Trans Canada Highway Closed Indefinitely

Wait just a minute. This picture really scares me. ... and there is easy access to the bridge's pylons. Hell, they even built a road right up to them!

If I were an evil genius, I would park a couple of U-hauls full of fertilizer and diesel fuel right by those pylons and make 'em go "boom" real good......

But you gotta presume that there's some disgruntled engineering grad student here in Canada on a student visa who has discovered Religion as a way of coping.



A tractor trailer of fertilizer wouldn't budge those pylons.

There are hundreds of critical points in our infrastructure that are far softer and more critical to our functioning as a country. Are we going to paralyze our society by trying to chase ghosts and what-if scenarios?
 
I can assume then that the majority of Canada's east-west land traffic is detoured through the states because it's faster, safer and cheaper?
 
They waived me right through. Remarkable since I dont exactly look like a choir boy

Not like border patrol is racist or anything
I have crossed hundreds of times

ONCE I was stopped, and I had an asian female in the car with me
Went inside to secondary interview and I was the only white person in there
(most were muslim but apparently the girls name was really similar to someone they were looking for, once they fingerprinted her I was allowed to pass)
 
The only reason I can surmise for the bridge span lifting up like that is the steel cables contracted in the cold more quickly than the concrete contracted and that pulled up the span and cracked the expansion joint, steel expands a bit quicker than concrete and contracts a bit quicker too, the temperature dropped 20 degrees in 24 hours, plus there was wind.

Can they not adjust the tension in the steel cables?

There's 3 cable stayed bridges in the Greater Vancouver area, two of them are huge, but Vancouver's climate is different.

The CN Tower is 2 inches taller on a hot summer day than on a cold winter day, they've proven this by using lasers to accurately measure the tower's height
 
Not like border patrol is racist or anything
I have crossed hundreds of times

ONCE I was stopped, and I had an asian female in the car with me
Went inside to secondary interview and I was the only white person in there
welcome to our world.
 
Now this is a Bridge for a country to be proud of! This structure makes the Nipigon bridge look like a bad joke. Note it's also a Cable Stayed design in the center part:

Amazing%20Bridge%20Structure_zpsaxmi27di.jpg
 
France I think
 
Is that bridge open yet?
 
Now this is a Bridge for a country to be proud of! This structure makes the Nipigon bridge look like a bad joke. Note it's also a Cable Stayed design in the center part:

Amazing%20Bridge%20Structure_zpsaxmi27di.jpg

That's a massive bridge! Holly cow I don't think I could drive on that bridge.So high.
 
Now this is a Bridge for a country to be proud of! This structure makes the Nipigon bridge look like a bad joke. Note it's also a Cable Stayed design in the center part:

Amazing%20Bridge%20Structure_zpsaxmi27di.jpg
That is the Millau bridge in southern France.
The tallest of the pillars is 1222 feet.
It is 1.6 miles long.
The road surface is 891 feet above the Tarn river valley.
It rises and falls up to 10 feet depending on temperature and weather conditions.
It cost $523 million to build.
In Canada we would spend that must researching it's feasibility before realizing we couldn't afford it.
It takes hours off the time it used to take to cross the valley for trucks.
 
That is the Millau bridge in southern France.
The tallest of the pillars is 1222 feet.
It is 1.6 miles long.
The road surface is 891 feet above the Tarn river valley.
It rises and falls up to 10 feet depending on temperature and weather conditions.
It cost $523 million to build.
In Canada we would spend that must researching it's feasibility before realizing we couldn't afford it.
It takes hours off the time it used to take to cross the valley for trucks.

Well, we did manage to build some impressive bridges in Canada as well. The most exciting news came out just a year ago or so. The extension of the Dempster all the way to Tuk. That will be my next road trip. Lake Ontario to the Arctic Ocean.
 
