Trump's Legacy

Darts

Well-known member
Jan 15, 2017
22,944
11,295
113
I think Trump will be a one term president. So, what will be his legacy?

His administration has balanced the extreme left wing bias in the judiciary with the appointment of two SCOTUS judges and 300 lower court federal judges. So, we should see some more (but not all) rational judgments in the coming years.
 
A total decimation of any pretense to decency, honesty, morality and decorum. A racial civil war. Enabled the subculture of ignorance and prejudice. Disturbed the balance of powers and might force numerous Constitutional amendments to prevent future fascism ( one possible plus). The most incompetent, disruptive and mentally unhinged idiot to ever inhabit the oval office.
 
If C19 gets much worse then his legacy will be C19, if C19 clears up then I think Trump will be remembered as the president who wanted to nuke a hurricane.
 
To quote Jon Stewart " he is our white hat hacker who showed us how the system of government is not protected". He is an example of the "kardashian" experience, where you are talked about because you shocked the senses, not because you have something, or anything to offer. He mopped the floor with a dozen republican contenders at the first debate, including the anointed one ( and smarter one) Jeb Bush.
The media gave him air time, face time and sound bites when he should have been ignored by all for the sake of advertising revenue.
Play stupid games, win stupid prizes.
Trumps republican victory was not supposed to happen.
He has no shame because he has never been or pretended to have a moral compass as a public figure. That was his super power to get past and continue to get past the media. His downfall will be is narcissistic, self indulgent and vain nature.
The peril is that if Biden performs so poorly that no one has confidence, there me another 4 years of work for Alec Baldwin.
A polarized electorate along political lines, the media and self indulgent interest groups that have their own agenda ahead of a national agenda will help Trump to get re elected.
as far fetched as it sounds, one of the two parties has to come out of the gate in September with a new electable, coherent, intelligent and experienced candidate in order to topple the silliness and restore some kind of order.
 
Trump will be remembered for having hastened the fall of the American Empire.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jalimon
Because of who Trump is facing (Biden) I'm not so sure about the one term. COVID-19 will run its course like any other virus.

Regardless, to look at what Trump has done to date as really setting himself apart.

1. As you noted, the 2 SCOTUS judges and 300 lower court federal judges is huge.
2. Securing the border. This was met with huge resistance, yet a massive promise kept.
(The black eye to this will be if Mexico does not pay for it as he touted.)
3. United States Embassy officially relocated to Jerusalem ( Many other US Presidents failed this same promise)
4. Trump walking into North Korea and shook hands with Jong-on
5. Replaced NAFTA and Withdrew from Paris Climate Accord.

Though I don't feel the following is part of a 'legacy', I feel them worth mentioning.
Besides the above, Trump was also the person who coined 'fake news'. Regards if you are left or right, hate him or like him,
everyone is awake to the bias now of mainstream media.

Also, Trump deserves credit for being the only one dealing with the US-China trade deal, as well Trump warned the
world about depending on China supplies prior to Covid-19.

What Trump has done with the economy, breaking records, and low unemployment is all outstanding. Especially as skeptics said the economy would crash in 6 months.
But not a legacy, and he will need something more as a 2020 platform. Healthcare would be a great start.

Misc - The current tensions in the US facing Blacks, is based on police actions. So do not find this to be racial based, through the media wants it to be such.
Most police are good, but the system is broke and needs to be fixed, not defunded.

I am afraid that the "accomplishments" you list here will be regarded as failures by future historians.
 
Some Presidents are known for big pieces of legislation and action that stand time (FDR, LBJ, Lincoln and Teddy Roosevelt). Some are known for presiding over economic booms like Reagan and Clinton. While others are known for stupid unforced errors like George W. Bush invading Iraq.

As Obama will be known for changing the discussion on healthcare, Trump will be known for changing the discussion on immigration and trade policies. While everyone is myopically focused on the immediate impact of COVID, the virus will put into motion moves to reduce globalization not just here but also in Europe.

The jury is still out on Trump's responsibility in the COVID outbreak. The death toll in Europe is still far ahead of the U.S. That's just a fact. The race riots have been building since Obama's term. I never blamed Obama.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kathleen
Democracies are like bamboo. They bend but they do not crack. The systems of government in China and Russia can look strong, but their inflexibility is their weakness.
 
Democracies are like bamboo. They bend but they do not crack. The systems of government in China and Russia can look strong, but their inflexibility is their weakness.
Russia is strong enough to actively influence installing an American president and have him help Russia throughout his term.
And not just a president but a guy who cannot show his taxes nor his school grades, who evaded military draft based on a fake disease, who has been involved in numerous scams such as fake charity and fake university, who was sleeping with pornstar while wife was pregnant, who basically doesn’t have an honest bone in his body.

his legacy hopefully is going to include going to jail. In an ideal world it would include tarring and feathering.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: BlueJays1992
The jury is still out on Trump's responsibility in the COVID outbreak. The death toll in Europe is still far ahead of the U.S. That's just a fact. The race riots have been building since Obama's term. I never blamed Obama.

