xdog said:
Non-union workers are more likely forced to work ot. With fewer people working o/t, work can be shared by more people which is helpful to the social lives of workers and also to the economy. Five people earning $50,000/year contribute more money to the economy than 1 paerson earning $250,000/year.
Employers are moving away from defined pension plans to save themselves money. They would rather the employee accept the risk of having rsp's rather than paying a fair pension to workers. It's also funny that companies that are getting rid of pensions for the general worker still provide guaranteed incomes to upper management.
Honda and Toyota pay top dollar (comparable to CAW workers) because they have to. They would pay $12/hour if they could get away with it. Because workers at Ford, Gm, Etc are paid so well, workers at Toyota and Honda also benefit.
I'm sure that non-union members of the work force also abuse sick benefits.
x
A couple of things (actually just about all of it) wrong with your argument
1. 5 people @ 50,000 vs 1 person @ 250,000
It doesn't work that way. The reason one guy is making 250,000 / year is because he / she is far more productive than the 5 you wish to replace him / her with. (individually & as a whole)
More than likely he /she is bring something special to the table such as sales or efficiency improvements. More than likely he /she is not going to punch a clock or take his regular coffee break @ 10:15 as described by union rules.
He will have the benefit of the company as a whole (owners & employees) as a priority
He will not demand OT pay as he understands, he is receiving a very good salary and OT may be required to make the company successful.
The 5 Union guys expect OT pay as a their god given right (the company is losing money, gee thats too bad- I worked these OT hours pay me!!!)
2. Benefits are very expensive (15-25% of a salary) & the benefits for 5 are far more expensive than for one, irrespective of the salaries.
3. Employers are moving away from defined pension plans to save themselves money. Because defined benefits are
very risky. Do you risk the company & many years of future operations , because previous management promised defined benefits to a union 25 years ago. I think you might be pissed if your operation had to close because they owe more to former pensioners than they have available. (its called bankruptcy)
4. Honda and Toyota pay top dollar (comparable to CAW workers) because they have to. WRONG, Because it makes good business sense to reward hard working employees who co-operate & work with management to make the company better & more profitable.
They prefer not to have a union dictate to them how many employees they must employ & what wage.
They have a partnership with their employees.
GM & Ford may not survive over the long haul (Ford in particular)
Why?
1. Their manufacturing cost per car is way higher than the Japanese. Why ?
They have massive legacy benefit costs to pay guys no longer making the cars. They caved into ridiculous union demands in the 70s 80s & 90s and are uncompetitive now
2. The quality sucks verses the Japanese. Why? Because they are far less automated due to unions demands to maintain certain employment levels.
Remember my words 20 years from now. GM & Ford will not be the same companies, if they are still in business