Today's Polls

Yes, it is a shame. Government policies have failed us, and more so our children. Governments of all stripes hide behind the lie that a part time job as a telemarketer is the same as a full time job as a steelworker, in order to avoid accountability for their mistakes.
Way too simplistic. Every time government creates a well-paid job, taxpayers scream they can't afford to pay for it, and the private sector would do it cheaper anyway. And how does that private sector 'do it cheaper'? By cutting wages, or off-shoring the jobs altogether. Which gratifies the taxpayers because purchase prices come down.

Of course welfare and policing costs are then under increased pressure (and didn't you mention public housing — as if there was such stuff available!) which eventually forces taxes up. But we can't do without our SUVs and cable TV! So we buy ever more made in China goods, don't repair the sewers, bridges, and hydro, then complain to the Cable Call Centre in Bangalore about the bad signal, so they'll dispatch the lowest-bidding subcontractor to fix it, so we can get back to watching reality TV show us who to vote for.

We don't just get the pols we deserve; we get the jobs we're willing to pay for. Just like there's only one taxpayer, and there's only one consumer. There's no one to sustain all those jobs but us. It's our government, it only fails us when we let it fail. And it always costs more when we do.

TANSTAAFL
 
Way too simplistic.

No, it's as simple as that.

Every time government creates a well-paid job, taxpayers scream they can't afford to pay for it, and the private sector would do it cheaper anyway. And how does that private sector 'do it cheaper'? By cutting wages, or off-shoring the jobs altogether. Which gratifies the taxpayers because purchase prices come down.

Of course welfare and policing costs are then under increased pressure (and didn't you mention public housing — as if there was such stuff available!) which eventually forces taxes up. But we can't do without our SUVs and cable TV! So we buy ever more made in China goods, don't repair the sewers, bridges, and hydro, then complain to the Cable Call Centre in Bangalore about the bad signal, so they'll dispatch the lowest-bidding subcontractor to fix it, so we can get back to watching reality TV show us who to vote for.

We don't just get the pols we deserve; we get the jobs we're willing to pay for. Just like there's only one taxpayer, and there's only one consumer. There's no one to sustain all those jobs but us. And it costs.

TANSTAAFL

Different conversation than the one we were having, but I'll respond. Obviously, there are functions that only government can do (e.g. organize the construction of highways) in order to defeat the "free rider" phenomenon, and to achieve economies of scale only possible when a single entity controls development. There are also functions that the government should do itself in order to maintain control over it's policy making role (e.g. administer licencing programs). However, there are many, many things that government still does which the private sector could do more economically and which do not undermine either of these concerns (collect garbage, drive Zambonis, mow the grass in public parks, etc, etc, etc.)

Whether a job must be done by government, or should be done by government, public sector jobs are only sustainable if there is a tax base to pay for them. The source of that tax base is ALWAYS the private sector. Therefore, the key to a healthy economy, including an effective and affordable public service, is a healthy private sector.

Governments don't create private sector jobs. They create the conditions for running businesses in the private sector. They can affect the cost of doing business (taxes, regulatory compliance) as well as the conditions of operation (operating hours, parking regulation, etc.).

NAFTA, more than any single government policy aside from corporate tax policy, sets the conditions for business in Canada. It tells manufacturing businesses that they will face competition from Mexican manufacturers whose lower production costs they cannot match. Any sensible businessperson would seriously consider this before establishing a manufacturing plant in Canada or in deciding whether to continuing to manufacture here.

NAFTA is good for shareholders. It's good for your RRSP's and private investments. It's bad for middle class employment, and therefore bad for the tax base. And a poor tax base is bad for public services.

Build middle class jobs and you will build an entire economy that will succeed and sustain itself.
 
