Traffic ticket question - lawyers please help!!

diane-35

New member
Aug 20, 2009
82
0
0
I received Notice of Trial for a ticket issued in October 2008. the trial date is Jan, 2010. This is more than a year. According this link http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traffic_ticket#Canada
I can file Charter Rights Violation if the ticket is more than a year old. How do I do that? Should I do that?? The ticket is of amount $450, but no point deduction.
 
First take a deep breath and relax, because there's no way you will be paying the full amount regardless. The charter violation option is available but because your trial is less than a month away you wont have the time to send the letters out and give them enough notice that you are pursuing that option.

There are a few options available to you.

First option is to plead gulity to a reduced charge. Talk to the prosecutor outside the court room 15 mins before and ask if you can plead gulity to a lesser charge. He/she might drop it down to $200-$250 if you plead gulity and avoid a trial. If they will not do that than,

Use a delay method. When it is your turn to speak infront of the justice, tell him/her that you just spoke to a lawyer in the hallway and found out that you are legally allowed to request disclosure and did not know what that meant until 10 minutes ago. The justice will tell you how you can request disclosure (if the cop is there, he will tell him/her to go downstairs and photocopy his/her notes and give them to you. Disclosure allows you to see the evidence against you, so you can mount a defense to your charge. The justice will consult with both you and the police officer and figure out a date when you can come back for your trial. I've done this 2 times, and both times the officer didn't show up to the 2nd court date because I was his only scheduled trial for that day. Seems a waste of resources to show up for a 20 minute trial. They will show up to your first court date though, because they'll have 20 other trial notices.

If you get this far, then its time to mount your defense. There are many ways to beat traffic tickets, but I would have no way of knowing what you are trying to fight! Time is on your side, because there is no humanly way possible the officer will remember giving you that ticket since it happened 2 years ago. It is easy at that point to discredit the officer as a witness, if you do some proper planning. PM me for more info if you need it
 
It's for illegal parking. only parked for 5 minutes for emergency and my blinker was on. But this is not the point right? The important point I want to argue is unreasonable amount of time I had to wait for the trial. I did nothing to cause this delay. Therefore it violated my charter rights.
 
if its a parking ticket, they will reduce it automatically by half or more, i've seen handicap parking tickets reduced to $100 just for pleading guilty. If you come prepared to fight, the prosecutor will not want to risk you beating him/her, and messing up their conviction rates. They will offer you a break if you plead guilty...

Your other option is to fight it
 
Okay so I should ask prosecutor to reduce to $100 or I will use Charter Rights Violation as defence to fight it? wont they get offended pissed? like it's some kind of thread? what's the best way I should negotiate with prosecutor?
 
with a traffic ticket its different, there is no disclosure

Send out all the notices that you intend to use a charter rights violation defence and show up prepared to use that...the judge might not allow you to use it though, so be prepared to fight it using another defence....you can talk to the prosecutor before, but he/she may not tell you how much they will recommend the fine gets lowered to before you agree to plead gulity
 
File an 11b application, at trial motion for a stay of proceedings. go to www.ticketcombat.com for more information.

You should request a disclosure, if they don't give one, file a Section 7 charter application and motion for stay.
 
you can get disclosure for parking tickets..
But what of value are you going to get from the disclosure and will the Judge "see right through it"?

'1410 while on parking duty in 1300 block of Bloor Street I observed a white Honda Civic Ontario Registration XYZ 1234 parked in handicapped zone, said vehicle had neither either handicapped plates or a handicapped placard on the drivers side dashboard nor hanging from the rearview mirror. I issued a citation for parking in a handicapped zone without handicapped permit to Ontario Registration XYZ 1234. Requested Dispatch to run registration came back active status registered to XYZ no handicapped permissions. Vehicle had it's hazard lights on.'

Your Honor/My Lord, clearly I should have a month and a half to prepare my case based upon not having had the Constables's notes. I don't know is that true in the GTA for parking tickets. . . . :rolleyes:
 
The Constable isn't allowed to look at their notes to refresh their memory??

