TTC union workers divided over tentative contract

train said:
Ask a teacher they get paid the same.

The first approx $9 k of taxable income is tax free

from $9 to $37 you pay at24% so $6.2

from $38 to $55 rate is 35% or another $6

My guess if they make $55 they take home $42 to $43 less whatever the union gouges them for.
OK Train, your post makes no sense, but what the hey I'm on my 8th beer
train said:
The first approx $9 k of taxable income is tax free
.
AFAIK nobody makes 9K anymore, unless you mean part-time work???
train said:
Ask a teacher they get paid the same.
I dont have a teacher around right now to ask
train said:
from $9 to $37 you pay at24% so $6.2
You mean 24% of the gross dollar per hour??? :confused:
train said:
My guess if they make $55 they take home $42 to $43 less whatever the union gouges them for.
Less what the union gouges them, which is how much exactly????

Sorry Train, just thought that post was a bit confusing
 
Four men were bragging about how smart their dogs were. The first, an engineer, had a dog named "T Square". The second, an accountant, had a dog named "Slide Rule" and the third, a chemist, had a dog called "Measure" and the fourth man was a Union member.

To show off, the engineer called his dog - "T Square, do your stuff." T Square trotted over to a desk, took some paper and a pen, and promptly drew a circle, a square and a triangle.

Everyone agreed that was pretty good, but the accountant said his dog could do better. He called his dog and said "Slide Rule, do your stuff." Slide Rule went out into the kitchen and returned with a dozen cookies. He divided them into four equal piles of three each. Everyone agreed that was good, but the chemist said his dog could do better. He called his dog and said "Measure, do your stuff". Measure got up, walked over to the fridge, took out a quart of milk, got a ten ounce glass from the cupboard then poured exactly eight ounces without spilling a drop.

Everyone agreed that was very good, then they turned to the Union Member and said "What can your dog do?".

The Union Member stood up, called his dog and said "Coffee Break" do your stuff. Coffee Break jumped to his feet, ate the cookies, drank the milk, shit on the paper, fucked the other three dogs, claimed he'd injured his back while doing so, filed a grievance report for unsafe working conditions, put in for Worker's Compensation and went home on sick leave.
 
Bud Plug said:
Just some quick facts about Unions:

Employers with unions have to find a way to make their workers 11% more productive or their businesses will fail. The businesses which succeed are counted in these statistics. The businesses which fail account for the declining rate of union representation in the private sector in Canada.

Union workers are entitled to more generous overtime pay, yet decline overtime more often than non-union counterparts. Unions fight against high levels of overtime, as they would prefer more employees to be hired (more union dues collected).

Union pension plans have proven so expensive that many employers have moved away from them to matching RSPs. Union support for the abolition of mandatory retirement may lead to the elimination of pensions altogether.

Unions demand superior benefits. However, abuse of drug and sick leave benefits have led to the cost of insuring those benefits rising by double digits in each of the last 5 years. Unions are vehemently against measures designed to reduce the abuse of these benefits.

Union employees can grieve "injustices" involving no monetary loss or losses less than $100 at a litigation cost to the employer and the union (ie union members) of several thousand dollars.

Minority political parties backed by union contributions supported medicare, maternity leave, etc. Ruling parties backed by big business actually made these things happen. Taxpayers, including corporate taxpayers, pay for these social benefits.

Non-union workers are more likely forced to work ot. With fewer people working o/t, work can be shared by more people which is helpful to the social lives of workers and also to the economy. Five people earning $50,000/year contribute more money to the economy than 1 paerson earning $250,000/year.

Employers are moving away from defined pension plans to save themselves money. They would rather the employee accept the risk of having rsp's rather than paying a fair pension to workers. It's also funny that companies that are getting rid of pensions for the general worker still provide guaranteed incomes to upper management.

Honda and Toyota pay top dollar (comparable to CAW workers) because they have to. They would pay $12/hour if they could get away with it. Because workers at Ford, Gm, Etc are paid so well, workers at Toyota and Honda also benefit.

