Traffic ticket question - lawyers please help!!

Just a BTW of general rather than specific relevance:
Decision in R. vs. Dehaney said:
In fairness to the prosecution, it is not due to any action, or lack thereof, that this matter has taken more than ten months to come to trial. The delay is strictly systemic as a result of limited judicial resources provided to the City of Mississauga[emphasis added]

I trust we'll all remember that the next time we hear someone tell us that tougher penalties will solve a 'crime' problem. Not unless we pay for more judges and courts it won't.
 
Just a BTW of general rather than specific relevance:

I trust we'll all remember that the next time we hear someone tell us that tougher penalties will solve a 'crime' problem. Not unless we pay for more judges and courts it won't.

And that those who advise using all sorts of legal loopholes to get out of deserved tickets will not complain when the taxes go up to cover the costs of more judicial employees....
 
Not to touch off another topic, but so-called technicalities and loopholes usually are there for good, sensible and even laudable purposes—like to protect the rights of citizens against the arbitrary use of state power. It's well and good that laws are enforced. But insisting that they be properly and expertly enforced—in all details—is a citizen's only power.

Unfortunately it's often the most vocal 'law and order' types who scream the loudest when the tax bills for their favourite repressive progams are presented. Never mind that they'd rather see lynch mob justice from cops on the courtroom steps, than real justice done in the courts according to law.

But sometimes laws just get badly drafted, and I digress.
 
Be aware that the time limits are just guidelines and one of the things the judge takes into account is the backlog of a particular jurisdiction. Some are significantly worse than others. I think Brampton is particularly bad.

But seriously, you're going to try and argue a Charter violation on your own? Good luck with that.

Wait a minute... just reading through this thread... and the OP parked in a handicapped space? Fuck her. Pay the fine you guilty bastard. First she doesn't mention that aspect at all because she knows people won't help her, then when it finally comes out (by someone else, no less) she creates all sorts of weasel-faced excuses why she shouldn't have to pay. Why does it matter that it was "only 5 minutes" if it was an improperly marked handicapped space?

Fuck her. She's just another one of the millions of peons out there who does something wrong and then tries to weasel out of it.

Pay the $450 and be grateful you didn't lose points.

And yes, it's blatantly evident that you don't care what people think of you because otherwise you wouldn't have parked in a fucking handicapped space! User. Karma's a bitch and you'll soon find that out. Can't wait when the judge finds out you're making technical Charter arguments because you took a disabled person's space. Brilliant!
 
Mostly likely the prosector will have hearsey evidence. Example, they claim you broke a by-law (parking in a handicap zone), but that by-law was written by city of toronto. So the prosecutor must give you certified copies, when you request your disclosure.

Under the evidence act of ontario, section 29, can be requested for by-laws, regulations, or proceeding, document. 11(b) is too much hassle these days...
Here is the link to the evidence act ontario :
http://www.e-laws.gov.on.ca/html/statutes/english/elaws_statutes_90e23_e.htm#BK35

Also, if you get a copy of the officers notes, immediately tell the JP that you can't read them and you like them typed out...
Can not the Crown ask for costs if you are convicted? You don't think the Court doesn't know what you are doing?
 
Can not the Crown ask for costs if you are convicted? You don't think the Court doesn't know what you are doing?

It's not a matter of the Courts knowing what we are doing. We are defending ourselves, and in order to answer the charge properly, you need a disclosure. The prosecution needs prima facie (evidnece on the face).

Yeah they can ask for court costs if your convicted, but who in their right mind would get convicted for a simple parking tickets? It's a numbers game for them, they have a script to follow : plead down every client, and tell my boss so that I look good. If it's outside the script, they won't follow.
 
Last edited:
It's not a matter of the Courts knowing what we are doing. We are defending ourselves, and in order to answer the charge properly, you need a disclosure.
The rules of the game may be entirely different in Ontario from what I'm used to. I was primarily reacting to your comment.
Also, if you get a copy of the officers notes, immediately tell the JP that you can't read them and you like them typed out...
Where I practice you wouldn't get away with that nonsense on a parking ticket or traffic infraction, unless it truly was illegible. Further even in that case, the Judge would very likely say that you had to pay the copying costs of the police agency (which are never the actual cost more like $5 for the first page and 25 cents for each additional page).
 
The rules of the game may be entirely different in Ontario from what I'm used to. I was primarily reacting to your comment.Where I practice you wouldn't get away with that nonsense on a parking ticket or traffic infraction, unless it truly was illegible. Further even in that case, the Judge would very likely say that you had to pay the copying costs of the police agency (which are never the actual cost more like $5 for the first page and 25 cents for each additional page).

I've seen it happen with my own eyes. It may not get it thrown out, but it does force an adjournment, and delay the proceedings. Okay, even it's $5 for the first page, and 25 cents for each additional page, those costs are recovered after you lose. and u wont lose if your smart. they simply do not have the time and day for it.
 
Last edited:
then what does it say?

In a nutshell, that when entering a public document into evidence, it is sufficient to provide a certified copy, and that if the document appears to have been certified by the appropriate person, that's good enough to prove it is in fact a certified copy of the original.
 
I WON!!! They ajourned it on the first court date because the justice did not have the form 4f EVEN THOUGH I served it! So I served it the 2nd time, and today went tot he court and they dismissed it! HAHA $500 fine gone!! YAYAYAY!
 
Fully explained in the thread yahoo. If you don't read it you'll miss useful details.
 
I WON!!! They ajourned it on the first court date because the justice did not have the form 4f EVEN THOUGH I served it! So I served it the 2nd time, and today went tot he court and they dismissed it! HAHA $500 fine gone!! YAYAYAY!
Congratulations, however, when you explained the facts more throughly it appeared that you had a sound case on the merits as well.