TTC driver assaults passenger on a crowded bus

This is grounds for assault? I'm sure the lawsuit is coming.
Presumably you are asking about civil assault, rather than the Criminal Assault with which Mr. Tulk has already been charged.

The real question is whether the TTC can be joined (was the off duty driver "working" at the time) and or is there insurance coverage.

Not only are there costs to bring a law suit, but are you really going to be able to take the man's life savings for pushing you on a bus?
 
The real question is whether the TTC can be joined (was the off duty driver "working" at the time) and or is there insurance coverage.

He was on his way to relieve a bus so he was on duty

"Ross also said there is no evidence that the TTC driver operating the bus did anything wrong and does not face disciplinary action." ??????????????


The slightest occurrence and bus is out of service while police come to stop frivolous lawsuits

the actual driver of that bus should have stopped and phoned it in when it occurred ( poor guy has to rat on his brother)
 
I'm completely shocked. People just keep knocking these poor under paid over worked TTC employees who are the front line trying to work while being harassed by camera wielding commoners.

The occasional nap or call home for rejuvenation has to be understood...:)
 
He was on his way to relieve a bus so he was on duty

Not necessarily. Was he being paid at the time? If so yes he was on duty, if he was merely commuting to his job as a passenger, then no he's not on duty.

"Ross also said there is no evidence that the TTC driver operating the bus did anything wrong and does not face disciplinary action." ??????????????

What article are you reading? The one Fred put up states "Mr. Ross, who said the Mr. Tulk has been disciplined but couldn't say whether he's still employed at the TTC"

If Mr. Tulk was not on the clock when the incident occurred then his dicipline would be for tarnishing the company's reputation while outside of work since he was in TTC livery when he shoved the passenger. If he was on the clock then they can add the physical assault to his discipline. Whether that would be enough for termination would depend on Mr. Tulk's record. One mistake in judgement would not (generally speaking) be a reason to fire an employee.
 
What article are you reading? The one Fred put up states "Mr. Ross, who said the Mr. Tulk has been disciplined but couldn't say whether he's still employed at the TTC"

If Mr. Tulk was not on the clock when the incident occurred then his dicipline would be for tarnishing the company's reputation while outside of work since he was in TTC livery when he shoved the passenger. If he was on the clock then they can add the physical assault to his discipline. Whether that would be enough for termination would depend on Mr. Tulk's record. One mistake in judgement would not (generally speaking) be a reason to fire an employee.

The driver of the bus was not disciplined ( not the driver that did the shoving) but I say the bus driver should have stopped the bus and reported it but you raise an interesting point if he was not on duty at the time then can he be disciplined by the TTC ???????? WHAT IF HE WAS NOT IN UNIFORM ??????? How can wearing a uniform that anyone can wear make a difference ( it is not like it is a cop uniform) ?
 
The driver of the bus was not disciplined ( not the driver that did the shoving) but I say the bus driver should have stopped the bus and reported it but you raise an interesting point if he was not on duty at the time then can he be disciplined by the TTC ???????? WHAT IF HE WAS NOT IN UNIFORM ??????? How can wearing a uniform that anyone can wear make a difference ( it is not like it is a cop uniform) ?

My apologies on the bus driver, I thought you were referring to the shoving driver, not the actively driving one.

As far as discipline while not on the job... very few companies allow you to publically tarnish their reputations even while you're not currently on the clock. I know my jobs have clauses in their policies to that effect and those clauses have stood up under arbitration.

If he was not working, not in uniform and did not reveal himself to be a TTC employee then I would say that they would have no grounds to discipline him as an employee.

If you were not an employee and performed antics to defame the TTC's rep while wearing a TTC employee's uniform they obviously couldn't discipline you, but they could sue you I suppose.
 
I agree that the TTC "inspector" or whoever he is, was in the wrong and needs to be disciplined.

But I saw the guy who was shoved on CITY TV news tonight saying he was to scared to ride the TTC anymore. Talk about a lawsuit scam in the making....what a whiner.
 
he was to scared to ride the TTC anymore. Talk about a lawsuit scam in the making....what a whiner.

He's also claiming his son is to terrified to ever ride the TTC again and is EMOTIONALLY DAMAGED

Give me a fracking break!
 
Posted in a thread below...

‘Screaming’ TTC worker shoved me, man claims

Isaac Gould rides the TTC with his 10-year-old son all the time.

However, now he says his son is afraid to ride the bus and feels “emotionally damaged” by an ugly episode with a Toronto Transit Commission employee last month.

That employee has been charged with assault after a Jan. 8 incident in which Gould says the man swore at him and pushed him into a steel pole on a TTC bus.

A TTC employee turned himself in to police Tuesday following an investigation.

Gould says it was about 10 a.m. on a Saturday when he and his son boarded a westbound bus on Sheppard Ave. E. at Scunthorpe Ave.

They were standing near the front of the packed bus when a uniformed TTC employee boarded at the Malvern bus terminal, according to Gould.

“He seemed irritated that the bus was late,” Gould told the Star. “He complained to the bus driver that the bus was 20 minutes late, but the driver replied that he was only 10 minutes late.”

When the bus arrived at a stop where about five people were waiting, the TTC employee erupted, according to Gould.

“(He) started screaming at everyone in the bus to move to the back, but you clearly couldn’t move,” he said.

Gould said his back was turned to the TTC employee, who was much larger than him.

“He got frustrated and grabbed me from behind and shoved me into the pole and told me to ‘get the f--- out of my way’ and proceeded to the back of the bus,” Gould said.

