Trump and Musk Are Destroying the Basics of a Healthy Democracy

Butler1000

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2011
30,999
5,142
113
It's possible, just difficult to say in a two party system, as you know.
Ballots in first past the post are very limited in the expressiveness in general and in a two-party system you always have people voting for only part of the suite of things a candidate is claiming to want to do.
It is a thing we will see play out in public opinion as it goes on.



I expect so.
It isn't like Trump and Musk are going to back off of their attempts to impose autocracy and oligarchy.



As I've said repeatedly, whether Musk and Trump will respect the courts is up in the air.



You're leaving the violence out.
Sure, violence is possible, especially if the deep state tries something nefarious, or Trump goes too far. We are in new territory here.
 

Butler1000

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2011
30,999
5,142
113
There is no such thing as a deep state. There is no cabal of nameless, faceless bureaucrats blocking the direct orders of the POTUS.

Show me one single verified case of the “deep state” interfering with the will of POTUS or congress. The troops stayed in Afghanistan because Obama chose to keep them there.

Trump wants to create his own Deep State; that’s why he’s trying to fire everybody he can and replace them with loyalists who won’t rat him out the next time he tries to extort political dirt on an opponent from a foreign leader.
You are correct about a cabal. What the deep state is is a collective group think especially on foreign policy and military/intelligence. It's like minded people hiring and promoting like minded people creating an institutional group think. It happens in all organizations.

In this case Obama campaigned on ending the wars. Instead he did the Surge. The reason was his advisors told him it was the only option. They may have given that answer coming from a position of THINKING it was. But they are heavily influenced by group think to pick that knowing "everyone" else is also thinking that way, and breaking from that can result in a mark on your career path.

Yes Trump is also trying to change that culture. That is what he was elected to do.
 

Knuckle Ball

Well-known member
Oct 15, 2017
7,510
3,718
113
Trump wanted peace with NK.John Bolton goes on the news and suggests the Libyan Formula for denuclearization.. just a coincidence I suppose. lol.
John Bolton was part of the deep state? He was the National Security Advisor. That is not the “deep state;” it is literally the opposite of the deep state.

A Deep State, as the theory goes, involves a secret conspiracy of people within the government pursuing their own goals and objectives. If John Bolton is making statements to the press about North Korea’s nukes it is hardly a secret. Everyone can see what he’s doing and if Trump didn’t like it he could have fired him.

Plus…as I recall that was around the time that Trump was calling Kim Jong Un “Little Rocket Man” and threatening him with “fire and fury”; they didn’t fall in love until later. So Bolton’s comments may have been entirely consistent with Trump’s messaging at the time.


The state dept had a 10M bounty on the head of the new Syrian leader, at the same time the CIA was arming him to attack Assad. How does that happen?
Because the new Syrian Leader was a known terrorist who’d had a bounty on his head for some time. The CIA had been arming the Syrian rebels since 2013. When arming rebels in Syria, chances are you might find yourself arming some terrorists.

Anyway…where is the Deep State conspiracy here? There isn’t one.
 
Last edited:

Knuckle Ball

Well-known member
Oct 15, 2017
7,510
3,718
113
You are correct about a cabal. What the deep state is is a collective group think especially on foreign policy and military/intelligence. It's like minded people hiring and promoting like minded people creating an institutional group think. It happens in all organizations.

In this case Obama campaigned on ending the wars. Instead he did the Surge. The reason was his advisors told him it was the only option. They may have given that answer coming from a position of THINKING it was. But they are heavily influenced by group think to pick that knowing "everyone" else is also thinking that way, and breaking from that can result in a mark on your career path.

Yes Trump is also trying to change that culture. That is what he was elected to do.
Group think and the Deep State are two entirely different things. You are conflating the two.
 

Butler1000

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2011
30,999
5,142
113
Group think and the Deep State are two entirely different things. You are conflating the two.
When it results in wars, intelligence agencies spying on its own citizens, perpetuating the oligarchy, and continued expansion of agencies to the point they are too powerful to oppose them yes, they qualify as deep state.

They are dangerous as well.
 

Butler1000

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2011
30,999
5,142
113
John Bolton was part of the deep state? He was the National Security Advisor. That is not the “deep state;” it is literally the opposite of the deep state.

A Deep State, as the theory goes, involves a secret conspiracy of people within the government pursuing their own goals and objectives. If John Bolton is making statements to the press about North Korea’s nukes it is hardly a secret. Everyone can see what he’s doing and if Trump didn’t like it he could have fired him.

