TTC could be declared essential by April

That's more an erosion of the definition of 'essential', IMHO. (Well, with the exception of things like Handy Trans, etc.) Very important, yes-- But you can already legislate them back to work, so there's already an easy way to keep things from getting too far out of hand. 'Profoundly inconvenient' and 'bad for the economy' should be separate from 'essential', otherwise what's the point?
Yes I agree ... well that it is IYHO not much more. You can always legislate Police, Fire & Ambulance back to work - why call that essential ? Is essential limited to life threatening only ? IMHO that is too narrow. The TTC is the ONLY way for a substantial group of people to get to work. In this case the TTC is directly affecting their livelihood - their ability to feed & clothe their families. I would call that an essential service and not limit it to just the Handy Trans service as you have suggested. Unless you feel somebody in a wheel can't navigate the streets but anyone that can walk should jog 10 or 15 miles to work.

But as you say ... IMHO
 
Yes I agree ... well that it is IYHO not much more. You can always legislate Police, Fire & Ambulance back to work - why call that essential ? Is essential limited to life threatening only ? IMHO that is too narrow. The TTC is the ONLY way for a substantial group of people to get to work. In this case the TTC is directly affecting their livelihood - their ability to feed & clothe their families. I would call that an essential service and not limit it to just the Handy Trans service as you have suggested.

The traditional definition of "Essential Service" if physical life threatening. If the ATU decided to go to the Supreme Court with this new legislation, there is a very good chance that it would be thrown out so the province and the city need to make the deal sweet enough to persuade Greg Kinnear not to go that route. "Major inconvenience" has never been sufficient grounds to label something "essential" the entire civil service can go out and there go welfare checks EI etc. Teachers, profs, school caretakers, some hospital workers, etc can go out. As we saw, garbage collectors can strike because it is an inconvenience which is the entire point.

Making strikes "illegal" does not stop strike either my friends. When unions feel they are treated badly enough they go on strike anyway.

Teachers made major gains when they did not have the right to strike with "mass resignations" every June until the gov't relented.

The adage goes, "if strikes are made illegal, you will just get llegal strikes".

When the cops get angry enough, they stop writing tickets. This puts enormous pressure on the city. When teachers get angry enough, they cancell extra curricular activities and refuse to cover absent classes or go to meetings. The only way to stop them is to lock them out.

Wise up to how the real world works. The right to strike is as important to democracy as the right to vote. The right to strike is a sacred right, without which we are talking about slavery.

The only way to get workers to give upn the right to strike is to offer binding arbitation by which, they almost always get bigger raises than they would get from their employer.
 
And/or threats, intimitation, bullying, violence, etc. Monopoly unions are a license to print money. When there is no competition, there is abuse and gouging.

Like unions invented monopolies LOL. There are competing unions in every field. If you do not like your union you switch to another. If you cannot persuade a majority to switch, I guess they were satisfied and you are the malcontent. You ought to see the competition for newly organized workers.
 
Like unions invented monopolies LOL. There are competing unions in every field. If you do not like your union you switch to another.

I meant the service provided by public service unions is a monopoly (funded with taxpayer money) although there are a few exceptions like schools where public schools compete with private schools but private schools are generally not taxpayer funded.
 
I meant the service provided by public service unions is a monopoly (funded with taxpayer money) although there are a few exceptions like schools where public schools compete with private schools but private schools are generally not taxpayer funded.

And you can actually make a 'not insane' case for some special arbitration levers there. (Just like unions have a list of legit policy grievances.)

But the simple truth is that 30 years of broadly neo-liberal economic policies, combined with deregulation, and a flattening of the tax system, has hammered the private sector working and middle class in North America in most of the productive (in the Adam Smith sense) sectors of the economy. Suggesting that the segments of the working population that have resisted that should 'take a haircut', as opposed to the people getting hammered 'figuring it out', and actually demanding what's in their self interest, strikes me as delusional 'Me and mine can win in a race to the bottom' type BS that has been repeatedly and empirically been proven to be wrong.

edit: If working class and middle class people could win in a race to the bottom they'd have done far better in the last 30 years in the 'Anglosphere' than they did. This only mirrors every other example of the same in the semi-modern era.
 
Like unions invented monopolies LOL. There are competing unions in every field. If you do not like your union you switch to another. If you cannot persuade a majority to switch, I guess they were satisfied and you are the malcontent. You ought to see the competition for newly organized workers.

So any of the big 3 auto companies can just switch to a more reasonable union.

Every union establishes a monopoly wrt the company they extort money from, just like the Mafia and Montreal pizza joints wrt cheese and pep.
With a government monopoly it is doubly damaging.

Really? you couldn't figure this out, union member are we?

Not that one would expect the thieving cunts in a union to be able to figure it out.

If only Paul Bernardo targeted union members instead of teenage girls, he would have been a hero and provider of justice, for they deserve much worse.
 
I meant the service provided by public service unions is a monopoly (funded with taxpayer money) although there are a few exceptions like schools where public schools compete with private schools but private schools are generally not taxpayer funded.

It makes no difference whether they are pubic or private. No difference whatsoever. Unions created the middle class and the middle income group across the western world. Without unons there would be no medicare, no pensions, no welfare no EI, nothing worthwhile. That is why the wealthy and the corporations attack unions so much. They want to be even richer off the backs of the common working person. Solidarity forever.
 
That is why the wealthy and the corporations attack unions so much. They want to be even richer off the backs of the common working person. Solidarity forever.

Without wealthy people and corporations, there would be no jobs. Corporations, not unions, create jobs which in turn creates the middle class which pays the taxes to fund monopoly publice sector unions.
 
Without wealthy people and corporations, there would be no jobs.

That's a talking point and not a fact. Just critically pick that apart on your own.
 
Back to the OP

Being declared essential does not guarantee better wages !

It depends on the arbitrator which is chosen by the government and if a Ronald Reagan or GW Bush is in power then you know they will go with an ultra conservative arbitrator who will dance to their political tune

Also essential services have gone on strike and union leaders jailed as a result so the belief that being declared essential makes the workers better off is wrong

Anyone disagree ?
 
It makes no difference whether they are pubic or private. No difference whatsoever. Unions created the middle class and the middle income group across the western world. Without unons there would be no medicare, no pensions, no welfare no EI, nothing worthwhile. That is why the wealthy and the corporations attack unions so much. They want to be even richer off the backs of the common working person. Solidarity forever.

Now we went through all this before in the great debate you and the rest of the union automatons waged in the thread on the garbage strike. I can't wait for you to bring out all those great unions that paved the way during the Egyptian empire. That was a goody MrBig. The high water mark of the union is behind us. Now it's time for them to be part of the solution and not a major part of the problem.
 
The high water mark of the union is behind us. Now it's time for them to be part of the solution and not a major part of the problem.
...by rolling over and participating in a race to the bottom that every bit of data indicates OVERWHELMINGLY favours the already rich and already powerful. No, I'd say it's people who don't act in their own self interest that are the greater problem. Or idiots who buy into the fairytale that are special and that they and theirs will prosper in some sort of 'corporate libertarian' paradise.
 
...by rolling over and participating in a race to the bottom that every bit of data indicates OVERWHELMINGLY favours the already rich and already powerful. No, I'd say it's people who don't act in their own self interest that are the greater problem. Or idiots who buy into the fairytale that are special and that they and theirs will prosper in some sort of 'corporate libertarian' paradise.

and I thought I wrote complex sentences sometimes. If I knew what you were trying to say I might agree with you, or not.