“He was pushing his way through the crowd, shoving everybody from right to left. He barged his way through the crowd to get off the bus.”

After Gould called police at 42 Division, a TTC dispatcher ordered the bus driver to pull over at McCowan Rd. and wait for officers to arrive.

Meanwhile, the TTC employee got off and boarded a northbound bus.

Gould said he was left with a sore arm but did not need any medical assistance.

Gould, who takes the TTC to pick up his son from the boy’s mother on weekends, said that he is more concerned about the emotional impact on his son.

“It seems more about the damage done to my son, that my son had to witness his father go through this from a TTC employee,” Gould said.

“It’s not like I have any other way to travel to pick up my son. Now my son does not want to take the TTC anymore. He is distraught from this.”

Police confirmed that detectives from 42 Division had investigated the alleged assault. “There were a lot of witnesses,” Const. Wendy Drummond said.

The TTC also provided police with video surveillance from the four on-board cameras.

TTC spokesman Brad Ross said the transit operator “takes this matter very seriously” and has disciplined the employee.

He would not elaborate because the matter is now before the courts.

Ross also said there is no evidence that the TTC driver operating the bus did anything wrong and does not face disciplinary action.

However, Gould faulted the TTC driver for ignoring him.

“I asked the bus driver to stop and that I was making a police report because I just got assaulted by one of his co-workers and he totally ignored me,” Gould said.

“When the gentlemen first came on the bus, the TTC driver called him Fred. He said, ‘Hi, Fred.’ But when I asked his name, he said, ‘I don’t know his name.’ That leaves me with questions about the kind of service that is going on with the TTC and what is being is being hidden and what is being revealed.”

Ross noted that the TTC has 12,000 TTC employees and that the vast majority perform their jobs professionally.

He said TTC employees are trained in customer service and in de-escalating situations before they get out of control.

“Our expectations are that our TTC employees should always treat our customers with courtesy and respect,” Ross said.

“With these allegations, that apparently did not happen.”

Gould, 40, said he has lived in this city all his life, and although incidents like this might be isolated, he says, “I’ve seen more bad than good” from TTC employees.

He said he has discussed his concerns both with TTC general manager Gary Webster and Mayor Rob Ford.

Frederick Tulk, 59, of Pickering, has been charged with assault.

He is scheduled to appear in court on March 17.

I'm just saying... erupted and screaming are fun words when your trying to get someone in trouble, but have you ever tried to make an announcement on a bus, you need to raise your voice, you have no choice. Also, shoving his way to the back, pushing people left and right? I do this on a daily basis in order to get off the damn bus.

What I get from this story is that this dude was in the front of the group and the driver made his way to the back, he was the first to get pushed aside so he could move forward and then dude started screaming 'rape'

In my opinion the only wrong by this driver was that he swore at the passenger as he made his way to the back... thats just my opinion though
 
Ontario law - He was NOT on duty. Second, even if he was on duty, his actions were not an integral part of his normal duties or connected thereto. So forget about partying the TTC.

Since he has been criminally charged, there go your punitive damages. Defendant cannot be punished twice over - once in criminal court and then again by punitive damages in civil court.

Welcome to a nice $500.00 piece of shit Small Claims Court lawsuit which will likely never even get to trial because of the costs and bother of pursuing it.
 
Ontario law - He was NOT on duty. Second, even if he was on duty, his actions were not an integral part of his normal duties or connected thereto. So forget about partying the TTC.

Since he has been criminally charged, there go your punitive damages. Defendant cannot be punished twice over - once in criminal court and then again by punitive damages in civil court.

Welcome to a nice $500.00 piece of shit Small Claims Court lawsuit which will likely never even get to trial because of the costs and bother of pursuing it.

He and his son will be back riding the TTC as soon as he realizes there is no money to be made.
 
What's the over/under on how long before Kinnear invokes the the prescription drug defense?
 
Ontario law - He was NOT on duty. Second, even if he was on duty, his actions were not an integral part of his normal duties or connected thereto. So forget about partying the TTC.

Since he has been criminally charged, there go your punitive damages. Defendant cannot be punished twice over - once in criminal court and then again by punitive damages in civil court.

Welcome to a nice $500.00 piece of shit Small Claims Court lawsuit which will likely never even get to trial because of the costs and bother of pursuing it.

My god, are you sure about that? None of that OJ civil trial option like they have in the US up here? How does one get recompense for injuries, lost time etc from an assault? In almost any assault worthy of the name, charges are laid. If it goes to diversion, then the court will demand restitution be made, but what if it goes to trial?

BTW, anyone got any back story info on this? Like have any witnesses come forward? I saw an interview with the victim, and and my bullshit alarm went off.
 
BTW, anyone got any back story info on this? Like have any witnesses come forward? I saw an interview with the victim, and and my bullshit alarm went off.
I'm sure the surveillance video and a statement from the "on duty" driver is all they needed to lay a charge. But yeah, it would be interesting to hear what other passengers had to say.
 
My apologies on the bus driver, I thought you were referring to the shoving driver, not the actively driving one.

And this is why I agree with those saying bullshit

Let us pretend the shover was you or me

If you or I were shoving people around screaming at them to get the fuck back it is the drivers responsibility to stop the bus and phone in an emergency situation

That is was TTC employee shoving makes no difference as to the proper procedure of the actual driver

The driver never did phone in or stop th e bus yet was found to have followed proper procedure