TTC Union turns down contract offer

Hmmm,

The TTC operates seven days a week, why do they get overtime for Sundays. If you choose a career/job that is 24/7 there's no overtime for working a regularly scheduled shift in your rotation. Overtime is above the scheduled work hours; statutory holidays are different but in some instances double time and one half is ridiculous.
 
I worked for a company for 32-plus years. The first couple of contracts involved an increase in benefits. Then the takeaways began. We never got back what was taken away.

Didn't matter, though. The union was on its death bed when I left because most new hires are on contract. And those are hired are offered worse pensions than what long-time employees receive.

If offered a guarantee of no outsourcing I would accept a decent job during financial crises

We still may have a depression so take the offer of a guaranteed decent paycheck and be happy

During next contract you get the giveaways back if economy is sound

Depending on the arbitrator decision will we see if essential service was a good idea for which side
 
Personally, I'd rather take my chances through arbitration than agree to any cuts to my contract. Every time. Whether the economy was good or bad.
 
Personally, I'd rather take my chances through arbitration than agree to any cuts to my contract. Every time. Whether the economy was good or bad.

BINGO! The province is about to find out the real cost of declaring the TTC an "essential service."

Anyone who thinks the government can take away workers' right to strike without it costing something is well and truly naive.
 
Hmmm,

The TTC operates seven days a week, why do they get overtime for Sundays.

Because management agreed to it.

You have the "rush to the bottom" mentality. Why have OT at all? Shit, why have minimum wage? Why have 8-hour work days? Why don't we just go back to the 1800's?

Hop back in your time machine...
 
Because management agreed to it.

You have the "rush to the bottom" mentality. Why have OT at all? Shit, why have minimum wage? Why have 8-hour work days? Why don't we just go back to the 1800's?

Hop back in your time machine...

I think you are missing the point and getting wound up in your union rhetoric. Overtime should be paid after, say, 40 hours worked in a week, not just because its a certain day of the week is what the real point is.
 
Because management agreed to it.

You have the "rush to the bottom" mentality. Why have OT at all? Shit, why have minimum wage? Why have 8-hour work days? Why don't we just go back to the 1800's?

Hop back in your time machine...

I think it has more to do with when it was introduced, back in a time when stores had to be closed, Newspapers could not have sunday editions etc. Sunday used to be almost a holiday with very few institutions allowed to be open, that is no longer the case and premiums for working on that day should no longer apply.

The removal of the free sick days I have no problem with either, an employer should have the right to ask for medical documentation. They can still get the days off under Ontario labour laws so they are not really losing anything.

And not getting a raise, this is where many unions always seem to forget employees still get a cost of living increase in their salary , a "raise" is something on top of that.

I have no problem with the contracting out guarantees however , with one exception , if a given piece of equipment has a problem and is still covered by a manufacturers warranty , that should not be considered contracting out.
 
For starters, they should replace the majority of the ticket collectors with machines for purchasing tickets etc. and install phones so anyone with a questions can simply pick up the receiver and talk to an operator. This would save a good chunk of change and possibly eliminate the need to cut services. Of course the unions wouldn't agree to that or any cost saving idea as we all know it's about jobs and nothing else!
Got a price for those automated ticket machines depreciated over their expected life? And don't forget to add in the annual costs of refilling and doing maintenance, preventive as well as when they break down. Wanna bet the annual cost of a human—who can do other things like call ambulances and police and tackle thugs—is the same or less.

Am I the only one old enough to remember cashiers checking out whole line-ups of people in the time it now takes just two folks to access their accounts and key in the PINs for their 'improved', chipped debit cards? There's a reason why MetroLinx still hasn't gotten their PRESTO card payment system rolled out yet; they're still doing beta testing.

Machines are definitely NOT the answer, though they can be of assistance.
 
Because management agreed to it.

You have the "rush to the bottom" mentality. Why have OT at all? Shit, why have minimum wage? Why have 8-hour work days? Why don't we just go back to the 1800's?

Hop back in your time machine...

Mr Elf,

I already knew the answer but thanks for taking the bait. There are many professions and jobs that work on a 24 hour clock not 8 hour clock.

I have been a member of a large union (public) and moderate size union in management (public). I've always worked in essential service which meant if there was a strike managers had to camp at work, and frontline union members worked on a two week schedule. Those union members working the two week rotations received 100% of their pay minus the usual deductions; however, their colleagues on the picket line received 100.00 per week and 20.00 per dependant.

In my line, workers and managers have their schedule for 12 months, weekends and stats are included in the regular schedule. Yes, there is a premium for workers on weekends and nightshifts but it really amounts to a handful of bits & bites. Managers scheduled for weekends do not receive premiums.

The large majority of public service positions involve weekends as a regular part with no overtime possibly the premium and again it amounts to peanuts.

As a unionist myself, I will say that we shoot ourselves regularly for marginal gains and never recouperate from strikes.

Overtime is hours above regularly scheduled shifts, call-ins, call-backs, being ordered, statutory days, banking of lieu time. If one chooses an industry that runs on the 24 clock, Sundays are included.

In addition, anyone that cannot work certain days for religious beliefs will get those days off and have two options:
1. Work another day of the week.
2. Lose the income for the day.
This is the law.

Overtime, in many instances, is required but shouldn't be the norm. I believe in unions for safety, harrassment, eap, std/ltd, bargaining but not holding hostages! When I was starting out as a casual on-call employee, I would miss 1 of 20 calls for work and the managers knew if I turned a shift down I was exhausted. As a casual employee, it's in one's best interest to take the 4 hour shifts because 90% of the time it becomes an 8 or 12 hour shift after 44 hours, it was overtime and casual employees have to inform the manager not the other way around.

