Tv show revolution

The program seems based on the conceit that there is no one who knows anything about how to build or opperate a steam engine.
 
I wanted to like it, but it's too dumb. The writers have no imagination at all. The steam engine is a good example - for some reason they are at a medieval tech state, instead of preindustrial.

And where did they get all the swords? There aren't that many blacksmiths out there. There are, however, lots of people who know how to handload ammunition, so the exposition from one character about how rare bullets are is retarded.

Miles and Monroe are supposed to be former USMC sergeants, but they're about 20 years too old for that rank. The writers clearly never bothered to research their own characters backstories or imagine the technological possibilities.

Other than that, it's a great show
 
Not sure if there is a tv show section but i am now hooked on this new show called revolution where all the power goes out

Same here, I love the show.

I will admit, I would tune in just to see Tracy Spiridakos.

The program seems based on the conceit that there is no one who knows anything about how to build or opperate a steam engine.

The Monroe Republic uses steam trains.
 
I love any type of Sci-Fi on tv so I do watch Revolution but I find myself rolling my eyes constantly when I watch this show....

It's like NBC couldn't make up it's mind whether it wanted to cater the show to adults or teens....

The episodes have been better as they progressed because they got darker but the writing still needs work....

And the acting by the characters that play the brother and sister are kind of wooden (they seem so stiff)...

Tracy Spirdakos is hot but she seems out of place at times....and the brother is kind of annoying,,,
 
Miles and Monroe are supposed to be former USMC sergeants, but they're about 20 years too old for that rank. The writers clearly never bothered to research their own characters backstories or imagine the technological possibilities.

Other than that, it's a great show


I think at the time of the Blackout Miles and Monroe were supposed to be in their early or mid twenties even though they looked a lot older than that...
 
I haven't seen the show. Do they give a good explanation as to why the power went out?

And that's another thing... They do, but it's this whole big slowly developing conspiracy mystery blah blah blah.

Wow, it's a tv show. If viewers were this picky when Star trek was on, it wouldn't have made it.

Are you seriously implying that something isn't worth arguing into the ground on terb using any minutiae necessary to beat that dead horse? You've changed, man.

I just want the writing to actually live up to the premise. Il'l happily accept the ridiculous premise of no power, or a phone booths that t**********ses time and space, or a bald British man in charge of a spaceship, but then the writing needs to actually explore the boundaries of how people would actually act. Like instead of a wooden palisade around the village, maybe they should have had a series of IEDs
 
Wow, it's a tv show. If viewers were this picky when Star trek was on, it wouldn't have made it.

The original show didn't really "make it" at first. Ratings for the original when on NBC were quite low, and the network canceled it after only 79 episodes.

It wasn't until it ran in syndication that it gained any notoriety. It became a pop culture favourite and that's when it took off eventually spawning a movie franchise, and 5 additional TV series. (Not to mention numerous books and marketing paraphernalia and eventually video games as well)

Star Trek was WELL ahead of its time in a number of aspects. It broke down barriers in Hollywood with regards to multicultural casts, and gave us design influences for a number of devices we now take for granted. (e.g. the "flip phone" cell phone design is pretty much a design copy of the original communicators.)
 
the difference is that star trek was (is) scientifically sound and technologically accurate...

We could start with the problem of the awesome number the 'bipedal' life forms they keep running into in their travels. and go from there; Warp drive, time travel, worm hole travel.
 
We could start with the problem of the awesome number the 'bipedal' life forms they keep running into in their travels. and go from there; Warp drive, time travel, worm hole travel.

True. Very true. By today's standards. Who knows what will become of the future.

If you would have told the average Joe on the street in 1967 that it would be possible to make a phone call/ send a letter/ watch a movie/ take a picture/ listen to music/ order a pizza/ buy a car/ find a girl to fuck, by using a device very similar to a ST communicator, he'd have thought you were completely looney! LoL

I'm not saying that ET 'bipedal' life forms exist or that Warp drive, time travel, worm hole travel etc are even possible... just not possible with our understanding of science as we know today.
 
Oddly enough, I came across this site recently:

http://www.buildtheenterprise.org/home-page1

An engineer proposing to actually build a copy of the Enterprise to use for space exploration. Whether it's possible is debatable. However, I would point out that the propensity to run into "bi-pedal" aliens on Star Trek was mainly dictated by an inability to produce convincing aliens that weren't also human actors. However, Star Trek did have a number of episodes where the aliens were of a completely different form, ie silicon or energy beings.
 
Warp drive, time travel, worm hole travel.
Star Trek, however, always acknowledged these difficulties and attempted to come up with scientifically rational, if not always “real world” ways around them e.g. the "Heisenberg compensator."
 
I watch it, but it's losing me.Watch the walking dead.THAT's how people at the end of the world react..they are grimy, sweaty, wearing dirty clothes and looking like they have not showered in a month.These folks are trappsing through the woods looking completely coiffed, fresh clothes(designer hiking clothes my wife also piped in),pearly white teeth(15 years later by the way) ,and for not have access to sugary foods that one lad has been able to keep on a generous amount of weight.

To suspend reality it's all in the details.Those folks fail miserably on that count.The show has a good premise.....the execution just has problems.Get rid of the Gap girls and boys and it would be much better.
 
We could start with the problem of the awesome number the 'bipedal' life forms they keep running into in their travels.


Star Trek TNG came up with a storyline on why so there so many bipedal lifeforms all over the galaxy...

Turns out an ancient race of beings (who were bipeds) went across the universe and planted their basic DNA into different planets (or something like that)....
Each planet's species would evolve into their own unique race but they would still have the basic physical make up of the original bipedal species that helped create them
 
Star Trek TNG came up with a storyline on why so there so many bipedal lifeforms all over the galaxy...

Turns out an ancient race of beings (who were bipeds) went across the universe and planted their basic DNA into different planets (or something like that)....
Each planet's species would evolve into their own unique race but they would still have the basic physical make up of the original bipedal species that helped create them

Sound like a tribe of FUJI's gone wild.

Setting aside the advantage of bipedaism has over other earthy forms, the number of confirmed Goldilocks earth like planets is quite small, approximately 35 out the ~900 confirmed exoplanet, although there are 'suspected' to be billions and billions of planets so the number of Goldilocks M class (for your Trekkies) could be quite large as a whole, but relatively at ~5%. i'd ask for frequent flyer miles before i set out to spread my seed on such a mission.