Plus…as I recall that was around the time that Trump was calling Kim Jong Un “Little Rocket Man” and threatening him with “fire and fury”; they didn’t fall in love until later.



Because the new Syrian Leader was a known terrorist who’d had a bounty on his head for some time. The CIA had been arming the Syrian rebels since 2013. When arming rebels in Syria, chances are you might find yourself arming some terrorists.

Anyway…where is the Deep State conspiracy here? There isn’t one.
John Bolton wants to invade and destroy Iran. Syria is a part of that.
 

Knuckle Ball

Well-known member
Oct 15, 2017
7,510
3,718
113
When it results in wars, intelligence agencies spying on its own citizens, perpetuating the oligarchy, and continued expansion of agencies to the point they are too powerful to oppose them yes, they qualify as deep state.

They are dangerous as well.
That sounds really bad but it doesn’t make it a deep state conspiracy.
 

nottyboi

Well-known member
May 14, 2008
23,268
1,891
113
Most, if not all, saw biden as a feeble man, who could barely walk up a set of stairs. Many said trump's in cognitive decline when the exact opposite is true. Usa needed trump at this particular time as their cities were descending into lawlessness.

Libs also say the richest man in the world is an idiot when he builds a rocket better than nasa. Imagine if Harris was president right now, the chaos we'd be in.
Maybe WWIII she would be giggling when she pressed the button, and probably drunk
 

nottyboi

Well-known member
May 14, 2008
23,268
1,891
113
You are correct about a cabal. What the deep state is is a collective group think especially on foreign policy and military/intelligence. It's like minded people hiring and promoting like minded people creating an institutional group think. It happens in all organizations.

In this case Obama campaigned on ending the wars. Instead he did the Surge. The reason was his advisors told him it was the only option. They may have given that answer coming from a position of THINKING it was. But they are heavily influenced by group think to pick that knowing "everyone" else is also thinking that way, and breaking from that can result in a mark on your career path.

Yes Trump is also trying to change that culture. That is what he was elected to do.
It pervades all institutions and also higher education. Look at the European leaders leading the charge to confront Russia, look at where they went to school, look at where they worked. They have all been assimilated..
 

nottyboi

Well-known member
May 14, 2008
23,268
1,891
113
That sounds really bad but it doesn’t make it a deep state conspiracy.
Deep State is just a term. Once it gets critical mass, it is self reinforcing. It takes what you are seeing to break it up because at some point the narrative just does not fit reality and people realize its bullshit. Russia will collapse, Russians will turn against Putin, the Russian economy will be rubble etc etc. Even then this may not work.
 

Knuckle Ball

Well-known member
Oct 15, 2017
7,510
3,718
113
FYI: It seems many of the right wing geniuses on terb have been using the term Deep State without understanding what it means. I know…I was SHOCKED too!

Anyhow, in the interest of clarity, here is the Wikipedia definition:

The deep state conspiracy theory in the United States is a false American political conspiracy theory that posits the existence of the deep state, a clandestine network of members of the federal government(especially within the FBI and CIA). The theory argues that there exist networks of collaborators within the leadership of the high-level financial and industrial entities, which exercise power alongside or within the elected United States government.[1]


You have now learned something new today.

Don’t bother to thank me.
 

Butler1000

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2011
30,999
5,142
113
That sounds really bad but it doesn’t make it a deep state conspiracy.
"Conspiracy"?

Deep State? Yes. Deep state can be defined as a perpetration of policy. As I outlined by continued appointments to create a culture. And promotion of policy.

When it becomes so entrenched how else would you define but as "DEEP"?
 

Butler1000

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2011
30,999
5,142
113
FYI: It seems many of the right wing geniuses on terb have been using the term Deep State without understanding what it means. I know…I was SHOCKED too!

Anyhow, in the interest of clarity, here is the Wikipedia definition:

The deep state conspiracy theory in the United States is a false American political conspiracy theory that posits the existence of the deep state, a clandestine network of members of the federal government(especially within the FBI and CIA). The theory argues that there exist networks of collaborators within the leadership of the high-level financial and industrial entities, which exercise power alongside or within the elected United States government.[1]


You have now learned something new today.

Don’t bother to thank me.

George Carlin explained it best
 

Knuckle Ball

Well-known member
Oct 15, 2017
7,510
3,718
113
Ashley Madison
Toronto Escorts