TTC Union turns down contract offer

I think we are missing a very big point here.
Silly servant unions and private sector unions really don't have much in common, even the CAW understands simple economics, civil servants ........ entitled, special, privileged, don't want to listen, don't give a shit.
I know people who have only worked as civil servants, teachers, drivers, posties etc, they have NO clue what the REAL world is like, they wouldn't last a day on the outside.
I have given up income in one form or another on a number of ocasions, during hard times, to keep my job.
None of the civil servant unions have or would have agree to even a wage freeze, so the result is/will be lost jobs, ...... much better.
Also, I find it funny how people wonder how/why FORD got elected, it really boils down to, being fed up with civil servants in general, and ANYBODY other than another MILLER.

FAST

So are you arguing that everyone should be paid less?
Public sector because they're better off then you and private sector because you have to in order to keep your job?
 
"So are you arguing that everyone should be paid less?"
I think that is the point. The larger, vocal group is now essentially stating lower salaries for everyone. The wealthy must be giggling to themselves all the way to the bank as the pressure to drive down salaries movement has been taken up by the very people who'll have their salaries reduced...and the rich'll get richer.
 
"So are you arguing that everyone should be paid less?"
I think that is the point. The larger, vocal group is now essentially stating lower salaries for everyone. The wealthy must be giggling to themselves all the way to the bank as the pressure to drive down salaries movement has been taken up by the very people who'll have their salaries reduced...and the rich'll get richer.

I think we are talking about the public sector only so I don`t think your comment, as popular as it might be with your comrades, makes any particular sense here.
 
I've read alot of bashing of the TTC workers here. While I am NOT a TTC worker I do know individuals who are, and were, and there are aspects of their jobs the most would not relish.
I suspect the majority of us, myself included, have a regular shift schedule for work and unless something major occurs we know when we are working for the next several weeks, if not months.
The TTC drivers work on a six week rotation after which they have to 'sign' for the next six weeks. Right now you could be working m-f 6am to 2pm with weekends off. In the next rotation you could end up working 10pm -6am thurs, fri, then 1am - 9am sat, sun, off monday, 9-5 on tues and off wed. That would be if you were lucky enough to get a shift that involved nothing but 8 straight hours each day. A lot of these shifts involve going in for 4 hours, off for 3hours, and then back in for another 4 hours so you end up with an 11 hour day but only get paid for 8.
 
The big picture

I've read alot of bashing of the TTC workers here. While I am NOT a TTC worker I do know individuals who are, and were, and there are aspects of their jobs the most would not relish.
I suspect the majority of us, myself included, have a regular shift schedule for work and unless something major occurs we know when we are working for the next several weeks, if not months.
The TTC drivers work on a six week rotation after which they have to 'sign' for the next six weeks. Right now you could be working m-f 6am to 2pm with weekends off. In the next rotation you could end up working 10pm -6am thurs, fri, then 1am - 9am sat, sun, off monday, 9-5 on tues and off wed. That would be if you were lucky enough to get a shift that involved nothing but 8 straight hours each day. A lot of these shifts involve going in for 4 hours, off for 3hours, and then back in for another 4 hours so you end up with an 11 hour day but only get paid for 8.

UNION BOSS..... Hey guys, I just got you more money and benifits for less work, but your job is really going to suck, give me a high 5.

FAST
 
Not a requirement

I think we are talking about the public sector only so I don`t think your comment, as popular as it might be with your comrades, makes any particular sense here.

Hey Possum, RE: t.o.leafs.fan & groggy.
It looks like reading and writing is not necessary for employment as civil servants.

FAST
 
Yeah, that's it. All this stuff http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opposition_to_trade_unions is just more of Justin Beiber's lies.
Hell the article doesn't include the moral aspect of using extortion to negotiate your wages. You will give us what you want or we will shut your business down, doesn't sound ethical to me. However I never thought occupation intimidation and demands had much to do with free speech and democracy but I guess I am alone on that also.

However you won't read the article and even if you do, months later you will continue with your slander, so I don't even know why I bother.
"I don't care what good work you have done and are doing, and no you cannot look at the books; you'll take what pay I offer, and work the hours and conditions I say or leave. Now" does sound ethical I suppose?

There's no extortion in a bargain freely agreed to, every law of economics springs from that 'fact'. Unfortunately whether you're shopping at No Frills, buying a Porsche, or paying your taxes, there's always room to whine "Extortion". Doesn't make it so.

Just what is there about a worker refusing to continue working under an expired contract when the employer won't budge on the new one that makes the worker and not the employer extortionate? Who made the employer God in your universe?