They need to build a bridge connecting Vancouver to Victoria island
 
They need to build a bridge connecting Vancouver to Victoria island
How about a bridge connecting Toronto to the Toronto Islands? Canada seems to be a ferry (fairy?) country instead of a bridge country. Must be the works of the powerful ferry lobby. Oh, and we hate building pipelines too (better to import oil from Iraq than Alberta). End of rant (for now).
 
That's a massive bridge! Holly cow I don't think I could drive on that bridge.So high.

I for sure couldn't drive on that bridge . Too high for me . LOL I get nervous on windy days crossing the bridge over the canal in Hamilton and the one in St Catharines . The bridge in Hamilton is worse because of the westerly winds .

There is a bridge ( Mackinac Bridge ) in Upper Michigan that is very long and high . You can stop before the bridge and call on a provided phone to have a driver come and drive you and your vehicle ( trucks and cars ) across the bridge . They even provide a ride for pedestrians , people on bicycles and snowmobilers .
 
So how do you repair the Nipigon Bridge? They apparently have some sort of tie down system in place, the Jersey barriers to weigh down the bridge have been removed and I assume when the weather gets warmer the steel cables will expand back and the bridge will settle back into place. Can someone with some engineering background explain how you would fix the bridge? Can those steel cables be adjusted in strength? Do they have adjustments? cause I assume the steel cables contracted in the cold and lifted up the bridge
 
now consider the st catherines bridge

close that and all usa bound trucks and back through buffalo and Niagara are fucked

also

all bridges to the usa and back to Canada check trucks after they cross

WTF! the bridge is a terrorist target

If you are referring to the Garden City Skyway there are a few ways around that bridge. The one in Nipigon, there is no way around it.
 
So how do you repair the Nipigon Bridge? They apparently have some sort of tie down system in place, the Jersey barriers to weigh down the bridge have been removed and I assume when the weather gets warmer the steel cables will expand back and the bridge will settle back into place. Can someone with some engineering background explain how you would fix the bridge? Can those steel cables be adjusted in strength? Do they have adjustments? cause I assume the steel cables contracted in the cold and lifted up the bridge

I crossed that bridge on Feb 15 and the barriers that were holding the bridge down were still there. They are working on it so it should be repaired soon. Will be heading back out west this week coming so I will get so see if it is fully open yet or still just the one lane.
 
A tractor trailer of fertilizer wouldn't budge those pylons.

If I had the time, the inclination, a slide-rule, and a cocktail napkin I could reply intelligently. I honestly don't know which one of us is correct, but please don't underestimate the energy released by a fuel-fertilizer bomb. I did the math once, for fun, and it wasn't as fun as I thought it would be. It was pretty scary, actually.

As it is I will take you at your word and assume that you're right. Instead I will turn my attention to where the cables attach to the deck. Or examine the decking itself in more detail. Or look at the lead-ups to the bridge, to see if there are any other choke-points there. This is a fun game, and I want to keep playing.

Seriously...I honestly don't know. But again, were I a really smart but disgruntled engineering graduate student who has come to Canada from Bu-fu-istan and who is not coping well with the transition to the mores of Western society (see: Esseghaier, Chiheb) then I would be looking at that bridge with intense interest.

Stepping back, I totally agree that there are unquestionably many soft spots in our critical infrastructure. If we were in a bar and not on the record, I could tell you a few ways to cripple our infrastructure that would be easier than attacking this particular bridge. But you don't know me and I don't know you, and for all you know I could be talking shit. Feeling lucky?

Aside: I didn't vote for the Dauphin, despite how lovely his hair appears to be. My job is to take care of people, either or before or after bad things happen. Were I a feather-bedding civil servant I would actually bill for the time it took me to write this. And to address your last point...It's a leading question but the answer is obviously "no". I have no interest in upsetting the masses with "what if's" and "maybe's". Keep the populace happy, do what you need to do as private citizen to make sure you ride out any unforseen circumstances. Thank me later.


There are hundreds of critical points in our infrastructure that are far softer and more critical to our functioning as a country. Are we going to paralyze our society by trying to chase ghosts and what-if scenarios?