Trudeau on Tax Avoidance

Bud Plug

Sexual Appliance
Aug 17, 2001
5,065
0
0
Is anyone else concerned that the Prime Minister doesn't seem to appreciate the difference between tax avoidance (legal) and tax evasion (illegal), yet has allocated 440 million dollars to the CRA to, apparently, address both issues?

http://www.thestar.com/news/canada/...more-transparency-on-offshore-tax-havens.html

What about his reference to people paying their "fair share of taxes" (as opposed to "paying the taxes they owe")? Sounds a lot like the Bernie Sanders income redistribution platform to me.

Is he just uninformed as to correct terminology, or is he hinting at a government tax crackdown on loopholes, deductions, and tax deferral opportunities, and not just investigation and prosecution of tax evaders?
 
Is he just uninformed as to correct terminology, or is he hinting at a government tax crackdown on loopholes, deductions, and tax deferral opportunities, and not just investigation and prosecution of tax evaders?

Trudeau is not the one making policy. He does not understand it, and will simply take his orders. He is our version of George W. Bush (platinum spoon + right name + easily led).
 
There wouldn't be a tax avoidance issue if our governments simply didn't tax us to death. The more taxes we pay the more likely people will try to avoid paying them.
 
There is nothing wrong with tax avoidance. It's tax EVASION that is illegal. Income splitting is tax avoidance. Having a secret bank account in the Cayman Islands is tax evasion and is only available to uber rich or Politicians.TPTB have these tax havens so they can corrupt our Politicians so they can always hold it over their heads so as to do they're bidding.

The truth of the matter is saxon is right. We are over taxed. And if people and our Politicians would simple recognize how money is created we could avoid all this nonsense and begin to prosper like we used to before Justin's Father handed our Public Bank over to the Bank of England and the Bank of International Settlements in 1974.

Our Government USED to issue our money at little to ZERO interest. So we had balanced budgets and didn't have to tax people thru the nose to pay the interest back to the Bank of England and the BIS. It's the God Damn Government that should issue the currency of our nation. Not go out and borrow it from a private entity ( yes all Central banks around the world are private Corporations ). And here's the rub. The private entity that we borrow our money from and then pay interest too....doesn't HAVE ANY MONEY !!!!

You've been lied to, hood winked, and had people.

WAKE UP !!!!
 
Tax avoidance by people and companies may not be illegal but it can be a distortion of tax policy. So funding cra to identify these loopholes so they can be closed is also part of the plan. He's bright enough to take expert advice and understand a leader is not a technocrat.
 
Tax avoidance by people and companies may not be illegal but it can be a distortion of tax policy. So funding cra to identify these loopholes so they can be closed is also part of the plan. He's bright enough to take expert advice and understand a leader is not a technocrat.

I'm sorry, but are you claiming that what Trudeau was trying [and failing] to say was that part of the 440 million allocated to the CRA was to study potential tax changes? And that the purpose of the study is to increase the amount of taxes to be paid by some taxpayers in the future? And that he has not instructed anyone to attempt to collect taxes from "tax avoiders"? Just want to be clear here.

p.s. It doesn't take a technocrat to know the difference between tax avoidance and tax evasion. That would have taken a one paragraph briefing note from his [expert?] staff.

It is simply amazing the free ride this guy is getting from the media. How he can spew out such confused nonsense and never be required by the press to even clarify his remarks is unfathomable.
 
Every country has tax loopholes, it's what keeps the wealthy and business from leaving. Should CRA close ALL loopholes you will see a flight of capital and business which isn't good.
 
Every country has tax loopholes, it's what keeps the wealthy and business from leaving. Should CRA close ALL loopholes you will see a flight of capital and business which isn't good.
Canada's taxes are way too high. To encourage the occasional rich immigrant (yes, not all of our immigrants need to be poor) to come to Canada we allowed them to set up an offshore trust exempt from Canadian taxes for 5 years. (P.S. There might have been recent changes to kill these trusts.)
 
As far as I'm concerned, both need to be addressed. Our taxes are higher than they need to be, because our tax code is full of loopholes, deductions and deferrals that shouldn't be there. Simplify the tax code, eliminate loopholes, lower rates across the board, add a few tax brackets at the top, and drastically cut the corporate rate, and we'd be just fine.
 
No
I'm sorry, but are you claiming that what Trudeau was trying [and failing] to say was that part of the 440 million allocated to the CRA was to study potential tax changes? And that the purpose of the study is to increase the amount of taxes to be paid by some taxpayers in the future? And that he has not instructed anyone to attempt to collect taxes from "tax avoiders"? Just want to be clear here.

p.s. It doesn't take a technocrat to know the difference between tax avoidance and tax evasion. That would have taken a one paragraph briefing note from his [expert?] staff.

It is simply amazing the free ride this guy is getting from the media. How he can spew out such confused nonsense and never be required by the press to even clarify his remarks is unfathomable.

You cannot collect. Taxes when none are due. 440 mil is a lot of money. It was allocated for a multitude of reasons. Both evasion and avoidance need to be reduced.
 
