Tomfoolery at City Hall

fuji

Banned
Jan 31, 2005
79,936
9
0
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
is.gd
This time, not Ford's fault. Elements of city staff appear to have deliberately misled the Mayor's office, and council generally, about the severity of the situation with the crumbling of the Gardiner and the danger posed to the public by falling concrete. Reports of imminent danger in public parking lots, playgrounds, and a Go train station, were withheld from council, despite requests for daily updates and actions plans.

When a third chunk of concrete plummeted off the Gardiner Expressway this spring, making it apparent something was seriously wrong with the elevated highway, Mayor Rob Ford’s office ordered an emergency meeting with top city staff and offered a blank cheque to get the situation under control.

Hundreds of documents obtained by the Star through freedom-of-information legislation offer a window into the panic that was unfolding at city hall during the early days of the crisis in May.

Emails show that while engineers and chipping crews were frantically working to identify and remove loose pieces deemed to be in “emergency” status, communications staff was distributing “key messages” designed to convince the public the nearly 60-year-old Gardiner Expressway was safe.

Amid recent accusations that city staff deliberately misled the public about the gravity of the situation, questions have been raised about how much the mayor’s office knew — especially after it was revealed that a member of Ford’s staff ordered a city spokesperson to craft talking points touting the highway’s safety.

Public works chair Denzil Minnan-Wong says that, based on what they were being told, he and the mayor’s office had every reason to believe the expressway was safe. Documents released to the Star support his claim.

Neither Minnan-Wong nor the mayor’s office appear to have been sent the damaging engineer memos. The documents suggest the administration was more or less told the same thing as the public: There’s no cause for alarm, the situation is under control and concrete separating from a larger mass is not unusual.

Furthermore, documents show that despite these reassurances, the mayor’s office ordered extra precautions for public safety.

On May 23, the morning after a third piece had fallen in a two-week span, Ford’s former policy director and current chief of staff, Mark Towhey, convened a meeting with staff in the mayor’s boardroom.

Minnan-Wong, who was in the room, said Thursday that staff explicitly said, “You don’t have anything to worry about … we have it under control.”

Regardless, Towhey made a series of demands.

All sidewalks, crosswalks and other “pedestrian-at-risk areas” should be inspected and made safe within four days, or be closed off. If a fourth chunk fell near one of these places before then, staff should look at closing all the areas immediately.

He questioned whether “overhead hazard” signs should be used until the review was complete and whether staff should create “temporary pedestrian crossings in safe areas.”

Towhey also requested that the entire 7-kilometre underbelly be examined within three weeks or sooner.

By the end of day, Towhey demanded a full status update, a strategy for the next 48 hours, a list of deployed resources, information on additional incidents, a contingency plan to manage traffic if the road needed to be closed, a communications strategy, and a process for police and all city staff to report back if they noticed suspicious concrete out on the road.

“There is political will to support staff’s efforts to procure the resources necessary to meet the aggressive time lines above, and to accelerate the rest of the already planned remedial work. Staff should advice the MO (mayor’s office) of any additional requirements necessary to expedite maintenance plans or if there is anything we can do to help move through obstacles,” Towhey wrote in a lengthy follow-up email.

“We would like to stretch our capabilities to get this done ASAP. If it is impossible, please let us know why today. If it is merely extremely difficult — let us know anything we can do politically to help expedite the process to achieve these timings. If you can do it faster — please do.”

Over the subsequent weeks, as city engineers reported back to staff via email that chunks of perilously loose concrete were dangling over playgrounds, parking lots and a GO station, the mayor’s office was not looped in on these communications.

In 2012, six pieces of concrete have plummeted from the embattled Gardiner Expressway. No injuries have been reported, although there has been damage to vehicles. But in addition to those six incidents, city engineers identified dozens and dozens of areas in need of “emergency” attention.

Engineers sent daily emails back to city hall warning that separated pieces might “fall any minute” and that parked cars were at risk of being hit. But it appears that the mayor’s office was only forwarded briefing notes related to chunks that actually fell, which did not paint an accurate picture of the situation.

It wasn’t until late June or early July that a high-level civil servant first told Towhey the situation was worse than believed.

Minnan-Wong said “we had no idea” how bad it was until recently

http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/cit...-in-the-dark-on-crumbling-gardiner-expressway
 
I doubt that anyone was trying to conceal anything. 'Is the Gardiner safe?' is a simple question that can only be answered with a pile of complex information. Same with 'Is the Gardiner falling down?'. Piles of data and engineering detail don't sell newspapers or advertising minute on the air. The way the story reads, the Mayor's guy moved briskly to make sure staff lived up to their summary of the reports, which said it's OK for now, but needs serious attention and work. Pretty much what we'd want him and them to do. Talking about concealed or witheld reports makes fun, but misleading headlines.

