Today's Polls

People need to come to grips that a foreign President is not gonna make a whole lot of difference in their daily lives

Canada's prosperity is heavily tied to the US. Trudeau: "living next to the US was like sleeping with an elephant — we are affected by “every twitch and grunt.”

- The US is Canada's largest trading partner. $800 billion bilaterally and >75% of Cdn exports. Any new tariffs or tightening of trade agreements could have significant impact on Canada's economy.
- Canada's dollar is very dependent on interest rates in the US. If they change monetary policy and the Cdn dollar rises, this could make Canada much less globally competitive.
- US companies own a huge number of Canadian companies and employee many Canadians. Many US companies have already shut down their Canadian operations (Caterpillar, Ford, GM, Cisco, IBM, HP) and repatriated the jobs to the US
- US companies control >80% of Cdn natural resource mining, refining and shipping.
- Do you not have any stock investments? Bad US monetary decisions could devalue your investments significantly, as a retiree can you afford a 30 - 40 - 50% decrease in cash flow?
- Canadian companies are dependent on American technology and investment for growth
- Current American energy policy has all but killed the Alberta economy (tar sands, pipelines, refinery expansion in NB, etc).
- Previous American lumber disputes has significantly impacted the BC economy.

If you are suggesting the new POTUS isn't going to bother with Canada, maybe that's true will Hillary (she hasn't really been clear on her position), but Trump is very clear he wants to re-negotiate trade agreements, bring jobs back to the US and make the US more competitive (from an American point of view I understand why), but none of these steps will be in Canada's interest. Not to mention reduced investment in Canada by American companies, less dependence on Cdn energy, etc.
 
Canada's prosperity is heavily tied to the US. Trudeau: "living next to the US was like sleeping with an elephant — we are affected by “every twitch and grunt.”

- The US is Canada's largest trading partner. $800 billion bilaterally and >75% of Cdn exports. Any new tariffs or tightening of trade agreements could have significant impact on Canada's economy.
- Canada's dollar is very dependent on interest rates in the US. If they change monetary policy and the Cdn dollar rises, this could make Canada much less globally competitive.
- US companies own a huge number of Canadian companies and employee many Canadians. Many US companies have already shut down their Canadian operations (Caterpillar, Ford, GM, Cisco, IBM, HP) and repatriated the jobs to the US
- US companies control >80% of Cdn natural resource mining, refining and shipping.
- Do you not have any stock investments? Bad US monetary decisions could devalue your investments significantly, as a retiree can you afford a 30 - 40 - 50% decrease in cash flow?
- Canadian companies are dependent on American technology and investment for growth
- Current American energy policy has all but killed the Alberta economy (tar sands, pipelines, refinery expansion in NB, etc).
- Previous American lumber disputes has significantly impacted the BC economy.

If you are suggesting the new POTUS isn't going to bother with Canada, maybe that's true will Hillary (she hasn't really been clear on her position), but Trump is very clear he wants to re-negotiate trade agreements, bring jobs back to the US and make the US more competitive (from an American point of view I understand why), but none of these steps will be in Canada's interest. Not to mention reduced investment in Canada by American companies, less dependence on Cdn energy, etc
From what I've heard Trump mainly wants to renegotiate Mexico's side of NAFTA, not so much Canada's side.
Especially the cheap labour Mexico gets.

Also a healthy US economy will only help Canada in the long run
 
Today's polls thus far:

General Election: Trump vs. Clinton vs. Johnson vs. Stein Rasmussen Reports Clinton 41, Trump 43, Johnson 5, Stein 3 Trump +2
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton LA Times/USC Tracking Clinton 45, Trump 44 Clinton +1
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton vs. Johnson vs. Stein IBD/TIPP Tracking Clinton 41, Trump 41, Johnson 8, Stein 4 Tie
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton IBD/TIPP Tracking Clinton 42, Trump 42 Tie


The link (for the disingenuous doubters): http://www.realclearpolitics.com/epolls/latest_polls/

I find the 14 point gap between 2 polls (the inaugural ABC poll and Rasmussen) published a day or less apart to be astonishing. I can't remember seeing anything like it before in my lifetime (in the US). I'm aware of various arguments concerning issues like oversampling of Democrats, question wording, totality of survey questions, and methods of surveying (mechanical/live). There is something amiss here.

