I think it really depends on the clients and the providers and seeing the split of regular experiences being shared so far have proven that.
On client side, it depends on what you're looking for. Many people seek variety but there're people looking for consistency and an expected experience which brings them comfort. I think one will hit the wall eventually if he seeks something more every time from a single provider. It'll plateau and then it's up to us to decide whether to move on or keep as regular. I'm a regular of my hair stylist for 20 years he cuts my hair the same way every time. I have the same tailor making my suit for 20+ years and now his son is making that for me. It became a type of "relationship" that I cherish. Yeah not saying we should apply that to SP but sometimes I do feel the same way. Also going to you favorite restaurant frequently does not mean you go there for your every meal, i.e. don't get attached.
On the provider side, it's very important not to take things for granted on the regulars 'cause that's when we WILL move on. The restaurant I frequented always provides good and professional service. Yeah there're some perks from time to time but in a normal situation I expect nothing but the complete service on the menu without any hint of short changing. Good professional providers (should) know that.