BudPlug said:
Yes, it is a shame. Government policies have failed us, and more so our children. Governments of all stripes hide behind the lie that a part time job as a telemarketer is the same as a full time job as a steelworker, in order to avoid accountability for their mistakes.
Different conversation than the one we were having, but I'll respond. Obviously, there are functions that only government can do (e.g. organize the construction of highways) in order to defeat the "free rider" phenomenon, and to achieve economies of scale only possible when a single entity controls development. There are also functions that the government should do itself in order to maintain control over it's policy making role (e.g. administer licencing programs). However, there are many, many things that government still does which the private sector could do more economically and which do not undermine either of these concerns (collect garbage, drive Zambonis, mow the grass in public parks, etc, etc, etc.)

Whether a job must be done by government, or should be done by government, public sector jobs are only sustainable if there is a tax base to pay for them. The source of that tax base is ALWAYS the private sector. Therefore, the key to a healthy economy, including an effective and affordable public service, is a healthy private sector.

Governments don't create private sector jobs. They create the conditions for running businesses in the private sector. They can affect the cost of doing business (taxes, regulatory compliance) as well as the conditions of operation (operating hours, parking regulation, etc.).

NAFTA, more than any single government policy aside from corporate tax policy, sets the conditions for business in Canada. It tells manufacturing businesses that they will face competition from Mexican manufacturers whose lower production costs they cannot match. Any sensible businessperson would seriously consider this before establishing a manufacturing plant in Canada or in deciding whether to continuing to manufacture here.

NAFTA is good for shareholders. It's good for your RRSP's and private investments. It's bad for middle class employment, and therefore bad for the tax base. And a poor tax base is bad for public services.

Build middle class jobs and you will build an entire economy that will succeed and sustain itself.
I'm sorry, but I cannot see how the above is any sort of reply to what I offered in response to your 'government has failed us' post. And I don't really see the 'failure' part in your reply. Unless you meant the underlying trickle-down NAFTA principle that's what's good for shareholders will be good for everyone. So it must be the government's fault we're unhappy being pissed on by people who got rich selling us cheap espresso machines.

We got the NAFTA business wanted, and it put cheap cars in our driveways, Thinsulate™ in our cheap runners and cheap TVs on our walls. That is, if we still had jobs to buy them with.

Actually, I think we agree here — sorta. We both mentioned that poor tax base, caused by poor jobs. But we won't ever get a better government doing a better job by first cutting the money it works with. And we can't expect to keep buying those cheap phones if we want good jobs making them. It all depends how wide you draw the self-sustaining circle that the money flows around, and if government says the whole circle must be here in Canada to restore middle-class jobs, then that induction cooktop you lusted for to keep up with the Middleton's will move outta reach.

And all that's without addressing the premise that somehow government, not the fabled free market, is responsible for prosperity. Besides, it's off-topic.
--------------
PS: We call it The Danforth here in Toronto because it was laid out and built by a private entrepreneur, a Yankee named Danforth. And 407 is still a private for-profit road. Besides honesty and fair-dealing, I'm not aware of any rules that determine who does what or how in Adam Smith's free and well-regulated market.
 
I'm sorry, but I cannot see how the above is any sort of reply to what I offered in response to your 'government has failed us' post. And I don't really see the 'failure' part in your reply.

True. But it's there, nonetheless.
 
Ohio will be the big one to watch out for. Ohio hasn't voted for the loser since it's support of Nixon over Kennedy in 1960
 
Ohio will be the big one to watch out for. Ohio hasn't voted for the loser since it's support of Nixon over Kennedy in 1960

Ohio doesn't matter as much as some others. Clinton doesn't need it. It's must win for Trump but not Clinton.

The interesting races are Pennsylvania, and although it's small, New Hampshire. They are the two on her path of least resistance to 270 that are the reddest.

Florida and Ohio are must wins for Trump but they are not part of Clinton's path of least resistance. There are 270 votes in states that are bluer then those two, e.g., PA and NH.

Texas is interesting for another reason in that it would be the tipping point for a Clinton landslide if she wins it.
 