In these circumstances, I don't know how anyone can be confident about what the numbers really are. As a result, the numbers that the media are relying upon as if they are beyond controversy seem less useful as reliable information and more useful in disclosing the agenda of that particular organization.

The tactics of the media in this election seem risky to me. If Trump were to win, I think that the credibility of most the media will be destroyed irreparably. Are things so bad (financially) in that industry that such a risk is worth taking? I guess we'll see the answer to all of these questions shortly.
 
The media and polls aren't one and the same.
Sure, lots of polls are done by papers and tv, but there are also independent polls done as well.
Are you claiming all polls and media are rigged, or only the ones that show Trump losing?

And why, given the big range of polls, do you refuse to consider the RCP national averages?
http://www.realclearpolitics.com/ep...s/general_election_trump_vs_clinton-5491.html

Why do you only look for individual polls that confirm your believe in rigging while ignoring others?
 
Today's polls this far:

General Election: Trump vs. Clinton vs. Johnson vs. Stein Rasmussen Reports Clinton 41, Trump 43, Johnson 5, Stein 3 Trump +2
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton LA Times/USC Tracking Clinton 45, Trump 44 Clinton +1
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton vs. Johnson vs. Stein IBD/TIPP Tracking Clinton 41, Trump 41, Johnson 8, Stein 4 Tie
General Election: Trump vs. Clinton IBD/TIPP Tracking Clinton 42, Trump 42 Tie


The link (for the disingenuous doubters): http://www.realclearpolitics.com/epolls/latest_polls/

I find the 14 point gap between 2 polls (the inaugural ABC poll and Rasmussen) published a day or less apart to be astonishing. I can't remember seeing anything like it before in my lifetime (in the US). I'm aware of various arguments concerning issues like oversampling of Democrats, question wording, totality of survey questions, and methods of surveying (mechanical/live). There is something amiss here.

In these circumstances, I don't know how anyone can be confident about what the numbers really are. As a result, the numbers that the media are relying upon as if they are beyond controversy seem less useful as reliable information and more useful in disclosing the agenda of that particular organization.

The tactics of the media in this election seem risky to me. If Trump were to win, I think that the credibility of most the media will be destroyed irreparably. Are things so bad (financially) in that industry that such a risk is worth taking? I guess we'll see the answer to all of these questions shortly.
Thanks for pointing out the reality of projecting nationwide results when citizens go out and vote from tiny statistical samples of people who like to answer questions on the phone.

But don't let me discourage anyone from arguing about how many untrustworthy results can be engraved on the head of a pin.
 
The media and polls aren't one and the same.
Sure, lots of polls are done by papers and tv, but there are also independent polls done as well.
Are you claiming all polls and media are rigged, or only the ones that show Trump losing?

And why, given the big range of polls, do you refuse to consider the RCP national averages?
http://www.realclearpolitics.com/ep...s/general_election_trump_vs_clinton-5491.html

Why do you only look for individual polls that confirm your believe in rigging while ignoring others?

Frank, the mistake I may be making is treating you as if you are interested in engaging in an honest discussion (and/or honestly reflecting on the substance of that discussion).

You suggest I'm cherry picking polls? I posted ALL of the polls posted thus far today. One of them shows Clinton leading. In addition, I mentioned a poll from yesterday that is THE most favourable to Clinton. Assuming you are not completely disingenuous, it would appear that you don't understand the concept.

As the day goes on, please feel free to update this thread with other polls as they are published, or post all the polls that are released tomorrow, or any other day. It won't undermine my principal point, which is an observation about the inconsistency of the polls. In my working world, I've learned that the truth almost always lies between two (or more) stated opinions. However, I've also learned that point of truth rarely lies at the EXACT midpoint of the difference between those positions, or at the average of several contending opinions.

I've already explained why I think it's useful to focus on only the most recent polls. Again Frank, you should read and well as write.

As to the relevance of mentioning the media as well as the polls, you already know the answer. Many voters will never go to sites like Realclearpolitics. They rely on what the media tell them that the polls say. If the media selects results, or an interpretation of the results, that favours one candidate, voters will have the wrong impression of where majority opinion sits. It is trite to say that many people are influenced by what they understand to be the majority view. This is a conscious campaign strategy, in an election where the co-operation between the vast majority of media outlets and the Clinton campaign is beyond argument.

