The Young Pope vs Taboo

Insidious Von

My head is my home
Sep 12, 2007
45,727
11,186
113
HBO is smarting.

They spent lavishly to create The Young Pope and the marketing that went with it - only to get throttled on the ratings by Taboo. A show they could have had. That's not going to change going into this week with Taboo going into it's crucial episode 6. The mystery surrounding the sunken slave ship will be revealed. It's no surprise that Jude Law cannot stand on ceremony with Tom Hardy. Taboo has a much more solid cast as well: Jonathan Pryce (Game of Thrones - Hugh Sparrow), Stephen Graham (Boardwalk Empire - Al Capone) and Franka Potente (Run Lola Run). But the biggest surprise is Mark Gatniss as the Prince Regent/future George IV. No one could have guessed that underneath the fat suit and acne is the same actor who plays Mycroft Holmes in Sherlock.

One historical fact that Taboo is getting right is the permanent rift that developed between The British Crown and The East India Company during the War of 1812.

Mark Gatniss is awesome!

 
That Taboo should be so well cast is no surprise. Nina Gold assembled it, along with Game of Thrones as well.

Ridley Scott produced the show, he hasn't worked with Tom Hardy since Black Hawk Down.
 
I tried watching "The Younge Pope" because it looked like it might be interesting.

I agree with xmontrealer, it is utterly unwatchable.

I watched parts of the first episode, then parts of the second and I thought it was the worst show I'd ever seen. Rambling, nonsensical, and worst of all boring. Both times I shut it down. I mean for HBO to put out such shit is unbelievable. The problem is the scripts are fucking idiotic. And Jude Law's acting is bizarre (goes with the writing I guess).

Have to wonder what HBO will do once Thrones is over.

Vinyl was kind of rambling and all over the map. The characters weren't bad. The acting was sometimes good, but again, the writing was awful.

I wanted to like Westworld and it had its moments, but all in all, it was kind of lame as well too.

Been watching "Medici Masters of Florence" on Netflix because I'm fascinated by the Italian Renaissance. Very good show. Also watched "the Crown" on Netflix which was also very good. (Neither of these shows are Sopranos or Thrones, but they are very good, with a slight edge to "The Crown" over Medici_
 
Young Pope I expect to break into a Demonic Possession theme at any second.

Taboo is a better program but has taken some serious historical criticism over its portrayal of the H.E.I.C.

119px-Flag_of_the_British_East_India_Company_%281801%29.svg.png
 
What did you find disagreeable Aardie? The E.I.C made La Cosa Nostra look like the Mickey Mouse club.

They made huge profits off of the slave trade and looting India of its diamonds, among other evils. And the threats made against Delaney were almost similar to those faced by William Wilberforce when he moved to have slavery banned.

 
Love Taboo. It also stars Oona Chaplin who plays Zilpha Geary who plays James Delaney (Tom Hardy) step sister. Oona Chaplin is the grand daughter of (pretty cool) Charlie Chaplin. I find her pretty attractive too. Never watched the Young Pope as it looks boring.

 
Oona's great grand father is Eugene O'Neil, she looks more like her grandmother Oona Sr than her mother Geraldine. She's been taking criticism for bad acting. I don't think so but her character is poorly written. So far she's been eclipsed by Franka Potente as Madame Helga and Jessica Buckley as Lorna Bow. Oona was endearing as The Queen of the North in Game of Thrones.

I like The Young Pope, but it may be too esoteric for North American audiences. It has creator-writer Paolo Sorrentino's signature style written all over it. His Continental Italian outlook may be too...nebulous for those not used to him. His work is of that vein and challenging to comprehend. However he did win a Best Foreign Language Oscar for The Great Beauty. HBO got the opportunity to make this series due to Pope Francis choosing not to live in the Papal apartments. In keeping with his austere way of life, Il Papa lives in a modest dwelling leaving the Papal apartments open to the public.

