
 
legal

Razon said:
Not legal to do that.. entrapment you have to state your recording, if you were gonna do that as a legal case, you would get your case thrown out and the person would be safe unless he did it again.. If someone did that during one of my interviews, i would end the interview and throw their ass out.

It is legal to do that. A lawyer told me you could that as long as I am not a cop.
Nor do I have to state that I am recording the conversation. I asked these questions when I took some issue I had, to a lawyer while he told me straight out about my issue, I asked what if I had a recorder.
 
papasmerf said:
I once got an interview with the post office because they thought I was a black female...............That made for an interesting 3 minutes. :D
You mean you only saw the interviewer for 3 minutes????????
 
Esco! said:
You mean you only saw the interviewer for 3 minutes????????

Turns out I was discovered to be a white male................Seems I checked te wrong box and he had to admit they were not interested in hiring white males......I was satisfied with knowing that affirmative action was the only reason they called me to an interview. You know reverse discrimination. Despite their insistence they did not do targeted hiring
 
Check-out the Ontario Human Rights Commission. They deal with employment-related discrimination and the issues you faced. It is illegal to discriminate based on age, gender, race or marital status. Are these employers that stupid?
 
Andy Stitzer said:
Would be a good idea to bring a tape recorder to every interview.

When interviewer does something wrong. Stop the recorder, show it to the person, and well the options are open.

1: You can have the tape for X bucks
2: I think I will be starting monday at [wage*1.33}


etc

That will get you started on the right path to a good relationship with your boss.
I would immediately terminate any taped interview and would not hire anyone who brought a tape recorder into any meeting

If the guy / lady is a jerk in the interview , chances are he / she will be a jerk to work for.
Your choices are:
1. Answer the question if you feel you really need the job
2. Tell them straight out "Never been asked that question before, I do not think it is appropriate." You have probably lost the job @ this point so his / her response may dictate how aggressive you get.
He / she may explain the question is related to some other hiring troubles they have had. How you play that is up to you

If he / she becomes a dick, tell them you are no longer interested in the job based upon the questions. Ask them for the proper spelling of their name and the name of the firms HR representative / complaints department as you
1. Do not like your valuable time wasted
2. Believe very strongly in the Charter of rights
Then leave the room quickly so you do not have to smell the shit they just deposited in their pants
 
JohnLarue said:
That will get you started on the right path to a good relationship with your boss.
I would immediately terminate any taped interview and would not hire anyone who brought a tape recorder into any meeting

If the guy / lady is a jerk in the interview , chances are he / she will be a jerk to work for.
Your choices are:
1. Answer the question if you feel you really need the job
2. Tell them straight out "Never been asked that question before, I do not think it is appropriate." You have probably lost the job @ this point so his / her response may dictate how aggressive you get.
He / she may explain the question is related to some other hiring troubles they have had. How you play that is up to you

If he / she becomes a dick, tell them you are no longer interested in the job based upon the questions. Ask them for the proper spelling of their name and the name of the firms HR representative / complaints department as you
1. Do not like your valuable time wasted
2. Believe very strongly in the Charter of rights
Then leave the room quickly so you do not have to smell the shit they just deposited in their pants
Certainly the two question posed are illegal in both Canada and the U.S.A. But the above is probably the best advice as to how to deal with it.
 
It's not illegal in Canada to record any conversation in which you yourself participate. Many people do it for simple record-keeping. Common courtesy means you usually inform the other party(s), but it's not a legal requirement.

In criminal cases, mostly, a person will not be convicted based on a recording done without his consent.

In civil cases (e.g a suit for damages for violation of human rights), recordings done without consent of the other party are mostly OK as evidence.
 
Andy Stitzer said:
WOuld be a good idea to bring a tape recorder to every interview.

When interviewer does something wrong. Stop the recorder, show it to the person, and well the options are open.

1: You can have the tape for X bucks
2: I think I will be starting monday at [wage*1.33}


etc
that sounds like extortion