Traffic 8, Al Qaeda 0

Now I know you're not having a good day. Government policy is seldom done on the basis of common sense. Easy popular and CYA comes first. Common sense is way down the list.

Plainly it has not been done on the basis of common sense! Seems like you are on the verge of agreeing with me that the money would be better spent elsewhere.
 
Nope, no way, nadda, niet, nien.

So then you really haven't answered this point:

"Similarly at the highest policy levels in government it makes sense to devote funding to those programs which are likely to save the most lives."

All you have done so far is agreed that the government isn't allocating funds in a common sense way.
 
So then you really haven't answered this point:

"Similarly at the highest policy levels in government it makes sense to devote funding to those programs which are likely to save the most lives."

All you have done so far is agreed that the government isn't allocating funds in a common sense way.

You're first point is wrong you asked if I was approaching agreement, I'm not.

Your second point is a blanket statement not applicable here when you've been arguing military allocation specifically. similarily yopur third point is also wrong.

You're just going around and around and it's turning into a really nice day outside. I think I'm done.
 
You're first point is wrong you asked if I was approaching agreement, I'm not.

Your second point is a blanket statement not applicable here when you've been arguing military allocation specifically. similarily yopur third point is also wrong.

You're just going around and around and it's turning into a really nice day outside. I think I'm done.

You haven't said anything here.

I conclude that you cannot think of any way to refute my point, but you don't like my point. So you are calling it wrong, but without supplying any reasons why it would be wrong.
 
What difference, exactly?

I've got another thread where I have Al Qaeda up against psycho mass murderers. They're leading on that one too, so if it's malice and intent you want perhaps you should reply on that thread. Either way Al Qaeda is irrelevant.

Why would I reply in another thread when this one is the stupid one that I take issue with?
 
When do we get the heart disease vs. al Qaeda and cancer vs. al Qaeda threads? :p

jwm

How about the God's Wrath vs. al Qaeda thread. Let's see those chumps match that.
 
I''m waiting for a "Godzilla vs Mothra" thread.


Anbarandy(The Dishonest Debater & Liar)
 
At any rate, either way Al Qaeda is irrelevant.

The closest I could come to agreeing with you would be to say that AQ is likely not the many-headed monster of a super-villain the media likes to portray. Unfortunately, the many heads are all "little" terror groups with the same goal and methods as Osama's boys (unless you think all these reports like the underwear bomber are actually CIA/mossad plants and not actually individuals motivated to perform acts of terror).
 
The closest I could come to agreeing with you would be to say that AQ is likely not the many-headed monster of a super-villain the media likes to portray. Unfortunately, the many heads are all "little" terror groups with the same goal and methods as Osama's boys (unless you think all these reports like the underwear bomber are actually CIA/mossad plants and not actually individuals motivated to perform acts of terror).

I agree, and these little groups will have the ability to attack soft targets, and kill small numbers of people here and there. Just like these traffic accidents are killing people.

No-one is saying we should do nothing. What I am saying, though, that we should do less.

If we diverted some of the money spent fighting Al Qaeda to fighting traffics we would save more lives than we save today.

What exactly is the argument against saving more lives anyway???
 
I agree, and these little groups will have the ability to attack soft targets, and kill small numbers of people here and there. Just like these traffic accidents are killing people.

No-one is saying we should do nothing. What I am saying, though, that we should do less.

If we diverted some of the money spent fighting Al Qaeda to fighting traffics we would save more lives than we save today.

What exactly is the argument against saving more lives anyway???

So fuji, you like numbers and you say we should spend less how much less, 10%, 30% 75%? If you can't come up with a dollar value or a percentage, then your arguments are empty because you have to know how much is enough to know what's too much. So please give us a benchmark to work from.
 
So fuji, you like numbers and you say we should spend less how much less, 10%, 30% 75%? If you can't come up with a dollar value or a percentage, then your arguments are empty because you have to know how much is enough to know what's too much. So please give us a benchmark to work from.

