University Advice Needed!!

johnyboy said:
Thanks for taking the time to read my post. My son goes to a small university and taking a 1st year business course. He was an honour student in high school and just finished his first semester with an 81 average mark. As he looks to me for advice I am concerned he should maybe focuss on getting into a bigger university or more prominent one in year 2 or 3. He wants to be a lawyer and works very hard to get those marks. My feeling is that university title is everything. I am rather dissapointed in the quality of the education he is recieving and it seems as though you don't even need to go to class. Several of his proffs have a very heavy accent which he has trouble understanding and they seem very unorganised and lazy. What should he do because you only get one shot at this. The reason for sending him to this university is he could stay at home but I think he is ready to move on. Is the someone you can get advice from on these matters as I really have no clue as I never went. Thanks

It's LSAT scores combined with undergrad marks that will determine whether he has shot at law school. You can get into law school after attending a smaller university. Your son may not do well in larger university setting. A kid who gets the honour roll in high school will likely get C+/B average in a more prestigious academic program. I think that 81% is a cut off point for many law schools if he nails the LSAT. I would make sure he knows he is just on cusp now and should lift grades higher if he really wants a shot.

I would recommend that he stay put for time being. He will squander opportunity if he changes school and his grades take a hit.

University title is not everything. In fact some schools do not really look well upon transfer students. Besides it is sometimes hard for the new kids to adapt to new school when they transfer. So they get picked last for study groups or don't know the classes to avoid.

He should start doing volunteer work at a food bank or mentoring underprivileged kids if he really wants to add something to his resume. Maybe he could volunteer at an organization for immigrants who are new to the country and want to start a business. It would look good on the law school application.

One last thing to bear in mind is that there are thousands of smarter, more qualified people who don't get into law school every year. The demand is much greater than the supply. It's said that getting into law school is the tougest thing. You would be amzed how little work is required once enrolled as everyone is on a "b" mark bell curve.

Fernie
 
Johnnyboy, a few comments:

LSAT scores are quite important, and for “traditional” straight from undergraduate education applicants so is one’s GPA, the more work experience one has the less important GPA becomes. Law Schools don’t much look at traditional graduate degree programs because the seminar and paper approach of most postgraduate level courses just doesn’t apply to law school.

There are only 16 common law (everyone save for Québec) law schools in Canada, so as a generality it’s harder to get into a Canadian law school. A fair number of Canadians therefore attend law school in the U.S. and have their degrees evaluated by the National Committee on Accreditation of the Federation of Law Societies of Canada typically this involves them doing an additional year at a Canadian school before being eligible for the bar exam.

There are also several law schools which offer joint degree programs that allow one to sit bar exams in both the U.S. and Canada.

The law schools at both Michigan State University and American University offer a four year joint program with the University of Ottawa and the University of Detroit-Mercy has a joint degree program with the University of Windsor.


http://rc.lsuc.on.ca/jsp/membershipServices/becomingALawyer.jsp
 
johnyboy said:
My son goes to a small university and taking a 1st year business course. He was an honour student in high school and just finished his first semester with an 81 average mark.

Well, where else did he apply? I say get into a University that is a good school with a name, THEN worry about having to pay for it after being accepted.
What courses did he take to be a honour student (basic arithmetic), then all of a sudden an "okay" 81 average mark (Calculus III)?

If Professors are absent minded, and I have had them too, one can always withdraw out of the course by a certain date. You are paying for it.

Gyaos Baltar.
 
Damondean said:
It is a little hard to give advice without knowing what univeristy he goes to now. But it appears that the LSAT test score is all that matters for law school.

The law is not for everyone so find out what he wants to do. I know a number of lawyers who do not like their biz. We have a lot of lawyers and it's a very competitive field.

As for the profs at you son's school, that seems to be par for the course. Every university only has a few star teachers who inspire students.

I am not sure that TERB is the best place for this sort of advice

I disagree, I would bet that TERB is an excellent place to ask such advice.

