Traffic 8, Al Qaeda 0

May I be the first to suggest a war on traffic. The US could send 120 000 troops into the streets of Toronto to shoot any and all motorists on site.

Cheers!
 
May I be the first to suggest a war on traffic. The US could send 120 000 troops into the streets of Toronto to shoot any and all motorists on site.

Cheers!

Serious answer, we probably would save more American lives if those 120000 soldiers were put to work directing traffic in dangerous intersections around the United States.

If you want to take it to the level of shooting drivers on sight--maybe if they shot drunk drivers on sight, but I do much prefer due process of law.
 
Unfortunately for your agenda here, trafic accidents are through negligence or stupidity. Terror attacks are out of malice and intent. Bit of a difference there.
 
Serious answer, we probably would save more American lives if those 120000 soldiers were put to work directing traffic in dangerous intersections around the United States.

If you want to take it to the level of shooting drivers on sight--maybe if they shot drunk drivers on sight, but I do much prefer due process of law.

I'm actually ok with that.... but they could shoot ppl who text message while driving on site too. They are far more dangerous than drunk drivers..... and I would hazard a guess more of them.

Cheers!
 
Unfortunately for your agenda here, trafic accidents are through negligence or stupidity. Terror attacks are out of malice and intent. Bit of a difference there.

What difference, exactly?

I've got another thread where I have Al Qaeda up against psycho mass murderers. They're leading on that one too, so if it's malice and intent you want perhaps you should reply on that thread. Either way Al Qaeda is irrelevant.
 
When do we get the heart disease vs. al Qaeda and cancer vs. al Qaeda threads? :p

jwm
 
So what do we do Fuji, back off and leave AQ alone, doing your math in our heads. Then someday down the road and dirty bomb goes off or a a biological attack on a water system is perpetrated somewhere in the free world, a tanker is rammed in too a bridge pier in San Francisco, followed closely by the sound of a collective Ooops!
 
Would Al Qaeda's & the Taleban's unique definition of deaths caused by motor vehicle accidents count as tallies in this game? Specifically the hundreds of motor vehicle accidents attributed to driver error by their suicide car bombers that have accidentally killed hundreds if not thousands of men, women, and children including Canadians?

Since we are discussing traffic accidents, let's not forget road conditions and their effect on motor vehicle deaths. Specifically Al Qaeda's & the Taleban's unique take on improving road conditions by their road and traffic engineering graduates with their roadside bombs and IEDs. Would the hundreds if not thousand of men, women and children including Canadians accidentally killed by these unique road and traffic improvement projects count as tallies in this game?

Sometimes sarcasm-laced reality is the only antidote for sheer, and utter stupidity.


sincerely yours,

Anbarandy(aka The Dishonest Debater & Liar)
 
Last edited:
So what do we do Fuji, back off and leave AQ alone, doing your math in our heads. Then someday down the road and dirty bomb goes off or a a biological attack on a water system is perpetrated somewhere in the free world, a tanker is rammed in too a bridge pier in San Francisco, followed closely by the sound of a collective Ooops!

No doubt AQ will try all sorts of things, and succeed now and then. The point being even when they do it won't be significant compared to traffic.

Do we back off? No.

Do we allocate money to threats based on the number of casualties the threat is expected to generate? Yes

We are currently spending a hell of a lot more money on Al Qaeda than their capability to hurt us justifies, compared to other things that kill people.
 
No doubt AQ will try all sorts of things, and succeed now and then. The point being even when they do it won't be significant compared to traffic.

Do we back off? No.

Do we allocate money to threats based on the number of casualties the threat is expected to generate? Yes

We are currently spending a hell of a lot more money on Al Qaeda than their capability to hurt us justifies, compared to other things that kill people.

So you've turned in to a bean counter of the worst kind. Until the next time it comes to your doorstep. Then you'll be in the front lines saying WTF! Why didn't you .........
 
So you've turned in to a bean counter of the worst kind. Until the next time it comes to your doorstep. Then you'll be in the front lines saying WTF! Why didn't you .........

I imagine that would be my reaction if I got seriously injured in a preventable traffic accident too.

The medical system has it right: Treatments are prescribed based on probabilities of death. It's a gruesome analysis, but it saves lives.
 
I imagine that would be my reaction if I got seriously injured in a preventable traffic accident too.

The medical system has it right: Treatments are prescribed based on probabilities of death. It's a gruesome analysis, but it saves lives.

I like to know where you got that one from. That may be true in the Emergency Ward and triage, but not in the medical profession as a whole, especially in the US.
 
How many threads are appropriate to cover this one rant ? Surely one was enough as it wasn't a particularly cogent observation to begin with.
 
I like to know where you got that one from. That may be true in the Emergency Ward and triage, but not in the medical profession as a whole, especially in the US.

Not only in the emergency ward, but at every level of care delivery doctors base their decisions on probabilities.

If you go in to your doctor presenting a lump his decisions on how to treat you will be based on probabilities of death. He will do some tests, and then estimate whether the risks of leaving the lump there are worse than the risks of surgery to remove it, or some other treatment.

Moreover at the resource allocation level hospitals in well run healthcare systems (perhaps not the US) allocate scarce resources to the person who needs them most: CAT scans are reserved for people who are suspected of having cancer, and are not ust routinely given to everyone as part of a routine checkup, for example.

Similarly at the highest policy levels in government it makes sense to devote funding to those programs which are likely to save the most lives.
 
Not only in the emergency ward, but at every level of care delivery doctors base their decisions on probabilities.

If you go in to your doctor presenting a lump his decisions on how to treat you will be based on probabilities of death. He will do some tests, and then estimate whether the risks of leaving the lump there are worse than the risks of surgery to remove it, or some other treatment.

Moreover at the resource allocation level hospitals in well run healthcare systems (perhaps not the US) allocate scarce resources to the person who needs them most: CAT scans are reserved for people who are suspected of having cancer, and are not ust routinely given to everyone as part of a routine checkup, for example.

Similarly at the highest policy levels in government it makes sense to devote funding to those programs which are likely to save the most lives.

Now I know you're not having a good day. Government policy is seldom done on the basis of common sense. Easy, popular, and CYA (or the Ministers arse) comes first. Common sense is way down the list.