I'll take a stab at it, but I want to say that I think if my idea were implemented the numbers should be reworked by someone with more data, and more time than I have.

Al Qaeda killed 3000 people (rounding up) in 2001. Let's assume that intervention since then prevented another 9/11 event in each subsequent year. So we are talking about a problem that causes 3000 deaths per year, potentially.

In the same year traffic accidents killed 42116 people, let's round down to 42000.

So Al Qaeda killed 7% as many people in 2001 as traffic did, it follows that we should spend not more than 7% of the traffic enforcement budget fighting Al Qaeda.
 
I'll take a stab at it, but I want to say that I think if my idea were implemented the numbers should be reworked by someone with more data, and more time than I have.

Al Qaeda killed 3000 people (rounding up) in 2001. Let's assume that intervention since then prevented another 9/11 event in each subsequent year. So we are talking about a problem that causes 3000 deaths per year, potentially.

In the same year traffic accidents killed 42116 people, let's round down to 42000.

So Al Qaeda killed 7% as many people in 2001 as traffic did, it follows that we should spend not more than 7% of the traffic enforcement budget fighting Al Qaeda.


.... and what was the budget spent by the feds on Traffic safety?
 
.... and what was the budget spent by the feds on Traffic safety?

According to the Congressional Budget Office, about 0.5% of GDP is spent on transportation and about 0.28% of GDP is spent on administration of justice. Together that means 0.728% of GDP is spent on transport and justice collectively. Traffic enforcement is only a small part of that, but let's say it was all of that. That means much less than 1/20th of 1% of GDP should be spent fighting terrorism.

USD GDP is about 14 trillion, so that works out to not more than 7.6 billion per year.

Since 2001 the US government has spent roughly 100 billion per year on the war on terror (specifically 944 billion in 9 years).

So we are talking about an overspend of over $90 billion per year relative to the magnitude of the actual threat.

Those are dollars collected from taxpayers, by the way, not magical imaginary money. Actual taxpayer's dollars, taken from the wallets of actual taxpayers.
 
.... and what was the budget spent by the feds on Traffic safety?

Too slow;

Total budget for NHTSA, the agency responsible for National Highway Safety was $815 million (2007). The cost of putting one infantry soldier in the field for a year (2008) is $500,000. Do the math. By your guidelines we could only allocate 1650 soldiers to the fight with AQ, if we spent the equivalent money on the war. Dream on. You love figures, but get blinded sometimes. (sorry phone rang)
 
Too slow;

Total budget for NHTSA, the agency responsible for National Highway Safety was $815 million (2007). The cost of putting one infantry soldier in the field for a year (2008) is $500,000. Do the math. By your guidelines we could only allocate 1650 soldiers to the fight with AQ, if we spent the equivalent money on the war. Dream on. You love figures, but get blinded sometimes. (sorry phone rang)

Sounds about right. Your numbers and mine are different, but do lead to the same conclusion: We should not have spent the mony on Iraq and Afghanistan: There is no way, numerically, that it could have paid off.

My view is that the Afghan was was morally justified, but financially? Pragmatically? It did not make sense. Iraq--an even bigger blunder.
 
]2. Fuji does not differentiate between accidental killing and intentional killing

Would you like to compare Al Qaeda to the national murder rate instead?

3. Fuji does not beleive AQ is a national security threat

It's not a belief. It's a conclusion I arrived at by analyzing the data. You, on the other hand, appear to have nothing to justify your belief that they are.
 
Sounds about right. Your numbers and mine are different, but do lead to the same conclusion: We should not have spent the mony on Iraq and Afghanistan: There is no way, numerically, that it could have paid off.

My view is that the Afghan was was morally justified, but financially? Pragmatically? It did not make sense. Iraq--an even bigger blunder.

Although I used larger numbers than you: I assu

Thank god bean counters don't lead men into battle.

I like a lot of what you say sometime Fuji, but not this time.