I did this several years ago after my divorce. The plan was to go date for fun, hobby, while someone else tried to match me up with another potential life partner. I paid about $2500 or $2700 for "3-4 dates a month" for a year.
I was in my early 30's, and the profile I was looking for was 25-35, University grad with a preference for post-grad education, white collar work, family oriented, and conventionally attractive (slim, well dressed, etc). I was living in Vancouver at the time.
I had plenty of dates, more than 3-4 a month. I found that the agency just kept throwing women at you, no where near your ideal... almost as if they agency ignored my criteria. I usually do fairly well on dates, at a minimum I'm able to keep conversation going while getting a few real laughs out. I got the feeling that many of these women were disappointed in me as a date because they had a list of requirements that I didn't meet either. I started to ask direct questions about what they were expecting, and it turns out some of them wanted a guy over 6'2" (I'm 5'11"), some wanted very fit men (I'm average at around 190, with my six pack days long behind me), some wanted men who were obviously more well to do than me, some women even wanted a different ethnicity (I'm Asian). Did I get laid here and there, meet some interesting people and had some fun? Absolutely. Was the agency looking out for me and my needs/quest for a partner... absolutely not.
I've concluded that the best way to meet someone is through your friends and social circle.
If you can easily afford it, I'd try it out at least once. It was nice to have 3-4 dates a month and me not have to work for it online or ask people out. I've often thought about paying a service to run my online dating profile and just tell me where to show up with a print out of all the emails I 'sent'.
Oh, after the 1st year, the agency kept calling me and giving me 'freebie' setups, upto 1 or 2 a month for another 6 or so months after. After that, I moved back to Toronto.