Sadly that is not a fact. A few European countries, Belgium, UK, Spain, Italy, Sweden are quite a bit higher than USA, but many other countries are much lower, Germany is a good example
 
Trump will be remembered for demonstrating that it remains possible to ride racism and white grievance all the way to the White House.
 
Far fewer American soldiers lost their lives in combat than in many previous presidential administrations.

Defeat of ISIS.
 
Because of who Trump is facing (Biden) I'm not so sure about the one term. COVID-19 will run its course like any other virus.

Regardless, to look at what Trump has done to date as really setting himself apart.

1. As you noted, the 2 SCOTUS judges and 300 lower court federal judges is huge.
2. Securing the border. This was met with huge resistance, yet a massive promise kept.
(The black eye to this will be if Mexico does not pay for it as he touted.)
3. United States Embassy officially relocated to Jerusalem ( Many other US Presidents failed this same promise)
4. Trump walking into North Korea and shook hands with Jong-on
5. Replaced NAFTA and Withdrew from Paris Climate Accord.

1 - Yes, many incompetent and very right wing judges are in place. This will work against any attempts to redo the judicial system with racial fairness.
2 - The wall is not built and a failure where it is built, easy to cut through and funding going through Trump buddies.
3 - With the US backing Israel is about to annex 30% of the West Bank and formalize apartheid, which will turn Israel into a pariah state like apartheid South Africa was.
4 - North Korea talks only made KJU look stronger to his people and gave him more time to build the bomb.
5 - The new NAFTA is the same as the old NAFTA, withdrawing from Paris the single largest climate change failure ever.

On top of that Trump's US has the worst COVID-19 response globally, suffered mass race protests (Trump today retweeted a supporter yelling 'white power') and is taking the US into a depression.
Its time for Trump to leave.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BlueJays1992
I think he'll be seen as amongst the worst. Not saying that as a USA liberal (I am an Aussie liberal party, the liberal party in Australia is a conservative centre-right party, the main competitor is the labour party which is a centre-left party; far left are democrats and green, far right is country party). Many USA republicans have also agreed he is the worst (the people who ran McCain's and Romney's campaigns who are now the Lincoln Project, I'd be one of those blokes).

First, the economy was a continuation of obama, even before the pandemic (of course great depression collapse after). Economic growth roughly the same as Obama (Trump 2.23 and 2.93% first 2 years, Obama 1.57 and 2.88% last 2 years) and nowhere near previous presidents (jimmy carter averaged about 5% growth lol), Obama added more jobs in his last 3 years than trump in his first 3. The unemployment got lower under Trump, but the decrease was larger under Obama. The percentage rise in stock market higher for obama over trump, but points higher under trump. Thus the point is even if economy better under trump v. Obama, it was not significantly better than Obama and both O and T had less GDP growth than almost all other presidents since the great depression. Also add the issue of cutting regulations. Too much? Too little? Honest people can disagree. Immigration? Also mixed. Obama deported more than Bush. But too far I think. Thus not saying those were good or bad, people can honourably disagree.

Second, left and right can honestly disagree about the judges, but Trump has put forth judges rated unqualified by the ABA for the first time.

Third, more lies than all presidents combined in the last 100 years (Obama told 18, Trump approaching 20,000). Attack on truth and fact.

Fourth, elimination of checks and balances through firing inspector general's and anyone investigating him. Through ignoring subpoenas. Through obstruction of justice (10 distinct acts in Mueller report).

Fifth, biggest USA deficit/debt in history.

Sixth, destruction of alliances/nato. USA had allies. Russia does not. China does not. Thus giving up a huge usa advantage over her competitors. Gave up Asia to China. Made concessions to north korea receiving nothing in return. Treasonous kowtowing to Russia believing Putin over his own intel agencies. Seeking foriegn help for reelection. Friendly to dictators, hostile to democracies. Any survey in any country show huge declines in admiration for USA, except in Russia and Israel. I work all over the world. USA is a laughing stock. People feel pity. It's extraordinary. Smart people who want to go to USA now going to Canada and Australia and UK instead.

Seventh, legacy of anti-science, supporting racists and confederates, mean spirited attacks on military families, other civilians.

Eighth, destruction of norms. USA system mostly worked because govt stayed within the norms. Now a shit ton of laws will be passed eliminating hiring family, clarifying emoluments, forcing release of taxes (remember he promised to release them after the election), distinct criminal penalties for ignogring subpoenas. He has moved USA toward banana republic style unaccountable govt, where family business intertwined w national business.

Ninth, botching pandemic. USA and south Korea have first death on same day. Since then SK has 250 deaths, USA 125,000.

Tenth, collapse of the economy.

11th, one of most corrupt administrations in USA history. Half the cabinet resigned under cloud. Most of campaign hierarchy in gaol.

I'm afraid that's how he'll be seen. History will say:
LEGACY:
Can't count on USA to honour treaties. USA dimished as a source of freedom in the world.
It is possible for autocracy to arise in USA.
Destruction of Republican party in its current form.
A strongly conservative court.
Tons of new laws codifying various norms.
A depression.
 