I'd wager that there are on here:

1. More University grads than not

2. More lawyers than you can shake your stick at

3. A few University profs even.



To the original poster:

I'm not a lawyer, but I do have a Univeristy Education. The guys I knew who went to law school (or more likely than not, failed to get in to Law School) all did the same thing - They took the easiest courses they could find in order to get the maximum grades. We're talking the artsie artsie courses. Get the marks, ace the LSAT, and you're in. Your undergrad counts for shit, they wanted to be lawyers damn it. (Problem was that by taking the bird courses, they didn't have the ability to really think or they weren't really that smart either - not that that would preclude you from a career in the law anyway. :D )

Mind you, as I said, most were too dumb to ace the LSAT, so they ended up with a useless Poli Sci Degree.

Now, if your son wants to be a corporate lawyer, or draw on his business education while working in the law, then yeah, he should be a University more known for its business program - Western, Queens, (U of T, Waterloo, MacMaster to a lesser extent.) At least then, if he didn't make the grade to get into LS, he'd have a decent degree from a good school. But the Catch 22 is that the better schools are much harder to get a higher average. Plus, if he wants a solid background in business and incorporate that into his legal career, he should finish his undergrad in Commerce, then get a job for 2 or 3 years working for one of the banks, or Accounting firms in order to gain valuable experience. If he's just going to go right into LS from his undergrad, then I'd be inclined to not worry about what school he's getting his undergrad at.

As to the profs, it was the same thing 20 years ago. Most profs HATE teaching, they view it strictly as a necessary evil. They are there to be part of academia, to research, to write books, papers, etc. Teaching empty headed 20 year old kids is work (There are a few exceptions, my late Italian History professor at McMaster - Dr. Ezio Cappadocia was one of the finest human beings I have ever met in my life. (I took history as an elective.) He LOVED teaching, and LOVED his students unlike any other prof I ever had. He was a man who was doing exactly what he was born to do. He was the Mohammed Ali of Univeristy professors.)
 
You can transfer up to 50% of your credits to another school so basically 2 years if you want to transfer. As long as they match up to a degree.

Don't get me wrong I am not some over bearing parent living vicarously through there child. And he is not making those comments about the Uoit but me sharing my observations. It is just that we both have no clue and you don't get a second chance. Ultimately it will be his decision. He did get accepted at other universities and took the tough courses in high school ie calculus III. After reading all of the post I certainly feel much better and have a better under standing of the process. Either my wife or me have not been to post secondary education so we are really not much help.

As far as the reasearch hours and whatever proffs do other than teaching it just seems weird to me that such little emphasis is put on the learing experience. Tough shit if you don't like it they say...well I get that ....but wasn't that GM's attitude not to long ago. :) Thanks for the replies!!!
 
johnyboy said:
Terb is a microcosim of society as we know it and the very best reside in the virtual world. We have lawyers proffs, university students past and present guidance counsellors, parents what more could you ask for. Just because they like an extra helping of poon is no reason to disqualify their opinion my friend

LOL,

I believe I said the same thing, however, you did say it so much better. :p
 
In thinking some more about this, I'd probably say....

Stay where he is for his undergrad, get the marks to get into LS.

If he fails to get into LS, then apply to grad school at one of the bigger Univesities in the province - U of T, York, Queens, McMaster, Western, etc. A Masters from there will cancel out any Undergrad from a small new University.

If his grades aren't good enough to get into LS, then do another Undergrad in another field. (If he truly wants in LS, then you do whatever it takes. He could get a second degree in a couple of years using credits from his first degress as his electives.)

Looking back, I should have stayed in University as long as I could. It was truly the best time of my life.
 
johnyboy said:
As far as the reasearch hours and whatever proffs do other than teaching it just seems weird to me that such little emphasis is put on the learing experience. Tough shit if you don't like it they say...well I get that ....but wasn't that GM's attitude not to long ago. :) Thanks for the replies!!!
It's rather like the military truism that officers who are the most proficient warriors and combat commanders aren't typically the one's promoted the fastest.

Similarly with professors, at most universities "publish or perish" rules the day, to get tenure you have to have a book (or two) published, while evaluations of teaching technique and performance count for very much less.
 
Uninversity of Ontario Institute of Technology in Oshawa

Aardvark154 said:
It's rather like the military truism that officers who are the most proficient warriors and combat commanders aren't typically the one's promoted the fastest.

Similarly with professors, at most universities "publish or perish" rules the day, to get tenure you have to have a book (or two) published, while evaluations of teaching technique and performance count for very much less.