That's what I was thinking too.

As well, I think it's risky to tell the judge you "just found out you're entitled to disclosure". A lot of judges would say "too bad, you're responsible for knowing how to fight your ticket or should have hired a lawyer to do it for you".

However, I think you could get off due to the amount of time that's passed since the charge.
 
How about plead guilty, pay the ticket, and never be so selfish again to take the spot of a handicapped person who may have needed the space.
N.B. This smart ass comment only applies if it was indeed a parking in handicapped space violation. If not, see all the advice above.
 
I know about the 11b procedure of the Charter if the delay is at least 8 months long and only know a little about the disclosure aspect.

What does Section 7 protect us would-be defendants from?

well in r vs. askov the courts have outlined between 8 to 10 months. The courts rule 18 months, but this is not set in stone.

Section 7 gives us the right to remain silent, etc, and disclosure and discovery in criminal cases. the full reading of the digest is here : http://www.canlii.org/en/ca/charter_digest/s-7.html
 
I received Notice of Trial for a ticket issued in October 2008. the trial date is Jan, 2010. This is more than a year. According this link http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traffic_ticket#Canada
I can file Charter Rights Violation if the ticket is more than a year old. How do I do that? Should I do that?? The ticket is of amount $450, but no point deduction.

There is a lot of partially correct information in this thread.

If you intend to make an argument under 11(b), file your notice. However, keep in mind that, despite what some people think, there is no "magic number" for delay. After 8 months you can't simply say "I have been denied my right to a trial within a reasonable time" and expect to get off the hook. In considering an 11(b) application, the JP will be considering a number of factors.

Someone mentioned the Askov decision, and this was the first major decision with respect to delay. It suggested that anything more than a 6-8 month delay was unreasonable. It was also grossly misinterpreted by the courts, resulting in 47,000 charges being stayed or withdrawn in Ontario alone in the 11 months following the decision. This led the Supreme Court to revisit the issue in R. v. Morin.

In Morin, they suggested that, in general, a delay of 8-10 months was reasonable. However, they also outlined the factors that a justice should consider when presented with an 11(b) application, and in that particular case found that the delay of more than 14 months was reasonable. So, in considering your application, the JP will be considering:

1. the length of the delay;
2. waiver of time periods;
3. the reasons for the delay, including
(a) inherent time requirements of the case,
(b) actions of the accused,
(c) actions of the Crown,
(d) limits on institutional resources, and
(e) other reasons for delay; and
4. prejudice to the accused.

In the case of a parking infraction, the most important factors will be 1, 3a), 3d) and 4. The delay in your case is about 15 months -- certainly lengthy. The inherent time requirements for a parking infraction are minimal, so that will work to your favour. However, the limits on institutional resources are high, and the prejudice to you is minimal. This will work against you. One question though is what municipality was this in? That will have an impact on the limits to institutional resources that are tolerated.

Now, what will happen if you pursue your application for redress pursuant to 11(b)? One of two things. The prosecutor may decide it's not worth their trouble and withdraw. If this were a small ticket I would expect this to happen. However, given the size of the ticket I wouldn't be surprised if they choose to proceed, in which case you will have to argue your 11(b) application, and they will oppose it. Keep in mind they do this regularly, and are able to pretty much work from a script as the issues are so common.

So, the question is, should you proceed with an 11(b) application or just pay the ticket? Well, there are really two ways of answering that. Did you park illegally? If so, maybe you should take responsibility for your actions and pay the fine. However, if you want to fight, you may want to talk to a lawyer or agent who handles POA offences, and they will be able to give you some kind of idea as far as the extent of delay tolerated in your jurisdiction. The other option, if you have the time, would be to go in to court in the next little while and see how cases are being handled. You'll see how old the cases being proceeded with are, and how responsive the justice is to an 11(b) argument if one is made.
 
I'm curious as to what parking infraction will garner a $450.00 ticket. The most I've ever heard of is around $150.00. Maybe parking in a handicapped spot in a fire zone in front of a fire station while blocking a fire hydrant?

That's a hellofa ticket.