I'm sure that non-union members of the work force also abuse sick benefits.


x
 
Unions have made working better for many workers, even those not in a union.

They are not perfect but its the "best" thing out there-for a worker.

If it wasn't for unions, there might be no such thing as overtime pay, work place safety, child labor laws. Working would be like those sweat shops you hear about in Mexico

Sure they increase costs of an item but they also making working more fair to all.
 
buckwheat1 said:
...as long as people understand that if there is NO labour agreement in areasonable time either side can ask for BINDING arbitration which usually leads to a better deal for the union (association) workers because they use the going rate in society which is now around 3.25 3.50% therefore arbitration would of cost teh TTC more $$$$$

BINGO!!! Finally someone who understands.
 
train said:
Nonsense. They are way better off because they don't have to pay dues and they can get promoted on merit instead of having to wait for someone to die.

Nonsense. They are way better off because the auto company pays them the same as they would make if they were unionized, without the dues. Plain and simple.

If you could wave your magic wand and cause every auto union to disappear overnight, the wages at Toyota and Honda would be dropping in a flash.

People at Toyota and Honda make what they do because of the unionized auto sector. They might not want to admit it, but it's true.
 
train said:
One guy in the ticket booth made $100,000 gross last year.

Which I have no problem with. Everyone loves to throw that example around, conveniently overlooking the fact that it's because of shitloads of overtime. If you have no life and want to spend every waking hour at work on OT, more power to you.

Funny how someone else claimed unionized workers don't want to work overtime yet here is a shining example of a guy who works OT out the wazoo and he gets blamed for making too much money. :rolleyes:

Sucking and blowing folks, sucking and blowing.
 
xdog said:
Non-union workers are more likely forced to work ot. With fewer people working o/t, work can be shared by more people which is helpful to the social lives of workers and also to the economy. Five people earning $50,000/year contribute more money to the economy than 1 paerson earning $250,000/year.

Employers are moving away from defined pension plans to save themselves money. They would rather the employee accept the risk of having rsp's rather than paying a fair pension to workers. It's also funny that companies that are getting rid of pensions for the general worker still provide guaranteed incomes to upper management.

Honda and Toyota pay top dollar (comparable to CAW workers) because they have to. They would pay $12/hour if they could get away with it. Because workers at Ford, Gm, Etc are paid so well, workers at Toyota and Honda also benefit.

I'm sure that non-union members of the work force also abuse sick benefits.

Quoted For Truth.
 
xdog said:
Non-union workers are more likely forced to work ot. With fewer people working o/t, work can be shared by more people which is helpful to the social lives of workers and also to the economy. Five people earning $50,000/year contribute more money to the economy than 1 paerson earning $250,000/year.

Employers are moving away from defined pension plans to save themselves money. They would rather the employee accept the risk of having rsp's rather than paying a fair pension to workers. It's also funny that companies that are getting rid of pensions for the general worker still provide guaranteed incomes to upper management.

Honda and Toyota pay top dollar (comparable to CAW workers) because they have to. They would pay $12/hour if they could get away with it. Because workers at Ford, Gm, Etc are paid so well, workers at Toyota and Honda also benefit.

I'm sure that non-union members of the work force also abuse sick benefits.


x

A couple of things (actually just about all of it) wrong with your argument

1. 5 people @ 50,000 vs 1 person @ 250,000
It doesn't work that way. The reason one guy is making 250,000 / year is because he / she is far more productive than the 5 you wish to replace him / her with. (individually & as a whole)
More than likely he /she is bring something special to the table such as sales or efficiency improvements. More than likely he /she is not going to punch a clock or take his regular coffee break @ 10:15 as described by union rules.
He will have the benefit of the company as a whole (owners & employees) as a priority
He will not demand OT pay as he understands, he is receiving a very good salary and OT may be required to make the company successful.
The 5 Union guys expect OT pay as a their god given right (the company is losing money, gee thats too bad- I worked these OT hours pay me!!!)