Other Matters: Who is Justin Beiber, and how is he relevant; couldn't find a mention in that irrelevant Wikipedia piece. But it did demonstrate your failing at predicting as well as your misunderstanding of the concept of debate and the definition of slander. But you might check that last out before you call someone a liar for expressing an opinion.

But, since you asked, please don't bother in future.
 
Got a price for those automated ticket machines depreciated over their expected life? And don't forget to add in the annual costs of refilling and doing maintenance, preventive as well as when they break down. Wanna bet the annual cost of a human—who can do other things like call ambulances and police and tackle thugs—is the same or less.
No
Not even close.

The machines need to be properly maintained
However
1 They are 24/7
2. They do not call in sick
3. Most important - They do not strike or threaten to strike (more on this below)

The Annual cost for an incremental employee is alway a lot more than annual salary / wages
Add in OT, medical . dental benefits, vaction pay and pension costs and the all in costs are 115- 135 % of the wage
If the pension is defined benefit vs. defined contribution there is an unknown future cost of potentially underfunded obligations
Since they are city employees it would not be surprising to find out the pension is an extremely generous one relative to the average tax payer's pension.

The hidden cost of an employee who strikes is very difficult to determine as the economic costs of lost productivity to business is huge when peole can not get to work and traffic is slowed right down
Machines do not fuck everyone else around by refusing to work
 
"I don't care what good work you have done and are doing, and no you cannot look at the books; you'll take what pay I offer, and work the hours and conditions I say or leave. Now" does sound ethical I suppose?

That is not an accurate representation of the worker - employer relationship
A better representation is :

I have a need for a employee to complete certain work tasks
I am will to pay x $ / year or hour which is
a) what I can afford
b) what my competition is paying
c) what I think is fair and reasonable for the work that I need completed.
I will also pay y$ to wards benefit costs and provide a safe work environment

Since you did not risk any capital starting this business you are not entitled to any excess profits
Nor are you entitled to review the books to second guess my business decisions

If you do not feel that X$ / year or hour is fair and reasonable then you are free to explore other options available to you.

The union model is :
Pay us this much or we stop working and prevent the business from exploring other options to get the needed work done

Yeah, not at all like extortion
 
Just a note to be clear here, JL: As this is a TTC union thread, we are discussing workers already employed under an agreement with the employer which has now reached its term. Negociatng a new agreement must be done according to the laws of the land, and whatever terms for such that were part of the expiring contract. Generally, as long as the parties discuss and negociate, the contract remains in force. If no one was trying to do better than the old deal, there'd be no thread. As long as the two parties are negociating, and being flexible, most contracts prohibit either a strike or a lockout.

In your model—which really is more like one for a new business hiring it's first workers—you've got both sides saying, "My number is the only number and fuck you if you don't buy it". The extortion—and both sides of your model are practising it—comes from whatever power and force each has to make the other side suffer, give in, and take their un-negociated number. It happens that both are using the same pressure point: My number or no income for you. A strike by the workers or a lockout by the employer.

You'll have to explain again how sweet and collegial your model employer is; I don't see it.

And, we should also remember that TTC workers have no power of extortion as they are forbidden to strike. You are pursuing a non-issue, raised only because some other anti-union bigot used the word "extortion'.

BTW, I did note your fact-free reply concerning machine ticket sales vs human. With some actual numbers you might have a point, but if reliable machines were available at seriously better costs, and ticket-sellers other duties could be done by others to make real savings, they'd be everywhere on every transit system already. Do show us the numbers for the up front and hidden costs of both; all I said—as did you—was that it's not as simple as looking at the machine's price F.O.B the TTC yards, or the Booth Attendant's pay-rate. Especially not when considering imaginary machines.
 
That is not an accurate representation of the worker - employer relationship
A better representation is :

I have a need for a employee to complete certain work tasks
I am will to pay x $ / year or hour which is
a) what I can afford
b) what my competition is paying
c) what I think is fair and reasonable for the work that I need completed.
I will also pay y$ to wards benefit costs and provide a safe work environment

Since you did not risk any capital starting this business you are not entitled to any excess profits
Nor are you entitled to review the books to second guess my business decisions

If you do not feel that X$ / year or hour is fair and reasonable then you are free to explore other options available to you.

The union model is :
Pay us this much or we stop working and prevent the business from exploring other options to get the needed work done

Yeah, not at all like extortion

Many of the most effective and successful employers around the word use a system where workers share in profits. Did you ever consider the possibility that one of the problems in labour management relations is people (on either side of the table) who take an adversarial approach like yours?
 
Many of the most effective and successful employers around the word use a system where workers share in profits. Did you ever consider the possibility that one of the problems in labour management relations is people (on either side of the table) who take an adversarial approach like yours?

