To Evict or Not to Evict

SuperCharge

Banned
Jun 11, 2011
2,519
1
0
A friend has a dog and supposedly moved into a pet friendly condominium and now his landlord is telling him that he has to get rid of the dog (it's a doberman) OR move out!

Is this even legal, and what sort of advice do you think I should give him?
 
The condominium will have rules for pets, type of pets, how much they can weigh, etc. Your friend’s lease should had a clause that says he agrees to follow the rules of the condominium.

If the condominium allows pets like your friend has, then the landlord probably can’t force your friend out, but not sure. There could be a clause in the lease agreement that says no pets, but don’t know if it is enforceable if the condominium allows pets like your friend has.

It is a different issue if the dog has been a nuisance.

I was somewhat involved in a case where people thought they were entitled to have pets, in a condo that did not allow them. Long story short, the people made a stand and lawyered up , but lost the case, lost their condo, and left with some substantial bills.
 
It was the "supposedly moved into a pet friendly condominium" that caught my attention. I'm thinking he found the condo is not pet friendly now. The guy could have thought the building was pet friendly because he saw other pets, but the rules say no pets. This guy might have been walking his doberman past security a few times a day to have his dog shit on the lawn outside the lobby door. Maybe the OP will fill in the blanks.

A doberman is too big a dog for a condo, and not the type of dog to have around other people in an elevator.
 
Should be cut and dry - check the condo rules; either dogs are allowed or they aren't.

I've lived in buildings where pets weren't allowed but where cats or small (and quiet) dogs were nonetheless tolerated, either by grandfathering older tenants/owners or by tolerance for small, quiet dogs. A doberman though?? If its a building where no-pet bylaws are overlooked for small, quiet pets, it would nonetheless be understandable that a big breed with an aggressive reputation would cause panic!! My gut feel - your buddy is going to have to get rid of the dog, or move.
 
Thanks for all the replies guys. Let me just clarify that when he initially signed the lease, the landlord was told that he had a dog and he was still rented the condo. There are people in his building who have dogs as well. Not sure if they are bigger dogs or smaller ones though.

I also should say that he is a good dog owner, I know he takes the dog out for long walks beside the humber river where he lives. The dog is 9 months old and he has spent alot of money on training and is having a tough time trying to figure out what he should do. I realise that condo's do have their own set of rules, however it was rented out to him with the knowledge of there being a dog.
 
I like animals more than I like people.

Odds are that people will often times do far more damage than animals to an apartment. (From what I've seen over the years.)

If the guy keeps his place clean and looks after the dog and pays the rent, I'd say he's a perfect tennant.
 
The tenant has two statutes to worry about.
His landlord still must ensure that his tenant, your friend, obeys the provisions of the Declaration, the Condo By-Laws and the condo rules. Even if ordinary residential tenancies cannot automatically be terminated because of the tenant having a pet, that doesn't mean the landlord can allow his tenant to violate the condo rules etc.
First, check the Declaration, By-Laws and the rules. If they permit dogs like the tenants, then there has to be other ground for the landlord to terminate the lease, such as nuisance or damage.