 
I couldn't stop laughing watching Prince George IV feast on a soft boiled ostrich egg. Not sure if it was Steven Knight who wrote the part as a degenerate glutton or Mark Gatniss ad libs. From what has been depicted, George IV suffered from the same type of eating disorder that cut down James Gandolfini. His father, George III, may have brought about the dissolution of the EIC much sooner. The Crown Prince didn't have the power to bring the EIC to heel and they continued to reap huge rewards from the slave trade. George III's mind had been eaten away by bi-polar disorder in his last years. The British Crown was in a desperate state, the gluttonous George IV with hugely unpopular with the British public. Gatniss is playing him with gusto.

 
His father, George III, may have brought about the dissolution of the EIC much sooner. The Crown Prince didn't have the power to bring the EIC to heel and they continued to reap huge rewards from the slave trade
However, historically that really isn't particularly supportable. In the time frame of this series there had been five Acts of Parliament dealing with the H.E.I.C.

The East India Company Act 1773

The Parliament imposed a series of administrative and economic reforms which clearly established Parliament's ultimate control over the Company and that the ultimate sovereignty was British rather than the Company's.


The East India Company Act 1784 (Pitt's India Act)

In political matters the East India Company was subordinated to the British government directly. Pitt's Act was deemed a failure because it quickly became apparent that the boundaries between government control and the company's powers were nebulous and highly subjective.

The Act of 1786

The Company functioned as a regularized subsidiary of the Crown, with greater accountability for its actions. Having temporarily achieved a state of truce with the Crown, the Company continued to expand its influence to nearby territories. By the middle of the 19th century, the Company's rule extended across most of India, Burma, Malaya, Singapore, and British Hong Kong, and a fifth of the world's population was under its trading influence. In addition, Penang, one of the states in Malaya, became the fourth most important settlement, a presidency, of the Company's Indian territories.

East India Company Act 1793

More a housekeeping act than the previous Acts it renewed the Company's charter until 1813.


East India Company Act 1813

This Act was the penultimate in the timeline of the series:

By this point the Company had gained control of all of India save for the Punjab and Sindh. The Indian Princes had become vassals of the Company.


It

Renewed the Charter of the Company to 1833

Asserted the sovereignty of the British Crown over the Company's Indian territories
Deprived the company of its trade monopoly to India, except for the trade in tea and the trade with China
Required the company to maintain its commercial and territorial accounts separately and distinctly.
And opened India to missionaries


As to the Columbia District/Oregon Country (Nootka Sound) as Canadians and Americans should know, this really didn't boil up into a real dispute until the late 1830's - early 1840's.

As to Slavery - British participation in the Slave Trade had been criminalized by the Slave Trade Act - 1807, although Slavery itself was not abolished until 1834.
 
I tried watching "The Younge Pope" because it looked like it might be interesting.

I agree with xmontrealer, it is utterly unwatchable.

I watched parts of the first episode, then parts of the second and I thought it was the worst show I'd ever seen. Rambling, nonsensical, and worst of all boring. Both times I shut it down. I mean for HBO to put out such shit is unbelievable. The problem is the scripts are fucking idiotic. And Jude Law's acting is bizarre (goes with the writing I guess).

Have to wonder what HBO will do once Thrones is over.

Vinyl was kind of rambling and all over the map. The characters weren't bad. The acting was sometimes good, but again, the writing was awful.

I wanted to like Westworld and it had its moments, but all in all, it was kind of lame as well too.

Been watching "Medici Masters of Florence" on Netflix because I'm fascinated by the Italian Renaissance. Very good show. Also watched "the Crown" on Netflix which was also very good. (Neither of these shows are Sopranos or Thrones, but they are very good, with a slight edge to "The Crown" over Medici_

Try Daredevil and Jessica Jones on Netflix. Add in Luke Cage. I won't comment on the upcoming Iron Fist until it's out.

Jessica Jones is especially good.
 