Trouble is he waited until pieces were raining down, instead of Day One of the Ford Era. Gardiner fallout is not a new thing.

There's been no lack of technical data about the current state of the Gardiner. The real question is how long we can expect it to last? Only the pols who have to approve the money can answer that one. The engineers can only tell them is, "for this much dough, you get this many years. Give or take.", and the pols actually have to think to ask the engineers for the the estimates. Then they have to put them on their agenda and discuss them. What we're discovering is that they haven't asked, and that they haven't discussed, not that anyone kept anything from them.

I'm sure one Councillor or another woulda remembered they hadn't considered the Gardiner since they demo'd the east end of it years and years ago, as soon as they stopped talking about plastic bags, magic gravy, downtown being unfit for raising kids and fantasy subways. But then, considering we've been reducing taxes, since everything's hunky-dory, who would propose a discussion about 6 year old expensive gloom and doom reports? No one in this polarized dogfight

And why would a staffer ever want question received wisdom from on high and mention the billions we need to spend on our deteriorating roads (the Gardiner being just one) when the mantra is: Cut taxes!

The info was there. The pols didn't to look for it.
 
No there was no concealing all right.

David Miller and his crew were WELL AWARE that ongoing maintenance was required, however for his term, Miller quietly diverted funds away from maintenance on the Gardiner, using it for many many of his green projects.

Miller lapsed for a number of years...and we are all paying for it now.


As for Adam Vaughans plan to sell the Gardiner and Don Valley for 8 billion, and make it a toll road in the private sector.
Why have a one time sale? Stupid idea.
Make it tolls if you like, but for gads sales...don't sell it.
 
No there was no concealing all right.

David Miller and his crew were WELL AWARE that ongoing maintenance was required, however for his term, Miller quietly diverted funds away from maintenance on the Gardiner, using it for many many of his green projects.

Miller lapsed for a number of years...and we are all paying for it now.


As for Adam Vaughans plan to sell the Gardiner and Don Valley for 8 billion, and make it a toll road in the private sector.
Why have a one time sale? Stupid idea.
Make it tolls if you like, but for gads sales...don't sell it.
Point of information: Among those who diverted those fund was a certain Councillor Rob Ford. Whether for or against that decision, he had to be aware it was premised on the Gardiner coming down east of Jarvis. If he voted for, the new Mayor should have been asking how his reduced City revenue stream would cover that. Against, he should have moved to restore the funds as soon as he was elected.

By all means blame the previous Council for what they messed up. But all sorts of them, including Rob are still in theirs seats, still messing up. More to the point, Rob's the one who made the biggest deal about how he was gonna fix things at City Hall. But he forgot about this one. And it'll take a whole lotta Magic Gravy to pay for. And a Mayor who can lead.

Oh and by the way. North York's water and sewer pipes were bought cheap by a tax-cutting Council there and they're rusting away after twenty years, while Toronto's hundred year old pipes seriously need replacing, and the Gardiner's not the only road in a mess and …, and … We got lotsa unfinished, overlooked expensive business that isn't getting cheaper for being ignored while we dream of casinos and football trophies.

But all Rob could see to do was repeal a tax.
 
How big do you think the lawsuit will be when someone's vehicle goes through, or someone is killed by falling concrete?
 
The fact of the matter is that the City of Toronto has been spending all of its cash on social programs for homeless, free day care, government housing, welfare, you name it, but at the same time they have been starving the Works department of cash needed to fix sewers, watermains, bridges, roads and yes of course - the Gardiner.

Mahovolich is exactly correct that during the reign of David Miller, almost all work of any substance was suspended on the Gardiner. The city did a couple of small repairs to the substructure around Spadina (the ramp piers) and a few of the piers underneath that that was it.

Miller made no secret that he wanted to tear down the Gardiner and as such, he made sure that almost no money was spent maintaining it.
 
Miller did add some infrastructure.......BIKE LANES.

If folks are gonna blame the Mayor of today for today's ills.......

THEN

we all better blame Miller (The Mayor) For the ills of his tenure.........

INCLUDING THE FORGOTTEN GARDINER!
 
I doubt that anyone was trying to conceal anything. 'Is the Gardiner safe?' is a simple question that can only be answered with a pile of complex information.

"There is a loose piece of concrete above a playground" seems like pretty simple, straightforward, easy to understand, and very actionable information.
 
Miller did add some infrastructure.......BIKE LANES.

If folks are gonna blame the Mayor of today for today's ills.......

THEN

we all better blame Miller (The Mayor) For the ills of his tenure.........

INCLUDING THE FORGOTTEN GARDINER!
Bike lanes are good.

And Miller floated the idea of tolls on the Gardiner, but of course all the right wingers shouted him down. As a hobbyist I'm sure that you are familiar with, and in favour of the system of "pay as you go" and being charged based on mileage.