I can't claim to know what the real numbers are, so I won't claim to. But I know that the media are in no better position than I am, yet they are pretending to know something they don't.

Which circles neatly back to you.
 
Frank, the mistake I may be making is treating you as if you are interested in engaging in an honest discussion (and/or honestly reflecting on the substance of that discussion).

You suggest I'm cherry picking polls? I posted ALL of the polls posted thus far today.

Thank you for clearly explaining the method to your cherry picking.
You pick only early morning poll results, which tend to be by the same few polls that consistently show Trump doing ok.
Rasmussen, LA times and IBD.

Same three sources you pick every morning.
That's cherry picking.
 
Thank you for clearly explaining the method to your cherry picking.
You pick only early morning poll results, which tend to be by the same few polls that consistently show Trump doing ok.
Rasmussen, LA times and IBD.

Same three sources you pick every morning.
That's cherry picking.

Frank,

According to you:

EVERY = twice (I thought you claimed to know something about statistical analysis? Hint - 2 points of data do not reveal a pattern.)
PICKING = posting every poll that had been published at the time of posting, mentioning others that run contrary to those polls, and inviting others to update the thread with further polls.
CHERRY PICKING = pointing out inconsistency (rather than its true meaning, which is to assert a consistency of results based on selectivity)

You don't see where you've gone wrong here? You are quite beyond hope.
 
…

I can't claim to know what the real numbers are, so I won't claim to. But I know that the media are in no better position than I am, yet they are pretending to know something they don't.

Which circles neatly back to you.
So why are you repeatedly playing the game of the ignorant and crooked media touting poll numbers you can't know are real? It makes me think that you aren't just as ignorant as the pollsters and the media — as you admitted — but that you're as self-serving, partial and biased as they are to boot.

Nothing against your right to your beliefs and opinions, or to stating them anyway you choose, but why clog up the Forum with details about polls you yourself say are crap? Ignore them. Or de-bunk them on sites for poll-watchers and professionals.

If your purpose is to help the general public understand them better, you're wasting your time and Fred's bandwidth here in Escort Reviewland.
 
There are plenty of polls that come up with different results.
And parties do their own internal polls which may show again different results.
That's why you look at averages of all the polls.

Again, there is no corruption shown here on this email
My point of that post was to show the polls were WAY off. 20+ points is a lot.
 
Frank,

According to you:

EVERY = twice (I thought you claimed to know something about statistical analysis? Hint - 2 points of data do not reveal a pattern.)
PICKING = posting every poll that had been published at the time of posting, mentioning others that run contrary to those polls, and inviting others to update the thread with further polls.
CHERRY PICKING = pointing out inconsistency (rather than its true meaning, which is to assert a consistency of results based on selectivity)

You don't see where you've gone wrong here? You are quite beyond hope.

You don't see what's wrong there?
I repeatedly point out that the RCP averages are the daily averages of all polls and are more representative then checking on the same three sources in the morning.

I keep giving you what you claim you want, updated the post with the most accurate information, and you continue to ignore that and to repost the same three pollsters.

Your source, reaclearpolitics, points out that Clinton is ahead by 6.1% now, according to the averages of all polls, including your three favourites.
http://www.realclearpolitics.com/ep...s/general_election_trump_vs_clinton-5491.html
 
So why are you repeatedly playing the game of the ignorant and crooked media touting poll numbers you don't know are real? You aren't just as ignorant as they — as you admitted — you're as self-serving, partial and biased as they.

Oldjones, I have briefly explained why I created this thread, but I'll elaborate.

I've been watching a lot of election coverage - from a variety of media outlets, both TV and internet (I've also reviewed a lot of written news, but lets leave that aside, for simplicity). Some are right leaning, but the vast majority are consistently (and most, unapologetically) liberal in their outlook, reporting and journalism.

I've also been reviewing the published polls, both national and in the swing states, on a regular basis.