Today's national polls (thus far):

General Election: Trump vs. Clinton LA Times/USC Tracking Clinton 45, Trump 45 Tie
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton vs. Johnson vs. Stein Rasmussen Reports Clinton 45, Trump 44, Johnson 4, Stein 1 Clinton +1
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton vs. Johnson vs. Stein ABC News Tracking Clinton 48, Trump 42, Johnson 5, Stein 1 Clinton +6
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton ABC News Tracking Clinton 51, Trump 44 Clinton +7
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton vs. Johnson vs. Stein IBD/TIPP Tracking Clinton 43, Trump 41, Johnson 8, Stein 2 Clinton +2

http://www.realclearpolitics.com/epolls/latest_polls/
 
Today's national polls (thus far):

General Election: Trump vs. Clinton LA Times/USC Tracking Clinton 45, Trump 45 Tie
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton vs. Johnson vs. Stein Rasmussen Reports Clinton 45, Trump 44, Johnson 4, Stein 1 Clinton +1
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton vs. Johnson vs. Stein ABC News Tracking Clinton 48, Trump 42, Johnson 5, Stein 1 Clinton +6
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton ABC News Tracking Clinton 51, Trump 44 Clinton +7
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton vs. Johnson vs. Stein IBD/TIPP Tracking Clinton 43, Trump 41, Johnson 8, Stein 2 Clinton +2

http://www.realclearpolitics.com/epolls/latest_polls/

Again, the averages are more useful then looking at just the early morning polls.
They say Clinton is up by 5.4%
http://www.realclearpolitics.com/ep...s/general_election_trump_vs_clinton-5491.html
 
Some notes about averages that should be obvious:

1. Polls that are released on different dates are premised on what information those polled had at the time. That knowledge is cumulative. Since something significant happens nearly every day of this campaign (especially at this stage of the campaign, with daily WikiLeaks, the Project Veritas tapes, more Trump accusers, daily speeches, daily endorsements/defections, the influence of previous daily polls), the averaging of polls (even averaging those published by the same polling organization) that were released on different days is SURE to provide an inaccurate picture of where voter preferences are TODAY. And, of course, what matters most is what those preferences will be on November 8 (and no other date).

2. Averaging different polls with different sampling groups, techniques and sample sizes may seem helpful, but it isn't. There is a simple way to illustrate this. If one party commissions 10 polls to be released simultaneously, and fashions its polling methods for all of these polls to favour its candidate, those 10 biased polls could only be balanced off if the other side also commissions exactly 10 polls with exactly the same (but opposite) level of polling bias (or some combination of polls and sufficient polling bias to counteract). Of course, it is impossible for a voter to know whether this balance has been struck. Accordingly, it is impossible for a voter to know whether averaging has totally removed, or merely mitigated, the bias or simple inaccuracy that accounts for outlying polls.

3. Truth, when it comes to opinion (which ultimately is what a poll is, an opinion about support for candidates) is not determined democratically. If 11 scientists say the earth is flat, and one says it is round, the minority view is not therefore wrong. Once you travel into earth orbit, and confirm the shape of the earth, that settles the matter, despite the overwhelming majority opinion. The diverse spread of the polls should tell us all that some of these polls are seriously inaccurate. However, we won't know which until election day.

In the meantime, it is interesting to look at the collection of individual polls. If the polls favouring Trump are accurate, there will be a very close election that will probably be determined solely on the basis of respective turnout. If the Clinton friendly polls are right, this will be an historic landslide. We'll know on Nov 8. Hopefully, people will recall afterward which polls turned out to be reliable and which didn't, and consider the polls published by that polling organization accordingly in the future. In the last 3 election cycles, the IBD poll has been the most accurate. Draw from that what you wish.

In the meantime, people who suggest that you look at the average of all polls are asking you to abandon logic.
 
Some notes about averages that should be obvious:

,....

In the meantime, people who suggest that you look at the average of all polls are asking you to abandon logic.

One would have to be able to think logically in the 1st place,....can't abandon something they never had.