I agree with you on the adversarial approach being a time waster but more often than not in my experience its been the union that has taken that position. When you think about it there is a good reason for that. Without the appearance of a "tough negotiation" with strike mandates, threats etc etc how does your average bargaining team demonstrate that they have wrung the last penny out of the deal.

So not only do they have to be adversarial they have to be publically so.

PS We have profit sharing in our non-union plants but not in our union ones (in Quebec). We have, however, just agreed to a new multi- year contract there.
 
Why would TTC workers possibly accept any initial contract offer from the City.

Mayor McCheese declared them an essential service.

Therefore, all contract disputes automatically go to arbitration.

Arbitration is always in favour of "the little guy"

Therefore, they will go to arbitration and get way more than the City will ever offer.

End of story.
 
Dreaming

Many of the most effective and successful employers around the word use a system where workers share in profits. Did you ever consider the possibility that one of the problems in labour management relations is people (on either side of the table) who take an adversarial approach like yours?

The CAW has always, absolutley refused to accept ANY profit sharing, period.
I have worked for companies that did, but NOT with a union.
Plus, profit from civil servants ????????
"adversarial approach"........... If you have EVER delt with unions, you would understand why that is the atmosphere.

FAST
 
If the arbitrator uses Final Offer Selection, and the City puts forward the more reasonable offer of the two, there's every reason to believe it would be selected.

But the Yahoos currently in charge at City Hall have an agenda that goes beyond what would be the best contract for both sides who make the TTC work, so they're putting forward a contract focussing on eliminating workers and worker-costs. Given the reductions in service already planned and the ridership reductions that will result from the fare-hike, there won't be much of a working TTC anyway.

But there will be more cars on the road.

And no new subway.
 
There is also more than one union that the TTC needs to bargain with. 113 only deals with mechanics,drivers,ticket people , there is also the trade union cupe 2 and i believe they also have plumbers and carpenters etc...

There is more to this story than just drivers, they all have their issues.

The ruling by the arbitrator should be out for xmas.
 
Echoing the statements of Ceiling Cat ITT.

http://i41.tinypic.com/16ljjhf.jpg

I'm really coming to hate the TTC and YRT... It's like every few months I hear one of them in the news complaining about this or that. Don't TTC tellers (the ones that sit on chairs, hand out tickets and make sure you've paid your dues) get more money than recent university undergrads without having to do anywhere near as much education? :( Correct me if I'm wrong, of course, it's just what I've heard.
 
they need to charge what it costs to ride the dam bus and stop taking money out of non riders pockets so some people can ride the rocket cheap. Fuel has gone up, parts have gone up, hydro has gone up, why is it such a surprise when the TTC fare has to go up as well. A lot of you people wanted Ford to raise taxes even more than he did, so why not just raise the price and make all the people happy who work for the TTC. If you want a cheap bus fare then get on board and find the cuts needed to keep the price at such a low level.
 
A lot of these shifts involve going in for 4 hours, off for 3hours, and then back in for another 4 hours so you end up with an 11 hour day but only get paid for 8.
Lol.

If only I were so lucky, in the private sector. My job usually involved working for 4 hours, then working for another 3 hours, then working for another 4 hours. In effect, working an 11 hour day, but only getting paid for 8. (Except when I had to work a few more hours in the evening to get reports ready for the next morning. Then it might be a 13-hour day, but still only getting paid for 8.).

It's called Getting The Job Done. And if I didn't like it, I had every freedom to find another job elsewhere.

As to the TTC, it's odd that their members claim here to want to keep things the same in their next agreement as in their last one, then want to get even more. But that's not how life works. And it's not how negotiations work. Everything's open for negotiation, and if they want more of something, they have to give up something else to keep the service on an even keel.
 
they need to charge what it costs to ride the dam bus and stop taking money out of non riders pockets so some people can ride the rocket cheap. Fuel has gone up, parts have gone up, hydro has gone up, why is it such a surprise when the TTC fare has to go up as well. A lot of you people wanted Ford to raise taxes even more than he did, so why not just raise the price and make all the people happy who work for the TTC. If you want a cheap bus fare then get on board and find the cuts needed to keep the price at such a low level.

I feel the same about roads. Roads and bridges cost a fortune to build. Far more than the TTC ever gets. They need to start charging what it costs to maintain the roads and bridges and infrastructure for automobile drivers.

People who drive in the City of Toronto should be paying what it costs to build roads and bridges. Enough of the free ride for drivers.

Then, there's highways. One fully laden highway truck does as much damage to the pavement structure as 10,000 car passes. So maybe truck drivers should be charged what it costs to build highways. Enough with the free ride for truckers. In fact, get the god damn trucks off the road entirely. Put all freight on trains and utilize intermodal trasport for final mile delivery.