Let me use just the national picture to illustrate the point I'm pursuing. What I've observed is the following:

1. The media has been almost unanimously claiming that Clinton is up from somewhere between 7 - 12 points nationally. If that's true (meaning not just that the polling supports that number, but also that the polling is an accurate predictor of voter preference and turnout), then the election would truly be already over.
2. Some media outlets, like CNN and MSNBC, are going so far as to say that the election is essentially over based on their analysis (and no, it's not lost on me that such analysis has to focus on state results, rather than national polling, but they present their state predictions as an extension of their trend analysis on the national level).
3. The media rarely, if ever, specifically presents the polls that are most favourable to Trump.
4. The media frequently, when relying on a single poll, presents whatever recent poll is most favourable to Clinton.
5. The media has spent very little time speaking about the magnitude of inconsistency between the extremes in the polling, and what that might mean regarding their ability to accurate represent the current support for either candidate at any one time.

I observed a similar phenomenon in the discussions taking place on this Board.

From these observations, I started to have a harder look at the polls, especially after the Trump accusers appeared and after the 2nd Presidential Debate, when the latest round of the "this election is over" media push began in earnest. I focussed on the daily release of polls, rather than averages which took into account longer periods of release. This election has had so many significant events, and there have been so many significant changes in momentum, that it made sense to me to look at this day by day, as the impact of each new event unfolded. I honestly believe that, the way this election has proceeded thus far, that there will be people changing their minds this year (or making up their minds for the first time) all the way up to the voting booth, based on whatever happens on the last day of the campaign.

What I saw didn't match what the media were saying. I saw some polls, after everything that Trump had done that had been proclaimed as fatal, showing him as tied or leading, and I also saw some polls that were light years away, claiming that Clinton had as much as a double digit lead. To me, this was/is astonishing.

I proceeded from the presumption, initially, that for there to be a balanced discussion of this issue, people should be aware of what the various polls actually were (accepting that each poll stands to be criticized for its methodology, etc), rather than what the media was representing the polling to be.

Quickly it was revealed that some (but not all) people don't want to engage in any such discussion. They have numbers they like, and they don't want to consider how those numbers are derived and how reliable/or unreliable they are, and they certainly don't want to acknowledge that there are other numbers to the contrary.

So, I'm not trying to claim that some polls are right and others wrong. I'm trying to illuminate that there is a significant inconsistency between the polls, and a significant inconsistency between polling and the conclusions that the media are presenting about the polls. The starting point of that discussion is an agreement as to what the most recent daily polls actually say.

Does that clear it up?
 
Oldjones, I have briefly explained why I created this thread, but I'll elaborate.
…edit…


So, I'm not trying to claim that some polls are right and others wrong. I'm trying to illuminate that there is a significant inconsistency between the polls, and a significant inconsistency between polling and the conclusions that the media are presenting about the polls. The starting point of that discussion is an agreement as to what the most recent daily polls actually say.

Does that clear it up?
None of that is anyway anyway surprising; in fact it was and is entirely to be expected. Polls are like playoff superstitions in hockey, they have nothing to do with real outcomes, but they comfort those they comfort. It could hardly be otherwise when the final outcome is the count secret ballots cast by a couple of hundred million voters and the superstition is how a couple of hundred folks may answer a telephone call. Likewise the media reporting, which will always skew —as does yours — to what the proprietors think will get them the hearing they want.

My own thinking is skewed by the fact that however anyone else may vote is utterly irrelevant to how I will. So I fail to see any value in polls, particularly when they're 'published' as they have been here and on the web by folks who have no concept of their numerical accuracy, and don't try to ascertain or state it. Who clearly don't even grasp the terms of reference that produced the numbers they cite or the standpoint they claim their fallacious numbers justify. I have even less confidence in post-polling manipulations that aggregate polls of unknown quality; they're as respectable as guys in raincoats offering tips at the track for the price of a drink. Or for a mouse-click when we're talking websites.

I said before that if clarity and exposure to actual published fact are what you're trying for, then cut-and-pastes and personal summaries of what you haven't pasted isn't the best way to achieve your goal. Links to everything is what HTML was made for. Besides you're likely to generate distractions like me, if you mix your personal preferences and précis's in with the objectivity you say you're trying for.

Still largely unanswered is why invest the effort giving wider credence to the polls at all, when you have said you don't have much faith in them.