Mr Elf, it is time that you stepped into the light and come out of the darkness.
 
I think it has more to do with when it was introduced, back in a time when stores had to be closed,

Agreed. But management agreed to enshrine it in the collective agreement so if they want to change it now they're going to have to negotiate it out (or modify it).

Getting OT on weekends is not unusual at all. Maybe if you're working in the retail/service industry but many, many industries pay OT to workers on weekends.

Saying someone who has historically received OT on weekends should stop getting it now smacks of "I don't get it so neither should they"...
 
But Keeb, that is the whole anti-union position in a nut-shell, at least when you hear it from the non-management folks: "I don't get that so no one should".

Everyone down to the same low level.
 
^^^ Yepper!!!

We call it the Race to the Bottom....:Eek:
 
But Keeb, that is the whole anti-union position in a nut-shell, at least when you hear it from the non-management folks: "I don't get that so no one should".

Everyone down to the same low level.

Yeah, that's it. All this stuff http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opposition_to_trade_unions is just more of Justin Beiber's lies.
Hell the article doesn't include the moral aspect of using extortion to negotiate your wages. You will give us what you want or we will shut your business down, doesn't sound ethical to me. However I never thought occupation intimidation and demands had much to do with free speech and democracy but I guess I am alone on that also.

However you won't read the article and even if you do, months later you will continue with your slander, so I don't even know why I bother.
 
The TTC Union will benefit enormously from arbitration, which historically has favoured unions. Ford really fucked this one up.
 
I think it has more to do with when it was introduced, back in a time when stores had to be closed, Newspapers could not have sunday editions etc. Sunday used to be almost a holiday with very few institutions allowed to be open, that is no longer the case and premiums for working on that day should no longer apply.

The removal of the free sick days I have no problem with either, an employer should have the right to ask for medical documentation. They can still get the days off under Ontario labour laws so they are not really losing anything.

And not getting a raise, this is where many unions always seem to forget employees still get a cost of living increase in their salary , a "raise" is something on top of that.

I have no problem with the contracting out guarantees however , with one exception , if a given piece of equipment has a problem and is still covered by a manufacturers warranty , that should not be considered contracting out.

so if I have a cold or flu, I have to get out of bed, go down to a walk in clinic( you can't just get a doctors appointment with no notice), put on a sars mask and be told to drink plenty of liquids and stay in bed? Then probably have to pay to get a note? Well, if I had to go through all that, I'd make sure the note was a good one and would probably stay off work longer than if I had just stayed in bed and phoned in sick.
 
Different

Don’t think the answer is so obvious. I worked for a company with about 250 employees that cut everyone’s pay by 10% during tougher times, and don’t remember anyone leaving directly after the notice was given. And the pay was market rate pay before the cut. Auto workers took a pay cut, don't remember hearing about a mass exit of workers.


I think we are missing a very big point here.
Silly servant unions and private sector unions really don't have much in common, even the CAW understands simple economics, civil servants ........ entitled, special, privileged, don't want to listen, don't give a shit.
I know people who have only worked as civil servants, teachers, drivers, posties etc, they have NO clue what the REAL world is like, they wouldn't last a day on the outside.
I have given up income in one form or another on a number of ocasions, during hard times, to keep my job.
None of the civil servant unions have or would have agree to even a wage freeze, so the result is/will be lost jobs, ...... much better.
Also, I find it funny how people wonder how/why FORD got elected, it really boils down to, being fed up with civil servants in general, and ANYBODY other than another MILLER.

FAST
 
I think we are missing a very big point here.
Silly servant unions and private sector unions really don't have much in common, even the CAW understands simple economics, civil servants ........ entitled, special, privileged, don't want to listen, don't give a shit.
I know people who have only worked as civil servants, teachers, drivers, posties etc, they have NO clue what the REAL world is like, they wouldn't last a day on the outside.
I have given up income in one form or another on a number of ocasions, during hard times, to keep my job.
None of the civil servant unions have or would have agree to even a wage freeze, so the result is/will be lost jobs, ...... much better.
Also, I find it funny how people wonder how/why FORD got elected, it really boils down to, being fed up with civil servants in general, and ANYBODY other than another MILLER.

FAST

interesting that the anti gov't worker rants always omit cops and soldiers ....even Ford gave the cops a raise whilst giving the garbagemen's children a lump of coal for Christmas.
 
And

interesting that the anti gov't worker rants always omit cops and soldiers ....even Ford gave the cops a raise whilst giving the garbagemen's children a lump of coal for Christmas.

And the cops LOST jobs.
Your putting toronto cops in the same sentence as our soldiers............ unbelievable !!!!!

FAST.
 
so if I have a cold or flu, I have to get out of bed, go down to a walk in clinic( you can't just get a doctors appointment with no notice), put on a sars mask and be told to drink plenty of liquids and stay in bed? Then probably have to pay to get a note? Well, if I had to go through all that, I'd make sure the note was a good one and would probably stay off work longer than if I had just stayed in bed and phoned in sick.

Then take it as a personal day and don't get paid like everyone else.
 
I have paid personal days that I can take with no notice and no doctors note, and I work private sector. It's understood they may be used for any personal reason. Maybe your kid is sick. Maybe you are hungover.

My company has a right to ask for a doctors note if you are sick beyond those days but we only do that for employees we suspect are taking the piss. Someone who has not been sick in two years is likely to be believed. Someone who is chronically late and such will be asked for proof.

The question really is total compensation. Set a number. Let employees decide (collectively) if they want it as salary, sick days, health benefits, etc, the question is what is the total cost.