Oona's great grand father is Eugene O'Neil, she looks more like her grandmother Oona Sr than her mother Geraldine. She's been taking criticism for bad acting. I don't think so but her character is poorly written. So far she's been eclipsed by Franka Potente as Madame Helga and Jessica Buckley as Lorna Bow. Oona was endearing as The Queen of the North in Game of Thrones.

I like The Young Pope, but it may be too esoteric for North American audiences. It has creator-writer Paolo Sorrentino's signature style written all over it. His Continental Italian outlook may be too...nebulous for those not used to him. His work is of that vein and challenging to comprehend. However he did win a Best Foreign Language Oscar for The Great Beauty. HBO got the opportunity to make this series due to Pope Francis choosing not to live in the Papal apartments. In keeping with his austere way of life, Il Papa lives in a modest dwelling leaving the Papal apartments open to the public.




Excellent observation IV. I thought that they filmed it in the Pope's proper residence since Pope Francis chose not to live there. I like The Young Pope too but it's a bit bizarre. Love the Italian women in it. I don't know about Taboo. Geez so many shows to watch.
 
I tried watching True Blood - I fell asleep each time. So far the only show that I must avoid, I will binge through it like a degenerate addict, is Homeland.

I'm still going to finish The Young Pope due to Paolo Sorrentino's writing. Taboo is building to a thumping conclusion, Steven Knight has ratcheted up the suspense with each episode. I just wish Hardy would stop putting himself through unnecessary risk. The waterboarding scene was gruesome, Jesse Ventura must have popped watching it.

I watched Deadpool recently, I enjoyed it more than I was expecting to. But I was disappointed that all the fight scenes were CGI. Maybe that's how it should be. Christian Bale, Heath Ledger and Tom Hardy punished their bodies to make Nolan's Batman trilogy so legendary. Is it right to expect that level of dedication from actors? The first fight scene in TDKR was filmed last, Bale and Hardy were not in the pink after doing it.

 
I really miss Heath Ledger, what a tragic waste of great talent.

The origin of The Joker:

 
Spoiler Alert:

Billy Bob deserved the Oscar much more than Halle Berry did. Angela Bassett, who IMHO was robbed for What's Love Got to Do With It, said that Berry's role was a stereotypical hysterical black woman. Some have also criticized the nature of Thornton's character - how could a diehard racist love a black woman? Obviously they weren't paying attention to the funeral scene, Thornton didn't show contrition for the fate of his son but he did appreciate the support of the black families that paid their respect. Which is the central theme of the film, for the sake of his own self-preservation he had to park his intolerance.

Btw Aardie what did you think of the waterboarding scene in Taboo? Yes indeed, the EIC was under the governance of Parliament - just like you said. There was no camera cut, so I must assume that Hardy allowed himself to be almost drowned. Boy did Sir Stuart Strange fuck up! He ask for a trade monopoly in exchange for The Crown laying claim to Vancouver Island. That must have gone over like a Lead Zeppelin with Prince George.
 
The fallout from Ep 7 has been wild.

Most found the waterboarding scene disturbing to say the least but I haven't found anything to suggest that Hardy actually did it himself. The camera seems to suggest that he did. So far the only hero of the series is George Chichester (Lucian Mmasmati), working doggedly to bring some measure of justice to the drowned slaves.

Tom has crafted his screen and public images to perfection. While being an obdurate hardman on screen, he projects himself as a devoted father and dog lover off it. No wonder Scarlett Johansson wants to bang him. He was once a junkie, he may eventually fuck up, you never know.

A Christmas offering:

 
I thumping ending to Taboo, very clever writing by Steven Knight. Nice to see George Chichester get some measure of justice for the drowned slaves. Jessie Buckley (Lorna Bow) really turned it around, when she first appeared she was reviled. Now she's very much the secondary hero. Her approval rating shot up by 60% from fan ratings. And Tom brought back an old anti-hero. 4/5 stars.