Canada's taxes are way too high. To encourage the occasional rich immigrant (yes, not all of our immigrants need to be poor) to come to Canada we allowed them to set up an offshore trust exempt from Canadian taxes for 5 years. (P.S. There might have been recent changes to kill these trusts.)

We already attract a lot of rich immigrants.
 
No

You cannot collect. Taxes when none are due. 440 mil is a lot of money. It was allocated for a multitude of reasons. Both evasion and avoidance need to be reduced.

You need the same briefing note that Trudeau does. Tax avoidance doesn't need to be reduced. Tax avoidance represents tax reduction that is allowed pursuant to current tax law. I think what you mean to say is that taxation should be increased. Of course, that doesn't sound so good, as you and Trudeau both know. Instead, 1984 style, Trudeau wants to blame people for not following laws that don't even exist yet by referring to "tax avoidance" as if there was something remotely wrong with it.

To my point, if the 440 million is for a variety of purposes, how about the press asking for a breakdown of what the money is for? Or are the liberal left press too preoccupied with someone's hair and wife to notice that what he says doesn't make any sense?
 
You need the same briefing note that Trudeau does. Tax avoidance doesn't need to be reduced. Tax avoidance represents tax reduction that is allowed pursuant to current tax law. I think what you mean to say is that taxation should be increased. Of course, that doesn't sound so good, as you and Trudeau both know. Instead, 1984 style, Trudeau wants to blame people for not following laws that don't even exist yet by referring to "tax avoidance" as if there was something remotely wrong with it.

To my point, if the 440 million is for a variety of purposes, how about the press asking for a breakdown of what the money is for? Or are the liberal left press too preoccupied with someone's hair and wife to notice that what he says doesn't make any sense?

Sure tax avoidance needs to be reduced. One of the things the budget did was to disallow the incorporation of doctors and other professional under partnerships to defer and avoid taxes. The was allowed in the past but has now been disallowed. For Ontario alone this will probably result in 2-3 billion in federal and provincial taxes. Reduction of avoidance means closing loopholes so that tax policy can operate as intended. Favorable small business tax rates are to incentivize entrepreneurship. Doctors and lawyers do not really meet that description.
 
Eliminate the corporate tax altogether. Corporations don't pay taxes, people pay taxes.

I wouldn't be against this, I just don't think it's feasible. To compensate, you'd have to drastically hike personal income taxes or slash spending, and there simply isn't the political will to accomplish either of those. Plus, in the current climate of greed, those corporate savings would go directly to the top earners without filtering to employees...something that we already have a problem with. We need a way to make Canada competitive without exacerbating wealth inequality.
 
Sure tax avoidance needs to be reduced. One of the things the budget did was to disallow the incorporation of doctors and other professional under partnerships to defer and avoid taxes. The was allowed in the past but has now been disallowed. For Ontario alone this will probably result in 2-3 billion in federal and provincial taxes. Reduction of avoidance means closing loopholes so that tax policy can operate as intended. Favorable small business tax rates are to incentivize entrepreneurship. Doctors and lawyers do not really meet that description.

You're a persistent one when it comes to using terminology incorrectly.

Just out of curiosity, why do you think medical and legal practices are not businesses? Don't you think they provide employment, purchase assets for their operations, or contract for the supplies and services of other businesses? Isn't that entrepreneurial to you?

Don't you think that the Trudeau government policy really simply boils down to they want higher income persons, whether professionals or not, to pay more in taxes, and has nothing to do with "distorting tax policy" or "abusing the rules"?
 
You're a persistent one when it comes to using terminology incorrectly.

Just out of curiosity, why do you think medical and legal practices are not businesses? Don't you think they provide employment, purchase assets for their operations, or contract for the supplies and services of other businesses? Isn't that entrepreneurial to you?

Don't you think that the Trudeau government policy really simply boils down to they want higher income persons, whether professionals or not, to pay more in taxes, and has nothing to do with "distorting tax policy" or "abusing the rules"?

Some are and some are not. Doctors are paid by the govt on a price for service contract and they are unionized. So no they are not a business in a traditional sense. Some lawyers are some are not. Partners that work within an established partnership are NOT in themselves companies, The firm is a company, but monies paid to individual partners are PERSONAL INCOME. And setting ones self up as private corp within a corp is IMHO not representative of the relationship and done purely for TAX AVOIDANCE purposes. This is the sort of thing that has been prohibited.
 
Some are and some are not. Doctors are paid by the govt on a price for service contract and they are unionized. So no they are not a business in a traditional sense. Some lawyers are some are not. Partners that work within an established partnership are NOT in themselves companies, The firm is a company, but monies paid to individual partners are PERSONAL INCOME. And setting ones self up as private corp within a corp is IMHO not representative of the relationship and done purely for TAX AVOIDANCE purposes. This is the sort of thing that has been prohibited.

Not to be disrespectful, but I think you need to learn a bit more about business organization structures and the way they are taxed before we could continue this discussion. You should have a solid understanding of this before you form an opinion about the effect or wisdom of the Liberal tax reform agenda.