I can certainly see how that would work and like I say the more I talk and read about it the more it makes sense :)
 
Sukdeep said:
It depends on your perspective. Is the primary objective of university to teach facts/theories, or to teach learning?

I've found that the most brilliant minds in a field are usually not particularly interested in teaching, but they offer the most for those who want to learn.

On the other hand, the teachers who spoon feed their students are usually rated the highest in course feedback.
Absolutely true, however, I believe more of a mix might be better for Undergraduates.
 
red said:
what is UOIT?



http://www.uoit.ca

University of Ontario Institute of Technology

And, it is, contrary to what some might believe, NOT tied academically to Durham College. They are, academically, both superfine institutions in their own right and independent of each other.
 
Sukdeep said:
It depends on your perspective. Is the primary objective of university to teach facts/theories, or to teach learning?

I've found that the most brilliant minds in a field are usually not particularly interested in teaching, but they offer the most for those who want to learn.

On the other hand, the teachers who spoon feed their students are usually rated the highest in course feedback.

I don't know, I had Walter Heller as my first Macro Econ professor. My finance prof was an "instructor" he enjoyed teaching so much he wasn't required to do research or publish - hardest instructor I had by FAR and clearly the best.

OTB
 
Your son should spend some time shadowing a lawyer or two to find out if that's the kind of life and work he really wants. As well, putting down shadowing experience on an application form will improve his chances a bit. The LSAT isn't everything anymore....
 
Just as a general rule acceptance into a grad program usually depends on...

1. Your relationship with any possible graduate advisors (its not who you know but who you blow)
2. Your marks on GRE, GRE Special, LSAT, MCAT
3. Marks in 3rd and 4th year, and references.
4. Extracuriccular activities including and especially volunteer work depending on the program you are applying to.

The difficulty in getting into grad programs is proportional to the number of slots available. If there are 16 schools offering Law degrees with an average acceptance number of 200 each vs 16 schools offering degrees in History with an average acceptance of 30 each..well which is harder to get into.

(Comparing History to Law might not be acceptable to some but my point is that Law is not the most difficult to get accepted to, as someone surmised previously)

And I also concur with Miachael about the last chance horse shit as I also went as a mature student with only a grade 10.

(BTW I am not a lawyer so my experience is from the good side....:))
 
I said:
Your son should spend some time shadowing a lawyer or two to find out if that's the kind of life and work he really wants. As well, putting down shadowing experience on an application form will improve his chances a bit. The LSAT isn't everything anymore....
Another point for "Johnyboy fils" to consider is that there are a lot of different areas of the law and needless to say he should shadow with someone practicing in an area which interests him.

As the expression goes "to thy own self be true" in other words practicing in an area of the law that holds your interest, is far more important than how "glamorous" an area of the law it is.
 
Pick maybe 5 good schools for law such as Dalhousie, U of T, McGill, Osgoode Hall, and Queens and talk to an advisor there. If law is what he wants to do, create a short list and try to meet the requirements of the faculties at those schools.
 
If business is his thing, UWO.
If law and the civil service, York/Osgood or Queen's.
If he wants to do law in Canada and the US, Windsor.

A joint LLB/MBA would enable him to pick and choose what he wants to do in the corporate world. UWO or Queens for that combo.

JMHO
 
In terms of school reputation you have two choices:

(1) University of Toronto

(2) A university that is well recognized for the specific program your son is interested in taking

Seriously. Outside of Canada pretty much everyone has heard of U of T but most other universities in Canada, no matter how good, are unknown outside of Canada except to people in specific fields where that University is especially good in that field.

So for example mathematicians in other countries will know about Waterloo, but most other people won't. Ditto for York and business, and so on, but U of T remains the ONLY Canadian university that is just generally perceived to be a top school worldwide.

If THIS matters to you, then the question is can he get into U of T and can he survive there? It's a LOT hader to graduate from U of T than it is to graduate from most universities in Ontario, and a bit harder to get in.

I am not convinced that you need a flashy university, and I myself did not go to U of T, but I have dealt with people overseas enough to know what is known around the world and what is not.

I think if your son knows exactly what he wants to do he should pick a school that is well known for that in Canada, but if what is important to you or him is the flashy name, just generally then you only have one choice in this country.

Sorry before people say it McGill, Queens, etc., they are well known in academic circles, but joe blow on the street in some other country hasn't heard of them.