2. Benefits are very expensive (15-25% of a salary) & the benefits for 5 are far more expensive than for one, irrespective of the salaries.

3. Employers are moving away from defined pension plans to save themselves money. Because defined benefits are very risky. Do you risk the company & many years of future operations , because previous management promised defined benefits to a union 25 years ago. I think you might be pissed if your operation had to close because they owe more to former pensioners than they have available. (its called bankruptcy)

4. Honda and Toyota pay top dollar (comparable to CAW workers) because they have to. WRONG, Because it makes good business sense to reward hard working employees who co-operate & work with management to make the company better & more profitable.
They prefer not to have a union dictate to them how many employees they must employ & what wage.
They have a partnership with their employees.

GM & Ford may not survive over the long haul (Ford in particular)
Why?
1. Their manufacturing cost per car is way higher than the Japanese. Why ?
They have massive legacy benefit costs to pay guys no longer making the cars. They caved into ridiculous union demands in the 70s 80s & 90s and are uncompetitive now
2. The quality sucks verses the Japanese. Why? Because they are far less automated due to unions demands to maintain certain employment levels.

Remember my words 20 years from now. GM & Ford will not be the same companies, if they are still in business
 
buckwheat1 said:
just some quick facts about Unions:

productivity in union enviroments is 11% higher than non union
better overtime provisions
better pension plans
better benefits
can grieve an injustice
there safer in their workplace(s)

unions were at the forefront of medicare, canadian pension plan, unemployment insurance, maturnity leave, vacations ect.
Would you please provide the source of your statistics?
 
"We have assessed the situation and decided that we will not expose our members to the dangers of assaults from angry and irrational members of the public," said Bob Kinnear, ATU Local 113 President.

The reports from our members of increases in threats and abuse from passengers last weekend, after we gave our original 48-hours' notice, has left us no choice but to withdraw our services immediately. We have a legal responsibility to protect the safety of our members and so does the TTC."


You think if they were recieving threats and abuse they might just wonder if they are in the wrong & might just start to wonder how many people lives they will disrupt in their quest for greed
 
Yes many people depend on them to make a living. Its a tough call, a strike would hurt many people and the poorest the most. But how else can they get a fair deal. Subcontracting work away from the union is not fair or right.

If the workers rejected the contract because of the just 3% raise-then that was wrong. If it was because the city is trying to take work away from the union to weaken them later on, then I can understand that.

The TTC workers should not walk off the job for at least another week. They should give some time to reach another deal.
 
I feel sorry for the general public that they are being fucked by the TTC unions. It's sad and it disgust me, but there is nothing we could do about it. We are at the TTC unions' mercy.

Next time when you get off the bus, remember to thank your driver for the ride and for his/her mercy.
 
I wonder how the TTC workers would reflect upon others who remove a service they rely on.
eg
1. All the bank tellers & ATM cash people suddenly went on strike, leaving the TTC workers without access to their precious cash (not realistic because the banks Will not allow a union to form). However you get the point.

2. All beer store & liquor store employees suddenly went on strike

3. All tobacco distribution employees suddenly went on strike.

4. Hospital & ambulance workers suddenly walked off the job demanding pay on par with TTC ticket collectors making 100K a year.
Gee, your not well & in need of medical attention, sorry its my god given right to get a fair wage

5. The accounting department which processes the checks did a work to rule & delayed the TTC workers pay checks by a couple of days/weeks (minor inconvenience relative to the accounting staffs right to a fair wage)

They (TTC strikers) would be singing a different tune
 
JohnLarue said:
I wonder how the TTC workers would reflect upon others who remove a service they rely on.
eg
1. All the bank tellers & ATM cash people suddenly went on strike, leaving the TTC workers without access to their precious cash (not realistic because the banks Will not allow a union to form). However you get the point.

All of the TDCanadaTrust branches in Sudbury are unionized.