FAST
 
Some notes about averages that should be obvious:

1. Polls that are released on different dates are premised on what information those polled had at the time. That knowledge is cumulative. Since something significant happens nearly every day of this campaign (especially at this stage of the campaign, with daily WikiLeaks, the Project Veritas tapes, more Trump accusers, daily speeches, daily endorsements/defections, the influence of previous daily polls), the averaging of polls (even averaging those published by the same polling organization) that were released on different days is SURE to provide an inaccurate picture of where voter preferences are TODAY. And, of course, what matters most is what those preferences will be on November 8 (and no other date).

2. Averaging different polls with different sampling groups, techniques and sample sizes may seem helpful, but it isn't. There is a simple way to illustrate this. If one party commissions 10 polls to be released simultaneously, and fashions its polling methods for all of these polls to favour its candidate, those 10 biased polls could only be balanced off if the other side also commissions exactly 10 polls with exactly the same (but opposite) level of polling bias (or some combination of polls and sufficient polling bias to counteract). Of course, it is impossible for a voter to know whether this balance has been struck. Accordingly, it is impossible for a voter to know whether averaging has totally removed, or merely mitigated, the bias or simple inaccuracy that accounts for outlying polls.

3. Truth, when it comes to opinion (which ultimately is what a poll is, an opinion about support for candidates) is not determined democratically. If 11 scientists say the earth is flat, and one says it is round, the minority view is not therefore wrong. Once you travel into earth orbit, and confirm the shape of the earth, that settles the matter, despite the overwhelming majority opinion. The diverse spread of the polls should tell us all that some of these polls are seriously inaccurate. However, we won't know which until election day.

This is your claim, yet the averages have held very close for a little while now, with Trump down between 4-7% over the last week or two.
http://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/2016-election-forecast/?ex_cid=rrpromo




In the meantime, it is interesting to look at the collection of individual polls. If the polls favouring Trump are accurate, there will be a very close election that will probably be determined solely on the basis of respective turnout. If the Clinton friendly polls are right, this will be an historic landslide. We'll know on Nov 8. Hopefully, people will recall afterward which polls turned out to be reliable and which didn't, and consider the polls published by that polling organization accordingly in the future. In the last 3 election cycles, the IBD poll has been the most accurate. Draw from that what you wish.

In the meantime, people who suggest that you look at the average of all polls are asking you to abandon logic.

There it is.
You continue to pick polls favouring Trump so that you can 'draw from that what you wish'.

Personally, I like looking at all the evidence, not just that which supports your confirmation bias.
 
Today's polls, thus far:

General Election: Trump vs. Clinton vs. Johnson vs. Stein ABC/Wash Post Tracking Clinton 46, Trump 45, Johnson 4, Stein 2 Clinton +1
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton ABC/Wash Post Tracking Clinton 49, Trump 47 Clinton +2
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton vs. Johnson vs. Stein IBD/TIPP Tracking Clinton 45, Trump 44, Johnson 4, Stein 2 Clinton +1
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton IBD/TIPP Tracking Clinton 45, Trump 43 Clinton +2

http://www.realclearpolitics.com/epolls/latest_polls/
 
Today's polls, thus far:

General Election: Trump vs. Clinton vs. Johnson vs. Stein ABC/Wash Post Tracking Clinton 46, Trump 45, Johnson 4, Stein 2 Clinton +1
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton ABC/Wash Post Tracking Clinton 49, Trump 47 Clinton +2
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton vs. Johnson vs. Stein IBD/TIPP Tracking Clinton 45, Trump 44, Johnson 4, Stein 2 Clinton +1
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton IBD/TIPP Tracking Clinton 45, Trump 43 Clinton +2

http://www.realclearpolitics.com/epolls/latest_polls/

RCP average has Clinton up by 2.9%.
http://www.realclearpolitics.com/ep...s/general_election_trump_vs_clinton-5491.html

Much more useful then the typical cherry picked, early morning choices of the Trumpster types.