Sadly that is not a fact. A few European countries, Belgium, UK, Spain, Italy, Sweden are quite a bit higher than USA, but many other countries are much lower, Germany is a good example
Then you don't know what a fact is. Europe has more deaths than the U.S. is a fact. You can present other facts, but you can't say that this is not a fact nor can you say it is not a relevant fact.

In response to your post, the U.S. is not uniform in its impact from the virus. Even with all the panic over Florida and Texas, the Tri-State area (NY, NJ and CT) has been hit much harder than other regions. I'll certainly give the Germans credit for their early testing and I'm guessing they isolated the vulnerable population.
 
COVID-19 will run its course like any other virus.


"Run its course like any other virus?

Like herpes, Hepatitis, HIV, rhinovirus (common cold) , Rabies virus, Zika virus... to name just a few incurable virus' that continue to "run <their> course"?

Other than the eminent Professor Trump who promised COVID will be gone by Easter Weekend when things warm up, where are you getting your scientific and health information from to come to this conclusion?
 
I think he'll be seen as amongst the worst. Not saying that as a USA liberal (I am an Aussie liberal party, the liberal party in Australia is a conservative centre-right party, the main competitor is the labour party which is a centre-left party; far left are democrats and green, far right is country party). Many USA republicans have also agreed he is the worst (the people who ran McCain's and Romney's campaigns who are now the Lincoln Project, I'd be one of those blokes).

First, the economy was a continuation of obama, even before the pandemic (of course great depression collapse after). Economic growth roughly the same as Obama (Trump 2.23 and 2.93% first 2 years, Obama 1.57 and 2.88% last 2 years) and nowhere near previous presidents (jimmy carter averaged about 5% growth lol), Obama added more jobs in his last 3 years than trump in his first 3. The unemployment got lower under Trump, but the decrease was larger under Obama. The percentage rise in stock market higher for obama over trump, but points higher under trump. Thus the point is even if economy better under trump v. Obama, it was not significantly better than Obama and both O and T had less GDP growth than almost all other presidents since the great depression. Also add the issue of cutting regulations. Too much? Too little? Honest people can disagree. Immigration? Also mixed. Obama deported more than Bush. But too far I think. Thus not saying those were good or bad, people can honourably disagree.

Second, left and right can honestly disagree about the judges, but Trump has put forth judges rated unqualified by the ABA for the first time.

Third, more lies than all presidents combined in the last 100 years (Obama told 18, Trump approaching 20,000). Attack on truth and fact.

Fourth, elimination of checks and balances through firing inspector general's and anyone investigating him. Through ignoring subpoenas. Through obstruction of justice (10 distinct acts in Mueller report).

Fifth, biggest USA deficit/debt in history.

Sixth, destruction of alliances/nato. USA had allies. Russia does not. China does not. Thus giving up a huge usa advantage over her competitors. Gave up Asia to China. Made concessions to north korea receiving nothing in return. Treasonous kowtowing to Russia believing Putin over his own intel agencies. Seeking foriegn help for reelection. Friendly to dictators, hostile to democracies. Any survey in any country show huge declines in admiration for USA, except in Russia and Israel. I work all over the world. USA is a laughing stock. People feel pity. It's extraordinary. Smart people who want to go to USA now going to Canada and Australia and UK instead.

Seventh, legacy of anti-science, supporting racists and confederates, mean spirited attacks on military families, other civilians.

Eighth, destruction of norms. USA system mostly worked because govt stayed within the norms. Now a shit ton of laws will be passed eliminating hiring family, clarifying emoluments, forcing release of taxes (remember he promised to release them after the election), distinct criminal penalties for ignogring subpoenas. He has moved USA toward banana republic style unaccountable govt, where family business intertwined w national business.

Ninth, botching pandemic. USA and south Korea have first death on same day. Since then SK has 250 deaths, USA 125,000.

Tenth, collapse of the economy.

11th, one of most corrupt administrations in USA history. Half the cabinet resigned under cloud. Most of campaign hierarchy in gaol.

I'm afraid that's how he'll be seen. History will say:
LEGACY:
Can't count on USA to honour treaties. USA dimished as a source of freedom in the world.
It is possible for autocracy to arise in USA.
Destruction of Republican party in its current form.
A strongly conservative court.
Tons of new laws codifying various norms.
A depression.
Kherg, this wasn't even remotely an objective and well-considered post. I expect rants from Frank not you.

I'll respond to economics and the myth of the Great Obama Recovery. Most nonpartisan economists attribute the recovery to massive Fed actions. Basically, the Fed has been very aggressive providing monetary stimulus to support the U.S. and global economies. The Obama fiscal stimulus was probably closer to helicopter money (dropping money on the economy) than infrastructure spending. Obama himself was caught on tape joking about it. I'm not saying Trump deficits were any better.

Many people from both sides of the political spectrum agree that the Obama Administration did not do enough to fundamentally restructure the large U.S. banks. Again, not entirely Obama's fault. The "experts" in the Treasury usually have deep connections to the large banks.